Outshone even Spy X Family?

Jun 25, 2022 9:03 PM

Offline

Apr 2018

101

Only people who like Kaguya-sama are watching the third season of it. I assume people who don’t like the show would have just dropped it during the first season and would not have stuck around for the next 2 just to give them low scores.

Same reason why fruits basket, a niche shoujo, is ranked so high and even hit number 1 briefly. The difference is that Kaguya-sama has the large fan base necessary for it to stay at the top

ZytoepJun 25, 2022 9:09 PM

Jun 25, 2022 9:05 PM

#3

-AirConditioner-

Offline

Dec 2020

156

ofc SxF was mid af nerds hyped it up to heaven

Jun 25, 2022 9:11 PM

#4

AishaBi

Offline

Jan 2021

273

Remocracy said:
Spy X Family was supposed to be the seasonal anime, and it got really high ratings. I’m just surprised Kaguya managed to go even further, because it seemed like everyone and their mom was watching SxF.

SxF never deserved that hype. At the beginning it was good but soon it became repetitive and annoying. Almost every episode just felt like fillers. Even in this season series like summertime rendering, tomodachi game deserved more than sxf.

Jun 25, 2022 9:12 PM

#5

Raph03

Offline

Apr 2022

243

AishaBi said:

Remocracy said:
Spy X Family was supposed to be the seasonal anime, and it got really high ratings. I’m just surprised Kaguya managed to go even further, because it seemed like everyone and their mom was watching SxF.

SxF never deserved that hype. At the beginning it was good but soon it became repetitive and annoying. Almost every episode just felt like fillers. Even in this season series like summertime rendering, tomodachi game deserved more than sxf.

Facts. I love Summertime Render, Tomodachi Game and even Date a Live(a long time fan) more than SxF

Jun 25, 2022 9:15 PM

#6

AishaBi

Offline

Jan 2021

273

Zytoep said:
Only people who like Kaguya-sama are watching the third season of it. I assume people who don’t like the show would have just dropped it during the first season and would not have stuck around for the next 2 just to give them low scores.

Same reason why fruits basket, a niche shoujo, is ranked so high and even hit number 1 briefly. The difference is that Kaguya-sama has the large fan base necessary for it to stay at the top

to like a season, you first have to watch it. People dropped it just because they don't like the genre especially shounen fanboys. And tbh even first few episodes of fmab and gintama wasn't that good as well infact most of the anime are like that.

Jun 25, 2022 9:19 PM

#7

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

AishaBi said:

Zytoep said:
Only people who like Kaguya-sama are watching the third season of it. I assume people who don’t like the show would have just dropped it during the first season and would not have stuck around for the next 2 just to give them low scores.

Same reason why fruits basket, a niche shoujo, is ranked so high and even hit number 1 briefly. The difference is that Kaguya-sama has the large fan base necessary for it to stay at the top

to like a season, you first have to watch it. People dropped it just because they don't like the genre especially shounen fanboys. And tbh even first few episodes of fmab and gintama wasn't that good as well infact most of the anime are like that.

truth mahn fruit basket is one the best romance animes i have ever scn but it hasn't reached the popularity it deserved

Jun 25, 2022 9:20 PM

#8

hinkahinkhurrrr

Offline

Mar 2021

31

I personally loved both, but Spy Fam was more just mindless enjoyable fluff to me while Love is War season 3 had much more compelling characters and a FAR better conclusion (LIW does have 2 more seasons to work off of but even if it were season 1 airing this season I'd still probably prefer it)

Jun 25, 2022 9:22 PM

#9

giezer

Offline

Apr 2021

7

MegaStride said:
This was Kagya’s weakest season. I love Kaguya, but unlike other fanboys who refuse to see criticism of their favorite show, I can tell when it’s not doing the best it can.

Spy x Family > Kaguya S3

I’m surprised you say that. I personally feel like this season was its strongest yet. The humour felt very fresh and unlike any other anime I have seen so far. I genuinely laughed at nearly every episode which I cant say about many shows. I guess that just goes to prove how subjective comedy is.

