Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
Attack on Titan
Available on Manga Store
New
Whats your thoughts on Floch?
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Feb 21, 2022 12:02 PM

Offline
Jun 2016
1132
He is made like that you will hate him, being a fanatic and how he is behaving is exactly how fanatics are.
2025 might be the year where I will be happy. This year is not happy year.
Feb 21, 2022 2:02 PM

Offline
Sep 2016
510
I'm not sure if this is a hot take but I think Floch/Flocke is like a worse version of Yelena. Yelena was essentially Zeke's right hand and seemed very cunning and always in control of the situation by being calm and collected.

Floch on the other hand, being kind of Eren's right hand man, seems very impulsive and brash while also seeming like a dude who came out of nowhere to spit commands that no one takes seriously if he doesn't threaten them with a gun. He just feels like a push-over to me but I think he was written like that on purpose. Even tho I don't really like him as a person I can still appreciate him as a character.
Yogen-No-KoFeb 21, 2022 2:07 PM
Feb 21, 2022 2:12 PM
Offline
Nov 2019
798
As a person? Nah he's a fucking nut case, but as a character? He's brilliant
Feb 21, 2022 2:18 PM
Offline
Jul 2018
561867
He's had great character development, but man I wanna punch that bitch in the face.
Feb 21, 2022 2:21 PM

Offline
Mar 2012
7011
ZXEAN said:
I hate him but he is a well written character.




Correct answer…
End Zionazism
Feb 21, 2022 6:34 PM
Offline
Sep 2021
22
neutral, dont really like or hate him
Feb 21, 2022 7:36 PM
Offline
Jul 2021
716
He is a very well written character
Apr 10, 2022 1:53 PM
Offline
Dec 2019
393
Like is an understatement, he makes me feel gay lmao. People say it's just fiction but nah I'd support him irl too ngl
Apr 10, 2022 2:56 PM

Offline
Mar 2018
93
Floch is one the most interesting characters in the story, I never imagined he would become so important after he survided Zeke's attack. I imagined that's a good character development.

He just represents the kind of people who would do anything to save their country and their people; pretty bitchy and kinda having a blind faith on Eren, but Floch still sees for what he wants.

Still, never cared about him.
Apr 10, 2022 3:37 PM

Offline
Dec 2016
349
He is better than the traitors imo
I don't like him but at least he cared about his homeland
Apr 10, 2022 8:03 PM

Offline
Mar 2018
96
I've never understood how people could like Floch or believe in his ideals. He's the opposite of what a real patriot is because he killed more Eldians than any other nationality and he's prepared to kill as many Eldians as it takes for his crazy fascist cult. He's exactly what the Marlyian regime was. I feel sick to my stomach when people compare Floch "the psychopath' to one of the best characters on the show, Erwin Smith. If Erwin was alive, he would be leading the charge against Eren. Somebody who was always curious about the possibility of people outside the walls would never agree to commit genocide. That being said, a character like Floch was needed to mirror the crazy radicals of the other side. Everyone on the show is a murderer and no one is innocent, but Floch and those who think like him on both sides have no redeeming qualities.
Apr 10, 2022 9:24 PM
Offline
May 2020
491
Hes quite crazy ass brat but nah his purpose in the story what matters
Apr 11, 2022 12:40 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
36
Floch is a hero. My personal fav character in this show now. He beat Erwin by an inch though, as he should. He is Erwin's true successor. Floch is him, but better.
Apr 11, 2022 12:44 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
36
Socita said:
I've never understood how people could like Floch or believe in his ideals. He's the opposite of what a real patriot is because he killed more Eldians than any other nationality and he's prepared to kill as many Eldians as it takes for his crazy fascist cult. He's exactly what the Marlyian regime was. I feel sick to my stomach when people compare Floch "the psychopath' to one of the best characters on the show, Erwin Smith. If Erwin was alive, he would be leading the charge against Eren. Somebody who was always curious about the possibility of people outside the walls would never agree to commit genocide. That being said, a character like Floch was needed to mirror the crazy radicals of the other side. Everyone on the show is a murderer and no one is innocent, but Floch and those who think like him on both sides have no redeeming qualities.

