Frieren and Violet

Honestly both of those girls are stoic bad choices. Even an average tsundere is better than a stoic girl. I am a man though so female taste will be far different. My best female character list would go to girls like Shamiiko, Squid Girl, or Jahy. Any Konosuba girl is fire too.

Best female characters in anime are Vladilena Milize from 86, Suzuha amane from Steins Gate and Ultear from Fairy Tail

Violet is a decent character, but Frieren ist just boring. Mao Mao is the best female character in recent years.

I was just talking about the best written characters. That’s what i thought you were trying to explain XD

For me at least, it’s kinda hard to tell you which one is better. I am personally not a fan of stoic characters. It’s just not my cup of tea. What I do look for is the character growth and how the story of this character progresses.

I personally believe it’s unfair to compare these two characters yet. Violet’s story is finished, so I naturally look upon her more favorably. However, Frieran’s story isn’t over yet. We will see what the story can bring to the table. Once her story is complete, I think that a decision on who is better can be made.

Can’t answer that as I haven’t watch Violet Evergarden. I love Frieren tho not sure why she is considered hated. Maybe it’s because of the relationship with Hummel and she didn’t really accept his feelings. But that’s what makes Frieren such a good character, after his death, she realised that she never really considered his feelings the way he was, so she is now living life trying to understand people better and accept those for who they are. Her development is amazing and incredibly well written

Maomao from Apothecary Diaries is the best written female protagonist of the past decade and has the potential to be the best of all time. Violet Evergarden is also top tier. Characters like Frieren, Vladilena Milize and Tanya are a tier below

I love both characters the most

These two have very different Aura but also very similar.

They both are stoic and hard to read but at the same time they are so pure.

Violet and Frieren also have the same aura when the fight.

When they go to battle mode they gives the vibes " you don't want to mess with me"l or " I'm way OP for you"

But they have their differences

They both trying to learn about human emotions but for different ret

Violet also tries to learn about feelings only to understand the 3 words Major said to her.

She's more romantic and pure hearted.

Frieren even if the ship with Himmel exists she's doing for all of her older companions equally.

Also the fact that she's an elf it's a bit more hard for her to understand human emotions.

Also she has more humour and childish vibes from Violet.

If with Violet you laugh 1 time with Frieren you laugh 10.

Also both characters help other people's with their problems.

But Frieren she's doing mostly adventures with a beautiful aftermath.

With Violet from the beginning until the end it's about emotions.

In the end they have a lot of similarities and differences

But I love them both the most.

In my humble to goodness opinion, through heaven and earth Kurumi Tokisaki is the only honoured waifu.
Any of these waifu are good IMO: Kurumi, Misaka Mikoto, Miku Nakano, Nino Nakano, Yuki, Marin Kitagawa…

Honestly I don't even think these characters are THAT similar, it's mostly just surface level analysis merchants in the anime community.

But as someone that much prefers Violet I would say her introspection is just way better and each individual scene feels like it has more value. A lot of Violet's character arc is really relatable in a way Frieren's wasn't as much and it really feels like in 12 episodes she has a much fuller journey than Frieren has in over double. Also she's just way prettier

The only ones who like Frieren more are my feet niggas cause they ate gooood.

Both aren't very different, but they focus on different things. For Violet, it's more about finding her feelings, while for Frieren, they tried to explain adventures and mentorship between characters. So for some people, Frieren is just boring. But in my opinion, they are both top of their genres. Frieren is fun while Violet is sympathetic.

@Sports_Friday Give me some examples because I don't understand what you mean, I can also say that something SEEMS to me and it seems to me that most of these scenes consist of cheap tear-jerking with cheap tricks, overdramatized monologues/dialogues intended to give the impression of "greater value" that wasn't there xD I'm curious what is more believable in Violet than Frieren to you? What does "believable" mean anyway? Oh...does the completed story (journey) of the characters seem more complete to you? Really? Frieren is prettier👌 maybe I'm biased but not more than you xD

@Ba-Cii10 Yes, this is why I started with they are not even that similar shows/characters. One is a a dedicated character drama and the other feels like something much closer to Aria. It's mostly personal preference which one people like more and I didn't personally enjoy Frieren being old and detached as much as other people but very much liked the overdramatized aspects of Violet.

I think Violet gets more hype because people become more attached to a character in a dedicated drama like that with how emotional it is

Frieren is slow burn show with lot of mundane moments where Violet(I haven’t watched it) from what i can tell is more on drama side which is supposed to make you cry, thats where the difference is. It's not about which character is better, it's just that most people prefer drama over slow pace.

Suzuha sucks, personally, I prefer Kurisu