Season 3 part 2 is now at Number two on Mal, with season 4 part 1 at number 8

Offline

Nov 2020

828

BloodyTaer said:

Andigowho said:
Why do people say that s3p2 had better animation? I preferred cg reiner over 2d s3p2 reiner. Since reiners titan has a lot of detail and its very hard to animate it look bad in s2p2. And overall besides the god tier scenes it wasn't all that better than s4

the whole arc what a massive strategic fight, how can that not be the coolest thing ever?

and a lot of people including myself prefer the 2d titans, thats why its #2, it is better than s4 by miles imo and many others apparently

yes I also agree S4 was good but s3p2 was far better in every aspect than S4

"I don't know about you
But I'm feeling 22
Everything will be alright if
You keep me next to you
You don't know about me
But I'll bet you want to
Everything will be alright if
We just keep dancing like we're 22, 22"

Apr 21, 2021 7:51 AM

#17

Offline

Nov 2019

1166

Kirito760 said:

BloodyTaer said:

the whole arc what a massive strategic fight, how can that not be the coolest thing ever?

and a lot of people including myself prefer the 2d titans, thats why its #2, it is better than s4 by miles imo and many others apparently

yes I also agree S4 was good but s3p2 was far better in every aspect than S4

In what way? Season 4 is far better story wise and consistency wise compared to part 2 of season 3.

Apr 21, 2021 8:01 AM

#18

Offline

Nov 2019

1166

Chiahk said:

Andigowho said:
Why do people say that s3p2 had better animation? I preferred cg reiner over 2d s3p2 reiner. Since reiners titan has a lot of detail and its very hard to animate it look bad in s2p2. And overall besides the god tier scenes it wasn't all that better than s4

I would take 2D Reiner any time of the day than seeing another CG titan.

2d can still be shit. Renier looked shit, even as a 2d titan. At least cgi, it's much more detailed.

Obviously it isn't as good as even the reanimated scenes from studio wit in season 4. But comparing season 3 part 2 to season 4 is less clear, considering the few times we did get 2d titans, they looked like crap.

2d can still be crap. Seven deadly sins being one of them. 3d can still be amazing. Anything that ufotable has made can prove that.

Apr 21, 2021 8:07 AM

#19

Offline

Nov 2020

828

racers551 said:

Kirito760 said:

yes I also agree S4 was good but s3p2 was far better in every aspect than S4

In what way? Season 4 is far better story wise and consistency wise compared to part 2 of season 3.

oh yes their was nothing in S3p2 except Levi vs beast titan epic fight, erwins last words, the history of Paradise Island and fantastic soundtracks.😒😒😒

"I don't know about you
But I'm feeling 22
Everything will be alright if
You keep me next to you
You don't know about me
But I'll bet you want to
Everything will be alright if
We just keep dancing like we're 22, 22"

Apr 21, 2021 8:12 AM

#20

Offline

Nov 2019

1166

Kirito760 said:

racers551 said:

In what way? Season 4 is far better story wise and consistency wise compared to part 2 of season 3.

oh yes their was nothing in S3p2 except Levi vs beast titan epic fight, erwins last words, the history of Paradise Island and fantastic soundtracks.😒😒😒

And there was nothing in season 4, except Eren fucking murdering innocent children, some like him, Sasha's death, Mikasa and Armin being called a slave, and undermined, Eren becoming a war criminal, Gabi turning from a likable to a hateable character, and back into a more likeable one, the war between Marley and Paradis, Falco being a Chad, a marleyan, Niccolo loving a Eldian soldier, Floche changing from the mentally tired and weak soldier to a badass who's able to turn against his own military, and make them into Titans, etc etc. Not to mention, Ashes on the Fire, and Call your name, instrumental, was fucking fantastic. Not to mention 2lives.

Way more happened in season 4 than in season 3 part 2, or even before season 3.

