Black Jack

Aug 18, 2010

IceAndCream

Recommended

Dr. Black Jack looks and acts like a gruff ol' doc from some cowboy town. An old surgical scar runs down his face; part of his hair has turned white, and he goes about wearing a big black coat thrown over his shoulders. By the way, he doesn't have a medical license, and charges an arm and a leg (sometimes literally) for his services. Yet still people come to him at his weatherbeaten shack on the hill. Whether hopeless cases that need his incredible skill, or criminals who can't go to a normal hospital.

"He'll only cure you if the price is ... right!" many scoff. Despite his crusty, ugly outside, might he possibly be a good person?

The drama is quite rich. And we cover every type of emotion possible, from comedy to tragedy and in-between. In each new encounter between the Doc and his patients and their families/friends/associates, we wonder which side of his face he is going to turn. Will he be cold and impassive, mercilessly demanding 30 million yen? Will he take on the case for free, or will he do it for some bizarre exchange?

As you might guess, Black Jack isn't as cold-hearted as tries to seem. Sometimes he has to give "tough love" style treatment. The patient may hate what he asks of them, but things turn out for the best in the end. And occasionally, he helps people for no apparent reason. Maybe he really has a heart of gold. He just buries it as hard as he can. Maybe it seems like he can't understand what it means to be chopped up and sewn together, and go through painful years of rehab. But he does. Because he has. After all, that's what that scar on his face, and many more all over his body, are from.

Several stories made me tear up. Like one where he saves a patient, and thereby causes the death not only her, but her entire family. You wonder if his cold outside is to protect himself from those kinds of outcomes. After all, how do you emotionally deal with that kind of responsibility?

Most of the light comedy in the series is carried by a girl (woman??) he essentially saves from the trash heap. In the body of a little girl, and treated like one, Pinoko insists that she is 18 years old, and is Black Jack's wife. Well, that's because they live together. A hopeless case that the Doc adopted to be his own daughter. The Doc would adopt someone!?! Yes, he must be a good person after all.

Each chapter is a self-contained story. At the end of each chapter, I had to pause, and decompress. Most endings are climactic, often with some unexpected twist, whether a tragic turn, happy ending; maybe bittersweet, or something to make you ponder.

The series began publication in the 70's. Lots of social issues from the time are brought up, from racism, women's rights, gang violence, and euthanasia, to animal rights, gender identity, and drug abuse. And other things from dirty politics to artificial intelligence.

Tezuka used his typical art style. It's much more rounded than I usually like for my comics. But I didn't notice it after the first few pages. I was too engrossed in the stories. More annoying was that many of the character designs are repeated for different people. It's like, "Wait, that looks exactly like the guy from two chapters ago!" but it's a different person.

Like any medical drama, it shouldn't be used as a reference for real medicine. Some procedures are impossible even now. And on that note, there are quite a lot of realistic close-ups on body parts that are being surgically worked on (including cut up flesh, knives slicing skin, innards). They don't look gory; mostly like black and white drawings out of medical textbooks. But if you get queasy around that kind of stuff, consider yourself cautioned. Sometimes more gory are the bodies of accident victims. We sometimes see mauled and burned bodies; some of that was a bit disturbing.

A rich and satisfying series about the fascinating character called Black Jack. A tad mature, very engaging, and highly recommended.

Open

Gift

Dec 3, 2016

Kuchisake-Onna

Recommended

I've seen all the Anime adaptations, and read all the Volumes to the Manga, and from what I've witnessed in both the Anime & Manga and Kuro himself has gone through a lot which is what brought about his overall philosophy as a Doctor.

However no matter the circumstance Kuro always goes the extra mile for each patient, whether it be because of a promise, the pay, or because Pinoko insist that he help he'll never give less than his 100%.

Although in actuality it's his moral code and the fact that he owes his own life to a Doctor who took risks that he himself has ...

Open

Gift

Feb 18, 2021

unimportantuser

Recommended

Black Jack is a pretty dope manga. Written & illustrated by the one & only Osamu Tezuka, it ran from 1973 to 1983 & was one of his most successful works as it was running & then became one of his most recognizable overtime. I really don’t know where else to take this intro so I guess we’ll get started. Probably gonna be some spoilers, just a heads up.

