Game v9: Castle Panic (Cult) | Game End - And thus magic rue the world. (2700 - ) - Forums

Apr 16, 2017 8:56 PM

#2701

Kit

Offline

Jan 2008

6269

momentairly thought doki was rosie because of the new forum set. wtf

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . anime . manga . updates . ♫♪. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Apr 16, 2017 8:56 PM

#2702

logic340

Offline

Jan 2010

15122

Sleipnirr said:
okay I am hammering vote reiynii

If he flips town this adds to the Rosie/CP/Sleipnirr cult team idea.

Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC

Apr 16, 2017 8:56 PM

#2703

Doughkey

Offline

Oct 2012

4729

Kit said:

Doughkey said:
So lynch is down to Rainy and CP, I am going to go do a quick read of what everyone has said about CP.

vote cp, only town are on cp and there are certainly scum on reiynii :3

k.

Apr 16, 2017 8:56 PM

#2704

PentaFlare

Offline

Aug 2014

6565

Kit said:

PentaFlare said:

Kit said:

PentaFlare said:

Kit said:

PentaFlare said:

Kit said:

PentaFlare said:

logic340 said:

PentaFlare said:

logic340 said:

PentaFlare said:

CorruptedPurity said:

logic340 said:

CorruptedPurity said:

logic340 said:

Oyasumi_Rosie said:

RE1031 said:

CorruptedPurity said:

RE1031 said:
Priest - grrr
Rosie - psychic
Ruu - pathologist
Logic - Town Crier
Reiynii - ??? (Sleepwalker presumably)

Wait who else claimed?

Sleepwalker doesn't know who they are. So as I said, we have 1 extra PR...

Right. Yes they are awfully suspicious.

I could check Kit tonight, though I think that might be a waste of my power

//Of course... even if we did this, since we are both telling the truth, you'd never believe us lol

I would say check:
Doki, Penta, or Astros tonight.

@Oyasumi_Rosie I BEG you to check Kit. I have deep reasons for this. But for now, I can say that if she is cleared, everyone can take her report in without any fear or skepticism and town will benefit alot. If she is scum, well, all the more better for us; one down.

I beg you to talk with all the town members and actually come to a consensus this time (unlike with the no lynch). I personally don't think Kit is a good look since we want to catch the Zombies or Cultist and it seems less likely that that is kit at this time with reiynii and Qoco both being caught up in a PR lie?

I said I have deep reasons. I need two conditions to be fulfilled before I can do something... One of them is Kit's alignment, the second is the number of zombies at start of day 4, AKA I need Kit's report. I have a strong theory that will find scum regardless of the results of Kit's report (I still need it though for it to work). But first I need to know that I can trust Kit. I beg of you, give me the OK that Kit is town and I promise you fireworks. Don't ask me about my plan now or the zombies can play around it at night, just trust me and check Kit. I need to 100% trust her or we're going to be mislynching.

Remember this thing? Purity kept harping on about how they had this big plan to track down all the zombies. That's a lot of attention being driven their way, especially from the zombies. The zombies are going to want Purity lynched or converted. As a cult leader, this is suuuuuper dangerous because you could risk killing your entire faction by getting the zombies against you. The cult leader needs to not be super aggressive in their attack against the zombies. The kind of cult leader I would expect is someone who indirectly hurts the zombies. Gives credit to claims like Kit and RE for example. People who's roles hurt the zombies. Supporting them hurts the zombies in the long run (unless Kit is fakeclaiming, but that's a whole other problem).

Unless you are saying Kit is the Zombie at this point there are none on CP's train so that point would be moot unless you think kit is the zombie?

I would respond to your question, but it is soooooooo unrelated to what I said that I can't even understand what you could possibly be asking.

What it has to do with your post is the fact that unless Kit is a Zombie your point is moot because the Zombies aren't trying to get CP lynched. It destroys your whole thought about getting the zombies on his bad side. From my point of view. It's not a defense for CP not Cult leader is what I am getting at.

Huh? My point is that Purity was talking about a huge plan to catch all the zombies as long as Kit is proven innocent. It has nothing to do with who is voting for who and everything to do with Purity having a way to catch zombies. This is dangerous for the zombies if it is true, so they will try to get rid of Purity. It doesn't matter if they actually have taken action to do so, simply by opening themselves up to the possibility, Purity would be making a bad play if they were cult leader. I don't think they can be cult leader.

Zombies can't convert cult, so perhaps he believed he had the charismatic upper hand to get out of a lynch even if zombies were against him, or that he would look townie enough even with that plan that zombies would not try to lynch him, preferring to find the "real" cult leader. Zombies don't get free info on cult.

That doesn't make any sense. You are basically accusing Purity of being so egotistical that they could talk their way out of any situation so the fact that they have an entire faction to carry would phase them one bit. Becoming a target would be a really bad call for the cult leader. It's simple.

I would call it confidence? And there's only a few zombies and they aren't all on the same page, jeez

Same page or not, they don't want to be caught. What Purity did was similar to taking a loudspeaker and yelling "HEY EVERYONE! I KNOW HOW TO CATCH ALL THE ZOMBIES AND I CAN DO IT BY THE END OF DAY 4!". Of course the zombies will be scared of that. It would be stupid for cult leader to make the zombies scared of them.

