Back to Potterz's Profile Potterz's Profile

When i first read this manga, i thought the story will just be about love between a childhood friend with a possessive main character. So i just read the first 5 chapters in a rush (not reading the entire thing). But, then it got interesting when the FL got a girlfriend, then i thought "WAIT..., i like this kind of story, it reminds me to one of my favorite shoujo manga, heroine shikkaku. And yeah, it is. So i start to be interested and read it with passion.

Story (8/10)
The story is pretty good for me because i like this kind of relationship. I know ... maybe some people doesn't like intense love triangle because it will be painful to read it. But, i really love it. Then, it becomes more interesting with the appearance of the SL as it makes the story more intense.

Art (6/10)
I'm gonna be honest here. The art is not great. The hair is kinda stiff and overall it's not a neat drawing. But, at least the character still has a good proportion and pretty face.

Character (8/10)
First, i'm gonna talk about the MC, nina. At first i thought she's gonna be an annoying shoujo manga girl just like in other shoujo manga where the girl all clingy to the FL, being jealous all the time, and show it to the FL. But, thankgod she is not that annoying. At least, she doesn't show that jealousy all the time and crying all the time. I'm not gonna say that i like her, she is a fine character for me.
Next is the FL, kyousuke. I know many people hate this kind of character (just like Rita in heroine shikkaku), but i don't hate him at all. I love the fact that he is not super considerate about nina like most the FL in shoujo manga does. I think this kind of action gives a space for nina to grow and makes her looks more mature and doesn't become an annoying girl. Not the best boy out there, but i like him
Next is the SL, Miyake-kun. Perhaps he is my favorite character. He is so nice and always shows kindness to nina. That's why i love him. He also blushes frequently and it is cute.
The last one is Yuiko, the bitch in this manga. Well, tbh, i don't think she really is a bitch. I mean, i found a whole lot of bitches in shoujo manga (even the MC in most shoujo manga are bitches who i really2 hates). But, i am fine with her character, she is annoying, but she knows her limit and we need this kind of person in this manga. So, she is fine for me

Enjoyment (8/10)
I read this manga only in 2 days and it count fast to me because i read slowly. The reason i give it a 9 because the first 5 chapters not really appealing and the second reason is because there is something missing there. And that missing thing is the depth of the story. Sometimes when i read shoujo manga i can feel painful and the feeling of the characters, but i don't really feeling it in this manga, so that is what lacking for me.

Overall (8/10)
overall it is a great manga. I really recommend it if u love intense love triangle thing because it will worth your time. It's not boring at all and it makes u wanna read it all the time till u finish it. And the most important thing u don't find a crying, annoying, and bitchy MC in this manga

If u read this review, pls help me found another good shoujo manga because i'm currently out of shoujo manga. thankyou

First of all, i wanna tell you that i don't really wanna read this manga in the first place. But, since i don't have any manga i can read in a while and i'm a sucker for love-hate relationship, finally, i tried to read it.

So, i have known this manga way before i read this. But, tbh, I hate the plot of this manga which is about a love between step-siblings (because for me, it doesn't matter whether u are step-siblings or real siblings. we call 2 people siblings because of the bond, not the blood). But, after all the boringness, finally, i read ... this manga.

Story (5/10)
The story is just mediocre for me. Nothing special and it just a usual shoujo manga with the delinquent perfect boy, idolized by everyone and this cute girl (actually she is not cute for me) who hate this delinquent in the past, but suddenly her mom remarried and she became a step-sibling with this delinquent, so she gradually starts to develop a romantic feeling towards him. It is the kind of story i hate the most in shoujo manga. Not only because they are sibling, but it's also because of the cliche of shoujo i found in this manga (For example all girls in her school idolized this delinquent and will confront anyone who gets close to him. I mean, THIS IS VERY CRINGEEEEEE).

Art (7/10)
it's a good art. not the best though. I don't really like the hair and eyes. Sometimes the eye looked pulled in the middle lol. but, still, it is a good art

Character (4/10)
This is the worst part of the manga. First, let's talk about the MC. Oh god, she is so bitchy. Maybe she acts cute and innocent on the outside, but she is a BITCH. She acts like she doesn't wanna developed more romantic relationship with the FL, but when he avoids her, she became so sad and act like she doesn't want to lose him (i found this kind of plot a lot in shoujo manga). It just disgusts me even more. I mean, if u wanna do something, do it with your full heart, not half-heartedly bitch. Next the FL. He is kinda cute, but still, he acts so stupid. He doesn't care about his new parents and just cares about his relationship. I feel bad for her mom, she trusts her daughter a lot, but she will stab her in the back, what an ungrateful daughter.