Apr 21, 2021 8:35 AM

#21

Offline

Nov 2020

828

racers551 said:

Kirito760 said:

oh yes their was nothing in S3p2 except Levi vs beast titan epic fight, erwins last words, the history of Paradise Island and fantastic soundtracks.😒😒😒

And there was nothing in season 4, except Eren fucking murdering innocent children, some like him, Sasha's death, Mikasa and Armin being called a slave, and undermined, Eren becoming a war criminal, Gabi turning from a likable to a hateable character, and back into a more likeable one, the war between Marley and Paradis, Falco being a Chad, a marleyan, Niccolo loving a Eldian soldier, Floche changing from the mentally tired and weak soldier to a badass who's able to turn against his own military, and make them into Titans, etc etc. Not to mention, Ashes on the Fire, and Call your name, instrumental, was fucking fantastic. Not to mention 2lives.

Way more happened in season 4 than in season 3 part 2, or even before season 3.

bro it's not wrong that you like S4 but I prefer s3p2 more

"I don't know about you
But I'm feeling 22
Everything will be alright if
You keep me next to you
You don't know about me
But I'll bet you want to
Everything will be alright if
We just keep dancing like we're 22, 22"

Apr 21, 2021 8:38 AM

#22

Offline

Nov 2019

1166

Kirito760 said:

racers551 said:

And there was nothing in season 4, except Eren fucking murdering innocent children, some like him, Sasha's death, Mikasa and Armin being called a slave, and undermined, Eren becoming a war criminal, Gabi turning from a likable to a hateable character, and back into a more likeable one, the war between Marley and Paradis, Falco being a Chad, a marleyan, Niccolo loving a Eldian soldier, Floche changing from the mentally tired and weak soldier to a badass who's able to turn against his own military, and make them into Titans, etc etc. Not to mention, Ashes on the Fire, and Call your name, instrumental, was fucking fantastic. Not to mention 2lives.

Way more happened in season 4 than in season 3 part 2, or even before season 3.

bro it's not wrong that you like S4 but I prefer s3p2 more

Okay. But if your argument is that more happened, you're wrong.

Apr 21, 2021 8:54 AM

#23

Offline

Nov 2020

828

racers551 said:

Kirito760 said:

bro it's not wrong that you like S4 but I prefer s3p2 more

Okay. But if your argument is that more happened, you're wrong.

@racers551 but according to community I am absolutely right.
its clear from the ratings that people like s3p2 more than s4

"I don't know about you
But I'm feeling 22
Everything will be alright if
You keep me next to you
You don't know about me
But I'll bet you want to
Everything will be alright if
We just keep dancing like we're 22, 22"

Apr 21, 2021 8:56 AM

#24

Offline

Nov 2019

1166

Kirito760 said:

racers551 said:

Okay. But if your argument is that more happened, you're wrong.

@racers551 but according to community I am absolutely right.
its clear from the ratings that people like s3p2 more than s4

I mean, okay.

That's their opinion. Mine is that it's not even close, and season 4 far outstrips what any other season had done. But people are allowed to have their opinions.

Apr 21, 2021 9:06 AM

#25

samashi20

Offline

Jan 2020

3409

I personally think that as long as both parts are in the top 10, I won't be mad. Season 3 p2 is the most loved by fans and the one with the least controversy around it which is why it's holding its spot as number 2. Had season 4 not been downvoted to death, it would have been higher.

In terms of action, I think both seasons had their fair share of action, maybe slightly more in season 4, but I'm not sure because

I sometimes forget to finish my sentences.

Apr 21, 2021 1:10 PM

#26

ImperialAk

Offline

Dec 2020

79

Well season 4 got attacked by dumb FMAB fans , MAPPA haters , also the ones who absolutely hated the ending and Season 3 part 2 fanboys . Like just because I won't get god tier animation I will overlook the amazing story telling of season 4 that's clearly way better than season 3 part 2 . The arcs that were covered in season 4 are considered peak of aot in manga with the first 5 episodes of season 4 part 2 being the greatest plot twist of Aot . Yet anime onlys managed to hate it. Honestly I thought MAL was a place where people would actually discuss things they likes but some of the posts are so hateful ( for many anime especially the top 10 ) , it feels like I am on twitter , made specifically for anime lol 😂. Aot season 4 and season 4 part 2 deserve positions in top 5 . Also to all the Toxic FMAB fans are you guys gonna downvote berserk too when it gets a better adaptation ?? There are quite a few anime that deserve to be above FMAB . AOT season 4 part one and two ,Monster etc .

