New
Apr 26, 2017 12:45 AM
#2701
Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they |
Apr 26, 2017 12:49 AM
#2702
Shinichi-Kun said: DenjaX said: aa-dono said: DenjaX said: I think you're trying to justify his role for him. Didn't he say he wasn't the hider and he mistaken the role of bus driver at the time?Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. What I am most concerned is those people capitalizing his mistake. So people like jack and logic? Blame me if you want I don't care tbh if he makes up a role and them refused to give me info when I ask or even vote for that matter. I can't save them I need people to work with me he messed up and could of fixed it but gave up. |
Apr 26, 2017 12:52 AM
#2703
Shinichi-Kun said: U 2 can throw salt all over me it wont change much @logic340 what are your throughs on the fact that jack and penta are both ok throwing away another town role without claiming their own role. I find that super odd @denjax @kit same question for you 2 Dude your role at this point is suppose to be used to save a power role and bite the kill you will have to use it at some point. It does not have to be tonight but some point you will. |
Apr 26, 2017 12:56 AM
#2704
Coelestin said: ... Is it wrong to start believing in a Jack/Penta/Grape/Logic power wolf scum team? :| @Shinichi-kun Let me confirm again. You are a Lightning Rod? Your role says you're "self-sacrificing" but there's no guarantee that you'll die, right? I doubt it is a 4 man team based off size of game and 3RD party also suppose tge 3rd would swing it a bit though since anti scum. I could see logic and Grape been scum less sp Penta |
Apr 26, 2017 3:37 AM
#2705
Shinichi-Kun said: Use your ability and have the doc protect anyone. Doesnt matter because as lightning rod, even protect goes to you.PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability We can potentially have a night without any deaths. Protect us for the sins of mankind. This optimal strategy is brought to you by DenjaX Inc. Slogan jingle: I respect that~~ |
DenjaXApr 26, 2017 3:42 AM
Apr 26, 2017 3:52 AM
#2706
DenjaX said: Shinichi-Kun said: Use your ability and have the doc protect anyone. Doesnt matter because as lightning rod, even protect goes to you.PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability We can potentially have a night without any deaths. Protect us for the sins of mankind. This optimal strategy is brought to you by DenjaX Inc. Slogan jingle: I respect that~~ This is a fair point actually as long as the doctor protects someone they is no drawback forgot about that part. |
Apr 26, 2017 4:01 AM
#2707
Jackrito said: DenjaX said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability We can potentially have a night without any deaths. Protect us for the sins of mankind. This optimal strategy is brought to you by DenjaX Inc. Slogan jingle: I respect that~~ This is a fair point actually as long as the doctor protects someone they is no drawback forgot about that part. Of course you "forgot" it because scum cant disclose this very strategy or else itll kneecap them. I am watching you Same goes to @PentaFlare why havent you thought of this? |
Apr 26, 2017 4:13 AM
#2708
Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: DenjaX said: aa-dono said: it is the other way around. He thought he was hider but he corrected himself which I find the most townie thing to do. And he admitted his mistake.DenjaX said: I think you're trying to justify his role for him. Didn't he say he wasn't the hider and he mistaken the role of bus driver at the time?Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. What I am most concerned is those people capitalizing his mistake. So people like jack and logic? Karote is changing his playstyle hes just playing the same ole way as every game lets not forget he was also town lol, u dont get to be town read for trying to match the town style of another player if anything that should be considered scummy. Just wondering how do you change playstyle and play same way, I do agree on playstyle change of logic though |
Apr 26, 2017 4:22 AM
#2709
DenjaX said: Jackrito said: DenjaX said: Shinichi-Kun said: Use your ability and have the doc protect anyone. Doesnt matter because as lightning rod, even protect goes to you.PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability We can potentially have a night without any deaths. Protect us for the sins of mankind. This optimal strategy is brought to you by DenjaX Inc. Slogan jingle: I respect that~~ This is a fair point actually as long as the doctor protects someone they is no drawback forgot about that part. Of course you "forgot" it because scum cant disclose this very strategy or else itll kneecap them. I am watching you Same goes to @PentaFlare why havent you thought of this? If I was scum that tactic would of failed because of doc anyway so why bring it up, it would be better off to wait for doc dead before bringing it up. |
Apr 26, 2017 4:47 AM
#2710
DenjaX said: Shinichi-Kun said: Use your ability and have the doc protect anyone. Doesnt matter because as lightning rod, even protect goes to you.PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability We can potentially have a night without any deaths. Protect us for the sins of mankind. This optimal strategy is brought to you by DenjaX Inc. Slogan jingle: I respect that~~ ^ Thinking the same here, hence the question to Shinichi as to whether his Lightnig Rod is literally suicidal or of it's just the name that makes one think that it's suicidal. Since we know that the doc exists and is active because of grrr's claim, there shouldn't be anything that could stop Shin's ability from stopping the night kill. |