Erwin would be fighting alongside Eren.
When Levi and Erwin were discussing the future plan before the Battle of Shiganshina, Erwin tells Levi that he will deal with external threats as there is someone beyond the walls who wants to kill them.
If Erwin was alive, he would have kept traitors in rein and the split inside Survey Corps wouldn't be there.
Apr 11, 2022 12:46 AM
Offline
Aug 2021
10436
I'm neutral but I think he is very firm in his stance so yeah
Apr 11, 2022 12:59 AM

Offline
Mar 2018
96
ft45 said:
Socita said:
I've never understood how people could like Floch or believe in his ideals. He's the opposite of what a real patriot is because he killed more Eldians than any other nationality and he's prepared to kill as many Eldians as it takes for his crazy fascist cult. He's exactly what the Marlyian regime was. I feel sick to my stomach when people compare Floch "the psychopath' to one of the best characters on the show, Erwin Smith. If Erwin was alive, he would be leading the charge against Eren. Somebody who was always curious about the possibility of people outside the walls would never agree to commit genocide. That being said, a character like Floch was needed to mirror the crazy radicals of the other side. Everyone on the show is a murderer and no one is innocent, but Floch and those who think like him on both sides have no redeeming qualities.

Erwin would be fighting alongside Eren.
When Levi and Erwin were discussing the future plan before the Battle of Shiganshina, Erwin tells Levi that he will deal with external threats as there is someone beyond the walls who wants to kill them.
If Erwin was alive, he would have kept traitors in rein and the split inside Survey Corps wouldn't be there.


I agree that the split in the corps wouldn't be there if Erwin was alive because Erwin would have plotted to kill Floch and his merry men from the get-go. If you think a man who had waited his whole life to prove that there were people outside the walls would want to wipe them out, then you know nothing about Erwin. His 3 most trusted people (Levi, Hange & Armin) who he had chosen himself to be humanity's weapon, his successor, and the brains of the corps respectively, are all against Eren . The only difference is that Ewin wouldn't have waited around for the fascist cult to take over. He wouldn't have let Nile, his old best friend and Pixis, his trusted ally die in vain.
Apr 11, 2022 1:57 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
36
Socita said:
ft45 said:

Erwin would be fighting alongside Eren.
When Levi and Erwin were discussing the future plan before the Battle of Shiganshina, Erwin tells Levi that he will deal with external threats as there is someone beyond the walls who wants to kill them.
If Erwin was alive, he would have kept traitors in rein and the split inside Survey Corps wouldn't be there.


I agree that the split in the corps wouldn't be there if Erwin was alive because Erwin would have plotted to kill Floch and his merry men from the get-go. If you think a man who had waited his whole life to prove that there were people outside the walls would want to wipe them out, then you know nothing about Erwin. His 3 most trusted people (Levi, Hange & Armin) who he had chosen himself to be humanity's weapon, his successor, and the brains of the corps respectively, are all against Eren . The only difference is that Ewin wouldn't have waited around for the fascist cult to take over. He wouldn't have let Nile, his old best friend and Pixis, his trusted ally die in vain.

Erwin wouldn't have plotted to kill Floch because there won't be any need for that. Erwin would himself become Floch. Floch is only there aiding Eren because top military brass has gone crazy and no one has any plans for the future, and also because he sees the devil in Eren, as he saw in Erwin who could rescue *humanity*.

Erwin's fascination isn't with people outside the walls, it is with the fact that there are humans outside the walls. And, as the conversation between Levi and Erwin shows, Erwin has no one-sided love for outsiders who want to kill them.

Now, let's see his "3 most trusted people" (lol). Levi is there and rightly so. Armin isn't "trusted people" as in, Armin isn't in his inner circle. And Hange herself admits that she is a failed commander. So, what we see is, self-hating-Armin and failed-commander-Hange doing their own senseless thing and Levi caught up with them by chance by the whole Zeke thing. Not saying Levi would be Yeagerist, but he wouldn't be with Alliance either.
So, whatever those three think or do is not on Erwin.

