yurkin said: Yeah, that's true. He'll shade his buddies, but I don't think I've seen him vote a buddy before, except for Crossbell, whom he later switched his vote off of one of the later days of that game. I think he'd probably also advise aa-dono and Eyeh to not vote on the same wagon.RE said: I'm definitely more confident on Phraze being town. Then you, then Abu. Then maybe even Mishu. The whole deal here with the amnesiac => sensor plan being a bust just feels really convenient, especially with that information coming out after Wisp's death. It could just be in my head. Something feels wrong here, is all. Hmm well if it was available for use more than once that would break the game for scum. Game design wise there is nothing weird about it. Like how the reloader can't give one more shot to the amnesiac for example. Mhmm but his involvement looked real on many occasions thought he's town. And logic never busses that's true [well can't remember what happened with D1 in the first Easter Egg game] I don't mean convenient as in a second use just not being available to us in general, but the fact he found out when he found out. I guess someone should have checked prior to today though. Kiiruma said: And the usual behavior/interactions with dead scum.Okay, so Aa is our obvious vote for today which is confirmed by the VC. The problem is that we've already used the Sensor ability and lost the Detective egg so we don't really have much info to go on other than wagonomics? |
...better to be hated for what you are than loved for something you are not. |
EyehAsherEyeh said: Hi everyone! Glad to play with you again, Wisp aa shin and others on that playerlist :D Gonna throw a random vote on the Regicide. Heretic! VOTE : Jamie_Lannister Was this vote really random? I would like to think so. I can't wrap my head around the Kiana-Abu interactions on page 6 but I feel like they are the most important of all Kiana-someone interactions in D1. logic340 said: Phraze said: Abu is not scum here try something else.I have an idea! @AbuHumaid don't u think questioning my rvs is unnecessary? looks scummy. /s This logic post ugh. I can see it coming from town. I don't think mafia logic tries to appeal to town Abu this much. Oh right, this. Reason I didn't want Phraze's was because I thought she was getting lynched so no use checking that egg. aa-dono said: Has Phraze ever been lazy town? This post is good for Phraze. Logic puts out the idea of Phraze being lazy town instead of scum and dono discredits it. Not sure if discredit is the right word here but yeah. logic340 said: i wouldn't have waited so long but i am anti-bus so there's that if she does flip scum. Considering we have one mafia left and logic and Phraze and unaligned, this post is good for town logic. Phraze said: also... I never been in a scumgame where my team wanted to bury me. I guess that's good for future ref This seems like a weird thing to mention unless for the first time you’re in a scumgame where your teams wants to bury you and you want to take advantage of the fact you were bussed in the future. dono’s vote wasn’t on you then though so fair enough. logic340 said: I'm going to give Kiiruma a chance i remember from the great race mafia (he was town) he tends to focus on mechanics a bit. I'll lend my support to the eyeh train for now. vote: eyeh Okay, in hindsight, these are probably coming for town. The “for now” from logic turns me off but at least I can be more than half sure about Abu. In general pushing the Kiiruma lynch to save Eyeh would have probably been quite easy for scum Abu/logic here. Phraze said: not sure I like the shift onto Eyeh. looks easy too. On the other hand Phraze disagrees with the train, and me as well in my post just below. imo it seemed too easy of a train as well so I can’t blame Phraze. So I like the reasons for voting Eyeh and those for NOT voting Eyeh, which makes this a little hard to read but it’s likely we’re all town here. Plus, unrelated, but let's be real, two scum on Phraze in FVC would be such a big bus. Mishukax said: Mh. Just realized a mechanical aspect of the game that makes it so that although Abu is my biggest townread, if Eyeh flips town Abu becomes my biggest scumread, assuming no other player does something way too scummy for my tastes that would put them above Abu. Would like to talk to the psychic egg about this since I'm not sure I want to put this out in the open, but psychic egg could easily be maf. Letting you guys know so that it doesn't feel as random if I can bring it up D2. But it still makes way more sense to put Abu as town for now. This is me being me. No one ever asked about this but I feel the need to justify myself here even if the LB is now dead. My reasoning back then was that, had I been LB, I would do my utmost to look town rather than losing time trying to signal through their own posts, because my goal would be to get killed by mafia, not to get lynched. I could achieve this by working with town and trying to appear as a big threat to mafia. So technically it became logical to think of my biggest town read Abu as simultaneously my biggest scum read. Thankfully Eyeh flipped scum, so obviously Abu is not “faking to be the best town ever,” if that’s even something one can easily fake in the first place. Not to mention that this whole idea of “LB wants to look town instead of signaling” is far from being the absolute LB mindset. I did see it as a possibility though. I thought the LB would be shooting for Literary and Decorative (two roles that can give hints), and considering Kiiruma had already claimed Literary, this is why I wanted the Decorative egg to claim earlier, to be able to compare the two players. It completely slipped my mind that LB could be neighbourizer. |
