Given a calm, stable mind (one not overwrought with the hyper adrenaline provided by Gurren Lagann battles) I honestly don't understand how you can rate this anime any higher than a 7. I watched the whole series, and yes it had me watching episode after episode (finished in three days), but really? People are saying it is the BEST anime out there?
The honest truth is that Gurren Lagann is purely of high entertainment value, but that is about it. Under closer scrutiny the series just plays to our most basic emotions which makes you THINK it is the most amazing anime ever, while in reality it just has lots of fights, lots of heartbreak, and lots of love... three things that humans really just respond well to, and find very entertaning, but this doesn't make it a work of art people...
*spoiler*
I will give Gurren Laggan credit for having a really cool time period jump at the end of the series, which had me going "Whoa, that's a really great move by the director/production team." Oh and Boota was amazing, my personal favorite character...