fucking evangelion is the best anime and work of media ever created and if you say anything else your opinion is shit and entirely disregarded and you don't deserve to remain on this earth
Hello agian, sorry for the late reply.
thank you for not being as retarded as those fanboys on my page..
Opinions are a thing, aren't they? Even in the less important topics such as anime and sports
Anyway, 1st season of SAO were hated for specific reasons:
1- They did not show how did the protagonist leveled up!! They just skipped the best part, sadly.
2- It ended up to be a romance anime in the end which is not a thing that shounen fans, or those that want more action or adventure, like.
For me, I'm a fan of romance anime, and I even like fighting animes like Fate/zero. SAO season 1 had them both and that's why I gave it 9/10
Now, lets review how to rate an anime... Well, I think you know this, but just in case, animes commonly rated based on:
1- story (how logical is the anime. The progression of the story itself, and is it missing any important points from the manga or the novel, etc... Does the story's pace change suddenly or was there a gradual and logical development.)
2- Enjoyment (It is based on your preference, so no one should be judged on this)
3- Characters ( Are they developing? does the character have one dimension or more? does it have a logical development? How many characters are there? Are they given enough space or are they just fillers? Are the characters unique or cliche?)
4- Sound (This one was actually the best thing in fate/zero, the OST, the opening, the ending, the voice actors, the sound effects during the fights)
5- Art ( during the fights and the character themselves. The environment, etc...)
So, as someone how does not like to be biased toward a specific show, I always use these as references when I give a rating, and I suppose you do too.
Now, you mentioned that SAO had Lots of plots hole and irrational characters. Can you tell me some?? BTW, I'm not saying that SAO in a perfect anime, and I might change my scoring if I watched it again, who knows?? Still, I want you to point out the holes and so..
Regarding Shelter, well, this is not even an anime, and I was shocked at how many people talked about it the first time it was aired. It went just viral immediately, even those that don't watch anime at all knew about it!! Are you imagining that? However, I only rated it based on the Sound and art, nothing more. and that's why it got 7, which is not a high score at all..
Now, regarding Mirai nikki. I've watched it 3 or 4 years ago, and YOU WOULD NOT BELIEVE HOW FRUSTRATED I WAS BECAUSE OF HOW STUPID SOME OF ITS SCENES WERE!! Yes, this anime was to me the worst and the best simultaneously, and I was not sure how to rate it for that reason!
Yuki was by far the worst character I've ever seen in my life, but Yuno?? Well, you can just go to Industry form the main page of MAL, then characters, and you will see that Yuno is on of the top 20 favored characters, while Saber is #30 so far (it may change, however, better or worse). If you did not like it, then it is just your taste, which is not a thing that I can judge you for, but don't make your taste tell you what is good or bad. otherwise, there will be a bias in your rating.
But lets talk now about your list, you dropped Fullmetal alchemist after giving it 5/10?? this show has #1 in rating, did you know that?? I have no comment on this. Do you have something to add after reading my whole comment? I'm open for discussion, but I apologize if I, for some reason, replied late. thank you for your understanding.
hello, just recently noticed your comment on my profile (you can check what I posted to the other guy)
Anyway, I gave fate/zero better score than SAO 2S and Shelter, and I have not add Bleach in my list yet!!! so why did you mention them??
Furthermore, Fate/zero has a bad story and character development and people are just being fanboys because of the novel that they were reading before the anime was made!!!
I really hope if there is a better way to discuss about it, if you're open for discussion about animes, instead of making comments in the profile page since it's difficult to be updated.. Still, I'll try to mention that Fate Zero had a great potential but they ruined it with the illogical characters and the weak dialogues. What do you think went good??
All Comments (3) Comments
thank you for not being as retarded as those fanboys on my page..
Opinions are a thing, aren't they? Even in the less important topics such as anime and sports
Anyway, 1st season of SAO were hated for specific reasons:
1- They did not show how did the protagonist leveled up!! They just skipped the best part, sadly.
2- It ended up to be a romance anime in the end which is not a thing that shounen fans, or those that want more action or adventure, like.
For me, I'm a fan of romance anime, and I even like fighting animes like Fate/zero. SAO season 1 had them both and that's why I gave it 9/10
Now, lets review how to rate an anime... Well, I think you know this, but just in case, animes commonly rated based on:
1- story (how logical is the anime. The progression of the story itself, and is it missing any important points from the manga or the novel, etc... Does the story's pace change suddenly or was there a gradual and logical development.)
2- Enjoyment (It is based on your preference, so no one should be judged on this)
3- Characters ( Are they developing? does the character have one dimension or more? does it have a logical development? How many characters are there? Are they given enough space or are they just fillers? Are the characters unique or cliche?)
4- Sound (This one was actually the best thing in fate/zero, the OST, the opening, the ending, the voice actors, the sound effects during the fights)
5- Art ( during the fights and the character themselves. The environment, etc...)
So, as someone how does not like to be biased toward a specific show, I always use these as references when I give a rating, and I suppose you do too.
Now, you mentioned that SAO had Lots of plots hole and irrational characters. Can you tell me some?? BTW, I'm not saying that SAO in a perfect anime, and I might change my scoring if I watched it again, who knows?? Still, I want you to point out the holes and so..
Regarding Shelter, well, this is not even an anime, and I was shocked at how many people talked about it the first time it was aired. It went just viral immediately, even those that don't watch anime at all knew about it!! Are you imagining that? However, I only rated it based on the Sound and art, nothing more. and that's why it got 7, which is not a high score at all..
Now, regarding Mirai nikki. I've watched it 3 or 4 years ago, and YOU WOULD NOT BELIEVE HOW FRUSTRATED I WAS BECAUSE OF HOW STUPID SOME OF ITS SCENES WERE!! Yes, this anime was to me the worst and the best simultaneously, and I was not sure how to rate it for that reason!
Yuki was by far the worst character I've ever seen in my life, but Yuno?? Well, you can just go to Industry form the main page of MAL, then characters, and you will see that Yuno is on of the top 20 favored characters, while Saber is #30 so far (it may change, however, better or worse). If you did not like it, then it is just your taste, which is not a thing that I can judge you for, but don't make your taste tell you what is good or bad. otherwise, there will be a bias in your rating.
But lets talk now about your list, you dropped Fullmetal alchemist after giving it 5/10?? this show has #1 in rating, did you know that?? I have no comment on this. Do you have something to add after reading my whole comment? I'm open for discussion, but I apologize if I, for some reason, replied late. thank you for your understanding.
Anyway, I gave fate/zero better score than SAO 2S and Shelter, and I have not add Bleach in my list yet!!! so why did you mention them??
Furthermore, Fate/zero has a bad story and character development and people are just being fanboys because of the novel that they were reading before the anime was made!!!
I really hope if there is a better way to discuss about it, if you're open for discussion about animes, instead of making comments in the profile page since it's difficult to be updated.. Still, I'll try to mention that Fate Zero had a great potential but they ruined it with the illogical characters and the weak dialogues. What do you think went good??