Enjoyment (8/10)
well, although i said all that bad things, i still enjoy the series. i finish it only in 2 days which means i still enjoy it (i only finish 24 chapters which already translated into English).

Overall (6/10)
I'm not gonna say it is a bad manga. It just that the plot doesn't really suit my taste and the character is kinda bitchy. U can try it if u like this kinda plot though.

Feel free to read this review. this is my personal opinion about H2O and don't be scared of getting spoiler because i will write "SPOILER" if there is a spoiler. so here we go

Story (9/10)
Tbh, at first, i expect more from this manhwa since other reviews give it a 9 or 8 and this manga also looks interesting in the cover. But, some of the plot doesn't go the way i wanted it to be and that's kinda left a hole in my heart (i mean it makes me feel like there is something kinda wrong). The story is great though. U don't find this ... kind of story often since it tells us about perspective in 6 different people, although not all people got an equal part. Not only that, but u can read several first chapter and u will know that this is not an ordinary shoujo thing, this is different. But, the problem for me maybe because the main character (in this case, i mean the person who got the most story) is not the girl i expected it to be at first (to make it easier lets call her hanako). And the funny thing is the girl that i think will be the MC in this manhwa is the one of the character with the least story. It kinda dissapoint me. Also, tbh, i hope there is a love triangle between hanako and other guys, but it is once again not as i expected and kinda dissapoint me. But, later on i can accept these changes and move on to the story. Believe me guys, when u read it u will have the same expectation as i do at first.

Art (5/10)
For the art, i don't think it is really impressive. The hair is not drawn really well and it is the worst part. i still think it is acceptable, but art maybe is the weakest part about this manhwa.

Character (8/10)
The character is attractive and funny for me. Every single one of them is good in their own way. I think my favorite one was the delinquent guys cuz he is so funny and it just fun seeing him trying hard for his loved one. Maybe the least impressive one is the MC herself, i still like her though compared to many other MC in shoujo manga who is so fucking annoying. It just that she maybe not as appealing as other character. But, she did make a good combination when she is with the delinquent guy.

Enjoyment (8/10)
I quite enjoy reading it and when i read this i just wanna finished it so badly so that it won't affect my study. The reason why i give it an 8 is because there is something that doesn't go the way i want it to be and also the ending is not really the best one. I think 43 chapter is just too short, (SPOILER) There are several parts i wanna see more, like i want to see more of hanako and hong soo, they are so cute together. Also, the nurse and eechan is my favorite couple of this manga, they are so funny and compatible, it is a shame that their love story doesn't have an extra chapter.

Overall (7/10)
Overall, i like this manhwa. Not, the best manhwa i've ever read (well, u can't expect this to beat the amazing "goong"), but i still think it is a good manhwa with serious problem and good drama.

So, i'm gonna try make this review spoiler-free. but, there maybe a little spoiler and in every spoiler part i'll put SPOILER ALERT.So, don't hesitate to read this review.

I love gakuen ouji because it is really enjoyable, i mean i read every single chapter without getting bored even once. it is so funny and refreshing to read it.

Story (7/10)
For me, i like the story because i haven't seen something like this before. It is about a school dominated by girls. But there is 2 parts that i feel like stupid and not needed. (SPOILER) the first one is when this girl named seriha come to ... this school. She is obviously a bitch and pretended to be a nice guy. She share false rumors and all the people in this school believe it, just like any other shoujo manga. I think it is so stupid for a top model to come to this school just to bully the MC (i mean you already success girl, how stupid u can be to just come to someone elses school because ur jealous and bully someone). The second part is the ending, i think the ending was rushed and i found this problem in many other shoujo manga.

Art (7/10)
The art for me, not the best, but it is ok as long as the character looking good

Character (8/10)
I like the character in this manga. The MC is not some type of weak girl who cry all the time (this type of girl makes me wanna slap her straight in her face). The Male lead is also cute and not too cold or something. I like their love hate relationship because it makes this manga so funny and enjoyable to read.

Enjoyment (9/10)
Just like i said b4, i really enjoy this manga and can't stop reading it. I even can't sleep because i keep thinking about it when i try to sleep lol.

Overall (8/10)
Overall, i think this is a good manga and really enjoyable. I think it doesn't matter whether the story is stupid or any other thing because the most important part when u read something is u have to enjoy it.

I know it is a really old manga, but i just read it several days ago and i can say that i enjoy this manga.

