Ruu said:#183 This is the first post of him that caught my attention. There are some jokes about logic and Suzu but then he says he suspects Suzu is scum. She had rvs him and he says asking questions for which you already know the answer to is not townish:
One she's kinda asking a question she already knows the answer to which is the biggest thing. But when you couple that in with how boring the topic of discussion is (lol nolynch) it approaches an area of fake I hardly ever see from town.
I find this absurd because asking q's you know what answer is the correct one is a good way to catch mafia. So making it look like it's bad makes me think he was just looking for an easy excuse to scumread her/vote for her.
Then he says something I don't fully understand and I want him to expand on:
I also hold suz to a higher standard
What were you expecting from her? You think Suzu is scum because she is not playing like you wish she was?
Not precisely and you are right that questions with hard fast answers (for example let's say that someone is a watcher and they know someone visited the kill you could ask the person to claim their role and action and possibly catch them in a lie) are good to ask if you're already keen on something. But when it comes to mushier things, theory, reads, fluffies, then asking comes off for the sake of asking depending on the question and who's asking it. Needs nuance in other words.Ruu said:#187 He finds Togs post about CP iffy but doesn't go into detail. He only says that Togs saying he thinks CP is town more than once looks suspicious. [tbh I do do the same as Togs when I'm town] What I don like about this post is that he asks Togs questions about CP playstyle which I find positive.
@Fo can you tell me why were you townreading grrr based on his claim?
That's just one of my tells that I should probably give up on. Wording choice and phrasing isn't very reliable and here I was admittedly forcing the issue to a bit but it did annoy me because as I've stated to logic this page going out of your way to reaffirm townreads lacks a lot of town motive a lot of the time. You can call it playstyle but what does it actually accomplish if not for reactions? And the read togs gave wasn't really looking for a reaction because he explained it and was in response to CP himself so he wasn't looking for thoughts on it.Ruu said:This post is... not good. He hadn't say anything about Rinto before and then suddenly he change his vote from Suzu to Rinto without any kind of explanation.
Fo said:Okay I'm caught up now.
vote: Rinto
And then...
Fo said:Also I wanna lynch this now,
vote: Wyndz
Posts are very detached despite interesting things going on at the moment; especially don't like his last on a gut level.
He voted for Suzu with a weak reason, then went for Rinto without explaining his reasons and then suddenly (a couple of posts after) goes for Wyndz (with at least some explanation but again mostly because of a gut feeling). But guess what? Even thou he actually had a reason for that last vote, he still went back to Rinto (
#470). Weird right? But guess what? Rinto was on the top 3 most likely to get lynch by then so going from his good vote on Wy to a secure lynch option is not a good sign. I still don't fully buy the idea of claiming doc and being a scum doctor. Why would he do that? That put him on the spot and people where ready to lynch him...
Well my vote on rinto was for pressure because if you recall at the time we were trying to get a flavorclaim out of him and get him to slip up. Once CP backed off I moved onto wyz because I thought he was scum, then later moved back to rinto once the air was clear and I could give more of full opinion on rinto's play.Ruu said:#506 you still find Wy scummy but you decided to change your vote? :/
Yea, I like to change my votes, like I said, depending on what's going on in the game at the moment or how I'm feeling.Ruu said:#508 Can you please tell me if you still find me scummy and your reasons behind it? I know that you said on #563 that you were starting to lean town with me but since you change your mind quite fast I want to see if you still have that impression.
Hmm? This question is weird it's like you know I'm town but are isoing my and scumcasing me. Uh. You're actually quite hard to read tbh. You've made some bad posts and some good posts. I think the scummiest thing you've done was have a completely off reaction to rinto and grrr's claims sometime back that I'm reminded of now that you asked me. But then your push on astros looked like it was coming from a genuine place like, you asked some good questions and got your scumread more engaged with the game. Question still remains why astros (a non-entity at that point) was your most dominate scumread, but the push looked pretty town imo.Ruu said:#516 This is an interesting post because he was townreading logic but then he suddenly appear before phase change and voted for logic. Like I said before, he seems to be going for the popular choice. Edit: he did say that maybe logic could be scum (#567). What is also relevant form that post is that now gruffin is suddenly on the scum list (no reasons again) and wy is not. He was his strongest scum read and now he is not relevant?
I don't know how many times I'll get to use this line again so might as well. Ruu said:693 and.. the logic vote arrives. And post
#697 involves asking penta about phase change... anxious much?
teehee