May 25, 2024
If you've come across this review, it's probably because you're interested in the work of Joh Araki or Shinobu Kaitani, or because one of your friends has recommended that you read this manga. Either way: it's a good reason.
In my personal situation, it's the first reason why I'm writing this review, even though it's already been a few years since I read the title in French, in a rather uncomfortable physical edition. I've been thinking about this title again recently because a new version of the anime ‘Bartender’ is currently being broadcast. As the latter is more accessible via translation, I had no worries that
...
the manga would soon find a new audience. It's a good thing, because for me, Joh Araki's work has a special flavour.
Sommelier is another manga that I really enjoyed. As there was nothing written about it on the site, I'd like to add my two cents by sharing my impressions of what was a very good read for me.
The manga follows a very talented Japanese sommelier working in France, navigating the complexities of wine culture and personal relationships. In the style of Bartender, the author takes us on a journey between very precise information about the drink in question, wine, and the various situations in which it is all played out. The manga stands out for its focus on the world of wine, a relatively unexplored theme in manga. The in-depth look at the sommelier profession offers an educational angle that's sure to interest you if you're interested in oenology. What's more, as the manga is set mainly in France, it adds an authentic European flavour to the narrative and setting. The manga offers cultural insights into both French and Japanese perspectives on wine. This aspect is particularly significant as it highlights how different cultures appreciate and integrate wine into their way of life. [...]
The writing of the characters is also an appreciable feature of this read. For example, the protagonist is described as a multifaceted character whose evolution is evident throughout the series. His journey from talented sommelier to someone who understands and connects with people through wine adds depth to his character. This aspect is something we regularly find in Joh Araki's manga, and perhaps even more generally among mangakas who have taken an interest in wine. Personally, it's this kind of aspect that interests me most in my reading at the moment.
As for the drawing, that will depend on you. If you're a fan of Shinbu Kaitani's style, you won't mind. However, if you're a fan of Shinbu Kaitani's style, you might be a little put off by the different faces. Personally, I saw quite an effort, particularly in the detail of the wine bottles and even in the scenery. I really appreciated that, although there's still plenty of room for improvement.
Overall, the real problem with this manga is that it's not very accessible. Indeed, the overall story of the manga remains a niche subject in this day and age. Readers with no interest in wine will quickly become bored reading this work. I haven't mentioned the pace of the manga, but although there are only 6 volumes, it's not very dynamic. The manga is aimed mainly at experienced readers who want to discover new and unusual things.
I'll end on a positive note. Sommelier is one of those unusual mangas that you need to try out if you want to complete your reading career. It's a really good manga, with a singular approach to many subjects. The educational dimension and its humour will be the ingredients that will ensure you have a good time. If you're ever curious enough to discover Joh Araki's work, I hope you won't forget this short and engaging work.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