You honestly think zombies would get scared from that and not think he's full of shit? ALL of the zombies? of which there were only 2 at the time?

After the number of crazy claims this game, it would be so much safer to kill any possible threat. The zombies want to play it safe with their numbers.

seriously, 2 people trying to get you lynched is not a threat. Source: astros and doki wanted me lynched and i didn't die

You don't understand the mentality of your lynch deciding your entire chance of victory. You worry a lot more about two people wanting you lynched.

Be like this seal. It is a happy seal.
~Review Guidelines~ | ~Recommendation Guidelines~ | ~Mafia Society~

Apr 16, 2017 8:57 PM

#2705

Kit

Offline

Jan 2008

6269

PentaFlare said:

logic340 said:

PentaFlare said:

logic340 said:

PentaFlare said:

logic340 said:

PentaFlare said:

logic340 said:

PentaFlare said:

logic340 said:
4 people voting reiynii right now what is the case against him?
Fake PR claim
Husband Hunting
Voted grrr D1
Knew grrr was lying?
What else?

Process of Elimination. My case is based on the idea that while everyone else seems at least a little townie, reiynii doesn't have an ounce of towniness yet. That is just scummy relative to everyone else.

Then he is in a basket with grrr basically. Do you think scum would act scummy especially if they are the cult leader?

I hate the case on reiynii and want all the votes moved to somewhere else. If he flips town there is no making them answer for these votes as cult will essentially hold the vote majority.

In a basket with grrr? grrr seems decently townie to me.
I don't think the cult leader would act scummy. I think the cult leader would be quite passive and try to slip by unnoticed. A lot of what reiynii has done fits the bill. Not making any strong pushes, making a fakeclaim and then backing off it. Blaming other's scumreads on their change in playstyle, etc. They don't want to be held accountable for anything. It's too neutral to be town at this point in the game.

How does grrr seem decently town. He seemed more town as scum in Kitty Mafia than he does here? I am scratching my head reading this post? I believe his is town but only because he seems to be more helpful to town as scum. I definitely wouldn't call it a town read though. So yeah pretty much throw him in a basket with grrr because trying to read these players is pretty much the same. Hard as fuck and knowing grrr lied you still are confident in a town read is worrisome for your information. Some of your current reads are worrisome acutally and I cannot clear you from being OZ as yet either because you didn't vote Qoco or even really show a feeling of anything when I called him out as scum D2.

Sorry what? Want to go look at my D2 again? The specific part where I voted Qoco and stuck on them even when they claimed pathologist? Is that not enough "voting for Qoco" for you?

grrr seems townie to me. Not because of their behaviour, because I never try to read grrr off behaviour, but because of my usual tools. VCA is the first. Qoco and him can't be partners because of it. He also can't be a cult leader, because like I have been saying with Purity, he wouldn't draw tons of attention to himself if he was. Therefore, not an original converter. Seems decently townie.

I hate to do this but I am calling bullshit on your Cult Leader grrr read. He voted me 5 fucking days in a row in Kitty Mafia and town let that shit happen so saying he wouldn't draw that type of attention to himself when you just watched it happen really chaps me right now and makes me want to vote for you.

But grrr didn't have to survive for his faction to win it Kitty mafia. You can't compare playing mafia to playing cult leader. Trying to play cult leader is really really hard. You have to basically be flawless. It is an enormous amount of pressure. That will change how anyone plays, so comparing a mafia meta is irrelevant.

Who says Cult leader has to survive? What if the cult can survive but not spread without the leader?

Doesn't the entire cult commit suicide when the cult leader dies? That's how all cults I've had in games in the past have worked.

nothing in the rules says that

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . anime . manga . updates . ♫♪. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Apr 16, 2017 8:57 PM

#2706

Kasai

Offline

Jan 2015

2911

vote change cp

Apr 16, 2017 8:57 PM

#2707

CorruptedPurity

Offline

Dec 2014

3945

RE1031 said:
@CorruptedPurity
What's your master plan? What's your master plan? What's your master plan?

I already told you. It was a skit to find out Rosie's and Kit's alignment. I couldn't kill all zombies, it was a bluff but it was also a way for me to check Kit and Rosie.

Apr 16, 2017 8:58 PM

#2708

Kasai

Offline

Jan 2015

2911

I am no cultist or zombie with anyone

Apr 16, 2017 8:58 PM

#2709

Doughkey

Offline

Oct 2012

4729

So I am completely neutral to both Rainy and CP, I think Rainys previous claim was risky for a scum to pull as a player I deem to not be ballsy. Cp has the added possibility of having been converted, whether that be zombie in best case scenario or cultist in slightly less favorable scenario. Rainy is an unlikely conversion target

Apr 16, 2017 8:58 PM

#2710

Astros

Offline

Dec 2013

9885

Sleip is sus.

Apr 16, 2017 8:58 PM

#2711