Jun 25, 2022 9:23 PM

#10

AishaBi

Offline

Jan 2021

273

Badass0123 said:

AishaBi said:

to like a season, you first have to watch it. People dropped it just because they don't like the genre especially shounen fanboys. And tbh even first few episodes of fmab and gintama wasn't that good as well infact most of the anime are like that.

truth mahn fruit basket is one the best romance animes i have ever scn but it hasn't reached the popularity it deserved

atleast kaguya sama has a huge fandom but fruit basket was not just against fmab fandom but against entire shounen fanboys and still they're in top 10

Jun 25, 2022 9:26 PM

#11

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

AishaBi said:

Badass0123 said:

truth mahn fruit basket is one the best romance animes i have ever scn but it hasn't reached the popularity it deserved

atleast kaguya sama has a huge fandom but fruit basket was not just against fmab fandom but against entire shounen fanboys and still they're in top 10

well still hope kaguya can the top position for some more tym the no. of 1/10 has doubled since yesterday

Jun 25, 2022 9:28 PM

#12

Reshiram_IX

Offline

May 2016

930

AishaBi said:

Remocracy said:
Spy X Family was supposed to be the seasonal anime, and it got really high ratings. I’m just surprised Kaguya managed to go even further, because it seemed like everyone and their mom was watching SxF.

SxF never deserved that hype. At the beginning it was good but soon it became repetitive and annoying. Almost every episode just felt like fillers. Even in this season series like summertime rendering, tomodachi game deserved more than sxf.

Just binged all Tomodachi Game. I had low expectations going in. Was just gonna let the series play in the background while I played my Switch, but 3 episodes in I was too engrossed to focus on my switch lol.

Jun 25, 2022 9:29 PM

#13

Wolfie0216

Offline

Feb 2022

3

Remocracy said:
Spy X Family was supposed to be the seasonal anime, and it got really high ratings. I’m just surprised Kaguya managed to go even further, because it seemed like everyone and their mom was watching SxF.

I didn't think it would be able to surpass Spy x Family and yeah it was highly expected to be the seasonal anime but the way Love is war ended this season really outshone spy x family over all, atleast, in my opinion!!!

Jun 25, 2022 9:30 PM

#14

JazzyLovesAhri

Offline

May 2021

70

can we not with the comparison forums? they are both good shows and are in a completely different categories

Jun 25, 2022 9:31 PM

#15

Peeti

Offline

Sep 2019

2168

Zytoep said:
Only people who like Kaguya-sama are watching the third season of it. I assume people who don’t like the show would have just dropped it during the first season and would not have stuck around for the next 2 just to give them low scores.

Same reason why fruits basket, a niche shoujo, is ranked so high and even hit number 1 briefly. The difference is that Kaguya-sama has the large fan base necessary for it to stay at the top

froots bosket hit number 1 and dowvoted below number 1. See the percentage of 1s in small fanbase anime in comparison to big size ones. Easy to downvote small babies.

"I think I wanted to attack something. Like betraying people or hurting people. And, well, it's not exactly nice, but hurting the readers too... In all honestly, I feel that's what I really wanted to do. For me, as a reader, when I think, "this manga will remain in my heart," it means, for example, it phenomenally hurt me: It's those kinds of experiences I'm after." - Pajime Hisayama (My favourite hurting author).

Jun 25, 2022 9:31 PM

#16

KiR4T

Offline

Jan 2021

2550

Kaguya sama has lesser members and is a sequel.

Jun 25, 2022 9:33 PM

#17

A_Random_Pers0n_

Offline

Jan 2022

5

MegaStride said:
One had an ending that reached a climax the other had an “ending” with there being a cour 2 in the Fall

One had a weak beginning but strong end (Kaguya) and the other was strong all-throughout (Spy x Family)

So while Kaguya might’ve shined brighter at the end, Spy x Family was the better seasonal and consistent (Kaguya’s last two seasons were, but def not this one).

Spy x Family > Kaguya S3. If you disagree, just admit recency bias and cope.

Yeah Spy×Family was consistent in the fact that it was consistently mid and had a few good episodes.

On the other hand, Kaguya-sama remained interesting the entire season and had an amazing ending.

So yeah Kaguya-sama was an overall better show.
And it's not recency bias.(Atleast for me)

Also it's just an opinion and ratings seem to say that most people think the same way that's it.

Jun 25, 2022 9:41 PM

#18

Mrboringday

Offline

Jan 2022

234

MegaStride said:
This was Kagya’s weakest season. I love Kaguya, but unlike other fanboys who refuse to see criticism of their favorite show, I can tell when it’s not doing the best it can.

Spy x Family > Kaguya S3

Spy x family this season is like deceiving the audience, you see in the genre it says action but in anime there is no action at all there is only slice of life. I lowered my score from 10 to 8 because I didn't see action in this anime

“Life is never boring, but some people choose to be bored.”

— Wayne Dyer

Jun 25, 2022 9:47 PM

#19

SabreDrago

Offline

Mar 2022

411

Zytoep said:
Only people who like Kaguya-sama are watching the third season of it. I assume people who don’t like the show would have just dropped it during the first season and would not have stuck around for the next 2 just to give them low scores.

