This show is probably not an isekai [Possible Spoilers]

Destroyer375 said:

is this really isekai. I read manga and in there cid is back to his original world with beta

Euthymia_Gerv said:
I don't really care what happens in the LN

Euthymia_Gerv said:


The thread was started discussing points shown so far in the ANIME to formulate a hypothesis about what could actually be happening, which would explain a lot of things. Why he's so overpowered. Everything always seems to go his way. Why he seems to be able to shape the world. Even his lies end up turning out to be true.

Using "facts" from ahead in the story from another source (the LN) is a spoiler. It adds information that hasn't been presented in the anime, which is by definition a spoiler.



Say you're discussing whether a character's eyes will be revealed to be green or blue in a game (it's a somewhat important plot point for some reason), and you discuss information that has been presented so far to argue that they are blue. Then I chime in "I worked on the DLC (I've been a game tester for 10+ years) and it's proven they are definitely not blue."

I didn't tell you outright that the character's eyes are green or how it's learned, but you now know something happens that reveals it, will be expecting it, and that they will be revealed to be green, which is a spoiler.



Actually yes it will. If I cared about what happens further in the story, I would have read the LN myself and had those questions answered already. I didn't read the LN because I didn't want that and instead chose to follow the anime and speculate based on the information presented in the anime so far.

Stating a "simple fact" that happens in the LN does ruin the experience. Not only has that information not been shown yet in the anime, but it's information from volume 4 of the LN, which also spoils events from the LN had I (or anyone else) decided to pick it up at some point.

EDIT:


So spoiling is ok because it's going to happen in the second season, which hasn't been released yet. Yeah, that makes a whole lot of sense.



Thanks for the spoiler, but he's dead in his original world. How can he go back? Unless the whole story is taking place as he is dying and he's imagining the whole thing.

Euthymia_Gerv said:


The thread was started discussing points shown so far in the ANIME to formulate a hypothesis about what could actually be happening, which would explain a lot of things. Why he's so overpowered. Everything always seems to go his way. Why he seems to be able to shape the world. Even his lies end up turning out to be true.

Using "facts" from ahead in the story from another source (the LN) is a spoiler. It adds information that hasn't been presented in the anime, which is by definition a spoiler.



Say you're discussing whether a character's eyes will be revealed to be green or blue in a game (it's a somewhat important plot point for some reason), and you discuss information that has been presented so far to argue that they are blue. Then I chime in "I worked on the DLC (I've been a game tester for 10+ years) and it's proven they are definitely not blue."

I didn't tell you outright that the character's eyes are green or how it's learned, but you now know something happens that reveals it, will be expecting it, and that they will be revealed to be green, which is a spoiler.



Actually yes it will. If I cared about what happens further in the story, I would have read the LN myself and had those questions answered already. I didn't read the LN because I didn't want that and instead chose to follow the anime and speculate based on the information presented in the anime so far.

Stating a "simple fact" that happens in the LN does ruin the experience. Not only has that information not been shown yet in the anime, but it's information from volume 4 of the LN, which also spoils events from the LN had I (or anyone else) decided to pick it up at some point.

EDIT:


So spoiling is ok because it's going to happen in the second season, which hasn't been released yet. Yeah, that makes a whole lot of sense.



Thanks for the spoiler, but he's dead in his original world. How can he go back? Unless the whole story is taking place as he is dying and he's imagining the whole thing.

Euthymia_Gerv said:


The thread was started discussing points shown so far in the ANIME to formulate a hypothesis about what could actually be happening, which would explain a lot of things. Why he's so overpowered. Everything always seems to go his way. Why he seems to be able to shape the world. Even his lies end up turning out to be true.

Using "facts" from ahead in the story from another source (the LN) is a spoiler. It adds information that hasn't been presented in the anime, which is by definition a spoiler.



Say you're discussing whether a character's eyes will be revealed to be green or blue in a game (it's a somewhat important plot point for some reason), and you discuss information that has been presented so far to argue that they are blue. Then I chime in "I worked on the DLC (I've been a game tester for 10+ years) and it's proven they are definitely not blue."

I didn't tell you outright that the character's eyes are green or how it's learned, but you now know something happens that reveals it, will be expecting it, and that they will be revealed to be green, which is a spoiler.



Actually yes it will. If I cared about what happens further in the story, I would have read the LN myself and had those questions answered already. I didn't read the LN because I didn't want that and instead chose to follow the anime and speculate based on the information presented in the anime so far.

Stating a "simple fact" that happens in the LN does ruin the experience. Not only has that information not been shown yet in the anime, but it's information from volume 4 of the LN, which also spoils events from the LN had I (or anyone else) decided to pick it up at some point.

EDIT:


So spoiling is ok because it's going to happen in the second season, which hasn't been released yet. Yeah, that makes a whole lot of sense.



Thanks for the spoiler, but he's dead in his original world. How can he go back? Unless the whole story is taking place as he is dying and he's imagining the whole thing.

Sayan_Pal said:
u idiot, u cannot ignore ln and anime is incomplete , it take from ln and in ln he go to earth,so he is not imagining. It is definitely isekai, and an reincarnate person can go back to earth, he is reincernated, he is not imagining, second season is not announced, and anime is adapted from ln vol 1 and 2, and in ln he go to earth using portal,it is not anime original series, the whole story not take place as imagination of cid

Euthymia_Gerv said:


The thread was started discussing points shown so far in the ANIME to formulate a hypothesis about what could actually be happening, which would explain a lot of things. Why he's so overpowered. Everything always seems to go his way. Why he seems to be able to shape the world. Even his lies end up turning out to be true.

Using "facts" from ahead in the story from another source (the LN) is a spoiler. It adds information that hasn't been presented in the anime, which is by definition a spoiler.



Say you're discussing whether a character's eyes will be revealed to be green or blue in a game (it's a somewhat important plot point for some reason), and you discuss information that has been presented so far to argue that they are blue. Then I chime in "I worked on the DLC (I've been a game tester for 10+ years) and it's proven they are definitely not blue."

I didn't tell you outright that the character's eyes are green or how it's learned, but you now know something happens that reveals it, will be expecting it, and that they will be revealed to be green, which is a spoiler.



Actually yes it will. If I cared about what happens further in the story, I would have read the LN myself and had those questions answered already. I didn't read the LN because I didn't want that and instead chose to follow the anime and speculate based on the information presented in the anime so far.

Stating a "simple fact" that happens in the LN does ruin the experience. Not only has that information not been shown yet in the anime, but it's information from volume 4 of the LN, which also spoils events from the LN had I (or anyone else) decided to pick it up at some point.

EDIT:


So spoiling is ok because it's going to happen in the second season, which hasn't been released yet. Yeah, that makes a whole lot of sense.



Thanks for the spoiler, but he's dead in his original world. How can he go back? Unless the whole story is taking place as he is dying and he's imagining the whole thing.

Euthymia_Gerv said:
For instance, the food appearing in this imagined world is because he knows of these things and his struggling brain is jumbling these memories into this imagined world. He assumes "I must have told X about this" to try to make sense of it. Because he assumed and he subconsciously controls the world he created, it becomes fact without him realizing or even having to question anyone about it.