SpRayquaza11 said:feyyazu35 said:I saw a lot of people on the internet who said that wit is better than mappa, but it is not. Don't get me wrong, mappa is not better than wit. In general, these studio comparisons are ridiculous anyway. They say wit is better just because the first 3 seasons of aot are better than the 4th season, but mappa has a time constraint Many people don't understand what you shoot. Let's compare if you want: vivy animations 9/10 jujutsu kaisen animations 9/10 vinland saga animations 8.5/10 dororo animations 8/10 ousama ranking animations 8.5/10 god of highschool animations 9/10 great pretender animations 8/10 yuri one ice animations 9/10 owari no seraph animations 8/10 dorohedoro animations 7.5/10 ........So both studios that make the best animations in the industry, but not wit>mappa, not mappa>wit
.
feyyazu35 said:mappa is inconsistent,even though they have given us great adaptations like jjk,dororo and all,they have kinda given us pretty half assed adaptations of great source materials as well,even if u do great job time to time,if u r inconsistent with your quality u r not a great studio
I've never seen anyone critisise wit for an adaptation,just look at ousama ranking,it's an awfully drawn manga(no disrespect to the mangaka bt yeah) to which wit has adapted so beautifully,they have originality,they have creativity,I've never seen mappa going out of their way to take their adaptation "a step further"
idk Abt u guys by I think wit is like my top 5 Fav studios of all time,mappa is good but too inconsistent with their work
No version of the mappa has been criticized, except for aot.
LeonYeager said:Wit also had time limitations, and had a much smaller staff so...
Pred8r said:feyyazu35 said:I saw a lot of people on the internet who said that wit is better than mappa, but it is not. Don't get me wrong, mappa is not better than wit. In general, these studio comparisons are ridiculous anyway. They say wit is better just because the first 3 seasons of aot are better than the 4th season, but mappa has a time constraint Many people don't understand what you shoot. Let's compare if you want: vivy animations 9/10 jujutsu kaisen animations 9/10 vinland saga animations 8.5/10 dororo animations 8/10 ousama ranking animations 8.5/10 god of highschool animations 9/10 great pretender animations 8/10 yuri one ice animations 9/10 owari no seraph animations 8/10 dorohedoro animations 7.5/10 ........So both studios that make the best animations in the industry, but not wit>mappa, not mappa>wit
Nope wit > mappa
period.
skillpower said:WIT have done way better job on AOT, but overall mappa might be better.
TBH mappa is a bigger studio so this isn't a fair comparison , although I would say as I mentioned in my review Mappa has done a better job than in AOT s4 *SINCE IT WAS A STUDIO TAKEOVER*, if wit was forced to do a takeover they would probably fuck up a lot more since takeover == bad idea , just look at one punch man s2 or SDS s3 and 4 if you wanna see how truly devastating takeovers can be...