Story:

Black Jack doesn’t really have any sort of narrative. It’s an episodic series with self contained stories that don’t really reference each other too much. While I don’t think Black Jack does anything at all to maybe ... convince non-believers or the episodic format or people who just don’t like episodic stuff in general that they’d like it given that the stories really don’t connect to one another aside from maybe a few callbacks. I never the less believe Black Jack’s individual stories are really strong. The main schtick of Black Jack is that the Kuroo Hazama is a black market doctor who goes around charging people (usually shady ones) obscene amounts of money in return for his services. In spite of being unlicensed & infamous for his schtick, Kuroo is actually one of, if not the best surgeon in Black Jack so people would have very good reasoning as to why they would want his services. This set-up isn’t necessarily the most original or creative set-up that could lead to interesting ideas however with stories such as Kuroo treating a whale, the origin story of how he created his technically daughter Pinoko, Kuroo’s origin story on why he became a doctor, etc. Black Jack more than makes up for its premise with some interesting (if at times frustratingly truncated) narratives, memorable characters, & somewhat reasonable pacing of these narratives. I can’t necessarily call every story in Black Jack great or even good, but seeing as we have 243 stories to tell (if you read scans of the official Vertical Comics release like I did) & the vast majority of them are good to great that’s forgivable. Before we move on, I do also need to mention that Black Jack may have some dated aspects or creepily disturbing or to some disgusting stories. There’s one story where this school announcer girl is on the verge of losing her voice so Black Jack treats her but then proceeds to say she can’t use her voice for a year or else the treatment won’t work. This is fine however there’s a scene where this girl who can’t talk almost gets raped by this group of guys. There’s another story that’s about this guy trying to cope with the loss of his girlfriend (or wife, one of those two) & one of his solutions is to then give his dog his GF’s voice to make it seem as if she’s still alive. This then leads to a scene of a little thing called beastiality near the end of the story, youch. Then there’s the way Tezuka presents Black people which, can definitely be seen as uncool to put it lightly. I personally didn’t take much issue with a lot of these topics I’ve just brought up, & in defense of Tezuka I don’t believe he intended for the drawings of the black people to look as stereotypically racist as they can look (at least I hope that was the case). However, I do feel it necessary to warn any potential readers of these aspects as I know some people probably wouldn’t have the level of tolerance towards these aspects that I had while reading the series

Characters:

The characters in Black Jack are pretty good I’d say. They aren’t exactly depp or layered characters necessarily (aside from Kuroo) but they are fun & memorable. Kuroo isn’t just my favorite character in Black Jack, he’s one of my favorite characters overall. I love his design & personality, he has a very cynical outlook on the world, a dark sense of humor, but underneath it all a heart of gold. Kuroo despite charging obscene amounts of money usually ends up treating some of his patients for completely free, rather that be because he gets screwed over or he believes the patient in question he’s treating is a good person true to what they believe in (as cheesy as that may sound). I can also appreciate how he refuses to become a licensed surgeon due to his outlook on hospitals & how money is seemingly more valuable to them than the life of a patient. If I had to bring up one thing I didn’t like about Black Jack, it’s Pinoko. Not that I think Pinoko is a bad character per-say but her speaking mannerisms can be grating because in general when I’m reading a manga, my brain always wants to say what the correct word is supposed to be (ex. Please instead of Pwease). In fairness there is an in universe explanation in the fact that Pinoko is only one & her speech hasn’t fully developed yet, but for an already unrealistic series that can get out there why’d that have to be realistic? Oh well. Anyhow we got characters such as the Whale Kuroo treats. Dr Kiriko, Black Jack’s nemesis who believes in peacefully killing his patients on their death bed rather than try to heal them back up. Joutarou Honma, the doctor who saved Kuroo’s life when he was a child & is there-fore the reason Kuroo became a doctor. Despite having a large cast of characters who largely only show up once I think Black Jack has some highly memorable characters.

Art:

Tezuka’s art style may be an acquired taste for some but if you read my Phoenix review or looked at my favorites list, you can guess that I not only love his art-style, but love Black Jack’s art as well. Black Jack is fairly typical of Tezuka’s art but it’s still really good. You can expect to see some great detailed background art. Creative uses of paneling that create a good sense of flow. Classic disney-esque character art with some really cool character designs that look good on the pages. You can expect some good ol’ Tezuka art out Black Jack like you would get out of Phoenix or any of his other manga. The text to art ratio is pretty good I’d say, Black Jack is still a text heavy series, it on average takes me an hour to an hour & a half to read a volume of Black Jack but Tezuka did a good job balancing it to where there’s just enough text that’s needed for the set-up & good character interactions, but not too much where it becomes a chore to read. If I had to bring another piece of criticism towards Black Jack, it would be the 4th wall breaks. Tezuka loves doing this in his other manga & I’ve never really been the hugest fan of it in any of his manga that I’ve read. Sometimes they can be cute & clever but a lot of the times they can be unnecessary & in some cases take away from the tone of the scene. I don’t think that happens too often in Black Jack to get on my nerves but I was never a fan of it when it did happen. I also need to bring up that if you’re squeamish towards human anatomy or how the inside of the human body looks I guess. You may want to proceed with caution because Tezuka can draw some pretty detailed depictions of human anatomy. I surprisingly didn’t find myself getting that sick actually so I guess it’s not too bad but again, proceed with caution.