Story (7/10)
This is a really long manga and there are so many dramas. But i still think the story is okay since i still enjoy reading it (i can’t believe it i am not bored by this manga at all). The things that keep bothering me to give the story a better score is the fact that the author takes the dramas too far sometimes. (SPOILER) For example, momo, the main character, keep changing her partner between toji and kairi everytime ... she has a huge problem with one of them. The funny thing is This girl is not even trying to find out more about what is really happening and just keep thinking about her own happiness. But the worst drama is when toji has to break up with momo because sae (the villain) threatening him. I know from the first time that kairi is the first male lead, but i never think that the author would pull a plot like this to make kairi and momo together. I think it is a really bad way to break up relationship and it is so unfair for toji, he needs a happy ending too. (SPOILER STOP HERE) Anyway, despite the drama that is so long and too much, i still enjoy every chapter of this manga and i think that is the most important part.

Art (6/10)
If only the author can maintain the art just like the first 20 something chapter i would give it a better score (Maybe she is tired and forgot how to draw the character lol). The art keeps dropping and dropping. When i read it, i realized that the character becoming more like a child (smaller and smaller), especially kairi. At the end of the chapter kairi looks totally different than the first time u read it. He looks more like a cute guy at the end instead of a cool guy. It is a really big dissapointment for me.

Character (8/10)
For me, the character is quite good but not that great. First, lets talk about this MC, momo. I think she is not impressive at all. She keeps worrying over a small thing and doesn’t developed so much at the end of the series. Next is kairi. He is good and so funny, i like how he transform to become a better and more serious. Next is toji. Tbh, i dont see any development in him at all, he is not a bad person to start with though. The last one is sae. I never hate this girl although she did so many bad things and even cross the line. She is funny and makes the story keeps going and interesting. For the role of a villain, she is not that annoying and i think shoujo manga this days have worse MC than this girl (well, i mean look at that MC crying all the time just irritates me).

Enjoyment (9/10)
Like i said before, never even once i bored reading this manga. And i think when u read something. Enjoyment is the most important thing. So, i really appreciate the author for making this manga so fun to read.

Overall (8/10)
Overall it is a really good manga for me since i enjoy it so much. I also love the ending. U must read this manga instead of searching for shoujo manga nowadays which is full of a slut, crybaby, goody two shoes MC.

I start reading this manga after searching through Minami Maki sensei's work, and i found that many people said this manga was her best job, so i tried it. So here is my review...

Story (7/10)
For me the plot is pretty good because i have never read any shoujo manga that talks about being a seiyuu. So it is a quite interesting plot at first. But, for me, the problem here is the feeling that i got when reading this manga and when i finished it. I read it pretty fast at first because it still interesting, but at some point i'm becoming slower and slower. ... I don't think The problem that is developed in this manga is important or you can say that it is kinda forced maybe? And what is worse is the feeling that i got after finished the series. I feel so unsatisfied after reading this, the ending is rushed and there are a lot of things that is not cleared yet to me. So it is really dissapointing.

Art (7/10)
well, the art also not the best in this manga. But, i kinda like the style. The male face proportion is not right for me (maybe too long), but i love the female face.

Character (7/10)
At first i kinda like the character, especially the ML. He has a tsundere character and it is kinda funny to see everytime he blushing. But, at the end, once again i feel dissapointed (i just think he lost this part of him that is interesting and becoming just a normal boy). for the FL, i don't quite like this type of character since the first time i read shoujo manga. She just too cheerful and trying to act strong all the time. I like it when she act strong, but sometimes it just too much that it makes me sick.

Enjoyment (7/10)
At first i enjoy this manga. But, it becoming les and less interesting that i'm not enjoying it as much as i used to.

Overall (7/10)
I know a lot of people love this manga. but, i just don't get the feeling that i search in this manga. This manga still categorized as good for me and i still recommend it if u don't have shoujo manga anymore to read. And to let you know, although this review contain a lot of bad critique about this manga, i still think this manga is better than many shoujo manga i have ever read and i almost give it an 8 if it not for the rushed ending.

tbh, i only read the manga until chapter 30, but still it is a really great shoujo manga. The interesting part for me is the MC who is a boy. He is so nice and likeable. The story so far is really interesting. the art also really cute and the character is the best so far. The female lead is not annoying like in so many shoujo manga, she is strong and unique in her own way. The male (MC) also really great and cute, he is not too cool and sometimes blushing, also doing something funny. I think this is what is lacking in ... so many shoujo manga.

