First thing is Kaichou wa Maid-sama! is funny, but also with aspects of seriousness.
(7) Story - It is a bit cliché, but a still great story nonetheless, a girl, the class president and a popular, handsome guy. Misaki seems to dislike Usui a bit for breaking girl's hearts. He finds her working in a maid café, when Misaki is usually tough and strict. It's very funny, as I said before, back and forth, also at school. I personally liked it even though it was one of my first anime.
(8) Art - Art was good, modern and clean. Also, they'd make a lot of funny faces throughout it.
(9) Sound - I liked the music, it did fit in with the theme.
(8) Character - The main cast were magnificent. The supporting characters were a bit of a let down though.
(8) Enjoyment/Overall - It was great. But the romance was up and down at all times. It's truly saddening that there's no season 2 of this.