Is Oreimo OVER-hated or UNDER-hated

Jun 30, 1:26 PM

IssyBoy

Offline

Apr 2020

312

Very self-explanatory question, just wanna know if y'all think the backlash towards Oreimo is deserved or not.

Nina supporter for life💕

Jun 30, 1:35 PM

wizdom224

Online

Jul 2021

1632

I don't know what you mean by 'backlash'. I just know that I love the show but would have liked a more fleshed out ending where

Jun 30, 4:46 PM

kusanagi_ZFG

Offline

Apr 2022

169

nobody cares that much about it anymore idk. but i enjoyed it. obviously there will be hate given its nature. but thats fine, and obviously most of the haters watched it, so if it was really so terrible its almost like they’re self reporting…

boredboredbored

Jun 30, 4:51 PM

FutoiOtaku

Offline

Nov 2023

933

It’s probably hated by people who express strict morality and can’t separate fiction from reality, and loved by people who secretly (or not?) find the illicit nature of the relationship exciting or stimulating. I’m in the middle somewhere. I like the consistency of the character writing even if I find the core concept a bit uncomfortable. It’s like the show is experimenting with this theme to prod the viewer into forming opinions or at least having a better understanding of themselves and how tolerant/ kinky they are. I liked it strongly rather than loved it.

Jun 30, 4:53 PM

I_love_sora2

Offline

Jun 2023

186

It’s over hated tbh ya it’s not mentioned much but when it is it’s always you fucking sicko why are you watching this but in actuality it’s not that bad it’s a good story but the ending ruined it but I still find it enjoyable plus it has incest which is in fact wincest

Jun 30, 4:54 PM

Emrys_

Offline

Oct 2023

I’ve actually been rewatching it recently. It all just stems from it being known as “that incest one”.
No one wants to give it a try. Despite it being actually funny. Idk if it fits into one of those definitions because most aren’t starring it. If I had to say thou then over hated. Thou I definitely think it needs criticism. Its shifting tones and odd ending that the authors editor made him change to avoid controversy felt lacking.
All I say if anyone wants to watch it try it first

HER. That is all.

Jun 30, 4:54 PM

I_love_sora2

Offline

Jun 2023

186

wizdom224 said:
I don't know what you mean by 'backlash'. I just know that I love the show but would have liked a more fleshed out ending where

Thank god love the incest

Jun 30, 4:56 PM

rohan121

Offline

Sep 2018

11550

The anime ending for s2 was very poor, but the overall series besides that is pretty great. It gained a lot of popularity based on its high merit in general. Oreimo portable is awesome if you want to see a good end with each girl.

Jun 30, 5:33 PM

Piromysl

Offline

Jul 2015

12289

Oreimo is totally enjoyable trash that requires you to completely shut your brain off in order to properly enjoy. I had an absolute blast watching it, because I've taken absolutely nothing seriously in it, especially the ending, to which I was prepared anyway, because it is obvious that THE main girl will win in the end.
Also, I said it many times and I've said it again.
Regardless if you love or hate this show, Kuroneko character is absolutely the best part of it and single reason why I would recommend to watch it for everyone. She singlehandedly carries the show. She is like Kurumi to Date a Live, but actually even better. I also think it was KanaHawa's best performance ever.

Jun 30, 5:40 PM

#10

Gran_Air

Offline

Sep 2019

I don’t really care much about it any more but I remember at the time I was just really confused with the ending. I might be remembering it wrong but it felt like he only built a good “relationship” with the short black haired girl but somehow everyone else fell in love with him as well 🤔. I watched it many years ago when I was pretty young so idk don’t take my words too seriously

Jun 30, 5:43 PM

#11

asphyxian

Offline

Jul 2021

well its a part of the big three in anime, including overflow and my wife became an elementary school student so its most definitely not underhated

Jun 30, 6:11 PM

#12

Moppit

Offline

Nov 2018

1268

I actually like the anime for the most part. Most of the bad reviews I saw are mostly focused on the relationship, so outside of that, I figured this would have praised more. The only real example I have seen close to this would be Usagi Drop. It has a high rating of being liked because there wasn't a second season.

MoppitJun 30, 11:17 PM

Jun 30, 6:27 PM

#13

JayTCU

Offline

Apr 2023

148

“Polarizing” “controversial” “contentious”. It’s not really about how people see it because it generates a lot of buzz.