Apr 26, 2017 4:58 AM
#2711
Jackrito said: Coelestin said: ... Is it wrong to start believing in a Jack/Penta/Grape/Logic power wolf scum team? :| @Shinichi-kun Let me confirm again. You are a Lightning Rod? Your role says you're "self-sacrificing" but there's no guarantee that you'll die, right? I doubt it is a 4 man team based off size of game and 3RD party also suppose tge 3rd would swing it a bit though since anti scum. I could see logic and Grape been scum less sp Penta Well, I'm just guessing that it's 4 peeps because formula says that around 1/4 of the players should be mafia, that's what you and Soren said in Game Manager training. I'm less familiar how that works out though when there's a third party. |
Apr 26, 2017 5:03 AM
#2712
Coelestin said: Jackrito said: Coelestin said: ... Is it wrong to start believing in a Jack/Penta/Grape/Logic power wolf scum team? :| @Shinichi-kun Let me confirm again. You are a Lightning Rod? Your role says you're "self-sacrificing" but there's no guarantee that you'll die, right? I doubt it is a 4 man team based off size of game and 3RD party also suppose tge 3rd would swing it a bit though since anti scum. I could see logic and Grape been scum less sp Penta Well, I'm just guessing that it's 4 peeps because formula says that around 1/4 of the players should be mafia, that's what you and Soren said in Game Manager training. I'm less familiar how that works out though when there's a third party. Depends on 3rd with it been town sided it would mean a stronger scum a lot of it depends on the power role though as well so hard to judge. I would do 3 in a setup of this size but never would use a anti mafia 3rd party though. I still think 3 though |
Apr 26, 2017 5:19 AM
#2713
Coelestin said: I corrected your potential team for you. There are likely only 3 scum in this set up otherwise they are a very weak team imo. Most suspicious of Grape but I will be taking time to look over the other two this morning. ... Is it wrong to start believing in a Jack/Penta/Grape/Logic power wolf scum team? :| @Shinichi-kun Let me confirm again. You are a Lightning Rod? Your role says you're "self-sacrificing" but there's no guarantee that you'll die, right? |
logic340Apr 26, 2017 5:29 AM
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 5:21 AM
#2714
Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 5:34 AM
#2715
logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. |
Apr 26, 2017 5:40 AM
#2716
Jackrito said: What if their are no full doc and full cop and what I have been doing was part of the conditions for "promotion"?logic340 said: Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 5:41 AM
#2717
| Maybe I am just thinking too much about what I know? |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 5:42 AM
#2718
logic340 said: Jackrito said: What if their are no full doc and full cop and what I have been doing was part of the conditions for "promotion"?logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. Then this would be a weird setup and you had amazing luck to pick right people |
Apr 26, 2017 5:51 AM
#2719
Jackrito said: I don't think it has to do with who I picked so much as what I chose to do?logic340 said: Jackrito said: logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. Then this would be a weird setup and you had amazing luck to pick right people |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 6:07 AM
#2720
Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability Okay, but if you aren't willing to prove yourself as town, I hope you start appearing like one next phase. You aren't immune to a rope. I shouldnt have too prove it, my role is proof enough, it wouldnt make sense for my new ability to be anything but town aligned. So unless you can provide examples of that and also explain why the real inheritor hasnt shown up then ur just as much talk as logic or qc is. Also why do i need to die to prove my innocence that seems counter intuitive That role isn't a free pass. Back-ups can be mafia. We've both played set-up where that has been the case. If you want me to highlight every scummy thing you did last phase I can. The post will be longer than what I wrote about grape though. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:08 AM
#2721
logic340 said: Jackrito said: I don't think it has to do with who I picked so much as what I chose to do?logic340 said: Jackrito said: What if their are no full doc and full cop and what I have been doing was part of the conditions for "promotion"?logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. Then this would be a weird setup and you had amazing luck to pick right people I see that sounds intresting if true only time i saw a upgrade role it was used on a person each night and 3rd party. Why say all this in the night though |
Apr 26, 2017 6:09 AM
#2722
Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. Not true. Kit is right here. If multiple people wouldn't have claimed day 1 as town, that is well past 1% of all cases. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:09 AM
#2723
