So Strange Fake is set to release, so what do you hope is next for Fate and the Nasuverse?

I hope for a Saber route remake from ufotable! DEEN adaptation is so bad, the mix all the routes from the novel to one!

@Memore I swear Nasu just said... he isn't looking to green light a remake at this time. It was during the 20th Anniversary showcase - lots of disappointed comments on the live stream.

So your second choice?

No, I'm not interested in that. There are a few things that will interest me if they are made.

Fate/Prototype
Fate/Hollow Ataraxia
Witch on the Holy Night sequels
more anime directed by Tomonori Sudou, who directed Heaven's Feel.

I don't think we will ever see an actual adaptation of fate/prototype since its a rejected script for fate/stay night but maybe Fate/Prototype: Sougin no Fragments (which is a prequel to fate/prototype) will get an adaptation someday.

On topic:I wait for a Hollow Atraxia adaptation or a redline adaptation.Maybe a Tsukihime remake is possible too especially with all these remakes we got and we are going to get this year.

One of the weaknesses in Fate seems to be the lack of story-lines separate from the games. Fate/Extra Record is being released as a game, so just like with FGO it comes out and then they adapt these games...

I would prefer if they went a route with the anime, and based the games off loose threads from the anime rather than vice-versa.
The other problem with adapting these games is the characters... Fate used to have a reasonable # of characters to follow. Now there are hundreds? There are so many playable servants it has lost all meaning now. And all these alternate versions and alternate routes & timelines.. it's not a story anymore it's just a massive gaming franchise with a very loose theme.
It would be better if they made sequels of the earlier anime. I want to see Astolfo in another grail war, and Saber Miss Arturia, Iskandar and Waver (head of magic school Waver) and what happens with the relationships to some of the characters from Apocrypha (like Uncle Gord, and that homunculus girl who totally wasn't a love interest; what happens when all the characters from Shirou's world including Rin, are old. Like a Next Gen story... but none of that will happen, it's just a game franchise with hardly anything recognizable anymore.

That would work well for Apocrypha, since the existing story reveals next to nothing about its characters.

@Lucifrost Well I mean, you learn a lot about Caules & Fiore Forvedge and how they become mages, I appreciated the backstory about the pet dog and its meaning; I wish they had given more info about the Musik family, who according to Gord were an important family on par with the main families...
But it expects you to derive the Servants' from their legends on your own; which I sort of liked... their weaknesses and wishes are implied by their known tragedies- no reason for them to reexplain the Greek heroes Chiron & Achilles, or Atalantae etc or William Shakespeare- although Astolfo's legend is much less known, and they took advantage of the vagueness to say, let's make him a pink haired femme boy who is all cheerful and energetic... brilliant!

Tsukihime remake, Saber route remake and Hollow Atraxia are the ones which I want the most.

That it goes far away and never returns?

I just hope for all of these fate/nasuverse shi* to stop . No more of these please . There's enough

No, I'm not interested in that. There are a few things that will interest me if they are made.

Fate/Prototype
Fate/Hollow Ataraxia
Witch on the Holy Night sequels
more anime directed by Tomonori Sudou, who directed Heaven's Feel.

@FZREMAKE

I think it go for me;

Hollow Atraxia as number 1 after the ones already announced
Then I'd go Tsukihime Piece of Glass Moon adaptation
Then third Fate/Stay Night remake with the 'final ending'
From there I mean Lord El Melloi Adventures would be awesome

After that I'm pretty chill with all the following to;
Then Fate/Redline
Possibly do Extella and Extella Link
And Prototype series
There is the Fate/Labyrinth and there's another Fate set around Norse mythology and characters in the Apocrypha Timeline

They could also go bold and do a Fate original anime series; that could be good as it be something none of us could really predict. All new characters, servants, grail war system.

@AnimePedestrian There is a higher chance of redline, prototype and samurai remnant getting animated right now then the main 3 that I wish for.
A totally new fate would be cool too.

@AnimePedestrian If wishes were horses then beggars would ride

@joemaamah

If turnips were watches, I'd wear one by my side.

@AnimePedestrian 😆😆😆
That's a new one on me!

