Isayama admitted in the latest interview that the theme of the last part was beyond his ability and he truly regretted it that he wasn’t able to do a better job expressing it.

May 10, 2021 11:31 AM

#201

majinale

Offline

Sep 2014

262

imbAF said:

el3mel said:

imbAF said:

el3mel said:

imbAF said:

majinale said:

imbAF said:

majinale said:

imbAF said:

And how does chapter 124, 125, 127, 130,131, 137 are bad? Like ,lets start with 124, how is that chapter bad?

Many people have analyzed the little marvel arc that starts at 124 and why it is subpar. There is no point in beating a dead horse. If you liked it and didn't perceive a massive drop in quality like i did, i am happy for you.

imbAF said:

Plus Eren did try. On Kruger words : " If you do not find love, the same things will repeat again and again " That means that eren has tried it countless times. But the end result would be the same. Him dying in one way or another

There is no indication that Eren is in groundhog day situation, where he is looping to a certain point. Until proven otherwise by the author with a spin-off or alternative ending we have to assume it's a fixed timeline with the typical bootstrap paradox. Kruger is talking about the way history repeats itself in general (or the the way it rhymes if you prefer that).

Can you at least mention 5 sub par points that chapter 124 has? like only 5, or 3?

You want specific things on one chapter? The plot-lines that started from chapter 124 on-wards are not only uninteresting but also contrived and and rushed because the rumbling is ongoing and any non-main-event things need to get resolved fast, things happen conveniently just because the plot needs them to. But i 'll bite.
It starts the Mr Leonheart - Annie plot line which leads in many wasted panels that could have gone to more important stuff, the story does actually follow him for several chapters after that. Annie is one of the weaker characters after she de-crystallized.
It starts the "Connie will feed Falco to his mother" retarded subplot that leads no where and only serves to make Armin look more pathetic of a character.
The Gabi in Sasha's pose was nauseatingly bad. Mind you that Kaya covered for her again after that, while she tried to kill her a few hours ago. Forgiveness and understanding is not something that happens in such short time for plot convenience.
I can go on and on, but this is not the focus of this thread, we kind of derailing it.

And none of this are actual bad points. You had to pick them cuz there is nothing else to point out that makes the chapter bad. Like NO WAY IN HELL anyone thinks that because Mr.Leonhart came into the scene is such a bad thing? LIKE WHAT? FOR REAL BROO? LMAOOO. In fact the connie sub plot is awesome. It shows how dark things have become. He was going to feed an innocent child to a titan. LMAO, i was expecting something weak, BUT TO ACTUALLY SAY that showing annies father is a weak point????????????????????????? LMAO , i am out

He was going to feed an innocent child to a titan then Armin managed to convince him otherwise in matter of seconds, to the point Connie gave a long speech few seconds later about how wrong it was.

Great writing everyone.

You're out indeed, lol.

He didn't convince him. He was ready to sacrifice himself? Why are you such a blatant liar ?

The subplot was solved by Armin deciding to feed himself to the mother instead of Falco and this action convinced Connie he was 100% wrong to the point of giving a speech about how he betrayed his morals by thinking of feeding Falco to it few seconds later lol.

In few seconds the entire problem was solved and Connie stopped talking about his mother entirely for the rest of the manga.

Awesome indeed. Didn't you say you were out ? LOL.

Ofc it's awesome. because connie wouldn't let his close friend to die, but was willing to kill a child for that? That way armin pointed Connie's hypocrisy through Connie's own action. LMAO how bad are you at reading ? And again this AWESOME plotpoint did not happen on 124 . And Connie was already second guessing himself. But go on, I enjoy people who need to be spoon fed from Isayama. Let me guess You like Edgy-badass characters?

And Connie left Falco, because he wanted to save his friend. If he still would have wanted to feed falco, he would probably have to fight armin, but since he did not let him die, he definitely wouldn't kill Armin, when Armin would defend falco. Why are you so bad at reading? You read anything other then generic shounen, other than manga?

What would he say more about his mother, that hasn't been said? By this "flawless" logic, Connie stopped talking about his mother even after he learned that it was her who was turned into the titan. Jesus, you argumentation is horrible

It was awesome according to your opinion and as i said in a post above that's fine. I consider that whole plot-line extremely bad and a waste of panels.
Saying others are bad at reading and LMAOing doesn't help your case though, it only makes you come of as a little brat.
Also accusing others of reading only generic shounen is also pretty rich, considering that both the conclusion to the Connie's plot and the alliance plot are as shounen as it can get. It's so much shounen that it feels like it's another manga altogether actually.

May 10, 2021 11:33 AM

#202

el3mel

Offline

Jul 2019

948