Attack on Titan
Which is better?
Season 4!!!
26.0%
141
Season 3 part 2!!!
74.0%
401
542 votes
| S4 suffers from a lot of technical stuff so I obviously think S3 is better . But that doesn't mean S4 is bad , its still very good , in fact I would even say the writing got better . |
| S3 Part 2 was masterpiece, whereas S4 Part 1 was just a plot for the S4 Part 2. So, my bet is that S3 Part 2 is better than S4 Part 1 whereas S4 Part 2 mostly will be better than the both and probably the best AOT Season. |
 |
| In terms of: Directing: Both Animation: S3P2 Visuals: Both Character Design: 50-50 (both had ups and downs) Consistency of quality: none (both had ups and downs Soundtracks: S3P2 Plot: S4 Characters: S4 Flow of Story: S4. Overall: S3P2. |
 |
| Ok so how does this matter again? The huntertards? The cgi haters? |
 |
| Yeah aot 3 is better action and animation wise. But season 4 is definitely better story wise I think story should be the top priority😬 |
 |
CrazyCatMan123 said: What do you think is better and why? Personally imo season 4 characters development is phenomenal and is unmatched by any other season, and the OST of season 4 is amazing! Season 3 however is a masterpiece in everything else, however I think if MAPPA had as much time as wit they could rival the quality of Season 3! Completely agreed |
| Who cares? It's MAL scores, literally irrelevant. |
 |
| The season 3 part 2 fans are spamming season 4 with 1s so their favorite season can be above it. What a disgusting fanbase |
 ManWild |
badmintona said: homie what are you talking about?? you're literally pulling shit out of your assBad CGI, Bad direction, Bad Opening, Bad soundtrack. A good story can't fix all the problems above. + the toxic fans and the overhype. they even started to hate on the previous seasons to make season 4 looks good, but now after s4 ended, those kids are now opening their eyes. |
ManWild said: The season 3 part 2 fans are spamming season 4 with 1s so their favorite season can be above it. What a disgusting fanbase This is such a sad reality we live in. No Mappa love. |
 |
Johan3333 said: I mean there was other action but still the rock throwing part was good action at least to me.Kaliyahscake said: Yeah aot 3 is better action and animation wise. But season 4 is definitely better story wise I think story should be the top priority😬 Action wise? Lmao, you mean nearly five episodes of the beast Titan throwing rocks at the survey corps is the better action? |
|
Apocalypto said: I dont get it, so people decided to raise their rating of S3P2 after watching S4. Why? after season 4 AoT got extremely populer, so people rated it more and all the seasons got higher, season 3 part 2 got higher too, but it stopped at one point (9.11) and then after people completed season 4, they lowered down the score ( from 9.16 to 9.11 and will probably go down to 9.08 or something like that ), i also lowered it down because i thought they will adapt right to 122 thats why i gave it 10 but since they didn't then its a 9. |
DayyanoEYEApr 3, 2021 5:04 AM
| U-Y-P-W-O-C-U-T-I-K-A-T-I-P-M-I-N-I-I-D-I-H-I-W-T-S-T-I-W-S-T-O-M-P-T-I-L-U-C-H-N-I-D-T-I-I-Y-I-M-N-O-W-S-T-S-W-N-I-B-W |
Mack_Yeager said: Kiyotaka696 said: after season 4 AoT got extremely populer, so people rated it more and all the seasons got higher, season 3 part 2 got higher too, but it stopped at one point (9.11) and then after people completed season 4, they lowered down the score ( from 9.16 to 9.11 and will probably go down to 9.08 or something like that ), i also lowered it down because i thought they will adapt right to 122 thats why i gave it 10 but since they didn't then its only a 9. What happened to the Marley arc ha?? What about that ,you forgot about that ha,the build up and the 4 episode bomb shell ,imo the most hypable part of 4 ,then you had the last 6 episodes of complete crazyness And to top it off the cliffhanger at ep 16 And after all that it gets a 9 ,really ?? ,You are underrating it ,I am sorry ,but all you people are underrating it ,and I still don't get why S3 p1 and s2 are so low in rating are you serious? you actually saying 9 is low? |
| U-Y-P-W-O-C-U-T-I-K-A-T-I-P-M-I-N-I-I-D-I-H-I-W-T-S-T-I-W-S-T-O-M-P-T-I-L-U-C-H-N-I-D-T-I-I-Y-I-M-N-O-W-S-T-S-W-N-I-B-W |
Johan3333 said: Okay that’s YOUR opinion and I’m gonna have mine aot only had 10 episodes but I still think it did better than aot season 4 not to say season 4 was bad or anything. I already said it was my opinion I’m not really trying to get I a argument or discuss sooo I’ll end it here :/Kaliyahscake said: I mean there was other action but still the rock throwing part was good action at least to me. The other action Levi massacring Beast Titan for not less than 2 minutes Reiner vs Eren Mikasa and co vs Reiner The other actions aren't even worth mentioning. Levi massacring the beast Titan like the context says was just that simple, it was hard carried by animation. Reiner vs Eren was shit even in terms of plot and animation, that 40 second match between them in Marley>>>> Mikasa and co vs Reiner was lame and borderline cringe only the animation and music made it bearable In the end, Season 3 part 2 just had better animation and music direction while the plot or the action context was mid. I'd even go ahead to say it had the weakest action of the entire series. |
