| It is hated by edgy cringelords, who defy the norms of pathetic grey mass, because it is very popular It is also hated by an army of Fate fans who go crazy everytime someone says something like "ah, ufotable, that's the guys who made Kimetsu no Yaiba, right?" idk how you can hate this anime. Solely because of the insane graphics and masterpieve soundtracks it is already one of the best |
 |
| IMO, it is just a standard shonen show with nothing that stands out. Yes, the animation is good but when you think about it everything other than the animation is just a basic story, cringy dialogues, humour that gets a laugh out of you once or twice and characters that are annoying af. The first season did have some faults here and there but it was pretty good(I still think episode 19 of S1 is one of the best episodes in anime)-- and then there was this clusterfuck of a 2nd season. I don't understand why ppl like the show to the extent they think its top 3 new gen but hey your opinion is yours and my opinion is that Demon slayer, which is acclaimed to be peak anime, in reality is just mid. |
 |
| It's hated because it's so well loved. The more people something is the more people feel like they need to vocalize their hate for it. Sometimes they just feel the need to express how unique they are, but sometimes they legitimately think everyone else is stupid for enjoying it and they're one of the chosen ones for realizing how bad it really is. People hate less popular shows too, but people don't talk about those in general so there's no value in expressing how much you hate them since no one is around to listen. |
  |
| AD forum users try to accept other opinions and not falling for bait hate thread challenge IMPOSSIBLE 100% RUN |
 |
| Imagine if Isekai Cheat Magician became the most popular anime ever, that's Demon Slayer. |
| Because they are typical salty jealous people, do not worry :) |
 (っ◔◡◔)っ 𝓘 𝔀𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓪𝓵𝓵 𝓱𝓪𝓿𝓮 𝓪 𝔀𝓸𝓷𝓭𝓮𝓻𝓯𝓾𝓵 𝓭𝓪𝔂 ♥ |
| because its just yet another shonen adaption which only became popular because of its animation? which while technically good etc obv cant fix the plot etc soooooooooooooo obv ppl are annoyed to see such a series being successful |
  |
Spoonmaster12 said: Duh, but the amount of hate is relevant Literally every anime will get hate. You won't find a single series that doesn't get hate. |
 |
| In my opinion, it's a generic story with basic characters and dumb jokes. Nothing to write home about aside from stellar animation and Yuki Kajiura's OST. IzuKei said: Isn't it logical to rate more impressive anime higher? I think in the anime community there is a lot of people who ranks animes by it's "complexity". Like, that kind of people who says things like "if it doesn't has a complex/heavy power system like HxH and a super deep story that makes me rethink my life choices then it's trash". |
|
Rinkashikachi said: Sadly, plot and characters matter tooIt is hated by edgy cringelords, who defy the norms of pathetic grey mass, because it is very popular It is also hated by an army of Fate fans who go crazy everytime someone says something like "ah, ufotable, that's the guys who made Kimetsu no Yaiba, right?" idk how you can hate this anime. Solely because of the insane graphics and masterpieve soundtracks it is already one of the best IzuKei said: You're right in a way, but I don't think viewers should concern themselves with what is happening behind the scenes. I'm judging the product, not the process which made itMarkVijet said: In my opinion, it's a generic story with basic characters and dumb jokes. Nothing to write home about aside from stellar animation and Yuki Kajiura's OST. Isn't it logical to rate more impressive anime higher? Yup, you are right. But it's also true that "originality" is a problematic measurement tool, since editors will always try that the story you write as a mangaka/novelist fits certain standards that "sells well", and if it's your main income source then you want it too. I think that "how well you use the tools you have (characters, world building, etc) to tell the story you want to tell" is a better measurement tool. That idea also makes those animes that are unique like Monogatari, more special and wonderful. |
|
| Everything that's super popular gets it's share of hate. Especially if it doesn't deserve the popularity because it's actually just mediocre. Rinkashikachi said: idk how you can hate this anime. Solely because of the insane graphics and masterpieve soundtracks it is already one of the best Well some people care more about story and characters, instead of shallow stuff like music and animation. |
grandy_UiDNov 7, 2022 8:14 AM
MarkVijet said: Rinkashikachi said: Sadly, plot and characters matter tooIt is hated by edgy cringelords, who defy the norms of pathetic grey mass, because it is very popular It is also hated by an army of Fate fans who go crazy everytime someone says something like "ah, ufotable, that's the guys who made Kimetsu no Yaiba, right?" idk how you can hate this anime. Solely because of the insane graphics and masterpieve soundtracks it is already one of the best IzuKei said: You're right in a way, but I don't think viewers should concern themselves with what is happening behind the scenes. I'm judging the product, not the process which made itYup, you are right. But it's also true that "originality" is a problematic measurement tool, since editors will always try that the story you write as a mangaka/novelist fits certain standards that "sells well", and if it's your main income source then you want it too. I think that "how well you use the tools you have (characters, world building, etc) to tell the story you want to tell" is a better measurement tool. That idea also makes those animes that are unique like Monogatari, more special and wonderful. plot and characters are at least average among the genre. Hating average goes back to my first point. There is a couple of great characters and plot twists like killing one of the most loved of them. this doesn't make characters and plot masterpieces, but it adds |
|
grandy_UiD said: Everything that's super popular gets it's share of hate. Especially if it doesn't deserve the popularity because it's actually just mediocre. Rinkashikachi said: idk how you can hate this anime. Solely because of the insane graphics and masterpieve soundtracks it is already one of the best Well some people care more about story and characters, instead of shallow stuff like music and animation. Imagine calling two types of art "shallow" almost with elitist disgust while having the audacity to present yourself as a person who understands art and has IQ above 0 |
|
ktg said: AwokenStroken said: On how I think it's flawed? I've wrote a review of it compiling my thoughts and feelings https://myanimelist.net/reviews.php?id=401803 If you truly wish to know :) I've read 3 of your paragraph. It is easy to critisize something if you lie about it. I didn't find any truth in those 3 paragraph, but nice try. what did i lie about? |
 |
Rinkashikachi said: grandy_UiD said: Everything that's super popular gets it's share of hate. Especially if it doesn't deserve the popularity because it's actually just mediocre. Well some people care more about story and characters, instead of shallow stuff like music and animation. Imagine calling two types of art "shallow" almost with elitist disgust while having the audacity to present yourself as a person who understands art and has IQ above 0 Who tf said anything about "art"? We talkin' anime here lol. |
Rinkashikachi said: wow never done beforeMarkVijet said: Sadly, plot and characters matter too You're right in a way, but I don't think viewers should concern themselves with what is happening behind the scenes. I'm judging the product, not the process which made it plot and characters are at least average among the genre. Hating average goes back to my first point. There is a couple of great characters and plot twists like killing one of the most loved of them. this doesn't make characters and plot masterpieces, but it adds |
|
grandy_UiD said: Rinkashikachi said: Imagine calling two types of art "shallow" almost with elitist disgust while having the audacity to present yourself as a person who understands art and has IQ above 0 Who tf said anything about "art"? We talkin' anime here lol. music and graphics are literally art. If they are shallow to you, you don't know crap about characters and story either. It is just "hahaha this guy cool, haha this story interesting" |
|
MarkVijet said: Rinkashikachi said: wow never done beforeplot and characters are at least average among the genre. Hating average goes back to my first point. There is a couple of great characters and plot twists like killing one of the most loved of them. this doesn't make characters and plot masterpieces, but it adds "Wow, it was done before, so I am going to hate it" that's how you sound right now. Before you blame me in misunderstanding your message, pls consider rereading the topic name. Because right now you are defending the hate towards something that's just not original in everything. You defend it by arguing with my position of why it shouldn't be hated. I said that something should not be hated for averageness. you got into an argument with me. If that's not your intention, than I suggest you to just leave this conversation. If that's indeed your intention than you are one of those cringelords and I don't want to waste my time on you. |
RinkashikachiNov 7, 2022 8:27 AM
|
Rinkashikachi said: music and graphics are literally art. If they are shallow to you, you don't know crap about characters and story either. It is just "hahaha this guy cool, haha this story interesting" Yeah, the "artistic value" of the drawings of your chinese cartoon is literally zero. At least a good story and characters are somewhat memorable, regardless of what they look or sound like. What will people be talking about in ten or twenty years? "Yeah, you remember how that one sword stroke in episode 17 of KnY looked really awesome"? Surely not. |
grandy_UiD said: Rinkashikachi said: music and graphics are literally art. If they are shallow to you, you don't know crap about characters and story either. It is just "hahaha this guy cool, haha this story interesting" Yeah, the "artistic value" of the drawings of your chinese cartoon is literally zero. At least a good story and characters are somewhat memorable, regardless of what they look or sound like. What will people be talking about in ten or twenty years? "Yeah, you remember how that one sword stroke in episode 17 of KnY looked really awesome"? Surely not. Lmao, dug yourself pretty deep. My point stands, done with you |
|
Rinkashikachi said: I mean, I do dislike Demon Slayer lmao, of course I'd defend the hate.MarkVijet said: wow never done before "Wow, it was done before, so I am going to hate it" that's how you sound right now. Before you blame me in misunderstanding your message, pls consider rereading the topic name. Because right now you are defending the hate towards something that's just not original in everything. You defend it by arguing with my position of why it shouldn't be hated. If that's not your intention, than I suggest you to just leave this conversation. If that's indeed your intention than you are one of those cringelords and I don't want to waste my time on you. |
|
MarkVijet said: Rinkashikachi said: I mean, I do dislike Demon Slayer lmao, of course I'd defend the hate."Wow, it was done before, so I am going to hate it" that's how you sound right now. Before you blame me in misunderstanding your message, pls consider rereading the topic name. Because right now you are defending the hate towards something that's just not original in everything. You defend it by arguing with my position of why it shouldn't be hated. If that's not your intention, than I suggest you to just leave this conversation. If that's indeed your intention than you are one of those cringelords and I don't want to waste my time on you. There is a huge difference between dislike and hate. Sadly for a guy with 13 y.o. emotional intellect there are only two colors of black and white. And I can't do anything to help you with that, so good luck |
|
Rinkashikachi said: Hate is a stronger word for dislike, yes. And why are you so much on the offensive? It's not like I insulted you at any point MarkVijet said: I mean, I do dislike Demon Slayer lmao, of course I'd defend the hate. There is a huge difference between dislike and hate. Sadly for a guy with 13 y.o. emotional intellect there are only two colors of black and white. And I can't do anything to help you with that, so good luck |
|
Okuuta said: I would not say that it "is hated" I personally see three categories of people regarding their opinion about DS: 1. The ones who think DS is one of the best anime ever just because they only have surface anime knowledge and watch only shows that are popular nowadays OR they just like well animated battle shounen (can't judge anybody). 2. The ones who think that DS is a mid show because characters are unidimensional, the plot is generic and too shounen-ish: Tanjirou's unnatural motivation to turn his sister back to normal, the classic trio, the fact that the MC has hidden special abilities and a tragic backstory, the line between evil and good is too obvious, and the plot is predictable. 3.The ones who totally hate DS because they think its a garbage in writting and only carried by its gorgeous animation. They are literally offensed by generic battle shounens. Yep , and that's all. Yupp and I'm part of the 2nd category🤷♂️ |
|
Rinkashikachi said: grandy_UiD said: Yeah, the "artistic value" of the drawings of your chinese cartoon is literally zero. At least a good story and characters are somewhat memorable, regardless of what they look or sound like. What will people be talking about in ten or twenty years? "Yeah, you remember how that one sword stroke in episode 17 of KnY looked really awesome"? Surely not. Lmao, dug yourself pretty deep. My point stands, done with you I'm sure you could never hate or even dislike a pretty person. After all, they are pretty. Doesn't matter if they have a shitty or just bland and boring personality. As long as they look nice, they are one of the best. Inner values don't matter. An anime would also be "one of the best" if it was literally some turds barfing out other turds, as long as the turds are nicely animated and the soundtrack was incredible, right? To me, soundtrack and animation/art direction can totally add to the experience of a show (or detract from it, if they are truly terrible) but they can never truly carry a show by themselves. Yes, I consider them MUCH less important than plot and/or characters and therefore I consider judging a show mainly on looks/sound to be shallow, within the medium (and obviously I think that my opinion on that is the corrent one). That is obviously not true when it comes to judging paintings, music by itself etc. That being said, I don't actually hate KnY lol. What I hate are people that claim it's one of the best shows ever solely "because it looks really cool, dude" and don't get tired of shoving that opinion down other people's throats. Okuuta said: I would not say that it "is hated" I personally see three categories of people regarding their opinion about DS: 1. The ones who think DS is one of the best anime ever just because they only have surface anime knowledge and watch only shows that are popular nowadays OR they just like well animated battle shounen (can't judge anybody). 2. The ones who think that DS is a mid show because characters are unidimensional, the plot is generic and too shounen-ish: Tanjirou's unnatural motivation to turn his sister back to normal, the classic trio, the fact that the MC has hidden special abilities and a tragic backstory, the line between evil and good is too obvious, and the plot is predictable. 3.The ones who totally hate DS because they think its a garbage in writting and only carried by its gorgeous animation. They are literally offensed by generic battle shounens. Yep , and that's all. My man here knows what's up. Very well put. |
More topics from this board
» Gurenge becomes top selling digital single song in Reiwa eraFZREMAKE - Apr 15 |
19 |
by HaremSevdalisi
»»
Yesterday, 2:13 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 18, 2019 |
312 |
by CicadaRex
»»
Apr 24, 12:21 PM |
|
» I don't get itn0tSamir - Jul 7, 2023 |
34 |
by guts4ever
»»
Apr 22, 12:44 PM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 27, 2019 |
272 |
by CicadaRex
»»
Apr 20, 4:20 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimetsu no Yaiba Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 20, 2019 |
282 |
by CicadaRex
»»
Apr 19, 11:49 AM |