Story = 8 - All in all each story is unique, there are some recurring characters but the thing that makes it special is how Koyomi deals with every problem his "harem" throws at him.
Hitagi Crab = 8 - This arc is about Hitagi Senjougahara and how Koyomi Ararararararagi helps her. The main problem with Hitagi is; she's as light as a feather so, Koyomi with the help of Old Man Oshino help her out.
Mayoi Snail = 8 - Following after Hitagi Crab, this story is about a young girl trying to find her way home for Mother's day, but the problem is; she's not alive anymore.
Suruga Monkey = 8 - My favorite arc. Kanbaru Suruga is your normal lesbo that has feelings for Hitagi, after finding out a guy named Koyomi is her boyfriend, she makes a wish on a "monkey's paw".
Nadeko Snake = 7 - my Least favorite arc coming from my least favorite character. She's trying so hard to be moe and cute it's freaking annoying. It's about Nadeko who is cursed by a boy she dumped and the girl who had a crush on that boy. A middle school love-triangle.
Tsubasa Cat = 9 - the final arc. I gave it a high Score because it closed the show pretty well. It's about Tsubasa's "illness" coming back and raising some trouble again.
Art = 9 - the art is good. It's animated by Shaft so, there are a lot of unexplainable scences, pictures and animations.
Sound = 8 - I love it how each arc has it's own OP and how the VA of main focus of that arc sings the OP as well.
Character = 9
Koyomi Arararararagi - the Main Character, a former vampire, he is like any generic lead character.
Hitagi Senjougahara - a tsundere-yandere, is that even a thing? Hitagi-san is Koyomi's girlfriend, she has sharp-tongue and always harasses Koyomi.
Meme Oshino - a mysterious man who Koyomi turns to whenever the supernatural is involved.
Shinobu Oshino - a former vampire who lost her powers. Currently in a loli form.
Mayoi Hachikuji - an elementary student, who was classified as a snail. She leads people astray.
Suruga Kanbaru - a lesbo, in-love with Hitagi and extremely perverted much to the dismay of Koyomi. She has a "monkey's paw".
Nadeko Sengoku - hmmm. Was cursed by a person she dumped, and was cursed again when a girl who has a crush on the person she dumped found out she dumped him. She's trying so hard to be cute and moe.
Tsubasa Hanekawa - Koyomi's best friend. Has the baka-neko inside her. Whenever she is stressed, baka-neko comes out and raises hell.
Enjoyment = 9 - This anime was fun! Seeing Koyomi react to different kinds of situations was funny. Each girl in his "harem" has their own personality, they aren't linear like any other harem animes. A little confusing because of Shaft, but hey, Shaft randomness made this anime for me.
Overall = 8 - It was a fun ride! All arcs were beautifully done. For people who want a little Romance in the Supernatural Anime. Bakemonogatari is for you.