PentaFlare said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability Okay, but if you aren't willing to prove yourself as town, I hope you start appearing like one next phase. You aren't immune to a rope. I shouldnt have too prove it, my role is proof enough, it wouldnt make sense for my new ability to be anything but town aligned. So unless you can provide examples of that and also explain why the real inheritor hasnt shown up then ur just as much talk as logic or qc is. Also why do i need to die to prove my innocence that seems counter intuitive That role isn't a free pass. Back-ups can be mafia. We've both played set-up where that has been the case. If you want me to highlight every scummy thing you did last phase I can. The post will be longer than what I wrote about grape though. I could agree with this my main issue is the phase change story that mentions inheritor makes it sound like a town role, would not be the first time a host misled in one though. |
Apr 26, 2017 6:12 AM
#2724
Coelestin said: Ok, I need to confirm something. @PentaFlare ONLY reply to the questions with yes or no. You know something about someone since the start of D3, right? And so do I. Do you have a strong read (doesn't matter if scum or town read) based on what you know about them or what they've said in the thread? Yes to both. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:15 AM
#2725
DenjaX said: Jackrito said: DenjaX said: Shinichi-Kun said: Use your ability and have the doc protect anyone. Doesnt matter because as lightning rod, even protect goes to you.PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability We can potentially have a night without any deaths. Protect us for the sins of mankind. This optimal strategy is brought to you by DenjaX Inc. Slogan jingle: I respect that~~ This is a fair point actually as long as the doctor protects someone they is no drawback forgot about that part. Of course you "forgot" it because scum cant disclose this very strategy or else itll kneecap them. I am watching you Same goes to @PentaFlare why havent you thought of this? Because I assumed it wouldn't work. It wouldn't be much if a sacrifice if he lived. Worth a shot though. No night kill would be swell. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:18 AM
#2726
Jackrito said: I said it during the day in the post where I said take this as my soft claim. I didn't specify why I felt the way that I did but that I had possibly had a hand in it. logic340 said: Jackrito said: logic340 said: Jackrito said: What if their are no full doc and full cop and what I have been doing was part of the conditions for "promotion"?logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. Then this would be a weird setup and you had amazing luck to pick right people I see that sounds intresting if true only time i saw a upgrade role it was used on a person each night and 3rd party. Why say all this in the night though logic340 said: grrr said: I was waiting for you to say this. I think I know how you became a Dr. and I if I am right then Rosie because a full cop after night 1.I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: It's not a manipulative ability if that is what you are wondering. I have done certain things and other things have happen in response to them. Lets see if this helps clear anything up basically I don't think there was a full a cop or full a dr in this game from the beginning. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: It very well could be and popped into my mind after I saw Rosie's flip considering what I did N1.logic340 said: grrr said: I was waiting for you to say this. I think I know how you became a Dr. and I if I am right then Rosie because a full cop after night 1.I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. guess this explains why i thought rosie soft claim was a full blwon cop and not just a depity the biggest question is does ur ability effect scum roles |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 6:19 AM
#2727
Jackrito said: PentaFlare said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability Okay, but if you aren't willing to prove yourself as town, I hope you start appearing like one next phase. You aren't immune to a rope. I shouldnt have too prove it, my role is proof enough, it wouldnt make sense for my new ability to be anything but town aligned. So unless you can provide examples of that and also explain why the real inheritor hasnt shown up then ur just as much talk as logic or qc is. Also why do i need to die to prove my innocence that seems counter intuitive That role isn't a free pass. Back-ups can be mafia. We've both played set-up where that has been the case. If you want me to highlight every scummy thing you did last phase I can. The post will be longer than what I wrote about grape though. I could agree with this my main issue is the phase change story that mentions inheritor makes it sound like a town role, would not be the first time a host misled in one though. I didn't get the strong feeling it was town. It seemed like it could be an evil with a cruel sense of humour. I am not willing to right off the role as town. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:20 AM
#2728
logic340 said: Jackrito said: I said it during the day in the post where I said take this as my soft claim. I didn't specify why I felt the way that I did but that I had possibly had a hand in it. logic340 said: Jackrito said: I don't think it has to do with who I picked so much as what I chose to do?logic340 said: Jackrito said: What if their are no full doc and full cop and what I have been doing was part of the conditions for "promotion"?logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. Then this would be a weird setup and you had amazing luck to pick right people I see that sounds intresting if true only time i saw a upgrade role it was used on a person each night and 3rd party. Why say all this in the night though logic340 said: grrr said: I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: It very well could be and popped into my mind after I saw Rosie's flip considering what I did N1.logic340 said: grrr said: I was waiting for you to say this. I think I know how you became a Dr. and I if I am right then Rosie because a full cop after night 1.I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. guess this explains why i thought rosie soft claim was a full blwon cop and not just a depity the biggest question is does ur ability effect scum roles Yeah I know you did, not sure why you bring it up again at night though scum may not of noticed it at the time. I get what you are saying it is clear dont worry |
Apr 26, 2017 6:21 AM
#2729
PentaFlare said: Jackrito said: PentaFlare said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: Shinichi-Kun said: PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability Okay, but if you aren't willing to prove yourself as town, I hope you start appearing like one next phase. You aren't immune to a rope. I shouldnt have too prove it, my role is proof enough, it wouldnt make sense for my new ability to be anything but town aligned. So unless you can provide examples of that and also explain why the real inheritor hasnt shown up then ur just as much talk as logic or qc is. Also why do i need to die to prove my innocence that seems counter intuitive That role isn't a free pass. Back-ups can be mafia. We've both played set-up where that has been the case. If you want me to highlight every scummy thing you did last phase I can. The post will be longer than what I wrote about grape though. I could agree with this my main issue is the phase change story that mentions inheritor makes it sound like a town role, would not be the first time a host misled in one though. I didn't get the strong feeling it was town. It seemed like it could be an evil with a cruel sense of humour. I am not willing to right off the role as town. I suppose you have a point there |
Apr 26, 2017 6:22 AM
#2730
| @Shinichi-kun If you can be doctor saved then you should 100% use your ability this phase. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:24 AM
#2731
Jackrito said: I mean I only brought it back up again because you said this "Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town."logic340 said: Jackrito said: logic340 said: Jackrito said: I don't think it has to do with who I picked so much as what I chose to do?logic340 said: Jackrito said: What if their are no full doc and full cop and what I have been doing was part of the conditions for "promotion"?logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. Then this would be a weird setup and you had amazing luck to pick right people I see that sounds intresting if true only time i saw a upgrade role it was used on a person each night and 3rd party. Why say all this in the night though logic340 said: grrr said: I was waiting for you to say this. I think I know how you became a Dr. and I if I am right then Rosie because a full cop after night 1.I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: It's not a manipulative ability if that is what you are wondering. I have done certain things and other things have happen in response to them. Lets see if this helps clear anything up basically I don't think there was a full a cop or full a dr in this game from the beginning. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: It very well could be and popped into my mind after I saw Rosie's flip considering what I did N1.logic340 said: grrr said: I was waiting for you to say this. I think I know how you became a Dr. and I if I am right then Rosie because a full cop after night 1.I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. guess this explains why i thought rosie soft claim was a full blwon cop and not just a depity the biggest question is does ur ability effect scum roles Yeah I know you did, not sure why you bring it up again at night though scum may not of noticed it at the time. I get what you are saying it is clear dont worry But I'll let it be. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 6:26 AM
#2732
PentaFlare said: Why should it be this phase instead of at his discretion? Wouldn't this ability be better served when the mafia don't know it's coming (if town). If he really is mafia then he gets protected anyway right? What do we learn from this?@Shinichi-kun If you can be doctor saved then you should 100% use your ability this phase. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 6:27 AM
#2733
logic340 said: Jackrito said: I mean I only brought it back up again because you said this "Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town."logic340 said: Jackrito said: I said it during the day in the post where I said take this as my soft claim. I didn't specify why I felt the way that I did but that I had possibly had a hand in it. logic340 said: Jackrito said: I don't think it has to do with who I picked so much as what I chose to do?logic340 said: Jackrito said: What if their are no full doc and full cop and what I have been doing was part of the conditions for "promotion"?logic340 said: Jackrito said: DenjaX also suggested the idea of a second 3rd party. If their were two anti-mafia tpr factions then I would expect mafia to be pretty OP? But maybe not so much knowing we have a Deputy, Lightning Rod, and Driver and the possibility of Nurse, Commuter?Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they Also add doc and cop in there as well and that is a really OP town. Then this would be a weird setup and you had amazing luck to pick right people I see that sounds intresting if true only time i saw a upgrade role it was used on a person each night and 3rd party. Why say all this in the night though logic340 said: grrr said: I was waiting for you to say this. I think I know how you became a Dr. and I if I am right then Rosie because a full cop after night 1.I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: It's not a manipulative ability if that is what you are wondering. I have done certain things and other things have happen in response to them. Lets see if this helps clear anything up basically I don't think there was a full a cop or full a dr in this game from the beginning. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: It very well could be and popped into my mind after I saw Rosie's flip considering what I did N1.logic340 said: grrr said: I was waiting for you to say this. I think I know how you became a Dr. and I if I am right then Rosie because a full cop after night 1.I was planning to keep it for me but I assume the mafia is likely to know this so: I am a doctor now. Given that Rosie is not a doctor I believe our precious doctor was converted. It is possible that the rosie death message is fake. Or who knows what. Well in any case I die tonight. Here is my will: Shinichi and chione are town. There is no point wasting time in them. Grapefruit, aa-dono, penta and logic need pressure. Farewell and good luck. you guys can take this as a soft claim if you like. guess this explains why i thought rosie soft claim was a full blwon cop and not just a depity the biggest question is does ur ability effect scum roles Yeah I know you did, not sure why you bring it up again at night though scum may not of noticed it at the time. I get what you are saying it is clear dont worry But I'll let it be. Yeah i forgot that at the time lol, sorry to make you reveal yourself again, I also cant be sure you are truthful either. |
Apr 26, 2017 6:31 AM
#2734
logic340 said: PentaFlare said: Why should it be this phase instead of at his discretion? Wouldn't this ability be better served when the mafia don't know it's coming (if town). If he really is mafia then he gets protected anyway right? What do we learn from this?@Shinichi-kun If you can be doctor saved then you should 100% use your ability this phase. I think it is to test him since actions are not matching role, I agree though forcing them to do it is bad since scum may have a way around it. Which could lead to another mislynch |
Apr 26, 2017 6:33 AM
#2735
logic340 said: PentaFlare said: Why should it be this phase instead of at his discretion? Wouldn't this ability be better served when the mafia don't know it's coming (if town). If he really is mafia then he gets protected anyway right? What do we learn from this?@Shinichi-kun If you can be doctor saved then you should 100% use your ability this phase. Because we haven't caught any scum yet. We are in a bad spot and really need to use every advantage we have. Once we catch one, everything else will fall into place easier. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:34 AM
#2736
logic340 said: PentaFlare said: Why should it be this phase instead of at his discretion? Wouldn't this ability be better served when the mafia don't know it's coming (if town). If he really is mafia then he gets protected anyway right? What do we learn from this?@Shinichi-kun If you can be doctor saved then you should 100% use your ability this phase. We wouldn't learn from it, but there would be no night kill. That's a big advantage. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 6:38 AM
#2737
PentaFlare said: So when you weren't thinking of him being protected and though he would eat the NK what advantage was that supposed to give town?logic340 said: PentaFlare said: @Shinichi-kun If you can be doctor saved then you should 100% use your ability this phase. We wouldn't learn from it, but there would be no night kill. That's a big advantage. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Apr 26, 2017 6:46 AM
#2738
logic340 said: PentaFlare said: So when you weren't thinking of him being protected and though he would eat the NK what advantage was that supposed to give town?logic340 said: PentaFlare said: Why should it be this phase instead of at his discretion? Wouldn't this ability be better served when the mafia don't know it's coming (if town). If he really is mafia then he gets protected anyway right? What do we learn from this?@Shinichi-kun If you can be doctor saved then you should 100% use your ability this phase. We wouldn't learn from it, but there would be no night kill. That's a big advantage. That was less general town help and more that there are certain people/roles I really don't want to die right now and was hoping he could keep them alive with the sacrifice. It was self-motivated for trying to push me closer to gamesolving. |
Be like this seal. It is a happy seal. ~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~ |
Apr 26, 2017 7:30 AM
#2739
PentaFlare said: Coelestin said: Ok, I need to confirm something. @PentaFlare ONLY reply to the questions with yes or no. You know something about someone since the start of D3, right? And so do I. Do you have a strong read (doesn't matter if scum or town read) based on what you know about them or what they've said in the thread? Yes to both. Great. logic340 said: Coelestin said: I corrected your potential team for you. There are likely only 3 scum in this set up otherwise they are a very weak team imo. Most suspicious of Grape but I will be taking time to look over the other two this morning. ... Is it wrong to start believing in a Jack/Penta/Grape/Logic power wolf scum team? :| @Shinichi-kun Let me confirm again. You are a Lightning Rod? Your role says you're "self-sacrificing" but there's no guarantee that you'll die, right? I agree with you and Jack on Grape. Really need to take a closer look again though. He's been let off since the train on himself dissolved and since then he hasn't posted much... If he's got time a poke or two might be good. @DenjaX Do you have any read on Grape? @Kit At which page are you currently? |
Apr 26, 2017 7:39 AM
#2740
| @Grapefruit21 Poke so I won't forget~ Would like to know your top 3 lynch targets tomorrow after the phase change. |
Apr 26, 2017 8:30 AM
#2741
Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: the percent does matter because by making the likelihood of me being town appear so low you are influencing town opinion and encouraging scum to agree with you /say I'm scumKit said: Shinichi-Kun said: so you've admitted that the situations are similar and that you have a bias/grudge against Miller claims. and you probably don't know how to use percentage to describe real probability so you're pulling 99/100 scum chances out of your ass. Ok.Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: you accept that karote made a mistake in regard to his role but won't accept Ruu could have?Kit said: Karotes claim makes it seem like he doesn't know his own role ie messing up a fake claim but I think fake claim would be more set in ones mind? Could be he forgot the exact wording of his role and that happens to me often so I'm not sure , would like to see more behavior from him to judge so so far I don't think one way or another on his claim. Pretty sure this is exactly what happened You have NO right to point out "this is probably what happened" in the aftermath of the lynch when you are doing the same thing to me that caused karotes lynch Not reallyur comparing 2 different roles in a similar situation also i had no involvement in karote dieing. Also the reason im not pursueing you is cause of that 1% doubt. Same implies to tpr i hate the role and distrust all tpr roles, miller claim literally could be a traitor role with some kind of activation like the judas role for all we know smh >3>. Also the exact percents dont matter because im saying ur not getting my vote yet anyways. Im not influencing anyone my charisma sucks lol |
Apr 26, 2017 8:32 AM
#2742
logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I wouldn't call it trying to take another players style. I have already explained that it's me trying to take a more passive approach instead of living at the top of the thread but it's not working out well for me. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: There is no winning for me is there? I want to go Rinto mode you guys wont let me (but Karote can and gets town read for it). I come out of Rinto mode give you what you want (Townie lyncher logic) and I'm capitalizing on people's mistakes?DenjaX said: aa-dono said: it is the other way around. He thought he was hider but he corrected himself which I find the most townie thing to do. And he admitted his mistake.DenjaX said: I think you're trying to justify his role for him. Didn't he say he wasn't the hider and he mistaken the role of bus driver at the time?Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. What I am most concerned is those people capitalizing his mistake. So people like jack and logic? Karote is changing his playstyle hes just playing the same ole way as every game lets not forget he was also town lol, u dont get to be town read for trying to match the town style of another player if anything that should be considered scummy. Shinichi-Kun said: Do you feel that we should just be claiming roles at any ole time? Jack didn't really have time to claim and have it mean anything with like 3 minutes before phase change? Why should Penta claim? I guess you could lump me into the same pile as them since I haven't claimed either. U 2 can throw salt all over me it wont change much @logic340 what are your throughs on the fact that jack and penta are both ok throwing away another town role without claiming their own role. I find that super odd @denjax @kit same question for you 2 Of course not but its almost day 4 and soon we will be in mylo if we arent already so i dont see the need to be hiding roles at this point. Cause its not easy i try that all the timem but as soon as i see a post i feel a need to reply to i jump right in. |
Apr 26, 2017 8:33 AM
#2743
Apr 26, 2017 8:33 AM
#2744
Coelestin said: ... Is it wrong to start believing in a Jack/Penta/Grape/Logic power wolf scum team? :| @Shinichi-kun Let me confirm again. You are a Lightning Rod? Your role says you're "self-sacrificing" but there's no guarantee that you'll die, right? no gunrantee if their is a protection role in place, that uses their ability on the sasme night i use mine then im pretty sure i can live. |
Apr 26, 2017 8:35 AM
#2745
Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: He scum reads those who scumread him (OMGUS'ed me). Just not seeing anything that could be considered remotely town and hen I ask no one has a post they can point to in support of it. What makes it an omgus? Because u suspect him? I might be biased here cause i also suspect you alot more recently. I feel like people mistake scum hunting for being town aligned, cause when i read people i consider their opinions and almost everything they say as a defining factor for their alignment. Sure their actions say otherwise but i feel like nothing QC has said has been that scummy, not for you as an example i can go pull out a bunch of lines that makes u scummy. Only problem is ur all action while he is all words who is more scummy? You do realise the first part is the def of the term right. Ok I'm getting sick of this Quco has not done much scummy maybe but not done much town here. Stop defending other people for not doing things poperly I can't deal with another loss because of bad town play. People need to step up at some level we are suppose to be a team so we can't carry people to end game who will ruin us. So we are suppose to lynch them instead? Not everyone plays with a town mindset i know i sometimes dont, but sometimes we have to work with or around that jack. Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. You know he is not doing that right, even though I do agree. Claim then talk :D, not gonna be told how to play my town game by people hiding behind their roles. Not sure how how I'm hiding behind my role to hide behide it would mean I'm using it as the sole reason to not be lynched. I don't see why me claiming should improve my standing it just gives scum more info.You were forced to claim by own bad play no i was forced to claim because i was told my lack of scum hunting made me scum which in reality it didnt, also i hinted at my role meany times. |
Apr 26, 2017 8:37 AM
#2746
Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Kit said: Shinichi-Kun said: that doesn't make any sense, instinctively people would rather hide anti town roles. It's counter intuitive to claim Miller even if it is optimal. I can't criticize ruu cause I might have done the same, and two others (Penta and Jack,) said they would not claim either Kit said: Well I see ppl are going to want me in angry and defensive mode! @jackrito @logic340 consider the following: Ruu never had Miller before and didn't know how to properly handle the role. I hate when players are on a newbies ass for not completely knowing all game meta ever and exactly how to play (in any game not just mafia) so it annoys me that people have ruus town play expectations so high. Miller not claiming does not mean they aren't Miller, it just means they aren't playing standard Miller strat.The soft claim is extremely obvious to me, having been in that game myself, I'm not sure what to say if you thing ruu set that up in preparation for a fake claim. Town breadcrumb their roles too, if anything it's nai but shows she didn't make it up during the night, she claimed it during the day. Logic why do you want me to say Ruu made a mistake? That's just another excuse, and a really shitty one because scum make mistakes too. I am not in ruus head so I can only point to evidence that she really is town If you want to prove my claim then invest me and see that I invest as mafia ;) is true. Hue ur funny that just be a waste of invest lol Also Ruu knew what were abilty/passive was anyone with a town mindset would be like oh shit my ability hurrts town i should tell the rest of the players. We are assuming the norm because of experience we are assuming people should be able to tell when their abilities are anti town lol. They can do them if u claim anwywhere outside of the first day phae ur are 99% scum end of story, only reason i havent pursued you is cause i think u might be tpr. I doubt they is another 3rd based off wincon having 2 anti scum 3rd is unbalanced if they were what are they EVen so they should still be scum or a traitor role for all we knw |
Apr 26, 2017 8:37 AM
#2747
Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: DenjaX said: aa-dono said: it is the other way around. He thought he was hider but he corrected himself which I find the most townie thing to do. And he admitted his mistake.DenjaX said: I think you're trying to justify his role for him. Didn't he say he wasn't the hider and he mistaken the role of bus driver at the time?Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. What I am most concerned is those people capitalizing his mistake. So people like jack and logic? Blame me if you want I don't care tbh if he makes up a role and them refused to give me info when I ask or even vote for that matter. I can't save them I need people to work with me he messed up and could of fixed it but gave up. I get you but i honestly dont feel like he was lacking in asmuch info as your getting at. |
Apr 26, 2017 8:40 AM
#2748
DenjaX said: Jackrito said: DenjaX said: Shinichi-Kun said: Use your ability and have the doc protect anyone. Doesnt matter because as lightning rod, even protect goes to you.PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. am i missing something here? Cause unless you've claimed then i dont think u have any right to tell me how to use my ability We can potentially have a night without any deaths. Protect us for the sins of mankind. This optimal strategy is brought to you by DenjaX Inc. Slogan jingle: I respect that~~ This is a fair point actually as long as the doctor protects someone they is no drawback forgot about that part. Of course you "forgot" it because scum cant disclose this very strategy or else itll kneecap them. I am watching you Same goes to @PentaFlare why havent you thought of this? I didnt forget this but if grrr is the doctor of course im worried lmfao Im watching both penta and jack tbh right now |
Apr 26, 2017 8:40 AM
#2749
Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: There is no winning for me is there? I want to go Rinto mode you guys wont let me (but Karote can and gets town read for it). I come out of Rinto mode give you what you want (Townie lyncher logic) and I'm capitalizing on people's mistakes?DenjaX said: aa-dono said: it is the other way around. He thought he was hider but he corrected himself which I find the most townie thing to do. And he admitted his mistake.DenjaX said: I think you're trying to justify his role for him. Didn't he say he wasn't the hider and he mistaken the role of bus driver at the time?Jackrito said: For the record, I believe Karote's claim. I believe people have 2 roles like Rosie have (Deputy - Cop) unless they are vanillas/goons. I think Karote might have a Hider as a modifier.logic340 said: Where is everyone? We need to discuss Karote's final claim. Who believes it's possible and why? I really don't know how to feel about it as I don't know much about balance in a setup. If it's scum aligned (and I believe it could be) then it's dangerous and needs to be dealt with. If it's true (the bus driver claim) then if anyone targeted Karote or Jack N1 they might want to reconsider their results. I don't buy it at all tbh they are some flaws in his thought pattern as well like him claiming he never compared it to hider which I have evidence of from the night. We also need him to explain his actions and why they picked the people they did. I see no reason to see them as town atm. @Karote care to verify? Now to question, is there a need for a transporter for this setup? Looking at peoples claim and flips makes it possible due to the setup is highly interactive. My only gripe about Karote's claims are the glaring mistakes about his claim and also the convenient timing of his claims. I find it suspicious. Other than that, his claim should be legit. It is a matter of knowing whether hes a town transporter or mafia transporter. What I am most concerned is those people capitalizing his mistake. So people like jack and logic? Karote is changing his playstyle hes just playing the same ole way as every game lets not forget he was also town lol, u dont get to be town read for trying to match the town style of another player if anything that should be considered scummy. Just wondering how do you change playstyle and play same way, I do agree on playstyle change of logic though *isnt lol i miss typed is. |
Apr 26, 2017 8:41 AM
#2750
Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: He scum reads those who scumread him (OMGUS'ed me). Just not seeing anything that could be considered remotely town and hen I ask no one has a post they can point to in support of it. What makes it an omgus? Because u suspect him? I might be biased here cause i also suspect you alot more recently. I feel like people mistake scum hunting for being town aligned, cause when i read people i consider their opinions and almost everything they say as a defining factor for their alignment. Sure their actions say otherwise but i feel like nothing QC has said has been that scummy, not for you as an example i can go pull out a bunch of lines that makes u scummy. Only problem is ur all action while he is all words who is more scummy? You do realise the first part is the def of the term right. Ok I'm getting sick of this Quco has not done much scummy maybe but not done much town here. Stop defending other people for not doing things poperly I can't deal with another loss because of bad town play. People need to step up at some level we are suppose to be a team so we can't carry people to end game who will ruin us. So we are suppose to lynch them instead? Not everyone plays with a town mindset i know i sometimes dont, but sometimes we have to work with or around that jack. Jackrito said: Shinichi-Kun said: Jackrito said: PentaFlare said: To be blunt, I want to remove you from my PoE pool. You have not been acting in a townlike way, so the best way I can determine your alignment is having you die for town this night. You know he is not doing that right, even though I do agree. Claim then talk :D, not gonna be told how to play my town game by people hiding behind their roles. Not sure how how I'm hiding behind my role to hide behide it would mean I'm using it as the sole reason to not be lynched. I don't see why me claiming should improve my standing it just gives scum more info.You were forced to claim by own bad play no i was forced to claim because i was told my lack of scum hunting made me scum which in reality it didnt, also i hinted at my role meany times. Of course I know that I tried to work with Karote, but they just gave up it , we can't work around them forever or they will win if scum Grr showed that in a recent game. i need at least some give and take with people. On the bottom bit I would not say you hinted many times at it, but I'm not the best with hints so maybe you did. The fact of the matter is if no one scum hunts town will never win, it does not make people scum for not doing so but means they are not helping the rest of us either. |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Give something to the user above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Soren - Oct 9, 2015 |
1395 |
by Serafos
»»
Yesterday, 9:10 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8755 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 11, 7:29 PM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1996 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2877 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1170 |
by Serafos
»»
Dec 7, 10:20 PM |