Have you ever thought 🤔 about this , it's been on my mind for a long time

Ginpachi_san said:
Not sure how you came up with this theory, but Olvia died when Robin was 8, 3 years before Luffy was even born

ashutoshanime said:
Luffy is 19 and Robin is 30. It doesn't make any sense to me 😕

Loaf_dontcare said:
Well... it's still possible that they are half siblings until proven otherwise. 🤷‍♀️

((I mean that Dragon is their father but that they have different mothers (Olvia/Robin and ?/Luffy))

Yeshaiah2015yesh said:

it's one piece , nothing makes sense does until it does.
that other guy already cleared that up, why drage this,

ashutoshanime said:

hypothetically assume that Olivia is dead during the buster call on Ohara when Robin was 8. Then who would clap the dead to make Luffy ??? ☠️

Yeshaiah2015yesh said:

bro stop giving me more copium, I'll take it any way

as New Gate said:- One Piece Exist
and as black beard said:- Dream Never End

i keep on dreaming, that's what one piece thought me😅

but I'll take the L for this.

Yeshaiah2015yesh said:

bro don't drag this, and your just editing the other guy's comment at this point.

and i can easily defend from your comments, if i want to drag this.
fro example, who knows Dr. Vegapunk made a clone from Nico Olvia, DNA and Dragon slapped that artificial meat. and made a meat loving child.
as you can see, with "Stussy" is a perfect clone from one of the former member of Rock's Pirates.
and "Edward Weevil" is said to be son of "Edward Newgate"( white beard). which is theorized that he made by "white beard" and stussy original DNA in Dr. Vegapunk's lab.
let be remind nothing is impossible in one piece.

even the greatest plot twists of one piece, which is till today Said to be one of the greatest Arc in one piece, that Ace was Pirate King:- Gold.D.Roger's son. was a last minute suggest from the editor to Odea sensa .

ashutoshanime said:

That maybe a possibility as you say this now but now as every chapter drops, it gives new perspectives of events which constantly changing the theories.For example, the latest chapter 1113 which made us head scratch when Vegapunk said his theory about the world will sink. Now if we see the entire OP plot with this theory of Vegapunk, then it can be of multiple ways such as Roger probably was aware of this theory and started the great pirate era which drove millions to the sea, aqua laguna at water 7, tequila bridge being this huge and ofcourse the redline where the "gods" reside, etc. I can understand the whole stussy clone and weevil thing but I find it very hard that it might be the same case with Olivia. If i remember correctly, it was said that she did join a pirate group to complete the "unfinished task" of her husband and yet we don't know who is Robin's father. If you analyse the strawhat crew, we don't know Luffy's mom, Zoro's family kinda was already revealed in the SBS, Nami's true parents, Franky's parents who are pirates and abandoned him. The only strawhat we got all the proper backstory is Sanji otherwise we know little about every other strawhats now.

Yeshaiah2015yesh said:

will will your keeping up with SBS, impressive.
with my bull shit theory i just ust came up on the fluke. i can still connect the dots, like after giving birthing to luffy, Nico Olvia clone, joines revolutionary army ofc hiding that dragon and she ware in a intimate relationship before. after some time she developed a different mind set or dissatisfaction or disagreement with dragon. and Nico Olvia clone asked Youvanka for a gender transfer and becomes the infamous crocodile mummy. which will fit with the ongoing theory perfectly. if it's so hard to believe.

will anyways bro i don't want to have beef with you or anything like that.

the reason i commented that way because, i already admitted that, i don't know to the guy who first comment.

so just pointed out the possibility. thats all.
and iam still admitting that my take on the matter was wrong. but you still aside the same thing as the first guy. so i commented that way

i wasn't being serious with the other commitments, just point some possibility that's al l . so sorry if I made a wrong impression .

Rhae said:
We all know Crocodile is Luffy's mom.

ashutoshanime said:

definitely you are not wrong. there is nothing bad in giving out your opinions. it would rather create an environment where we all fans of the same series would share our thoughts on the story so far and would get to know new things from different perspectives. 👍🏻

Rhae said:
@Yeshaiah2015yesh

Have you seen fanarts of female Crocodile? It's kinda hot, not gonna lie.

Rhae said:
@Yeshaiah2015yesh

Have you seen fanarts of female Crocodile? It's kinda hot, not gonna lie.

Zarutaku said:
Maybe Luffy's mom is from Wano, that would satisfy the Japanese audience.

Yeshaiah2015yesh said:
Is it possible that Robin and luffy are related. And Nico Olvia might be luffy's actual mother.
And we know that dragon never talked about his family to the revolutionaries. Even to yuvaonka . So it's not entirely impossible. And the fact that he wanted to meet Robin for a long time.
See i not so sure about the topic and i haven't down any reaserch on this matter. So please share your thoughts . Know that I just want to diskus this topic

ashutoshanime said:

hypothetically assume that Olivia is dead during the buster call on Ohara when Robin was 8. Then who would clap the dead to make Luffy ??? ☠️

SKILIFT26 said:

Hogback… ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