well i have been reading this webtoon since the first time it is released on webtoon. Tbh, my first impression is great, i immediately add true beauty to my favorite webtoon list. I also think that this webtoon have a really high potential to be one of the best and definitely popular (since the art is a legend and the story is pretty good) AT THE BEGINNING. But something did happen, I DROPPED THIS WEBTOON. Tbh, the reason why i dropped is not because i was bored, it never bores me, it just feels too cheesy for me and that's why i dropped it. I ... dropped since there is a show called 'prince of prince' i guess. And tbh, before i dropped it i already don't like this webtoon for quite a time. So here, let me start the review

the reason why i give 4 for the story is because it just keep repeating itself in soooooo many chapters. The beginning is so good and the author has a really great idea about makeup and accepting ur true self. But, what will happenned if the MC already accept herself? how can the story goes on? this is what happenned in this webtoon. The story just go out of the main plot and it becomes more and more ridiculous. it starts when seojun already knows jugyeong face without makeup and after that point on, there are a lot of repeating scene, ESPECIALLY WHEN JUGYEONG CHAT WITH SEOJUN IN PHONE WHICH IS SO CHEESY. So, in short, after that point on the story only tells about makeup thing and keep freezing until the time when suho came.

for the art, u don't have to ask me. It is so great and for me, it is the best of all the manga, manhwa, and manhua i have ever read. And this is the only strong point for me which is really standout and i believe the art is the reason why this webtoon so popular

The character is great AT FIRST AGAIN. jugyeong is nice and funny at the beginning, but as the times goes, rather then development i can say that she's become more childish and getting degraded, and this thing also happen to seojun. I love seojun at first more than suho. But, since he and jugyeong going out, the author keeps making seojun looks like such a bad guy and that's why i don't like him anymore. For suho, i love his personality in the beginning and i think he degraded only a tiny. I still love him though. In short, what is lacking is character development

For the enjoyment, like what i said in the beginning, i still enjoy this webtoon because it is good tbh. It just cheesy sometimes and i enjoy it a lot more in the beginning. Like, when it first released, i love it so so much.

Overall, despite its popularity, i think this webtoon is so so good at the beginning. Idk how the author throws the story that this webtoon change from being sooooo good toooo soooo bad. I do believe that there are a lot of people out there that have the same feeling as me because i have confirmed it with my friends and they also agree.

Not to be disrespectful. I still love this webtoon overall, i just think with such an amazing art which i can't find anywhere else, this webtoon will be completed with a great story as well. That's why i hope the author will make a cooperation with other people who can make a great story, so that it can become a legendary webtoon

i have read a ton of shoujo manga, but only a few manhwa, especially the black and white one ( which i think better than the color one ). First of all, i wanna tell you that, to be honest, i really want to give this manhwa a 9, but my heart telling me to not, so be it.

The story is about a girl who has to hide her identity and act as a boy for a very long time ( you can read the plot ). The story is great for me, but there are several part that is still lacking and ... the author also too cruel for me. The bad side of the story which i think several people also think the same as me is the relationship between hyunbin and yunha. I ship both of them till the end and i know that they love each other so much. But, the storyline just keep going over and over for several times between those two. And one more thing that is kinda stupid for me is hyunbin herself, if she had just revealed herself, i dont think the problem will be so complicated.

The character is good, not great. There are a lot of flaw going on in each character. The one i hate the most obviously yae ha, a stupid girl who has a twisted personality. I actually like hyunbin, she is a poor girl and i feel really sorry for her. Yeah its a good character, but they are just good. The love story is also not so cute.

Overall i think its a really worthy manhwa, u need to read it for sure. The reason i give it an 8 despite of 9 is because i dont feel a strong feeling while reading this which i think is the most important thing when u watch something. I only feel kinda sad and my heart moved just a little but. even (SPOILER) when oong died, i still dont feel so sad, i hope he live though.

well, i start watching this anime only because i run out of anime and i found a review about this anime, so i try it cuz i think its a little bit interesting. tbh, at the first 6 episode i think it's just mediocre, like nothing special, just an ordinary anime about club and other stuff. but, when i entered episode 7, it become quite interesting and it keeps improving until the last episode.
the story is simple, only about a club who is in the verge of disbanding. the art also good but not great. the characters for me are above the average, they have ... their own problem and their personality is so interesting. for the enjoyment, i think i can say that i pretty enjoy watching this anime, because the last 6 episode is just so great for me. well, although i pretty sad about the ending which is not as i expected and want, but at least there is still a chance they can be together in the future, so i tolerate it.
in short, i think it is worth ur time if u want to watch this anime, maybe the first 6 episode quite boring and just so-so, but believe me, it will be so fun later on.