Basic Game V6: Kitty Mafia | Game End - Mafia Win!

logic340 said:
I'm still open to this.

Grapefruit21 said:
For my neutral pile I have conflicting reads on each of them.
PentaFlare is an awesome scum player and hasn't done anything outside their range, but they have been overall townie. I think the push and then explanation for the CorruptedPurity was great and matches a lot of my own thinking. I also am somewhat sympathetic to not wanting to share reads that might change because of them. That said withholding reads is a great way to not be held accountable for them. I also think that logic's defense is pretty incriminating for Penta if logic were to flip scum, which is my prevailing world right now. Penta was townie, but not so obv town that people should have been rushing to say we should lynch the claimed town PR before the VT. And Claire wasn't so scummy to have earned that.

Followind has done almost nothing but has the opposite tonal purity to Sollux in my opinion. For some reason a lot of his posts just have a scummy feel I can't shake, but as above the recent Sollux is scummy because they are doing the same thing as me is awesome and I really want to town read him for having the cajones to make that read. Anyone who has played with him before let me know if that's inside his scum range.

grrr comes across as pretty helpful and cogent this game. I'd had a solid town lean here most of the game. However on my last reread I noticed something I can't get off. He could have been white knighting CorruptedPurity. That 12345 read was a reach and I'm not sure if I'm slipping into a pocket with him mind melding with me on logic. That is all tinfoil to be sure, but enough to knock him down a peg or two for me.

DenjaX said:
Vote:Shinichi-Kun

Obviously mafia gave you summary notes that is why you were able to catch up rather fast.

PentaFlare said:

Would you like to explain to me how my case against CP was bad? You didn't do it during D1 so I'll gladly hear it now.

Also, defending me and attacking Claire are basically interchangeable and you can't deny you were attacking Claire. My point about you seeming closed off to looking into me still stands, particularly when you were pressuring grapefruit about not thinking about reads on players and only focusing on mechanics.

logic340 said:
@Grapefruit21, @PentaFlare, @_Claire_ I am not saying that CP isn't scum I am saying your cases boil down to a combination of resentment (Clarie and Grapefruit) and pro-town behavior (at least what it was classed in a previous game). I have a hard to buying that lynch right now and the fact that I can say 2 of the 3 feel spiteful instead of justified makes me more concerned about the train. I asked Claire to verify that CP's meta read on Grape was wrong and shading and she wouldn't do even going as far as to ask me to ask the question again in a post that she quoted said question. Like I really feel they are trying too hard.

I was dead to rights as scum and they couldn't get me because their arguments were flawed, tunneled too hard, though they could nail me for some BS that wasn't real (knowing Rosie's PR)., and had questionable behavior themselves. I am asking them to step back and be certain rather than lynching off emotion. Again it's weird to me that the two scum from the last game are leading the vote here do you guy think we rolled scum together again or something?

And with this I am out for a while. I may check in but posting will be minimal for a little while.

PentaFlare said:
I'm going to be gone for most of the afternoon. I may be back before the phase change but I'm not actually sure. Either way, I'm happy enough with my vote. I want a flip from logic or grape because either of their alignments will be really useful for VCA and interaction analysis. However, I would prefer logic because I scumread logic more than grape.

amberwillow said:
vote: Logic

I hate to be in this position

logic340 said:
Information over an actual scum lynch? This doesn't feel like town Penta. Lets lynch scum instead of mislynching town for information.

RE1031 said:
vote: logic340
Really, really sorry but I'd love to see Grapefruit wriggle out of this one.