Jun 30, 7:47 PM

#14

SwagsOnB

Offline

Apr 2023

111

Extremely overhated. The thing people criticize the show for is actually a strength. Their relationship is beautiful. It’s easily one of the most accurate depictions of sibling dynamics in anime.

SwagsOnBJun 30, 7:57 PM

Jun 30, 11:49 PM

#15

slvrcofe21

Offline

Mar 2013

126

I liked the show. Didn’t care for the ending though. It was weird to me but whatever. I thought he should end up with KuroNeko. I think that was her name.

Jul 1, 12:46 AM

#16

Buny0058

Offline

Nov 2022

935

It’s put in the same catagory as eromanga sensei. Might largely be hated due to being compared to that.

Jul 1, 2:18 PM

#17

Grenadier020

Offline

Jun 2015

Its overhated, if it wasn't for the incest it would be mid to be honest and poeple wouldn't be as interested.

They wouldn't care for another mid SOL Romance anime.

Great characters tho, that was the best of the show.

Jul 1, 2:52 PM

#18

Vultureneck

Offline

Mar 2018

The show has better character writing than most shows, and while the story was a bit messy in some parts, I will stand by the show being something genuinely good. It's compared to eromanga sensei a lot, but it's way more sophisticated; any similarities only run surface level imo.

Jul 2, 7:31 PM

#19

PatientPanda

Offline

May 2024

Overhated, I remember years ago when it first came out, I was just going on plot based and it was good. The characters were well developed to the story and the ending at first I was like HUH? Why? but then as i grew older I was like oh shit okay nvm. But based on the story and plot, it was pretty good for two seasons :)

Jul 4, 12:27 PM

#20

MinchiMint

Offline

Jan 2021

I will start by saying I don't have anything against incest in anime. I had no problem with Eromanga Sensei for that matter. That being said, I do not understand the ending. It felt forced, almost as if the writer just couldn't find a decent way to pull the show back into siscon.
It was indeed very enjoyable until around the second part of S2, like some said earlier Kuroneko had a bus driver position in the story, and then, in my opinion, the show just kind of throws all it built in terms of character development and said story into the trash and just brought a half-assed, and often almost repulsive pull back into siscon finale. That kind of ending could work in some cases, but it just didn't fit for me, and felt surprisingly wrong; rant-like almost.

Jul 4, 12:31 PM

#21

Archean-Return

Online

Dec 2022

5308

Every anime that has any real commitment to sibling love has a 2.00 weighted score handicap as a consequence. Users here rate based on their preconceived opinions on themes an anime contains, rather than how it delivers on them.

Oreimo is better than most romcoms, and knows exactly how to set the scene in the same situations where lesser series would fail at it. Of course it's underrated.

Archean-ReturnJul 4, 12:37 PM

ｲ乇刀乇乃尺ﾑ乇

╔⏤═⏤╝

╚⏤═⏤╗

☽ Shaded Horizon ☾

Jul 10, 9:45 AM

#22

the_Krsd

Offline

Jan 2017

The show is only for people who like to see shitty people doing what they want and a self-flagellating brother that just takes shit without complaint.

Jul 13, 3:19 AM

#23

Armio

Offline

Apr 2014

my repulsion to him suddenly breaking up with kuroneko is practically a core memory.

Jul 18, 9:33 PM

#24

LuckySprayz

Offline

Aug 2022

All yall going to jail, under hated

Jul 19, 6:21 AM

#25

IssyBoy

Offline

Apr 2020

312

Reply to LuckySprayz

All yall going to jail, under hated

@LuckySprayz Bro is taking fictional media seriously..

Nina supporter for life💕

See All Discussions

Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Kuro4735 - Nov 28, 2010	352	by PedroKarim64 »» Nov 16, 3:00 PM
Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Kuro4735 - Nov 7, 2010	401	by PedroKarim64 »» Nov 13, 2:13 PM
Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Kuro4735 - Oct 9, 2010	266	by zebi__ »» Oct 29, 12:58 PM
» I love Kirino EV222IL - Dec 2, 2016	2	by canadasnow »» Oct 26, 7:13 PM
» The Otaku Perception IssyBoy - Oct 10	11	by PatientPanda »» Oct 17, 2:32 AM

Is Oreimo OVER-hated or UNDER-hated

More topics from this board

Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» I love Kirino

» The Otaku Perception

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters