Attack on Titan
Servillian said: Up to 123: 10/10 Final arc: 6/10 Honestly I’d still give it a 9/10 but my opinions might change once I reread it I honestly think the only 10/10 in Attack on Titan is Return to Shiganshina and maybe the Marley arc in my honest opinion. the first part of the manga wasn't even that ground breaking at all I would give it a 8/10. The war arc imo was amazing up till chapter 132. The Last chapter was not very good tho Ill rate it 4/10. I give the whole series a 8/10. |
| Greed has poisoned men’s souls, has barricaded the world with hate, has goose-stepped us into misery and bloodshed. |
| Staying with 8/10. A already started to like it less because of the "too much" of the fantasy/plot twists later after they came back from their attack at Liberio. End seems just like your usual ending. I think it was an okay-ish shounen ... interesting mainly because of his setting (at the start) and with nice anime adaptions. (Visually´with colors + sound and voice acting added and with weekly release ... this is much better.) --- I think the part where Eren started with his big plans (And Yelena and the Jagerist faction, etc.) - is where I started to dislike it. But I thougt it mainly was because of the monthly releases. (Hard to keep up with all the different chars and their intentions.) In the anime - so far - I liked it. (But the part where I started to dislike it in the manga ... only began at the end of the recent season. Good stuff was up until the reveal that Gabi killed Sasha. Liked the minor chars here and there backgrounds and emotions.) But Eren ... yeah ... boring shounen main char. Strongest were the political arc, the return to Shinganshina ... and the background story (when Eren was hidden in Lliberio) ... until they returned from their attack there. |
| 8/10 the last chapter is offensive trash, but up to that point I thought it was a 10/10 |
| thats what-she |
| Until chapter 132 it was a 10/10. It started slowly declining until 137 and I liked 138. 139 was disappointing in general but anything that didn't have to do with Eren and his character was at least decent. I moved it to 9/10. I don't think that a couple of mid chapters can change my opinion about the whole manga. |
| Man, listen to them tear into me. Good thing I'm used to it. |
| Attack On Titan for me went between 8 - 10 range throughout the final chapters. But this last chapter. Oh boy. What a mess. I like AOT enough to give it an 8/10 but fuck. That ending. I can only pray that Berserk doesn't do that shit. |
  Even If We Painstakingly Piece Together Something Lost, It Doesn't Mean Things Will Ever go Back To How They Were - Guts  |
SilverLeo said: 9,5/10 139 was a difficult landing, but I personally liked it. After S4 ended I went straight to the manga and read 115-138 in a week and then waited for 139. And I don't know why but 139 was exactly what I expected. I really saw this ending coming with Eren being a "tragic hero". I think too many people where too much in love with "Chaderen", a facade he put up so he could cope with the madness. Like how the hell would you cope with all the things he sees? Absolut madness and hell. And the moment it was shown that he is not Chaderen people started to go off, because the facade they loved is not real + all the theories that they clinging onto were not real lol Lol its not that people cling to him, many people even expected a ending like this. Its just that the ending is not very fitting and cringy. Considering how Yams orignal approach made AoT such a good series its a shame that he ended things like this. I mean in the end Yam can do what he wants with his manga, but if fans have the right to praise AoT (which happend more than often) they also have any right to show their disappointment. It seems you need to understand this first. |
| Snk was one of my favorite series of all time up until I read chapter 132-->139 ,Chapter 123-->131 Had its highs and lows but it was still amazing imo but I didn't like how the story started to progress after chapter 131 and I HATED the last chapter. I gave it a 9 overall but I think I'll lower my score in the future |
| I'd say it was a solid 8 but right now, all I can give it is a hard 6. It was good, but how it ended really broke the whole deal for me. I expected that the series will highly likely end up with an anti-hero sacrifice ending, but I never anticipated that it'll be this unsatisfying. The whole deus ex machina thingy that happened made me question the whole point of the former arcs. On top of that, the world building aspect was completely thrown off the window after all the tension and buildup that it had and wasn't even wrapped up properly and as the reader, you were just left to assume that "everything got reset and they have to start over again". Lastly, how the ship was forced in the end really felt unnatural and dumb with Eren going completely out of character like a busted sadboy after all the stuff that he did. I pretty much get the ending, make no mistake. It's just that it's a complete dud for all those tension that it built. I don't really want to say this but how this ended really gave me those Game of Thrones flashbacks. |
ZnraApr 10, 2021 2:45 PM
 Those with dirty minds will find my Steam pic offensive |