About comrades, Pixis himself distrusted Erwin lmfao. Spiking their wine with spinal fluid wasn't ideal, but Floch did what he had to do against foes far greater and more powerful than him.
Apr 11, 2022 2:29 AM

Offline
Mar 2018
96
ft45 said:
Socita said:


I agree that the split in the corps wouldn't be there if Erwin was alive because Erwin would have plotted to kill Floch and his merry men from the get-go. If you think a man who had waited his whole life to prove that there were people outside the walls would want to wipe them out, then you know nothing about Erwin. His 3 most trusted people (Levi, Hange & Armin) who he had chosen himself to be humanity's weapon, his successor, and the brains of the corps respectively, are all against Eren . The only difference is that Ewin wouldn't have waited around for the fascist cult to take over. He wouldn't have let Nile, his old best friend and Pixis, his trusted ally die in vain.

Erwin wouldn't have plotted to kill Floch because there won't be any need for that. Erwin would himself become Floch. Floch is only there aiding Eren because top military brass has gone crazy and no one has any plans for the future, and also because he sees the devil in Eren, as he saw in Erwin who could rescue *humanity*.

Erwin's fascination isn't with people outside the walls, it is with the fact that there are humans outside the walls. And, as the conversation between Levi and Erwin shows, Erwin has no one-sided love for outsiders who want to kill them.

Now, let's see his "3 most trusted people" (lol). Levi is there and rightly so. Armin isn't "trusted people" as in, Armin isn't in his inner circle. And Hange herself admits that she is a failed commander. So, what we see is, self-hating-Armin and failed-commander-Hange doing their own senseless thing and Levi caught up with them by chance by the whole Zeke thing. Not saying Levi would be Yeagerist, but he wouldn't be with Alliance either.
So, whatever those three think or do is not on Erwin.

About comrades, Pixis himself distrusted Erwin lmfao. Spiking their wine with spinal fluid wasn't ideal, but Floch did what he had to do against foes far greater and more powerful than him.


Oh, boy! Everything you said is so wrong. Erwin was the smartest character. He's not a nutjob like Floch. He's not a n.a.z.i/fascist like Floch & his cult. He's a real leader who differentiated between real enemies and 'the whole world'. Erwin knew that there were enemies outside the walls, and he would have done everything in his power to stop the Marlyian military. But he would never agree to commit genocide like a psychopath. He would have known that Eldia couldn't survive on its own without other countries and their technology. He would have known that wiping out the world would lead to a civil war in Eldia until they they'd wipe out each other. He wouldn't have betrayed the volunteers who opposed Zeke and Yelena. Erwin was a politician and a diplomat at heart. He could make people follow him to their deaths with mere words. He could have made the entire world focus their hatred on the fascist cult and proven that Eldians are peace-seekers not devils. He wasn't a coward who participated in one serious fight and lost his marbles, and instead of going to a therapist, he became a complete psychopath like Floch.
Erwin chose Hange to be the commander. Just because she doubts herself doesn't mean he would have stopped believing in her. Levi was his right hand more than his actual arm that he lost. If you think Levi would join the cult of nutjobs, you seriously know nothing about Levi. Erwin trusted Armin since the beginning and trusted his judgement. Armin's hesitation makes him human, but when it's time to act, he's reliable.

Pixis didn't trust anyone at the beginning because he's smart but Erwin and the scouts wouldn't have achieved so much without him. Nile was Erwin's best friend after Miche when he was a cadet. Erwin wouldn't have let them die like that or wouldn't have let their deaths be in vain.

Floch tries to be what he thinks Erwin was, but he fails miserably because he didn't know the real Erwin and he's mentally unstable to lead. Jean and Armin are the ones who are carrying Erwin's legacy. Floch is nothing but an ant that nobody would remember in the show, unlike Erwin whose memory is the drive for Hange, Levi and Armin to keep pushing forward.

Anyway, I won't argue with you anymore. You're free to have your own opinions and interpretations. I just hope that if Floch was a real person, you wouldn't support him and that you just like him as a fictional character.
Peace out ✌🏼
Apr 11, 2022 3:12 AM
Offline
Jun 2020
205
Socita said:
ft45 said:

Erwin wouldn't have plotted to kill Floch because there won't be any need for that. Erwin would himself become Floch. Floch is only there aiding Eren because top military brass has gone crazy and no one has any plans for the future, and also because he sees the devil in Eren, as he saw in Erwin who could rescue *humanity*.

Erwin's fascination isn't with people outside the walls, it is with the fact that there are humans outside the walls. And, as the conversation between Levi and Erwin shows, Erwin has no one-sided love for outsiders who want to kill them.

Now, let's see his "3 most trusted people" (lol). Levi is there and rightly so. Armin isn't "trusted people" as in, Armin isn't in his inner circle. And Hange herself admits that she is a failed commander. So, what we see is, self-hating-Armin and failed-commander-Hange doing their own senseless thing and Levi caught up with them by chance by the whole Zeke thing. Not saying Levi would be Yeagerist, but he wouldn't be with Alliance either.
So, whatever those three think or do is not on Erwin.

About comrades, Pixis himself distrusted Erwin lmfao. Spiking their wine with spinal fluid wasn't ideal, but Floch did what he had to do against foes far greater and more powerful than him.


Oh, boy! Everything you said is so wrong. Erwin was the smartest character. He's not a nutjob like Floch. He's not a n.a.z.i/fascist like Floch & his cult. He's a real leader who differentiated between real enemies and 'the whole world'. Erwin knew that there were enemies outside the walls, and he would have done everything in his power to stop the Marlyian military. But he would never agree to commit genocide like a psychopath. He would have known that Eldia couldn't survive on its own without other countries and their technology. He would have known that wiping out the world would lead to a civil war in Eldia until they they'd wipe out each other. He wouldn't have betrayed the volunteers who opposed Zeke and Yelena. Erwin was a politician and a diplomat at heart. He could make people follow him to their deaths with mere words. He could have made the entire world focus their hatred on the fascist cult and proven that Eldians are peace-seekers not devils. He wasn't a coward who participated in one serious fight and lost his marbles, and instead of going to a therapist, he became a complete psychopath like Floch.
Erwin chose Hange to be the commander. Just because she doubts herself doesn't mean he would have stopped believing in her. Levi was his right hand more than his actual arm that he lost. If you think Levi would join the cult of nutjobs, you seriously know nothing about Levi. Erwin trusted Armin since the beginning and trusted his judgement. Armin's hesitation makes him human, but when it's time to act, he's reliable.

Pixis didn't trust anyone at the beginning because he's smart but Erwin and the scouts wouldn't have achieved so much without him. Nile was Erwin's best friend after Miche when he was a cadet. Erwin wouldn't have let them die like that or wouldn't have let their deaths be in vain.

Floch tries to be what he thinks Erwin was, but he fails miserably because he didn't know the real Erwin and he's mentally unstable to lead. Jean and Armin are the ones who are carrying Erwin's legacy. Floch is nothing but an ant that nobody would remember in the show, unlike Erwin whose memory is the drive for Hange, Levi and Armin to keep pushing forward.

Anyway, I won't argue with you anymore. You're free to have your own opinions and interpretations. I just hope that if Floch was a real person, you wouldn't support him and that you just like him as a fictional character.
Peace out ✌🏼
Also, Erwin had a deep guilt for sacrificing his comrades. He also knew his actions were very extreme for sacrificing the citizens of Stohess. That's why he was willing to accept any punishment. We also see him overthrow the government without any bloodshed. We never saw him being hostile towards his enemies. As much as the government was corrupt and responsible for the death of his father, his eyes were never filled with hatred. I like Floch as a character and understand what he brings to the story but he doesn't carry Erwin's ideals.
sammymaheshApr 11, 2022 3:17 AM

I'm level on mal-badges. View my badges.

Apr 11, 2022 5:10 AM

Offline
Mar 2018
96
sammymahesh said:
Socita said:


Oh, boy! Everything you said is so wrong. Erwin was the smartest character. He's not a nutjob like Floch. He's not a n.a.z.i/fascist like Floch & his cult. He's a real leader who differentiated between real enemies and 'the whole world'. Erwin knew that there were enemies outside the walls, and he would have done everything in his power to stop the Marlyian military. But he would never agree to commit genocide like a psychopath. He would have known that Eldia couldn't survive on its own without other countries and their technology. He would have known that wiping out the world would lead to a civil war in Eldia until they they'd wipe out each other. He wouldn't have betrayed the volunteers who opposed Zeke and Yelena. Erwin was a politician and a diplomat at heart. He could make people follow him to their deaths with mere words. He could have made the entire world focus their hatred on the fascist cult and proven that Eldians are peace-seekers not devils. He wasn't a coward who participated in one serious fight and lost his marbles, and instead of going to a therapist, he became a complete psychopath like Floch.
Erwin chose Hange to be the commander. Just because she doubts herself doesn't mean he would have stopped believing in her. Levi was his right hand more than his actual arm that he lost. If you think Levi would join the cult of nutjobs, you seriously know nothing about Levi. Erwin trusted Armin since the beginning and trusted his judgement. Armin's hesitation makes him human, but when it's time to act, he's reliable.

Pixis didn't trust anyone at the beginning because he's smart but Erwin and the scouts wouldn't have achieved so much without him. Nile was Erwin's best friend after Miche when he was a cadet. Erwin wouldn't have let them die like that or wouldn't have let their deaths be in vain.

Floch tries to be what he thinks Erwin was, but he fails miserably because he didn't know the real Erwin and he's mentally unstable to lead. Jean and Armin are the ones who are carrying Erwin's legacy. Floch is nothing but an ant that nobody would remember in the show, unlike Erwin whose memory is the drive for Hange, Levi and Armin to keep pushing forward.

Anyway, I won't argue with you anymore. You're free to have your own opinions and interpretations. I just hope that if Floch was a real person, you wouldn't support him and that you just like him as a fictional character.
Peace out ✌🏼
Also, Erwin had a deep guilt for sacrificing his comrades. He also knew his actions were very extreme for sacrificing the citizens of Stohess. That's why he was willing to accept any punishment. We also see him overthrow the government without any bloodshed. We never saw him being hostile towards his enemies. As much as the government was corrupt and responsible for the death of his father, his eyes were never filled with hatred. I like Floch as a character and understand what he brings to the story but he doesn't carry Erwin's ideals.


Exactly! Floch's character is needed to show that there are extremists on both sides. It's war in a nutshell. It's not black and white. There are radical psychopaths on both sides. There are murderers who are trying to atone on both sides. There are also good innocent people on both sides. There is a cycle of hatred, corruption, injustice and oppression that needs to be broken. Just like Marco said, they should have talked things through instead of repeating the cycle again and again. Sadly, history has taught us that peace treaties don't happen until after unimaginable bloodshed occurs, but peace is an attainable goal while commiting a global genocide to save one divided, primitive country on the brink of a civil war is just something unrealistic and stupid.
Apr 11, 2022 5:15 AM
Offline
Nov 2019
798
Dude is a massive twat and an extremist, but his character is unironically amazing and I love him for that. That's where the love for him shoulda ended tbh, the idolising from one half of the fandom is honestly concerning
Apr 11, 2022 11:07 AM
Offline
Mar 2015
209
It's not that I like him, but everyone else is just a bafoon, so I'll side with the guy that has clear goals and convictions, even if he's an asshole.
Apr 11, 2022 4:51 PM

Offline
Jul 2021
3934
Yea, he was the best character and the only thing keeping me sane through the shit show.

Apr 11, 2022 7:58 PM

Offline
Feb 2017
1032
Zxtsukii said:
I like him as a character and dislike him as a person as he stands exactly opposite of everything AoT stands for lol


ah yes... aot is about romance and not chasing for freedom, keep moving forward, and dedicate your heart.

the cringevengers is better written than floch

MAL score and most user-based rating system are all joke, Imagine trusting plebs and hivemind. Find users who have good sense and rating and use them as a reference. Check my guide to rate
Your taste is trash. Cope, seethe, mald
Apr 11, 2022 8:13 PM

Offline
Feb 2017
1032
Socita said:
ft45 said:

Erwin wouldn't have plotted to kill Floch because there won't be any need for that. Erwin would himself become Floch. Floch is only there aiding Eren because top military brass has gone crazy and no one has any plans for the future, and also because he sees the devil in Eren, as he saw in Erwin who could rescue *humanity*.

Erwin's fascination isn't with people outside the walls, it is with the fact that there are humans outside the walls. And, as the conversation between Levi and Erwin shows, Erwin has no one-sided love for outsiders who want to kill them.

Now, let's see his "3 most trusted people" (lol). Levi is there and rightly so. Armin isn't "trusted people" as in, Armin isn't in his inner circle. And Hange herself admits that she is a failed commander. So, what we see is, self-hating-Armin and failed-commander-Hange doing their own senseless thing and Levi caught up with them by chance by the whole Zeke thing. Not saying Levi would be Yeagerist, but he wouldn't be with Alliance either.
So, whatever those three think or do is not on Erwin.

About comrades, Pixis himself distrusted Erwin lmfao. Spiking their wine with spinal fluid wasn't ideal, but Floch did what he had to do against foes far greater and more powerful than him.


Oh, boy! Everything you said is so wrong. Erwin was the smartest character. He's not a nutjob like Floch. He's not a n.a.z.i/fascist like Floch & his cult. He's a real leader who differentiated between real enemies and 'the whole world'. Erwin knew that there were enemies outside the walls, and he would have done everything in his power to stop the Marlyian military. But he would never agree to commit genocide like a psychopath. He would have known that Eldia couldn't survive on its own without other countries and their technology. He would have known that wiping out the world would lead to a civil war in Eldia until they they'd wipe out each other. He wouldn't have betrayed the volunteers who opposed Zeke and Yelena. Erwin was a politician and a diplomat at heart. He could make people follow him to their deaths with mere words. He could have made the entire world focus their hatred on the fascist cult and proven that Eldians are peace-seekers not devils. He wasn't a coward who participated in one serious fight and lost his marbles, and instead of going to a therapist, he became a complete psychopath like Floch.
Erwin chose Hange to be the commander. Just because she doubts herself doesn't mean he would have stopped believing in her. Levi was his right hand more than his actual arm that he lost. If you think Levi would join the cult of nutjobs, you seriously know nothing about Levi. Erwin trusted Armin since the beginning and trusted his judgement. Armin's hesitation makes him human, but when it's time to act, he's reliable.

Floch tries to be what he thinks Erwin was, but he fails miserably because he didn't know the real Erwin and he's mentally unstable to lead. Jean and Armin are the ones who are carrying Erwin's legacy. Floch is nothing but an ant that nobody would remember in the show, unlike Erwin whose memory is the drive for Hange, Levi and Armin to keep pushing forward.



erwin never knew there are human on the other side and now they are the enemy, he's literally dead bruh.

his character basically only want prove his dad wrong (to justify giving armin the serum which is a main chara plot armor) and willing to do everything to defeat enemy with level headed decision.

floch is true successor of erwin and anybody who disagree is coping and seething.

saying erwin would not agree to eren plan is only a headcanon and dumb shit hacksayama write from hange with her bullshit claim.

levi character is dead since s3p2, he's just a dog to erwin, the same as mikasa a dog to eren. his only purpose is being fan favorite and milking fujoshit.

MAL score and most user-based rating system are all joke, Imagine trusting plebs and hivemind. Find users who have good sense and rating and use them as a reference. Check my guide to rate
Your taste is trash. Cope, seethe, mald
Apr 11, 2022 8:28 PM

Offline
Sep 2009
79
I don't like him or hate him I'm neutral I understand his loyalty to his country. Ofc I don't agree with the plan of Eren for genocide. Everything is really conflicting for me because I understand both sides, but I do choose the side of Armin. For me Armin is the best character he definatly represents me between being against genocide but also in conflict in killing his teamates and his friend Eren. :(
Apr 11, 2022 10:18 PM

Offline
Nov 2020
1513
evoniee said:
Zxtsukii said:
I like him as a character and dislike him as a person as he stands exactly opposite of everything AoT stands for lol


ah yes... aot is about romance and not chasing for freedom, keep moving forward, and dedicate your heart.

the cringevengers is better written than floch
Are you a child? Bc no way someone older than 5 year old would call alliance aka scouts cringevengers XDXD

═════════════════════════════
You're going to be all right. You just stumbled over a stone in the road.
It means nothing. Your goal lies far beyond this. Doesn't it?
I'm sure you'll overcome this.
You'll walk again... soon.

═════════════════════════════
Apr 11, 2022 11:26 PM
Offline
Feb 2022
36
Socita said:
ft45 said:

Erwin wouldn't have plotted to kill Floch because there won't be any need for that. Erwin would himself become Floch. Floch is only there aiding Eren because top military brass has gone crazy and no one has any plans for the future, and also because he sees the devil in Eren, as he saw in Erwin who could rescue *humanity*.

Erwin's fascination isn't with people outside the walls, it is with the fact that there are humans outside the walls. And, as the conversation between Levi and Erwin shows, Erwin has no one-sided love for outsiders who want to kill them.

Now, let's see his "3 most trusted people" (lol). Levi is there and rightly so. Armin isn't "trusted people" as in, Armin isn't in his inner circle. And Hange herself admits that she is a failed commander. So, what we see is, self-hating-Armin and failed-commander-Hange doing their own senseless thing and Levi caught up with them by chance by the whole Zeke thing. Not saying Levi would be Yeagerist, but he wouldn't be with Alliance either.
So, whatever those three think or do is not on Erwin.

About comrades, Pixis himself distrusted Erwin lmfao. Spiking their wine with spinal fluid wasn't ideal, but Floch did what he had to do against foes far greater and more powerful than him.


Oh, boy! Everything you said is so wrong. Erwin was the smartest character. He's not a nutjob like Floch. He's not a n.a.z.i/fascist like Floch & his cult. He's a real leader who differentiated between real enemies and 'the whole world'. Erwin knew that there were enemies outside the walls, and he would have done everything in his power to stop the Marlyian military. But he would never agree to commit genocide like a psychopath. He would have known that Eldia couldn't survive on its own without other countries and their technology. He would have known that wiping out the world would lead to a civil war in Eldia until they they'd wipe out each other. He wouldn't have betrayed the volunteers who opposed Zeke and Yelena. Erwin was a politician and a diplomat at heart. He could make people follow him to their deaths with mere words. He could have made the entire world focus their hatred on the fascist cult and proven that Eldians are peace-seekers not devils. He wasn't a coward who participated in one serious fight and lost his marbles, and instead of going to a therapist, he became a complete psychopath like Floch.
Erwin chose Hange to be the commander. Just because she doubts herself doesn't mean he would have stopped believing in her. Levi was his right hand more than his actual arm that he lost. If you think Levi would join the cult of nutjobs, you seriously know nothing about Levi. Erwin trusted Armin since the beginning and trusted his judgement. Armin's hesitation makes him human, but when it's time to act, he's reliable.

Pixis didn't trust anyone at the beginning because he's smart but Erwin and the scouts wouldn't have achieved so much without him. Nile was Erwin's best friend after Miche when he was a cadet. Erwin wouldn't have let them die like that or wouldn't have let their deaths be in vain.

Floch tries to be what he thinks Erwin was, but he fails miserably because he didn't know the real Erwin and he's mentally unstable to lead. Jean and Armin are the ones who are carrying Erwin's legacy. Floch is nothing but an ant that nobody would remember in the show, unlike Erwin whose memory is the drive for Hange, Levi and Armin to keep pushing forward.

Anyway, I won't argue with you anymore. You're free to have your own opinions and interpretations. I just hope that if Floch was a real person, you wouldn't support him and that you just like him as a fictional character.
Peace out ✌🏼

words.. words and no brains.

Eldia survived fine without the outsider's tech and will survive and evolve on its own. The entire fantasy that somehow you can change the minds of the whole world that Eldians are peace-seekers and not devils is lunacy. The fact is, Eldians are devils who can turn into demons and do monstrous things. The evidence is in front of you, and still you retards refuse to acknowledge this. I believe that their salvation lies in acceptance of who they are, and not shying away from the truth, about themselves and the world.

"Floch tries to be what he thinks Erwin was, but he fails miserably because he didn't know the real Erwin"
Yes, you're right here. Floch had no idea Erwin wore a mask in front of his comrades, and his real motivations had nothing to do with the preservation of humanity. Floch on the other hand became what Erwin was pretending to be. And for this reason, Floch > Erwin in many ways, in my opinion.

Also, regarding your last paragraph that whether I'll support him IRL or not, and do I like him only as a fictional character. The study of literature accepts that the tales are not real, but it also entails the acknowledgment that the tales represent a degree of truth about the world. I know AOT isn't literature but I think it comes pretty close to it in spirit. That's all I will say.
ft45Apr 11, 2022 11:32 PM
Apr 11, 2022 11:53 PM

Offline
Jul 2017
14
I don't like him, but that's mainly because of how annoying his english va sounds to me.
Apr 13, 2022 3:23 PM

Offline
Feb 2017
1032
Zxtsukii said:
evoniee said:


ah yes... aot is about romance and not chasing for freedom, keep moving forward, and dedicate your heart.

the cringevengers is better written than floch
Are you a child? Bc no way someone older than 5 year old would call alliance aka scouts cringevengers XDXD


still better than thoughtless fanboy defending dogshit writing which is more childlike behavior.
cope and seethe, cringevengers and path + fumbling arc are dogshit written.
it's literally the worst point of this franchise and thoughtless fanboy like you praising it.

MAL score and most user-based rating system are all joke, Imagine trusting plebs and hivemind. Find users who have good sense and rating and use them as a reference. Check my guide to rate
Your taste is trash. Cope, seethe, mald
Apr 17, 2022 8:37 AM

Offline
Nov 2020
1513
evoniee said:
Zxtsukii said:
Are you a child? Bc no way someone older than 5 year old would call alliance aka scouts cringevengers XDXD


still better than thoughtless fanboy defending dogshit writing which is more childlike behavior.
cope and seethe, cringevengers and path + fumbling arc are dogshit written.
it's literally the worst point of this franchise and thoughtless fanboy like you praising it.
Average Titanfolker behaviour

═════════════════════════════
You're going to be all right. You just stumbled over a stone in the road.
It means nothing. Your goal lies far beyond this. Doesn't it?
I'm sure you'll overcome this.
You'll walk again... soon.

═════════════════════════════
May 28, 2022 6:43 AM
Offline
May 2022
1
He was most loyal to eldia and eren
Jun 20, 2022 3:14 AM
Offline
Jan 2021
273
Zxtsukii said:
evoniee said:


still better than thoughtless fanboy defending dogshit writing which is more childlike behavior.
cope and seethe, cringevengers and path + fumbling arc are dogshit written.
it's literally the worst point of this franchise and thoughtless fanboy like you praising it.
Average Titanfolker behaviour
Zxtsukii said:
evoniee said:


still better than thoughtless fanboy defending dogshit writing which is more childlike behavior.
cope and seethe, cringevengers and path + fumbling arc are dogshit written.
it's literally the worst point of this franchise and thoughtless fanboy like you praising it.
Average Titanfolker behaviour
Floch>>>>>>>>>>> cringevengers and stop behaving like 10yr old
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Feb 6, 2022

474 by graciana »»
Yesterday, 8:08 AM

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Apr 3, 2022

574 by mateben »»
Oct 4, 7:46 AM

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Jan 30, 2022

557 by Goxist »»
Sep 21, 4:36 AM

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Mar 6, 2022

313 by Hylianticipated »»
Sep 3, 10:48 PM

» I think eren did the right thing ( 1 2 )

SenseixSenpai - Feb 4, 2022

53 by MergedZamasu »»
Aug 28, 12:29 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login