I stand by the camp that there are no such things as totally objective ratings/reviews since people look out for different things in the works that they consume. While my ratings are subjected to personal taste, I try to back up every score with concrete reasons. I would readily recommend anything that's scored an 8 or above!
What I like a lot:
Trippy psychological shows that mess around with the viewers because they can (just look at my list of favorite anime and you'll know lol)
Rich atmosphere and world-building eg. Shinsekai Yori (!!!)
Works that really utilize the strengths of animation as a medium. Animation literally allows the creators to do ANYTHING unless they have no money, and works that bring out effects unattainable in live action have my respect (like how you can never replicate the beauty of Utena or FLCL in live action) (or any Satoshi Kon work)
What I dislike:
'Psychological' stories that put on the facade of being 'deep' but contain no real substance, often come with pointless ecchi (Mirai Nikki, Elfen Lied etc.)
Chuunibyou wish fulfillment crap to make losers feel better about themselves (which is why we need shows like Eva to give them a hard reality bitch slap in the face)
Feel free to discuss any work with me! (this includes manga even though I've given up on updating my manga list) You can also find me on my Tumblr.