Why Raeliana Ended Up at the Duke's Mansion

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

I've read about a baker's dozen isekai manga/mahnwa, and this is by far the best one. It has drama and romance without being over the top. The plot has intrigue, mystery, and is compelling without being too contrived. Everything is well thought out and the story is well constructed. All of the characters are interesting in their own way, every single one. The twists are well-timed and while you can predict the occasional plot turn, most are welcomed surprises. The only thing that keeps this from being a 10/10 is some pacing issues. There are certain parts that overstay their welcome and I feel like ... the climax and ending of the story are a tad rushed. It's not something that overly detracts from the beauty of this story, but it's something that keeps it from reaching the level of masterpiece for me. It's a high quality story and I highly recommend it.

it's been a long time since i last read it so my memory may be innacurate.

PLOT: the story starts off with raeliana wanting to do something about her ill-fated life as an expendable character in the novel she read. at first glance, it isn't much different from other transmigration manhwas. as the story progresses, it gives clues about the truth behind her transmigration, arguably the main conflict of the story. literally everything that happened to her life as raeliana was because of a certain action of someone who didn't want to remain as a nobody in a novel (it's confusing since i can't really provide ... too much spoilers).

The most memorable is the fact the reason why Noah suddenly liked Raeliana. gotta admit, i liked their dynamic when they were still pretending to be a couple but when noah fell in love, i got turned off. i can't really find any credible reason why he would like her cause i don't consider 'because you're different' valid. to me, it felt forced and that was hard for me to read during the story.

i'd rather not go with the specifics. the story is pretty decent with a few holes here and there, with the biggest one being the romance. the characters are decent as well. not too complex but not too bland either. def one of the better manhwas out there

First off, it needs to be clarified that this manhwa is not 27 chapters. I'm not sure why MAL shows it that way, but there are in fact 158 chapters with the final 11 counting as 'extras'. What ultimately drew me to this was the anime adaptation which only covers the story up to around chapter 50. What happens after, was a very plodding story that introduces several new people, places, and figures without really utilizing them in any gratifying narrative payoff.
The story starts with a modern teenage girl trying to get into college. Her future derails however after she dies and is reincarnated as ... an extra in a popular romance novel from her past life who is fated to die. Using her knowledge of the story, she makes a deal with the main love interest in order to avoid her fate. Without going into spoilers, the story just seems to go where it wants without concern for advancing the narrative. It can't decide on whether it wants to be a rom com with occasional drama, or slice of life. I want to be fair here. The best way I can describe my dissatisfaction is that the story makes a lot of "tight turns" very clumsily. Too many events just "happen" without proper buildup or any future payoff. Up until chapter 50, I was on board with this story. The art is nice and the chibi art for the comedy segments may occasionally illicit a chuckle. However, the most interesting/enjoyable characters like Raeliana's adorable little sister, her stylist Nick Maddox, and Ansley (one of the only female guards) barely get any screen time over the course of the story. I read this over 3 days and I'm struggling to remember anything significant happening between chapter 50 and 90 when the story finally starts to feel like it's moving forward. I wanted to put it down so many times, but that average MAL score (at the time of this writing) 8.19 was too significant to ignore. Again, without spoiling the end, the main reason why the MC reincarnated into this world ends up being pretty silly in hindsight. It doesn't even tie up all loose ends like the fate of certain characters. If I knew how the story would unfold, I would never have read it in the first place. I have to believe that the novel does a better job of covering world lore and fleshing out characters than this. Otherwise it just feels like needless padding. For anyone seeking a better story along similar lines, I would highly recommend "The First Night With the Duke". It's shorter, still charming, not amazing, but it's the same story just told better.