Overall

So that’s Black Jack & it’s a pretty cool series I’ve gotta say. From its characters, its art, its passion, the enjoyment I get from reading it. It’s definitely a series I would call a favorite & one I would call a pretty good introduction to the world of Osamu Tezuka. I’m feeling a 9.5 for this one.

Open

Gift

Dec 21, 2015

ItIsIDio

Recommended

Black Jack can be a good choice if you'd enjoy some dramatic stories, even if sometimes they really don't nail it or you'd want to observe how manga used to be written back in the 70's and what was the mentality of the writers back then. As Tezuka touches on a range of subjects, you would easily observe some things about his own mentality and even the industry's back then. Black Jack is a collection of stories from the life of Black Jack, some dramatic, some attempting to be dramatic and becoming comical, some with questionable content, but most interesting and still enjoyable.

The stories ... were rearranged and released in an optimal rather than chronological order. Sometimes this will create some problems for the story, but it will make the story more optimal as the manga wasn't exactly released with a lot of the continuity in mind, but rather some of Tezuka's random ideas. The manga itself started as a horror manga, rather than a drama, so it also helps establish the drama side better.

Back to what I said about drama, some of the chapters nail their drama really well do this really well, but some really fail on it, ending up as silly instead. I assume it's because Tezuka tried to be overlydramatic and illustrate his point through too many coincidental events in the stories or he simply had an idea but he was pressed on time and couldn't come up with any better idea or couldn't hold up well with it. Sometimes you'll even found repeated themes. I think as a result of the fact that at times he tried to take the manga too seriously, he sometimes likes to get the manga to break the fourth wall, either through his own characters or by including himself in the manga.

As for the questionable content I specified earlier, it's pretty much a result of aging. I'll say that some things were different back then and just leave it at that. It's pretty much things you would expect which I doubt could be found offensive, at best you'll find silly, except maybe for the chapters that were removed from the volumes for questionable content themselves. Which I couldn't find and I've heard that they are only in japanese, so, if you know japanese, you might have better luck unraveling exactly what's the peak for questionable content.

Overall the story goes in a lot of places and it can best be summed up as a collection of the more notable stories of the unlicensed surgeon Black Jack. As it goes into a wide variety of themes, the best way I can describe the story is dramatic, as most of the stories are that or are aspiring to be dramatic. Also keep in mind that the story is a collection of stories about Black Jack, so don't expect the manga to have a conclusive ending and be more than just a collection of stories.

The art style is from when manga took great western influences but, for instance, the surgical parts of it are drawn in a moredetailed style, so if you're afraid if there's anything medical that would suffer as a result of the art, do not worry a bit, it won't. If art style is not a big yiff for you but you still dislike it, keep in mind that the overall style of manga was under development. So if you don't generally care much about the art, don't weigh too much on Black Jack's. At the time there wasn't much differentiation in between art styles.

Now, character wise, there's not a whole lot of characters to talk about, as some even if recurring won't be memorable, while some will be. The most developed character in the story is Black Jack, of who's development is best shown inside the chapters themselves, but just in case you might have the wrong idea of what kind of character Black Jack is, he is a medical genius which does not own a medical license, who will operate on you only if you can meet his outrageously high demands. While he does value money, quite a lot, he also does value honesty and integrity and he shows that through his work. There are plenty of layers to Black Jack's character. So don't lose sight of that. Talking about any other characters would be spoilery, but note that they generally aren't bad. They usually are means to an end but some of the recurring characters will be interesting. Just don't expect TOO much from them. Most of the focus is on Black Jack & the drama surrounding his operations and real issues of the time that do apply even today, to some extent.

The stories are very enjoyable even when they don't achieve the purpose they try to set for themselves and what I mentioned as questionable only ends up as silly at best, by no means offensive or disturbing. If you're ever in the mood for a bunch of short stories that travel a great deal of themes, Black Jack is a good choice.

Open

Gift

Black Jack
Edit

What would you like to edit?

Alternative Titles

Information

Statistics

Available At

Resources

Write a Review
Reviews

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

Black Jack Edit What would you like to edit? SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links

Alternative Titles

Information

Statistics

Available At

Resources

Write a Review Reviews

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters

Black Jack
Edit

What would you like to edit?

Write a Review
Reviews