Apr 21, 2021 1:54 PM

#27

Leoradiuju2004

Offline

Aug 2020

1138

Well season 4 got attacked by dumb FMAB fans , MAPPA haters , also the ones who absolutely hated the ending and Season 3 part 2 fanboys . Like just because I won't get god tier animation I will overlook the amazing story telling of season 4 that's clearly way better than season 3 part 2 . The arcs that were covered in season 4 are considered peak of aot in manga with the first 5 episodes of season 4 part 2 being the greatest plot twist of Aot . Yet anime onlys managed to hate it. Honestly I thought MAL was a place where people would actually discuss things they likes but some of the posts are so hateful ( for many anime especially the top 10 ) , it feels like I am on twitter , made specifically for anime lol . Aot season 4 and season 4 part 2 deserve positions in top 5 . Also to all the Toxic FMAB fans are you guys gonna downvote berserk too when it gets a better adaptation ?? There are quite a few anime that deserve to be above FMAB . AOT season 4 part one and two ,Monster etc .

in fact, I'm starting to believe that FMAB's fanboys are less toxic than AOT's. at least they don't fight each other and agree that their anime is the best. unlike the AOT fandom (the most toxic), who argue about whether the animation is good or bad, about whether its ending sucks or not or people like you: who think their favorite part of anime should be higher when the whole story itself is very good.

a wise user of MAL said:
Just to clarify, adaptations should absolutely stand on their own

Apr 21, 2021 2:14 PM

#28

CLADDAN

Offline

Dec 2020

974

I don't think any AoT has business being this high, but s3p2 definitely deserves to be higher than S4, post-timeskip AoT is a mess.

Apr 21, 2021 2:16 PM

#29

HoodKublaiKhan

Offline

Jun 2020

3748

Well some people liked the action in szn3pt2 more

Apr 21, 2021 10:03 PM

#30

Offline

Nov 2020

828

Leoradiuju2004 said:

Well season 4 got attacked by dumb FMAB fans , MAPPA haters , also the ones who absolutely hated the ending and Season 3 part 2 fanboys . Like just because I won't get god tier animation I will overlook the amazing story telling of season 4 that's clearly way better than season 3 part 2 . The arcs that were covered in season 4 are considered peak of aot in manga with the first 5 episodes of season 4 part 2 being the greatest plot twist of Aot . Yet anime onlys managed to hate it. Honestly I thought MAL was a place where people would actually discuss things they likes but some of the posts are so hateful ( for many anime especially the top 10 ) , it feels like I am on twitter , made specifically for anime lol . Aot season 4 and season 4 part 2 deserve positions in top 5 . Also to all the Toxic FMAB fans are you guys gonna downvote berserk too when it gets a better adaptation ?? There are quite a few anime that deserve to be above FMAB . AOT season 4 part one and two ,Monster etc .

in fact, I'm starting to believe that FMAB's fanboys are less toxic than AOT's. at least they don't fight each other and agree that their anime is the best. unlike the AOT fandom (the most toxic), who argue about whether the animation is good or bad, about whether its ending sucks or not or people like you: who think their favorite part of anime should be higher when the whole story itself is very good.

I don't remember fmab having any other season that they can fight on and fmab fanboys do fight more than aot fans on fma vs fmab

"I don't know about you
But I'm feeling 22
Everything will be alright if
You keep me next to you
You don't know about me
But I'll bet you want to
Everything will be alright if
We just keep dancing like we're 22, 22"

Apr 21, 2021 10:16 PM

#31

Offline

Nov 2020

828

ImperialAk said:
Well season 4 got attacked by dumb FMAB fans , MAPPA haters , also the ones who absolutely hated the ending and Season 3 part 2 fanboys . Like just because I won't get god tier animation I will overlook the amazing story telling of season 4 that's clearly way better than season 3 part 2 . The arcs that were covered in season 4 are considered peak of aot in manga with the first 5 episodes of season 4 part 2 being the greatest plot twist of Aot . Yet anime onlys managed to hate it. Honestly I thought MAL was a place where people would actually discuss things they likes but some of the posts are so hateful ( for many anime especially the top 10 ) , it feels like I am on twitter , made specifically for anime lol 😂. Aot season 4 and season 4 part 2 deserve positions in top 5 . Also to all the Toxic FMAB fans are you guys gonna downvote berserk too when it gets a better adaptation ?? There are quite a few anime that deserve to be above FMAB . AOT season 4 part one and two ,Monster etc .