| Backreading, I am okay with voting Kiiruma next. There's a lot less to say about these than I even thought, I did have the impression he hadn't posted a lot but the thought crossed my mind a few times that people were discrediting this slot too much because of "mechanical talk." Now I totally see where that's coming from. That said, I still wouldn't lock this slot as scum if it wasn't for a few additional things that bothered me: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=500#msg57571297 Eyeh voting Kiiruma. This post may easily have been an advice or a disagreement of Kii's scumplay rather than accusations against a townie. logic340 said: How serious are these votes on Kiiruma? While the Kiiruma vote prospects are building and Phraze is accused of floundering by Lucian, logic leaves room with this post to reinterpret Kiiruma. And then: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=600#msg57574920 Eyeh infamously votes Phraze in response to the train. To add to it: https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=700#msg57577283 Eyeh finds Kiiruma scummier than Phraze (while still voting Phraze). https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=600#msg57574688 dono’s D1 reads. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=800#msg57579689 dono is also scumreading Kiiruma without voting him. |
Just posting this to save, I don't think that Shin is a pressing matter after looking at Kiiruma and ironace, plus I want to wait to get his D2 posts before saying anything. I remember his D2 as more productive and opinionated. |
| Other notes https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=300#msg57566581 yurkin saying kiana is lost bunny. Considering the LB was not killed on N1 this makes yurkin quite town actually. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=350#msg57566615 And now yurkin saying Kiana is scum? maybe she meant lost bunny there? In any case, if she's scum, she would have killed Kiana in most scenarios. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=350#msg57567621 Shin saying he knows a few people who could be LB. I'd like to say this is similar to yurkin identifying the LB and not killing them during night, but not quite, since Shin's guesses at who is LB were probably wrong back then lol, plus he never did say who he thought it was, so even as scum there's no indication that Shin knew who the LB was. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=550#msg57572868 Phraze voting Lucian + yurkin agreeing below. On one hand, a Lucian lynch was impossible on D1 so this hardly comes from mafia for that reason. On another hand, this could just be testing the waters on an eventual Lucian lynch, especially since there were players like me who had heavy doubts about Lucian. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1780306&show=600#msg57574639 logic’s D1 reads, for reference. dono town lean is to note but I'm not making a big deal out of it. I didn't think dono's day 1 was *particularly* scummy myself but I still would have preferred a neutral read here. |
| I know that's a lot of "for reference" but I like being organized when backreading. Hopefully it helps you out too. Sorry if the direct links annoy you, I just couldn't be arsed to number the posts. Before I go I will say that I am not voting dono for the simple reason that it is dono and you guys can think what you want about that. <3 Vote: Kiiruma |
| I just got told I quoted posts elsewhere, don't worry, it's just my secret club I use to post drafts of various sign-ups and to archive some profile stuff. The thread name CCC Secret Santa is the name of a secret santa event I prepared for another club, I just used that thread to preview my posts. My bad though, I forgot you can get pinged from a secret club. Please disregard this >.< |
Mishukax said: i have done this as town before i had a secret mafia notes club and ruu (of all people) was tagged in a post. Needless to say it's oog so i wont hold it against you nor will i use it in your favor. I now use a 3rd party website for mafia notes. I just got told I quoted posts elsewhere, don't worry, it's just my secret club I use to post drafts of various sign-ups and to archive some profile stuff. The thread name CCC Secret Santa is the name of a secret santa event I prepared for another club, I just used that thread to preview my posts. My bad though, I forgot you can get pinged from a secret club. Please disregard this >.< |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC  |
