Mar 24, 2017
This manga started out as "ok" and ended as "bad", I guess I'll break it down into story, art, character, and then add a last part for enjoyment and overall rating.
Story: 3/10
The story in this manga started off well, but it became really predictable really fast. In the first half there were a couple twists that got me by surprise, but those started to run low pretty fast once I caught on to some of the hints that are sprinkled in the story arcs. The reader can pretty much tell what happened on the island by the time they find the second or third major
...
clue. This stays pretty consistent throughout the rest of the manga. The reader is fed clues that they can decipher pretty easily, and piece together what is going on. However, towards the end of the manga the author throws in a final twist that doesn't really make sense, and the ending comes pretty fast leaving a lot of plot holes and unexplained loose ends.
Art: 4/10
The art in this manga is sub par to say the least, I didn't find the character design for the male characters to be very appealing, I can only say that really one or two male characters seemed memorable to me as far as their physical appearance went. The girls were decent looking, and being an ecchi manga this is important; however, the ecchi gets really stale in this. What do I mean by that? I mean when the girls are nude their bodies all pretty much look the same. They look good, but they look the same. Also, the ecchi scenes really are all the same. By the time you get to the third scene of the girls taking baths together it just starts to be immersion breaking and you wonder if the author ran out of ideas to make the dialogue interesting. Other than that, there were really no memorable landscape shots that I can recall, so reading for the scenery doesn't seem like a good idea. Overall the art is just okay, it's not bad per se but its just not memorable.
Character: 3/10
This, aside from the ending, is where the manga really drops the ball. I just found the characters to be extremely predictable and stereotypical. The main character is a dude who, for probably two thirds of the manga, doubts his abilities as a leader despite the fact that he leads his group through all their obstacles. This makes it extremely stale when every single time the group faces adversity the main character says to himself, "Oh no, is this it? Can I not get them through this?" and then they use the classic power of friendship to persevere. Other than that, the characters just seem flat out dumb sometimes. The author suspends their understanding of a clue, when it is so painfully obvious what it means. I don't know if this is because the author thought he didn't want to reveal his ideas too soon or what, but it didn't work and it just makes the characters seem mentally deficient. This contradicts other scenarios where the characters will come to a conclusion about something that makes no sense whatsoever. A good example is when the stereotypical "smart kid" calculates an islands distance using the Pythagorean Theorem, despite only knowing the distance of one side of the triangle. Basically, the characters show no continuity with their intelligence.
Enjoyment: 5/10
I cant say that I didn't enjoy reading this manga. There were a couple times where the author did things I didn't expect, and there were a good amount of interesting facts sprinkled throughout that I learned about. It was cool learning about extinct animals I didn't know existed, and the characters seemed to know about some historical events that I learned about because of this manga. Other than that, the entertainment is a shallow type of fun I guess. It's cool to see fight scenes or survival scenes and the ecchi scenes appeal to the primitive human brain. I cant say that I would recommend this but I cant say that I regret reading it either. It wasn't bad enough to drop. I can't stress how bad the ending was though, it really seemed like it must have gotten cancelled or something. There were so many loose ends that never got tied.
Overall rating: 3.75/10 rounded up to 4/10.
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
