What do people see in this anime that I don't?

Turtles_Hunter said:
It's close enough to SAO, but they can like it because it's new enough and hasn't gained that much popularity. Wait for a few month. Befor the end of the cour, you will see people beginning to trash it, to not be the ones that like it, because they would look stupid.

Blood_Butterfly said:
This crappy is a new goblin slayer. An overrated show, which fans say is a mature and dark show, but in reality is another average anime with the same story that many other animes have had

LoganMcClure21 said:
If you don’t like the show or the plot or anything about it then leave like I personally am not a fan of Mob Psycho but that doesn’t mean I get to tell everyone that likes it that it’s overrated just because I don’t like it.

Jin_uzuki said:
"This is Isekai is good, it's totally not like the other isekai, we swear" is my favorite Isekai/LN meme.

AnimeSucks420 said:
nothing, its overrated for some reason, but then again bnha also got popular and its garbage so dw

Ressonancee said:
Come on another repetitive isekai harem shits
I want more romcom animes!!!! lol

Groenboys said:
Good that everybody is arguing with eachother instead of awnsering my question


Like jesus I just want to know from the people who haven't read the manga or novel why they gave the anime a 10. Yes I understand that manga and novel readers gave it a 10 because it gets better in the future, but I don't understand it from the people who didn't read them.


Jesus this thread is cancer

Alpha_Tranny said:
I don’t give it a 10 but I find the anime a compelling breathe of fresh air in contrast to other isekai anime. The biggest and most notable change is how they portray the protagonist being in the lowest social state with the lowest power level while other shows of its ilk would do the opposite as well as play on the idea of the female character that for no reason dotes on him has ulterior motives.

TL;DR I find how they handle the protagonist compelling in contrast to other isekai.

fmadiva said:
Don't trust anyone on this website, they have horrible tastes here.

I gave it a 1/10 out of spite because I'm tired of shows pandering to incel nobodies who's never touched a tit or amounted to anything in life and giving them self inserts when they could take the RPG/fantasy genre and actually, idk, do something different with it without regurgitating the same formula over and over. Isekai is a great concept often completely ruined by the superficial power fantasies of otaku NEETs and it's sad.

This is why anime as a genre needs more diverse writers and producers need to pick up more original and unique light novels like No. 6 because plenty of them exist I'm sure.

Ressonancee said:
Come on another repetitive isekai harem shits
I want more romcom animes!!!! lol

Turtles_Hunter said:
Because for you 85k people rating the show before it air is a sign of quality. It's a sign of brainless fanboyism, at best. There are some every cour. Not bad, but not so good either, that are hype by the community into being the one.

filipcentko552 said:
Its Kinema Citrus so u know Its good

Groenboys said:
Good that everybody is arguing with eachother instead of awnsering my question


Like jesus I just want to know from the people who haven't read the manga or novel why they gave the anime a 10. Yes I understand that manga and novel readers gave it a 10 because it gets better in the future, but I don't understand it from the people who didn't read them.


Jesus this thread is cancer

Turtles_Hunter said:
According to the stats a vast majority of people think SAO is very good, so by your logic it is very good, since a lot of people said so (my opinion on that is that it has its time, but a lot of default, especially after the first arc). There is a french humorist (Coluche) that once said "It's not because they are plenty to be wrong that they are right.".

Anyway, I wasn't even saying they were wrong, heck how would I know, I haven't seen it, since it hasn't started airing. And that's my point. A good series can have an awful adaptation (Berserk for example, the new Hoshin adaptation, or to leave the animation world, the Hobbit Trilogy) - and from what I read about it until now, it's close enough to SAO, and thus might follow the same path. Because the hate bandwagon is only as strong as the hype train, and if you've been in the anime "community" for long enough, you would know people tend to hate because they don't want to be in the part of people that defend it, even if they still watch every episode... Even you avoided to rate SAO, when you began Alicization, meaning you probably have seen the whole SAO franchise. You just proved my point. People don't want to say they watch/like it, because a vocal part think it's the worse thing ever, so either people join them or just avoid to express themselves about it. It's not new.

Anyway, I just said it's stupid to rate an anime from the knowledge of the original material, or because of what you heard. And to do that you have to be a brainless fanboy. Because you can't even differentiate the original material from it's adaptation. It was never about hate or listening to my opinion, because I actually don't have one. I fear it's gonna be like all those overhyped show that just end being decent. I might be wrong about that. But still that doesn't make the 85k people that already gave it high scores less of some brainless fanboys. (and my bad, I just realised you were part of those, which explain why you were so much on the defensive).

Turtles_Hunter said:
Because for you 85k people rating the show before it air is a sign of quality. It's a sign of brainless fanboyism, at best. There are some every cour. Not bad, but not so good either, that are hype by the community into being the one.

MABfan11 said:


if you're tired of isekai that are self-insert harem power fantasies, then you should check out Re:Zero, as it was created by a guy who hates those exact tropes

StargazerSazuri said:
https://myanimelist.net/anime/35790/Tate_no_Yuusha_no_Nariagari/stats

I can't see why people just wanna pure hate and underrate an anime because it's getting a lot of praise. Like it doesn't deserve under a 4. Even if you don't like Isekai, adventure, or seinen.

I know the question wasn't directed towards people who read the manga/LN, but it's because it actually seems to follow the manga. I can't speak for the LN because I haven't read it.

fmadiva said:


I don't bang with shows that have sezualized 12yo looking girls either so I would rather not, I'm tired of that shit too

Thanks for the recommendation though, I appreciate it

fmadiva said:


I don't bang with shows that have sezualized 12yo looking girls either so I would rather not, I'm tired of that shit too

Thanks for the recommendation though, I appreciate it