| aa-dono-scum lean Kiiruma-idk Shinichi-kun-slight scum lean since i feel like the games in which is is town he tends to have more idk..impact? Phraze-i never understand her enough to give her a lean, but this time, i believe she is town. yurkin-idk RE-town logic340-town prolly, scum logic feels less ... responsive? Mishukax-idk AbuHumaid-town ironace-whatever |
 |
| what makes u all sure of kii tho? |
|
| ~scrambled egg ~explosive egg ~spooky egg ~detective egg ~chrono egg ~sparkling egg ~musical egg ~decorative egg ~literary egg ~psychic egg ~full metal egg ~crystal egg ~camouflage egg ~angel egg |
|
AbuHumaid said: Vote: aa-dono Now it's time for Shin and Mishu to vote themselves. And Kiiruma to vote Shin. Why would i vote myself? I'm town lol i would never allow anyone but myself to be the hammer vote. Phraze said: if things come to worse tho.. amnesiac could be scum. Wisp died. They still have very little choice in what they choose, cause if they don't follow us they just get lynched. ironace said: vote:ironace ironace said: gotta say i dont like shinichi just being kind of .. there Says the person who is voting himself and has done as little as i have. RE said: logic340 said: OH MY GOD WHYI just spoke to togs sensor plan will not work since it was already activated..... Its a very strong ability thats why lol AbuHumaid said: Inactive/lurky players are so fucking frustrating, looking at Shin, Ace, and Kiiruma. Why even join the game if you can't dedicate some time for the game? Sigh says the person who has overrall lurked more than me in all the games they played. See how that works my friend? AbuHumaid said: logic340 said: Mishu is unlikely, I jailed him, and Ace redirected Awa, yet mafia still managed to kill Wisp.Mishukax, RE, yurkin, Shinichi-kun, Kiiruma Mafia likely among these players Remove yurkin and RE PoE mishu/shin/kii there is still an off chance 1 of those is scum. My opinion is that if awa was known to be scum she wouldnt make the kill. |
  |
RE said: yurkin said: I'm definitely more confident on Phraze being town. Then you, then Abu. Then maybe even Mishu.Really? Logic is the one I'm most sure about being town The whole deal here with the amnesiac => sensor plan being a bust just feels really convenient, especially with that information coming out after Wisp's death. It could just be in my head. Something feels wrong here, is all. Nothing really wrong about it, i thought it wouldnt work because the ability itself is busted. Which is why it normally only has a 1 shot. |
|
@shinichi-kun but im always like this tho :< |
|
ironace said: what makes u all sure of kii tho? Kinda feels like hes playing the clueless sheep if that makes any sense. |
|
| Phraze Logic Yurkin RE as of right now could never be scum Abu is prob scum but less likely than the rest Most likely to be scum Mishu Iron Awa- If she flips scum that clears mishu, due to how the night actions went. If she doesn't flip scum its still possible for mishu to be scum. kiiruma |
|
Phraze (3) - Kiana_Kaslana, EyehAsherEyeh, aa-dono Don't forget kyle checked this wagon and at the time kiana wasn't shot so he was still town. Which means that awa is actually 100% scum which in that case confirms mishu is town. |
|
| @ironace Who did you redirect awa too? |
|
 |
| @aa-dono word of advice when there is a role that can check wagons, avoid voting with your scum buddies. As to avoid situations exactly like this one where you both were on the off wagon. |
|
| I added some clues to find scum here: |
|
| Ignore he clues cause i am like 99% sure I know who the final scum is. |
|
ironace said: Can you explain the Shinichi read to me? Which games are you thinking of specifically?aa-dono-scum lean Kiiruma-idk Shinichi-kun-slight scum lean since i feel like the games in which is is town he tends to have more idk..impact? Phraze-i never understand her enough to give her a lean, but this time, i believe she is town. yurkin-idk RE-town logic340-town prolly, scum logic feels less ... responsive? Mishukax-idk AbuHumaid-town ironace-whatever And what makes this game different for you, when it comes to reading Phraze? |
...better to be hated for what you are than loved for something you are not. |
idk who it was redirected to, it just randomizes the target of their ability |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: Ignore he clues cause i am like 99% sure I know who the final scum is. do tell then >_> |
|
@aa-dono what were ur results? |
|
| @re its just a gut feeling on shinichi on phraze its cause i feel like phraze believes she knows my meta since she has played with me as scum in one game(loss was on me tho) where i lurked alot if she sees me inactive she instantly has her eyes on me- that i feel is a town telling thing from her |
|
ironace said: Can you explain to me how you went about making your list?~scrambled egg ~explosive egg ~spooky egg ~detective egg ~chrono egg ~sparkling egg ~musical egg ~decorative egg ~literary egg ~psychic egg ~full metal egg ~crystal egg ~camouflage egg ~angel egg |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