Same reason why fruits basket, a niche shoujo, is ranked so high and even hit number 1 briefly. The difference is that Kaguya-sama has the large fan base necessary for it to stay at the top

Yeah it pretty much sums it up. Compare kaguya sama s1 score and spy x family for a more balanced comparison. It's S3 for kaguya sama so all the haters got filtered out. So the only remaining members are hardcore kaguya fans who will spam nothing less than a 10. Even kingdom S4 and S5 have such a high score with a member count of 25k for a similar reason.

Also asking this question in kaguya forum doesn't help. Ask the same question in SxF forum and you'll get contrasting answers.

Jun 25, 2022 9:48 PM

#20

roxy_kouhai

Offline

Jun 2021

908

Remocracy said:
Spy X Family was supposed to be the seasonal anime, and it got really high ratings. I’m just surprised Kaguya managed to go even further, because it seemed like everyone and their mom was watching SxF.

You might be surprised but Kaguya manga readers already predicted that this is gonna be anime of the season. "Even Spy x Family" got me laughing, Spy x Family is good but it's overhyped...it was never even close to beating Kaguya-sama ever since Aka created this arc.

Jun 25, 2022 9:48 PM

#21

SabreDrago

Offline

Mar 2022

411

AishaBi said:

Zytoep said:
Only people who like Kaguya-sama are watching the third season of it. I assume people who don’t like the show would have just dropped it during the first season and would not have stuck around for the next 2 just to give them low scores.

Same reason why fruits basket, a niche shoujo, is ranked so high and even hit number 1 briefly. The difference is that Kaguya-sama has the large fan base necessary for it to stay at the top

to like a season, you first have to watch it. People dropped it just because they don't like the genre especially shounen fanboys. And tbh even first few episodes of fmab and gintama wasn't that good as well infact most of the anime are like that.

So the same applies for SxF. Compare s1 kaguya to SxF and you'll get your answer. Also SxF has more bot 1s than kaguya

Jun 25, 2022 9:56 PM

#22

Mrboringday

Offline

Jan 2022

234

MegaStride said:

Mrboringday said:

Spy x family this season is like deceiving the audience, you see in the genre it says action but in anime there is no action at all there is only slice of life. I lowered my score from 10 to 8 because I didn't see action in this anime

2 things

1. That’s your own expectations’ fault

2. The series does contain action. It’s just focusing more on SoL now. Don’t forget this isn’t 100% an action show, if has small pockets of it spread across the series.

yes you are right that spy x family focuses on slice of life and i think it's good that's why i give it an 8 but it's a shame their only advantage is this, the rest is their action, their romance is very lacking and among them yor is the weakest in character

“Life is never boring, but some people choose to be bored.”

— Wayne Dyer

Jun 25, 2022 10:01 PM

#23

A_Random_Pers0n_

Offline

Jan 2022

5

MegaStride said:

A_Random_Pers0n_ said:

Yeah Spy×Family was consistent in the fact that it was consistently mid and had a few good episodes.

On the other hand, Kaguya-sama remained interesting the entire season and had an amazing ending.

So yeah Kaguya-sama was an overall better show.
And it's not recency bias.(Atleast for me)

Also it's just an opinion and ratings seem to say that most people think the same way that's it.

Only people who unironically use “mid” are children. Strange coincidence.

1) Children don't know the meaning of mid.
2) I guess I have offended someone here.
3) For you I'll say "Spy×Family was just Ok".

I hope you are fine with this

Jun 25, 2022 10:19 PM

#24

A_Random_Pers0n_

Offline

Jan 2022

5

MegaStride said:

A_Random_Pers0n_ said:

1) Children don't know the meaning of mid.
2) I guess I have offended someone here.
3) For you I'll say "Spy×Family was just Ok".

I hope you are fine with this

You haven’t give a single show below a 7

And you are going to give SF a 7

And call it mid

As a 7

L m f a o

I have given shows below 7.

Yes I am not saying SF is bad, it's similar to AOT season 4 part 2. It started of really good, I was invested in it but then got predictable and boring each passing episode.

And also, I don't usually pick up shows that I won't end up liking to some degree, so I have less shows below 7.

I know very well that I give shows a higher ratings usually so you can say my 7s will be your 6s. For me, the gap between a 6 and a 7 is huge and like a 5 and a 6 is nearly the same just slight difference. So for me, a 5 or a 6 means forgettable/dead average. And 7 is Ok. 8 is good 9 is very good. And 10 is perfect. You can decide where you would put mid somewhere in this.

