| Before i watch this i already has low expectation. But in the end the quality is still blow me away. Its F***ing lower than i expected. First of all whats with that CandyCrush eye, it looks like the director wanna Crush author's dream(feel sorry for him tbh). The animation, oh maaaan dafuq is that, looks like Nanatsu no taizai has competitor Conclusion go for the manga, Seriously |
xavien54 said: Before i watch this i already has low expectation. But in the end the quality is still blow me away. Its F***ing lower than i expected. First of all whats with that CandyCrush eye, it looks like the director wanna Crush author's dream(feel sorry for him tbh). The animation, oh maaaan dafuq is that, looks like Nanatsu no taizai has competitor Conclusion go for the manga, Seriously Nanatsu no Taizai has a competitor is preety good comparison XD . |
"We are all like fireworks: we climb, we shine and always go our separate ways and become further apart. But even when that time comes, let's not disappear like a firework and continue to shine.. forever ." |
| Manga version of LNs are like 99% of the time inferior to the LN in every way possible. So the LN is probably even better. |
 |
xavien54 said: Before i watch this i already has low expectation. But in the end the quality is still blow me away. Its F***ing lower than i expected. First of all whats with that CandyCrush eye, it looks like the director wanna Crush author's dream(feel sorry for him tbh). The animation, oh maaaan dafuq is that, looks like Nanatsu no taizai has competitor Conclusion go for the manga, Seriously Indeed, manga looks absolutely clean compared to the anime. When I saw the way the animated Livia and Angie I was frustrated and it didnt change a single bit after watching the anime |
MadanielFL said: Manga version of LNs are like 99% of the time inferior to the LN in every way possible. So the LN is probably even better. LN doesnt have drawings only few ilustration so no |
xavien54 said: And the manga has:MadanielFL said: Manga version of LNs are like 99% of the time inferior to the LN in every way possible. So the LN is probably even better. LN doesnt have drawings only few ilustration so no inferior art Inferior dialogue Is far behind the LN release. Inferior narrative (they literally have to cut all the non-dialogue text). The LN is always superior to the manga in every way possible, its the original way the story was meant to be consumed, the manga has to cut all the narrative and dialogue into something smaller so it can fit in the manga format. |
|
| I read the first three chapters to see if my opinion on manga has changed, and nope, still fucking garbage and inferior to almost all animation. Manga purists are always angry or saddened because they've already seen the whole story once over, so everything that is adapted immediately makes less of an impression on themselves and if every trivial BS thing isn't added to the anime, they start to scream and rage about how their beloved manga has been butchered lol... Anime brings black and white scribblings to life, adds dimension and makes it ten times better. The average animation >> the top manga. If I wanted to read something, I sure as hell wouldn't read what's pretty much equivalent to a picture book lol, at least with a novel, your imagination runs much more wild, because they don't give you anything other than words. The only thing better than their counterparts are H doujins XD |
GakutoDeathGlareApr 17, 2022 8:52 PM
| Of course the manga is better, that's like saying reading the lord of the rings novel is better than the movie, of course it is, you can't get some of the nuances in a visual media as well as a text media. That said, the real problem i have is people claiming the anime is bad, so far the anime hasn't really gone too far from the source and has only cut things that can be cut, the anime is fine imo, better than i expected tbh (except the animation, the manga's art is legendary, the anime's is average to subpar). |
MadanielFL said: And the manga has: inferior art Inferior dialogue Is far behind the LN release. Inferior narrative (they literally have to cut all the non-dialogue text). The LN is always superior to the manga in every way possible, its the original way the story was meant to be consumed, the manga has to cut all the narrative and dialogue into something smaller so it can fit in the manga format. No, i know that LN is far superior telling story than manga. But manga is more enjoyable to me even the story cut in half. Imagine Harry potter or Game of throne has comic, it will be awesome. Anyway Depend on the artist+author, if it bad manga i wont read it |
xavien54Apr 18, 2022 4:35 AM