logic340 said: lolironace said: Can you explain to me how you went about making your list?~scrambled egg ~explosive egg ~spooky egg ~detective egg ~chrono egg ~sparkling egg ~musical egg ~decorative egg ~literary egg ~psychic egg ~full metal egg ~crystal egg ~camouflage egg ~angel egg i thought the game would start earlier than it did, so i thought i would be available for d1 and then try to screw stuff up n1 i just wanted some scrambled eggs i told togs that and said that i dont really care which egg i get, except scrambled hee said all right but make a list since it feels unfair for others? or somethign like that i said, all right ill do it for ya i dont remember why i chose the explosive egg second and not spooky, since i recall my reasoning for spooky-since i get myslynched alot, id still be helpfull dead most of the others i didnt chose since i felt like others would be better in using theem like angel or fullmetal |
|
🐰 Vote Count 3.3 🐰 aa-dono (5) - logic340, yurkin, Phraze, AbuHumaid, RE ironace (1) - ironace Kiiruma (1) - Mishukax Not Voting (3) - aa-dono, Kiiruma, Shinichi-kun >>Day 3 Timer<< |
 |
aa-dono said: I added some clues to find scum here: Well played after listening to this song i see what you did. If i am reading into correctly it's something only i would notice. |
|
By not replying to this ur just strengthening my scum read just saying. |
|
| You realize aa-dono has essentially been red checked, right? Also, care to share who the final scum is? |
...better to be hated for what you are than loved for something you are not. |
aa-dono said: I would love some answers to the questions I’ve asked you.Don't treat me like I'm dead. Also, unpopular opinion, that I know no one would care, but I'll say this again anyway: I'm not scum. I don't know why Wisp got the results he got, but you're just gonna get a town flip. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
ironace said: what makes u all sure of kii tho? Tbh I'm just waiting for whoever got the Sparkling egg to come out. If they state their list then everything will be fine and if they don't state their list, the only reason they'd do that is if Scum has it because they know how important it is. |
| My personality: |
Shinichi-Kun said: sidenote: possible for u to use usernames? lol. might be confusingPhraze (3) - Kiana_Kaslana, EyehAsherEyeh, aa-dono Don't forget kyle checked this wagon and at the time kiana wasn't shot so he was still town. Which means that awa is actually 100% scum which in that case confirms mishu is town. |
 |
AbuHumaid said: not really. it depends on mood, like me. he was in CoD as scum I think, and pretty active.Guys, does scum!Shin lurk? |
|
| hmm.. I think I'll flip Shin next. he's fairly defensive once alone as scum >w> |
|
RE said: You realize aa-dono has essentially been red checked, right? Also, care to share who the final scum is? I Mean it strengthens my read on her partner silly lol |
|
Phraze said: hmm.. I think I'll flip Shin next. he's fairly defensive once alone as scum >w> I'm never defensive. Have you seen my list? Do you really think as mafia I put the musical egg first. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: just because ur vanilla doesn't mean ur cleared. I think u know better than that to argue this. and by defensive.. I remember u were cornered in the halloween game before :3Phraze said: hmm.. I think I'll flip Shin next. he's fairly defensive once alone as scum >w> I'm never defensive. Have you seen my list? Do you really think as mafia I put the musical egg first. |
|
Phraze said: Shinichi-Kun said: just because ur vanilla doesn't mean ur cleared. I think u know better than that to argue this. and by defensive.. I remember u were cornered in the halloween game before :3I'm never defensive. Have you seen my list? Do you really think as mafia I put the musical egg first. I put musical first cause I am town though lol. |
|
Shinichi-Kun said: it's possible just so you could say this. I find you bomb talk to be kind of a town tell at this point. Your teammate would have complied with your request imo.Phraze said: hmm.. I think I'll flip Shin next. he's fairly defensive once alone as scum >w> I'm never defensive. Have you seen my list? Do you really think as mafia I put the musical egg first. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
AbuHumaid said: I'm thinking it's between kii and ace now. Shinichi calling out his teammates role like that doesn't feel right.Shinichi-Kun said: Me and Mishu are never scum, you haven't been reading the thread, have you?Phraze Logic Yurkin RE as of right now could never be scum Abu is prob scum but less likely than the rest Most likely to be scum Mishu Iron Awa- If she flips scum that clears mishu, due to how the night actions went. If she doesn't flip scum its still possible for mishu to be scum. kiiruma It's between you/Kiiruma/Ace. Ace being the less likely. |
| Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8756 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 24, 8:27 AM |
|
» [READ THIS] - Mafia Colosseumosieorb18 - Jun 5, 2019 |
3 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 24, 8:27 AM |
|
» [GAME] Never have I ever... ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Jan 30, 2016 |
1623 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 20, 7:43 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1997 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 20, 7:42 PM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2878 |
by Serafos
»»
Jan 20, 7:41 PM |