i might be biased since i'm a fan of Natsuki Takaya's previous work which is Fruits Basket...
even so Hoshi Wa Utau does not deliver to a mainstream audience since the plot is quite slow.the intricateness,the drama is thick but the comedy is thin.dont expect the same humour from fruits basket...
i recommend this manga to those who enjoys a slow but meaningful story;that is hoshi wa utau.
perhaps at an earlier stage you might find the characters typical after all the heroine is a typical cute but foolish girl..but as i thread on the story she grew on me,she has so many flaws but her strong will
...
Alternative TitlesSynonyms: Star Sings, Twinkle Stars Like Singing A Song Japanese: 星は歌う More titlesInformationType: Manga
Volumes: 11
Chapters: 66
Status: Finished
Published: Jun 5, 2007 to Jan 20, 2011
Demographic:
Shoujo
Serialization:
Hana to Yume Authors:
Takaya, Natsuki (Story & Art) Statistics Ranked: #23032 2 based on the top manga page. Please note that 'R18+' titles are excluded. Popularity: #2398
Members: 8,458
Favorites: 118 Resources | Reviews
Filtered Results: 5 / 7
Sort
Your Feelings Categories Mar 4, 2012
Finally finished reading Hoshi ha Utau, by the infamous Takaya Natsuki of Fruits Basket fame. If you've read that manga (not just watched the anime), you'll understand what I mean.
For 9 volumes it was pretty damn good. Straight-forward shoujo. Then the inevitable Natsuki Twist. Made me seethe with anger until the very last chapter, where it rectified it. I'm not sure I'm "over it" yet because it essentially cancels out the rage-inducing twist, but at least it ended well. I guess I'd recommend it if you like some relatively heavy romance. It's slow, almost like Toume Kei pacing,but she's like the exact opposite in which she puts ... Jul 1, 2021
Looking at what other reviewers had to say about this manga, I went in not expecting much more than a good story with a decent ending. Wow was I undersold on this one. Twinkle Stars is genuinely on par with Fruits Basket when it comes to Natsuki Takaya's other works and I'm honestly surprised I never hear people talk about it.
As other people have said, this story starts off slow. We are being introduced to characters and getting some setup to later plot threads but the payoff is well worth it. Takaya is amazing at what she does with story threads and tying certain aspects ... Aug 1, 2014
Hoshi wa Utau is a shoujo manga written by Natsuki Takaya, known for Fruits Basket. While Hoshi wa Utau does not really compare to Fruits Basket, it's still a solid shoujo manga that's really worth a read. Spoilers ahead.
Story: 7 The plot isn't anything really new or ground breaking, but it works well enough and is still enjoyable and engaging. The story is both sad and uplifting at the same time, and Natsuki Takaya manages to balance these elements really well. There was also the twist at the end with Chihiro going back to Tokyo to help Sakura. Although it was obvious that Chihiro and Sakuya ... Jul 4, 2018
To start, I just need to get this off my chest: The English title drives me crazy. Like, it looks like a mistranslation and very obviously should have been 'Twinkling Stars' or something and nobody caught that?! Anyway...
I'll be honest. I picked this one up because I'm a huge Fruits Basket fan. If I wasn't already in love with Takaya's work, the summary never would have caught my attention enough to buy even the first volume to try it out. But I had faith that there was going to be something deeper, and I think that faith was rewarded. The romance really wasn't what resonated ... |