|
| Good to see s3p2 back above s4 |
| S3P2 supremacy, you love to see it. |
 |
| nahhh Season 4 is better |
Rect0r said: Lol it didn't took it over it's just that season 4 went lower(which is should) Why should it? I'd say this is the best aot season, for now. s4p1 had a great story and better characters with better development and more complex, but all this was only in the first part (ep 1-8), which I consider incredible, but the second part became slow in which they talked too much about some things unnecessary and lengthened (I have not seen the last 3 chapters but I know what will happen). In addition, there was a drastic change in the art style along with the animation that is not to everyone's liking. and then this s3p2, which has everything i said, action, story, incredible pace, epicity, great characters (erwin, grisha, kruger, levi, armin, etc), the return of shiganshina is a great arc that everyone loves , because of how intense and epic it is, the revelation of the basement that left us all shocked because it changed everything perfectly what we had thought. Grisha's story that made us understand everything and unite the threads of history and the end of the beginning , which would be to see the protagonists go to the sea and play there for that final moment of eren pointing towards the horizon wondering if by defeating the enemies they will achieve freedom. This is just my opinion of why I consider s3p2 the best so far, because it has everything that is SNK, maybe I will change my mind when s4p2 is released and believe that this is the peak of AOT (although I already have many spoilers of that lol) |
 a wise user of MAL said: Just to clarify, adaptations should absolutely stand on their own |
racers551 said: You can say that, and I can say it sucked.MasterNeutral said: Good to see s3p2 back above s4 Why? In terms of story, I wouldn't even say season 3 part 2 comes close. |
racers551 said: I don't care about how it looks S3P2 could look like berserk 2016 for all I care and I would have rated it the same. One big thing I can't stand this season is all the new characters it's developing as if I care at all about them, it's boring af and no before you suggest I need mindless fighting to keep my attention blah blah My favorite anime are Monster and Texhnolyze, as long as what is going on I find interesting slower pace is A ok. There's just nothing so far this season I found interesting to keep me here, I dropped it after ep 6 I think and just asked my friend for spoilers about what's happening in the manga and apparently it's also garbage so w/. I got all I needed from this series no reason to continue.MasterNeutral said: You can say that, and I can say it sucked. No, how did it suck? The story, which is what I'm mostly focusing on, was way better. Also, forgetting the Colossal titan? That was cgi, and it was nowhere near the cgi for the titans in season 4. The season 4 ones were beastars level, whereas the one in season 3 part 2 was so stiff. |
MasterNeutral said: You can say that, and I can say it sucked. No, how did it suck? The story, which is what I'm mostly focusing on, was way better. Also, forgetting the Colossal titan? That was cgi, and it was nowhere near the cgi for the titans in season 4. The season 4 ones were beastars level, whereas the one in season 3 part 2 was so stiff. |
a wise user of MAL said: Just to clarify, adaptations should absolutely stand on their own |
ManWild said: The season 3 part 2 fans are spamming season 4 with 1s so their favorite season can be above it. What a disgusting fanbase What a disgrace.. Acting like it's not the same show.. I think we all need to chill. Both seasons were phenomenal, but in different aspects. You are entitled to have a favorite, that's for sure, but be happy about one overtaking the other? Are we going to start score wars within the same fandom? Like come on this is the same show, and we made it this far, so can we stop this nonsense already? I would personally love to see both at the top because both are masterpieces and had so many strong points. Let's not bring this fandom's reputation any lower. Mod Edit: Merged duplicated posts; please use the edit button. |
KuniiApr 9, 2021 7:06 AM
| I sometimes forget to finish my sentences. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » What is your LEAST favorite episode?Enri_eu - Sep 25 |
6 |
by Rishabh_452
»»
Yesterday, 8:06 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 23, 2019 |
411 |
by graciana
»»
Oct 4, 6:49 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 9, 2019 |
417 |
by mateben
»»
Oct 4, 7:47 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Thorf - May 26, 2019 |
746 |
by Goxist
»»
Sep 21, 4:35 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 16, 2019 |
551 |
by ShinyPuppy
»»
Sep 14, 11:39 PM |