| Up until 138 I would've given it a 9/10. Sure, it stumbled here and there from time to time, but overall it explored very interesting themes about war and destructive ideologies without caricaturizing it's characters as pure good or pure evil. And then along came 139 with it's destiny bullshit, justification of genocide and fascist ending. I think that ruins the overall experience, but it's still got some amazing stuff that can stand on its own if you ignore that dogshit final chapter so I'd give it a 7 or an 8 depending on my mood. |
 |
| 8/10. Sure the ending leaves a strong sour taste but I enjoyed the series a lot. The ending could have been better but then again it all comes down to Isayama, glad he was able to finish the series how he wanted. |
| 1 to 89 9/10 Pre time-skip it was awesome. 90 to 123 8/10 Political world building is not Isayama's strong suit , but it had awesome parts as well, also paths chapters were pretty good. 124 to 138 5/10 This part the series started deviating from the formula , i didn't like where it was going, since the "to save the world" marvel stuff do not belong in that setting. And then comes the abysmal 139 making any theme established in the manga a joke in retrospect 1/10 Overall 4/10 , "Hurting" the reader with a sad ending is fine, spiting on their face wasting their time is not |
| Had to lower my score from a 10 to a 7. The problem with this last chapter is that it ruins a lot of amazing moments from previous chapters including the fan favourite moments in 120-122. Rereading AoT will no longer give me that adrenaline rush I used to feel and it will honestly make me cringe at some parts. Attack on Titan is known as a series that gets better on rewatch but after ch 139, it is no longer that case. |
| 1 - 123 is 10/10 final arc is 7 ending is 3 would give it a solid 9 |
SilverLeo said: Satoya said: Lol its not that people cling to him, many people even expected a ending like this. Its just that the ending is not very fitting and cringy. Considering how Yams orignal approach made AoT such a good series its a shame that he ended things like this. I mean in the end Yam can do what he wants with his manga, but if fans have the right to praise AoT (which happend more than often) they also have any right to show their disappointment. It seems you need to understand this first. No I understand. Of course everybody has their own opinion and should have! But you can't tell me that after being an Anime only and going into discussion threads of S4 and seeing everywhere "Chaderen" and "KingFloch" that people didn't hope it was reality lol Of course these people might have also thought that Eren is bluffing and still wants to safe his friends, but for me it really did seem like they wanted the badass to be true. I see it that the biggest problems for people are that Eren is not what they wanted him to + him being in love with Mikasa, eventhough that I think Yams foreshadowed quiet a bit in the last arc and I ain't even a shipper and caught onto that lol Probably because I read 155-138 in a week lol I think the ending for the main cast is fitting and yeah the Armin/Eren talk isn't the best written dialoge, but I think it made the point clear. I guess the true answers about the ending will be delivered in June when Isayamas interview will be released in the magazine! I still feel like this will age like the prequels lol Hated at the beginning but over time more and more will like it, especially after the anime. I have to disagree again. Youre always using the term Chadren but youre missing the point. Its not about Chad or not, they are disappointed how everything played out and I absolutely agree with those people. There are so many ways that would end the series in a much better way, if you want to see the reasons read the other threads. |
maxigirl56 said: God, people are so dramatic! They're acting like the ending was the worst in anime history. Yes, the ending was sub-par, but it didn't ruin the entire show. People are just finding something aot to hate bc it's so popular, and they wanna seem cool. it was a 10/10 for me until the final arc the final arc was like a 7 IMO Overall I gave it a 9 because the rest of the manga was outstanding. Because the rest of the manga was so great, it made the ending seem worse than it really was when in reality, the ending was an average ending to an excellent story. aot is definitely not a 0/10 or a 1/10 for the whole story bc the ending was average. MAL users who rate it 1 or 0 is a haters. They even call the whole series a shit just because mediocre ending. MAL users is a definiton of AoT haters rn. |
More topics from this board
» Most underrated AOT part/arc in your opinion?DarkFirefly72 - Oct 7 |
11 |
by Rexaly
»»
Oct 9, 11:00 PM |
|
» 'Even a Child Can Do It': Shonen Jump Editor Calls Out Attack on Titan as Just 'Making a Lot of Noise'deg - Jul 18 |
6 |
by therealnagora
»»
Sep 13, 10:00 AM |
|
» Worst death of the series?Dragevard - May 29, 2021 |
3 |
by Kawaii_Otaku04
»»
Aug 3, 8:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 19 Discussionricardocsc - Oct 2, 2012 |
17 |
by Jeffrey8172
»»
Jul 11, 7:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 130 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )keragamming - Jul 6, 2020 |
213 |
by Adam_________
»»
Jun 3, 1:39 PM |