Jun 25, 2022 10:34 PM

#25

s1lvDrag0n

Offline

Aug 2020

131

People who don’t like Kaguya-sama wouldn’t be watching the third season of it. Leading to only the genuine fans to rate it highly, same thing happened with Fruit Basket if I’m not wrong.

Jun 25, 2022 10:42 PM

#26

ThatGuystoff

Offline

Oct 2019

7

SXF Start strong,but now is just entertaining
Kaguya is very good in every moment

Jun 25, 2022 10:45 PM

#27

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

s1lvDrag0n said:
People who don’t like Kaguya-sama wouldn’t be watching the third season of it. Leading to only the genuine fans to rate it highly, same thing happened with Fruit Basket if I’m not wrong.

if its just that kaguya would have got 9.5 + easily

Jun 25, 2022 10:51 PM

#28

gamibo

Offline

Jan 2022

282

Zytoep said:
Only people who like Kaguya-sama are watching the third season of it. I assume people who don’t like the show would have just dropped it during the first season and would not have stuck around for the next 2 just to give them low scores.

Same reason why fruits basket, a niche shoujo, is ranked so high and even hit number 1 briefly. The difference is that Kaguya-sama has the large fan base necessary for it to stay at the top

If Kaguya Season 1 starting episodes were not average then % of People who left after Season 1 would have been 0.9% ....I felt that S1 starting episodes were not that good but it got to whole another level after Chika Dance episode😁.Personally though I feel that Season 2 had the best animation and comedy,hence S2 was the best out of all three seasons for me.

Jun 25, 2022 10:52 PM

#29

xyro14

Offline

May 2020

491

This season of LIW is the culmination of their confession war, it's the awaited moment since S1 so you can't expect it to be not monumental. Spy x Family is all good but as of the moment it's still yet to offer its overarching package

Jun 25, 2022 10:54 PM

#30

revyHOLiC

Offline

Nov 2016

299

SxF was mid, its so simple that new anime watcher can enjoy it

Jun 25, 2022 10:55 PM

#31

EdgyLord666

Offline

Oct 2021

2037

Remocracy said:
because it seemed like everyone and their mom was watching SxF.

Well this is true, SxF still has the highest members. As for score, people already mentioned why, Kaguya is in the 3rd season afterall.

Jun 25, 2022 11:02 PM

#32

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

Kaguya Sama reached its peak in S3 while in case of Spy x Family not a single major event have take place. I am just waiting for Loid's backstory which is peak Spy x Family at the moment.

I think it's better if you compare S1 of Kaguya Sama with Spy x Family S1 lol.

ZXEANJun 25, 2022 11:09 PM

Jun 25, 2022 11:11 PM

#33

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

Badass0123 said:

s1lvDrag0n said:
People who don’t like Kaguya-sama wouldn’t be watching the third season of it. Leading to only the genuine fans to rate it highly, same thing happened with Fruit Basket if I’m not wrong.

if its just that kaguya would have got 9.5 + easily

Do you think everyone will rate it 10/10.

Jun 25, 2022 11:12 PM

#34

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

if its just that kaguya would have got 9.5 + easily

Do you think everyone will rate it 10/10.

nah most will rate 9 or 10 if they r really kaguya fans as u said

Jun 25, 2022 11:12 PM

#35

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

revyHOLiC said:
SxF was mid, its so simple that new anime watcher can enjoy it

It's mid because everyone can enjoy this show ?

Jun 25, 2022 11:14 PM

#36

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

Badass0123 said:

ZXEAN said:

Do you think everyone will rate it 10/10.

nah most will rate 9 or 10 if they r really kaguya fans as u said

Most of them yes ofcourse but there are also people who will rate this show 7 or 8 even though they enjoyed this show just because this starting episode was weak.

Jun 25, 2022 11:14 PM

#37

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:
Kaguya Sama reached its peak in S3 while in case of Spy x Family not a single major event have take place. I am just waiting for Loid's backstory which is peak Spy x Family at the moment.

I think it's better if you compare S1 of Kaguya Sama with Spy x Family S1 lol.

well its better to not compare bcoz i cant c a single point in which spy x is better

Jun 25, 2022 11:15 PM

#38

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

nah most will rate 9 or 10 if they r really kaguya fans as u said

Most of them yes ofcourse but there are also people who will rate this show 7 or 8 even though they enjoyed this show just because this starting episode was weak.

thats like 1% of total wat difference can it make

Jun 25, 2022 11:18 PM

#39

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

Badass0123 said:

ZXEAN said:
Kaguya Sama reached its peak in S3 while in case of Spy x Family not a single major event have take place. I am just waiting for Loid's backstory which is peak Spy x Family at the moment.