yes fmab is overrated shit

"I don't know about you
But I'm feeling 22
Everything will be alright if
You keep me next to you
You don't know about me
But I'll bet you want to
Everything will be alright if
We just keep dancing like we're 22, 22"

Apr 22, 2021 1:32 PM

#32

OnzimaLeader

Offline

Jan 2021

17

story wise season 4 is better but season 3 part 2 is just pure hyoe that was built up for the last 47 episodes at that point but imo i have them at the exact same level

Apr 22, 2021 8:49 PM

#33

JJ_jose

Offline

Nov 2019

798

Season 4 right now is in the situation season 3 was in. Not many people liked part 1 of season 3 due to lack of titan fights and the whole political government thing, and it was mostly build up for the massive hype storm that would take place in part 2 at the fight in shiganshina. It's the same again, most of season 4 part 1 is the build up to part 2, and part 2 will immediately start with bat shit insane fights and reveals like season 3 part 2, INSIDE shiganshina once again. It's now all come full circle, It is literally season 3 all over again, and honestly I love it and and I'm geeking out over it. I predict part 2 is gonna get the same love as season 3 part 2 due to the similar but still different nature, watch, the colossal story progression and action of both season 3 part 2 and season 4 part 2 are gonna be duking it out on top, and honestly anyone still giving a crap about the CGI or the whole MAPPA thing are slowly gonna fizzle out just like all the nit picking for season 3 part 2 did. "2 titans meet, as it was written" -Samuel Hayden. Sorry couldn't help the doom reference

Apr 23, 2021 9:21 AM

#34

zach293

Offline

Dec 2019

471

s3p2 is literally unbelievable, so it DESERVES IT

Apr 26, 2021 11:29 PM

#35

Offline

Sep 2020

2292

Andigowho said:

BloodyTaer said:

the whole arc what a massive strategic fight, how can that not be the coolest thing ever?

and a lot of people including myself prefer the 2d titans, thats why its #2, it is better than s4 by miles imo and many others apparently

ok im talking abou the animation not the story and imo i prefer consistantly good cg teiner than shit reiner in most of the shots. Im not hating on wit i prefer it over mappa but i can't deny that fact

Let's face it if S4 p1 was upto 8 episodes instead of 16 then the kids would rate it higher ,because that was the end the action arc,if you get what I mean ,even it would have gone above fmab at no 1,mappa planning was bad in this situation

Then later it should have been continued in winter 2022 from ep 9 of s4 that would make more sence and people won't be upset ,plus the production team will get more time to prepare for part 2

Mack_YeagerApr 26, 2021 11:32 PM

Apr 26, 2021 11:30 PM

#36

Offline

Sep 2020

2292

OnzimaLeader said:
story wise season 4 is better but season 3 part 2 is just pure hyoe that was built up for the last 47 episodes at that point but imo i have them at the exact same level

The colour pallets in previous season actually makes me wanna give it a 10

Apr 26, 2021 11:35 PM

#37

Offline

Sep 2020

2292

JJ_jose said:
Season 4 right now is in the situation season 3 was in. Not many people liked part 1 of season 3 due to lack of titan fights and the whole political government thing, and it was mostly build up for the massive hype storm that would take place in part 2 at the fight in shiganshina. It's the same again, most of season 4 part 1 is the build up to part 2, and part 2 will immediately start with bat shit insane fights and reveals like season 3 part 2, INSIDE shiganshina once again. It's now all come full circle, It is literally season 3 all over again, and honestly I love it and and I'm geeking out over it. I predict part 2 is gonna get the same love as season 3 part 2 due to the similar but still different nature, watch, the colossal story progression and action of both season 3 part 2 and season 4 part 2 are gonna be duking it out on top, and honestly anyone still giving a crap about the CGI or the whole MAPPA thing are slowly gonna fizzle out just like all the nit picking for season 3 part 2 did. "2 titans meet, as it was written" -Samuel Hayden. Sorry couldn't help the doom reference

Yeah exactly so objectively S3 p1 is actually a 9.6/10
S1p1:9.2/10
S1p2:9.3/10

S2:9.5/10
S3p2 is a 9.7/10
S4p1 is a 9.8/10

Apr 26, 2021 11:37 PM

#38