@joemaamah XD, it comes from the one you posted

If wishes were horses, beggars would ride.
If turnips were watches, I'd wear one by my side.
If "ifs" and "ands" were pots and pans,
There'd be no work for tinkers' hands.




The more you know I'm I right... (is it weird this threat has descended into quoting poetry)

@AnimePedestrian Well, 'tis the season...
If "ifs" and "buts" were candy and nuts,
how merry Christmas would be!

That is difficult to do when characters are not faithful to said legends.

That it goes far away and never returns?

@joemaamah I certainly wouldn't try and change your opinion although I always find it odd when someone comes in to a thread about anything they don't like just to add a comment that doesn't really contribute to anything at all related to the topic. I guess the engagement that I'll mildly oblige with for a single post is probably the goal for most of these.

But seeing the Vash pfp mixed with the aforementioned definitely painted a picture of you probably also hate Stampede and I find it amusing of how easily readable people like you are just based on a few simple observations. Respect for the favorite character taste sans Frieren(I'll at least say that she's the best of a pedestrian cast in a good show for sure) and Yor though.

@Syrian187 Oh, it definitely contributes. Opposite opinions over the simpering of fanboys/girls always adds to a discussion. Yes there can be other valid opinions.

And yes, except for the last couple episodes, Stampede totally sucked.

@Lucifrost It stretches the truths of, of the legends of, the epic heroes a great deal.

But you think only Apocrypha do this- I think the whole idea of Arturia since Fate/Stay Night being King Arthur as a woman is itself kind of ridiculous, especially how they tried to make a backstory of Mordred calling the woman "father" (which was in Apocrypha) and that just didn't work.
But despite the awkwardness of trying to explain this gender swap with lore; we all still accept Arturia and love the character anyway.

@joemaamah Ok I'll bite this isn't really a thread of fanboys/fangirls you're projecting a bit there seemed to me nothing more than a question for people who like type moon to see what they would be interested in seeing animated next. Hell I myself stated I have little to no interest in the mediocre slop that is some of the fate spin offs and fgo related shows.

I might agree with the differing opinion sentiment but I would say that "That it goes far away and never returns" offers nothing in the way of reasoning or opinions as to why you feel that way, so I'd be hard pressed to call it that. Closer to a bait response than it is an actual formed opinion.

I'd agree that Stampede started a bit slow but in my opinion the second half especially the last few episodes were great and setup the interest for the second part perfectly. So at least I can say that's more than most Stampede haters would admit so respect for that. Most of them didn't even watch the first episode or called it shit for the 3d or some nonsensical reason like some half baked character like Milly not being there. Which oddly enough I think it becomes clear pretty quickly that Meryls personality, Millies appearance, and Vash's personality were being setup to develop for the next part and sure enough the last episodes confirm that so I guess an unfortunate miss from that lot.

Closing note I'd also say that most OG Trigun fans really have their blinders on when acting like the show wasn't all over the place and only had one impactful moment in it's entirety being the Wolfwood scene. As much as Trigun OG will always be one of my favorites, I also can't just pretend that the ending didn't make a whole lot of sense either. Still OG Trigun ep 1 will always be one of my favorite character intros/ep 1s of all time along with Hellsing and Samurai Champloos ep1 introductions.

@Lucifrost It stretches the truths of, of the legends of, the epic heroes a great deal.

But you think only Apocrypha do this- I think the whole idea of Arturia since Fate/Stay Night being King Arthur as a woman is itself kind of ridiculous, especially how they tried to make a backstory of Mordred calling the woman "father" (which was in Apocrypha) and that just didn't work.
But despite the awkwardness of trying to explain this gender swap with lore; we all still accept Arturia and love the character anyway.

@Syrian187 Oh, it definitely contributes. Opposite opinions over the simpering of fanboys/girls always adds to a discussion. Yes there can be other valid opinions.

And yes, except for the last couple episodes, Stampede totally sucked.

@Syrian187

I made the thread purely to see what direction the fans hope to go in. More so say three or four years from now hopefully Aniplex hasn't totally botched the direction and are doing something barely anyone wanted like Singularity 5 or something XD.

