[spoilers] This can't be happening........ no way this is real

Dull_Lull said:
I know I should wait and watch the movie before judging but based on the spoilers I've seen and read, they fucked up so many scenes with this adaptation. They removed Rider and Rin from the last part, literally paid Illya's character dust, and apparently removed the monologue from the Nine Lives scene??? What the hell is even going on here. Haven't heard news of Kirei yet but if they also fucked up his character then that's going to be the final nail in the coffin for me.

On a brighter note, the Salter vs Medusa/Shirou fight looked dope.

Dull_Lull said:
I know I should wait and watch the movie before judging but based on the spoilers I've seen and read, they fucked up so many scenes with this adaptation. They removed Rider and Rin from the last part, literally paid Illya's character dust, and apparently removed the monologue from the Nine Lives scene??? What the hell is even going on here. Haven't heard news of Kirei yet but if they also fucked up his character then that's going to be the final nail in the coffin for me.

On a brighter note, the Salter vs Medusa/Shirou fight looked dope.

HaroldT15 said:
Hey dull_lull just watch the fcking movie. And you'll understand why. You dont have my respect if you watch illegally. This is still an early rating for me it should be at least 8.5-10

Dull_Lull said:


Fly me to Japan then so I can watch it.

HaroldT15 said:


Get a job. Lol what a useless weeb.

HaroldT15 said:


Get a job. Lol what a useless weeb.

Dull_Lull said:


Never mind. Found a camrip <3

ssjokg said:
i suggest to not watch it. Skip around to get an idea but dont ruin your experience, especially with the fights.

iiTzSawu said:
Where can I watch the movie?

Dull_Lull said:


Couldn't even get past 10 minutes. RIP. I really can't enjoy it fully without understanding shit unfortunately.



It's a camrip though with no subs.

Dull_Lull said:


Couldn't even get past 10 minutes. RIP. I really can't enjoy it fully without understanding shit unfortunately.



It's a camrip though with no subs.

RuriNeko said:


There have been people who haven't watched spreading a lot of misinformation. Based off of those who did watch the movie, the movie sounds really good. They said that as opposed to the previous 2 movies which mostly focused on Sakura, this one gave more time to all of the characters. People who watched it said Illya had enough screen time and her last scene was done REALLY well (it was word-for-word, from what I've heard.) All of Kirei's scenes were intact (they even had his flashback with his wife Claudia killing herself and Kirei saying he wished he could've killed her,) and the movie took some time to draw parallels between Shirou and Kirei early in the movie to set up the final fight. The final fight has most of the dialogue intact, although some of the philosophical conversation before the fight is moved to during the fight (the fight itself is the exact same as in the VN, a brutal fistfight.) Some of Shirou's "memory loss" made it into the movie as well. The 3 founding families showed up in the movie and Zelretch has some dialogue too.

Nine Lives didn't have most of the monologuing, from what I've heard, but everyone seems to be satisfied with how it was done (people say it was portrayed well enough visually that they weren't really miffed about how the monologues were cut out. They say the metaphorical wind scene with Archer was really good too.) For the epilogue, Rider and Rin are definitely present, but there isn't a recreation of the last CG in the route, it is Shirou and Sakura walking side-by-side.

There were a lot of people on 4chan who didn't watch the movie and were trying to troll others into thinking that certain things were cut out, though, or went crazy about what they thought was cut out.

Aure0lin said:
for some reason the camrip was removed from nyaa, i saw some segments and im still disappointed at no light and darkness
they couldn't even get this part right

Fireblazze said:

What is a CG in anime? Is it important to the adaptation?

Emblemz said:

I saw that bit but that's not something they were ever going to convey because the movies hardly use monologues. Aside from the ost choice, I think it was fine. Though I'm reserving my actual opinion for the BD

Emblemz said:
Which isn't really a big deal tbf if you're not going into detail with a monologue on why hitting his head is a no no. I don't think it exceeds the source but it isn't reducing it either. Its fine but ill reserve judgment later

Aure0lin said:
it's fine if ufo manages something just as good but i felt that ufo's version took a lot of tension out of the scene. visual adaptations also shouldn't directly copy a monologue anyways but should still visually communicate the same ideas expressed through the monologues

ssjokg said:
People here expecting a 2 hour movie to adapt every scene faithfully because that is somehow doable.

KtKr said:


It's better that they complain now after watching parts of shitty chinese camrip so they lower their expectations for the actual movie and don't whine about it when BD will finally be out.

ssjokg said:
This is a Fate adaptation.You know that they will be whining for years.

FireFistYK said:


This is so true! I'm a huge fan of the VN and I don't get how people don't see that Fate/Stay Night got one of the best VN adaptations ever? The only adaptation that's better is Steins Gate and maybe Clannad

I adore all of Ufotables works when it comes to Fate because they've done an amazing job with most of them. There are obviously some faults here and there (mainly Shirou inner monologues in UBW and cutting out Illya in HF) but people can't expect them to deliver 1-1 adaptation

PraiseTheSun123 said:


Because Steins;Gate didn't skip anything important. Most of what was adapted is enough to make the story and characters work (otherwise it won't have a 9.13 score yk).

The only things of relevance that weren't adapted are some additional explanations about Reading Steiner and the explanation of why there was a connection between the lab and SERN.

ssjokg said:
And nothing was missing from FSN's adaptations that would make it hard to understand what is happening or how Shirou things.

ssjokg said:
and how much protection Okabe has because of the attractor field

2000yearoldloli said:
Yes, omitting more than half of one of the most iconic scenes in the entire VN definitely doesn't affect the story at all, and if you're not satisfied about it you're just nitpicking.

This kind of baseless positivity and praise is just as bad as unnecessary negativity.

2000yearoldloli said:
Yes, omitting more than half of one of the most iconic scenes in the entire VN definitely doesn't affect the story at all, and if you're not satisfied about it you're just nitpicking.

This kind of baseless positivity and praise is just as bad as unnecessary negativity.

Kokorowagurasu said:
I don't have much to complain about the movie. I still need to watch it with english subs to fully understand it. With my current japanese level I could understand something in between 70~80% (something I could get by context), I had my japanese friend explain some of the harder parts to me.

It was a lot more story focused than the last two movies, and the first fight scenes were a bit lackluster, but alter saber vs rider was probably the best fight scene I have ever seen in the series (at least animation wise) so it make up for the other ones. Shirou vs Kotomine and Kotomine vs Assassin / Zouken was also pretty cool.

I did not like some parts of the soundtrack, the scene where Shirou was running "inside" the UBW, they had an EDM music instead of a more epic-ish song, which I did not like much. Still the movie was great!

Also, some of the dialogues in some parts were a bit "Japanese anime cliche" imo, but just some small parts.

Askaa said:

by running inside the UBW you mean the wind scene ??
if that what you are talking about then they were playing Emiya theme and its a pretty iconic theme
in fact most of the fans were hoping that they well play that theme in the movie

Kokorowagurasu said:


Yes, I think we are talking about the same scene. I have been away from the series for quite awhile so while it felt familiar, I did not recall it from the other movies or the anime. I personally felt that of of the Aimer songs would fit better there, but that is just me! If it is one of the iconic songs from the series it totally makes sense!

I feel like I should go and watch the movie again... but I'm not sure if I will or not.