GakutoDeathGlare said: I read the first three chapters to see if my opinion on manga has changed, and nope, still fucking garbage and inferior to almost all animation. Manga purists are always angry or saddened because they've already seen the whole story once over, so everything that is adapted immediately makes less of an impression on themselves and if every trivial BS thing isn't added to the anime, they start to scream and rage about how their beloved manga has been butchered lol... Anime brings black and white scribblings to life, adds dimension and makes it ten times better. The average animation >> the top manga. If I wanted to read something, I sure as hell wouldn't read what's pretty much equivalent to a picture book lol, at least with a novel, your imagination runs much more wild, because they don't give you anything other than words. The only thing better than their counterparts are H doujins XD Why people that like the manga version for specific source is purist ? I dont understand people like you. Your way of thinking is so inferior I never said i like mangas better than animes. Even i agree LN is always superior for telling story than manga or anime. I guess ex-arm is considered good to you because it has voice acting and animation lmao. |
xavien54Apr 18, 2022 4:40 AM
xavien54 said: You must have missed where I said "almost all animation" and "the average animation" lol. Does Ex Arm fall into those categories? I don't think so. GakutoDeathGlare said: I read the first three chapters to see if my opinion on manga has changed, and nope, still fucking garbage and inferior to almost all animation. Manga purists are always angry or saddened because they've already seen the whole story once over, so everything that is adapted immediately makes less of an impression on themselves and if every trivial BS thing isn't added to the anime, they start to scream and rage about how their beloved manga has been butchered lol... Anime brings black and white scribblings to life, adds dimension and makes it ten times better. The average animation >> the top manga. If I wanted to read something, I sure as hell wouldn't read what's pretty much equivalent to a picture book lol, at least with a novel, your imagination runs much more wild, because they don't give you anything other than words. The only thing better than their counterparts are H doujins XD Why people that like the manga version for specific source is purist ? I dont understand people like you. Your way of thinking is so inferior I never said i like mangas better than animes. Even i agree LN is always superior for telling story than manga or anime. I guess ex-arm is considered good to you because it has voice acting and animation lmao. |
xavien54 said: Before i watch this i already has low expectation. But in the end the quality is still blow me away. Its F***ing lower than i expected. First of all whats with that CandyCrush eye, it looks like the director wanna Crush author's dream(feel sorry for him tbh). The animation, oh maaaan dafuq is that, looks like Nanatsu no taizai has competitor Conclusion go for the manga, Seriously Erm.... Actually..... The Live Action Is Better..... Erm.... You Wrong.... The Manga Sucks..... Erm....... Go Watch The Live Action Instead..... Erm....... |
| I think the anime is great. The voice acting is great, the story is interesting and the animation is decent. The unique eyes you just gotta get used to and for me it just sets it apart from other series. Anime adaptations at the end of the day exists to be advertisement and it did make me start reading the manga(up to date now) and I'll eventually read the novel too when I've finished my current readings. |
  |
| We already have a topic, not even one week old, telling exactly this. Why the hell do you feel your opinion is important enough to create a separate one? To don't make offtop, I'll just copy my answer from previous one: ThirteenEleven said: I've read my share of manga, LN and VN, so I'm not some anime-only purist. And let me tell you that manga readers going to anime forum and telling anime watchers to go read manga is one of the more annoying behaviours I keep seeing on MAL. I'm watching anime because... I want to WATCH ANIME. Then I rate it what it deserves as an ANIME. When I want to read manga, I search for one. Tbh sometimes I think adaptation discussions (like skipping or changing stuff) should be done in source material's forum, not adaptation's. |
| For me the anime isn't that bad it is tolerable but I also read the manga for the parts that anime didn't cover so I have no complain about it besides the story is pretty much the same so the animation didn't hindered me from enjoying the anime adaptation |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Otome Game Sekai wa Mob ni Kibishii Sekai desu Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 22, 2022 |
86 |
by itz_hamzakhan
»»
Today, 2:06 AM |
|
» Less fav genres are romance and mecha. Why did I love thisAvamarie316 - Oct 3 |
11 |
by Yeshaiah2015yesh
»»
Oct 4, 11:22 PM |
|
Poll: » Otome Game Sekai wa Mob ni Kibishii Sekai desu Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Jun 19, 2022 |
172 |
by Thyriad-oPPailov
»»
Aug 18, 10:11 AM |
|
Poll: » Otome Game Sekai wa Mob ni Kibishii Sekai desu Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jun 12, 2022 |
102 |
by Thyriad-oPPailov
»»
Aug 18, 9:32 AM |
|
Poll: » Otome Game Sekai wa Mob ni Kibishii Sekai desu Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - May 8, 2022 |
132 |
by Thyriad-oPPailov
»»
Aug 17, 11:36 AM |