@joemaamah

I'm kindof a hardcore Type Moon fan. Like I play Grand Order, play some of the games, I watched the scuffed 20th livestream for 6 hours before finally being among the first to see Strange Fake as it aired on YouTube.

So uncharitably I'm a fanboy.

But circling back to point one as a result I prefer to catch the communities takes, as I'll happily watch Extella Link the anime but I imagine most other fans would groan and roll there eyes if that was announced.

And luckily the Type Moon fan base isn't afraid of giving opinions. There's like factions, Ufotable stans, Zero purists, Visual Novel elitist, Gilgamesh wannabes, during the live stream there was a Deen apologist as well.

So the fanbase isn't like say Re;Zero or Dragon Ball where the next thing must clearly be worshiped. Type Moon fans are like Gundam fans - they all have there favourite shows, and those opinions colour there hopes for the next projects.

@SuperAdventure

I mean to be fair, Achilles and Chiron are like super close to the legend. Shakespeare is certainly eccentric but it makes him more interesting to watch.

Astolfo - the paladin in his story really did lose his sanity and dress in drag.

Mordred as the 'son' of king Arthur but both being chicks - I chalk that up to it being anime.

Cu Culainn is a badass, checks out with the legend being a total badass. Gilgamesh is the same. Dark Knight was purely that way for the twist in Zero. So most of it all makes sense.

Will say Jack the Ripper finally getting justice in his new interpretation. Loli Jack was so... Mid

@AnimePedestrian Oh yes I totally agree, I thought the portrayals were really good and fun; and love Astolfo. I didn't know he had gone insane or done drag; I had only ever read the Wikipedia entry on him which wasn't very detailed back then. But I do think the legends were stretched a bit for entertainment purposes (as they should be)
The Mordred/King Arthur thing made me cringe real hard when I saw it in Apocrypha... but yea, we love the characters despite this and know it's like that because ANIME. The first figures I bought were of Mordred, Astolfo and Saber.

The whole Jack the Ripper thing seemed also to be a bit too anime and kinda gross- but the theory that he was possibly an orphaned neglected and diseased street kid getting revenge on London society through insane violence is actually a pretty compelling idea.
Clearly fiction entirely, but still a consideration....

@AnimePedestrian Nothing wrong with being a fanboy, as long as you have solid reasons behind your fandom, and you're not just another lemming leaping off the hype cliff.

And being a fanboy doesn't mean you have to like everything the producers lay down. TBH I'm a Bungo Stray Dogs fanboy. But I thought the last season was absolutely horrible. I found out that wasn't a real popular opinion. Too bad. I stated my reasons in my review, and left it at that. Good thing there were no trees around, I might have been crucified!

"There was a Deen apologist as well."
🤣🤣🤣

@joemaamah

I know, he was arguing with everyone it was so damn funny. I will say, I like Stay Night 2006 for the charming soundtrack, decent first attempt, and the more wholistic story where Saber, Rin and Sakura even Kieri and Gilgamesh all have decent endings. Only real characters who get a little snubbed are Shinji and oddly Lancer (who shines more in UBW).

@AnimePedestrian One of the great reasons I keep coming back to the anime community. They can take some of the most outrageous positions and defend them to the death. I have to admit I admire the spirit. And I find it perversely entertaining as well.

@joemaamah It's what anime fans do best, how else can we explain the massive success of Isekai XD

Big things I'd want for a Type-Moon adaptation: either said Tsukihime remake or Kinoko Nasu's earliest work, Notes.

@AnimePedestrian 🤣 That's just history repeating itself. First it was mecha in the 80s and 90s. Now we have to withstand the onslaught of garbage isekais until the worm turns and the next "thing" comes down the pike.

@joemaamah

Hopefully the next thing just isn't the same locations on repeat.

I only watched two Isekai - Overlord and Re;Zero the thought someone out there somewhere has watched some nerd get teleported to the same damn fantasy world over and over and over again and wasn't bored on the 100s show is a testament to there persons love of waifu I guess.

I guess Mecha really could be boiled down to space or a human city/town but at least there were some more interesting world building efforts. Not just, there be elfs and cute cat boys.