I think it's better if you compare S1 of Kaguya Sama with Spy x Family S1 lol.

well its better to not compare bcoz i cant c a single point in which spy x is better

Yes there will always be some minority like you but I am talking about other who loves both the series.

Jun 25, 2022 11:19 PM

#40

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

Badass0123 said:

ZXEAN said:

Most of them yes ofcourse but there are also people who will rate this show 7 or 8 even though they enjoyed this show just because this starting episode was weak.

thats like 1% of total wat difference can it make

Score below 9.5 I guess.

Jun 25, 2022 11:19 PM

#41

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

well its better to not compare bcoz i cant c a single point in which spy x is better

Yes there will always be some minority like you but I am talking about other who loves both the series.

nah mahn i gave spy x 9 i loved the show but if we talk abt animation, direction, sound, op , ed then

Jun 25, 2022 11:21 PM

#42

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

thats like 1% of total wat difference can it make

Score below 9.5 I guess.

9.5 is a score if i remember correctly only almost reached by gintama only if kaguya could reach that i would be surprised

Jun 25, 2022 11:24 PM

#43

emolano

Offline

Feb 2018

207

Spy x Family adaptation was a let down. Considering how popular it got, I bet SxF would have at least the second place locked up have it received the direction it deserved.

Jun 25, 2022 11:26 PM

#44

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

Badass0123 said:

ZXEAN said:

Yes there will always be some minority like you but I am talking about other who loves both the series.

nah mahn i gave spy x 9 i loved the show but if we talk abt animation, direction, sound, op , ed then

I don't want to compare but Spy x Family direction, Soundtrack by Know Name and Animation by Wit and Cloverworks was simply outstanding. Spy x Family anime excited the manga in term of quantity.

Jun 25, 2022 11:32 PM

#45

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

nah mahn i gave spy x 9 i loved the show but if we talk abt animation, direction, sound, op , ed then

I don't want to compare but Spy x Family direction, Soundtrack by Know Name and Animation by Wit and Cloverworks was simply outstanding. Spy x Family anime excited the manga in term of quantity.

dude have u scn kaguya sama well i liked spy x manga better

Jun 25, 2022 11:33 PM

#46

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

emolano said:
Spy x Family adaptation was a let down. Considering how popular it got, I bet SxF would have at least the second place locked up have it received the direction it deserved.

so true mahn its manga is better in most parts

Jun 25, 2022 11:33 PM

#47

ZXEAN

Offline

Sep 2020

5898

Badass0123 said:

ZXEAN said:

I don't want to compare but Spy x Family direction, Soundtrack by Know Name and Animation by Wit and Cloverworks was simply outstanding. Spy x Family anime excited the manga in term of quantity.

dude have u scn kaguya sama well i liked spy x manga better

I have seen Kaguya Sama. I like Spy x Family anime better.

You you have time just check this out.

ZXEANJun 25, 2022 11:40 PM

Jun 25, 2022 11:35 PM

#48

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

dude have u scn kaguya sama well i liked spy x manga better

I have seen Kaguya Sama. I like Spy x Family anime better.

well anyway it was niz talking to u but i still think spy x could have been much better if they got as much love as a1 gave kaguya

Jun 25, 2022 11:37 PM

#49

Badass0123

Offline

Oct 2018

104

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

dude have u scn kaguya sama well i liked spy x manga better

I have seen Kaguya Sama. I like Spy x Family anime better.

You you have time just check this out.

ZXEAN said:

Badass0123 said:

dude have u scn kaguya sama well i liked spy x manga better

I have seen Kaguya Sama. I like Spy x Family anime better.

You you have time just check this out.

ok mahn👍👍🙂

Jun 25, 2022 11:37 PM

#50

nishant0

Offline

Nov 2021

2466

Kaguya Sama is sequel and spy x family is not so it’s not surprising but you can compare spy x family with the first season of kaguya Sama.

Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Kronweber - Jun 25, 2022	536	by StuartMckngTown »» Oct 2, 7:02 PM
Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) Stark700 - Jun 17, 2022	234	by NadiaEros »» Sep 14, 5:19 PM
Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Stark700 - Jun 10, 2022	198	by NadiaEros »» Sep 14, 5:18 PM
Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) cchigu - Jun 24, 2022	428	by topfloorboss45 »» Sep 1, 1:28 PM
Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) cchigu - Jun 3, 2022	199	by topfloorboss45 »» Sep 1, 11:40 AM

Outshone even Spy X Family?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai: Ultra Romantic Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters