| It's a very edgy and dumb fun type of series for me but my problem with the anime is that it really doesn't do justice to the great art and the facial expressions of the manga. |
| Purely BIAS against enjoying edgy shows, people are a lot more critical when it comes to the plot of the shows like these compared to le wholesome and comedy/meme'y shows like Spy x Family that has all its faults forgiven. |
| Cause,it is superficial and bland,with EVERYTHING. I was expecting good stuff from the 3rd game thanks to my manga reading friends,so i decided to read it myself and can confirm that it also is crude and shitty. |
 |
kyo_1 said: Tyraq said: It's a very edgy and dumb fun type of series for me but my problem with the anime is that it really doesn't do justice to the great art and the facial expressions of the manga. if people seriously think that it should be rated 1 lower than the manga because of facial expressions then somethings gone wrong xD it’s still good i’d rate the manga a 9 and the series a 9 tbh (although the series is slightly worse than the manga so 8.9) Well tbh if you've read the manga you should be able to tell that the anime can never have scenes like this. |
Tyraq said: thats exactly my point, while the anime won’t be able to have moments like this it hasn’t got to many other probably i think (possibly pacing) I could see someone rate it lower because they don’t like pacing but for facial expressions? That’s just getting stupidkyo_1 said: if people seriously think that it should be rated 1 lower than the manga because of facial expressions then somethings gone wrong xD it’s still good i’d rate the manga a 9 and the series a 9 tbh (although the series is slightly worse than the manga so 8.9) Well tbh if you've read the manga you should be able to tell that the anime can never have scenes like this. |
kyo_1 said: Tyraq said: thats exactly my point, while the anime won’t be able to have moments like this it’s hasn’t got to many other probably i think (possibly pacing) I could see someone rate it lower because they don’t like pacing but for facial expressions? That’s just getting stupidWell tbh if you've read the manga you should be able to tell that the anime can never have scenes like this. Well it's not just facial expressions, I think the manga does a much better job in creating the proper atmosphere and there's much more tension. I just said that facial expressions and the great art of the manga were something that I could never see in the anime because I really enjoyed the manga because of those. Not saying the anime is bad but I just gave my issue on the anime. |
Tyraq said: so surely if you only liked the manga for the art and expressions you completely dislike the anime?kyo_1 said: thats exactly my point, while the anime won’t be able to have moments like this it’s hasn’t got to many other probably i think (possibly pacing) I could see someone rate it lower because they don’t like pacing but for facial expressions? That’s just getting stupid Well it's not just facial expressions, I think the manga does a much better job in creating the proper atmosphere and there's much more tension. I just said that facial expressions and the great art of the manga were something that I could never see in the anime because I really enjoyed the manga because of those. Not saying the anime is bad but I just gave my issue on the anime. |
kyo_1 said: so surely if you only liked the manga for the art and expressions you completely dislike the anime? I didn't only enjoy the manga for the art and expressions nor do I think the anime is bad, because it isn't. I just stated some reasons on why I was a bit disappointed with the anime. |
| Well you've already listed one reason. I don't plan on watching it yet because it sounds like an anime that's been done a lot before. I've only watched first episode summary. |
 |
kyo_1 said: Tyraq said: i feel like this thread was for people who hated it because the anime was specifically bad so i think i took it wrongly xDI didn't only enjoy the manga for the art and expressions nor do I think the anime is bad, because it isn't. I just stated some reasons on why I was a bit disappointed with the anime. Lol it's fine, I guess I should've been more specific with my claims. |
Tyraq said: kyo_1 said: if people seriously think that it should be rated 1 lower than the manga because of facial expressions then somethings gone wrong xD it’s still good i’d rate the manga a 9 and the series a 9 tbh (although the series is slightly worse than the manga so 8.9) Well tbh if you've read the manga you should be able to tell that the anime can never have scenes like this. In which chapter is this face made ? and why wouldn't they adapt it ? I saw this in many edit so curious coz also looks pretty cool |
 |
official_brown said: PoputePalhossa said: it has death note ep 37 tipe of plots whit m. shoujo site characters edit: gramr Bruh, not Shoujo Site, that stuff is legit messed up. Wait what are you guy talking about ? Elaborate. |
|
Pillsbury_Uchiha said: when something goes wrong the show is like well actually... then does the flashback of their master plan That's mainly coz Yuuichi plays with everyone from the get go If it was done in that instant and shown instead of flashbacks than than there wouldn't be any shock factor left which could get boring But I get your reasoning. |
|
Pred8r said: Tyraq said: Well tbh if you've read the manga you should be able to tell that the anime can never have scenes like this. In which chapter is this face made ? and why wouldn't they adapt it ? I saw this in many edit so curious coz also looks pretty cool It's at the end of chapter 63. I meant if the anime were to adapt a scene such as that it most likely wouldn't do it justice but they may not even adapt it at all because from what I've watched the anime has been cutting out multiple dialogues between the characters. |
Tyraq said: Ohh I seePred8r said: In which chapter is this face made ? and why wouldn't they adapt it ? I saw this in many edit so curious coz also looks pretty cool It's at the end of chapter 63. I meant if the anime were to adapt a scene such as that it most likely wouldn't do it justice but they may not even adapt it at all because from what I've watched the anime has been cutting out multiple dialogues between the characters. I'm not even sure if we'll get s2 tho I'm def reading the manga after the anime ends. Also what app or site you used to make that extended favs ? Or Photoshop ? |
|
I just screenshotted my favs from my Anilist account lol. |
| Lol that works too I also have an anilist acc (tho not updated) so might do that. |
|
| People don't hate this series, people just don't like the anime adaptation. The manga is a masterpiece, while this is just ok. |
  SEIBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA |
AishaBi said: caliburn1337 said: a lot of anime onlys hate this series because the MC is edgy and too smart. At the beginning they hated this series because because it was too predictable, later they hated this series because it's too unpredictable and use an excuse as cringe. You can even look at all the comments in this thread. This anime is criminally underrated because of these peoplePeople don't hate this series, people just don't like the anime adaptation. The manga is a masterpiece, while this is just ok. It's edgy because the anime makes Yuuichi feel edgy. All the characters feel pretty superficial on the anime, and when the adaptation is this bad people won't even try checking out the manga, which is a shame. |
| SEIBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA |
AishaBi said: Is there any valid reason to hate this series? I do agree the animation isn't top notch but it isn't that bad either. Anime with mind games tend to have lots of asspull and plotholes yet I haven't seen flaws till now. I'm genuinely asking because I couldn't find any reason to say this show as bad. because the mind games are the only good thing about it. the animation is below average. the directing is boring at best. the music is nothing special. it's edgy, and a lot of times not in a good way. the script is weak at best. thr art is meh. the pacing isn't the best. it doesn't have any truly original ideas. it doesn't use show don't tell and it doesn't even have good design. not for the characters, not for everything else. |
| Also available at: YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCK8spdL1M_J-z0vO2C7jPLw Second Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@AshPolygonsDo/videos Twitter: https://x.com/APolygons2 Backloggd: https://backloggd.com/games/lib/rating?page=8 IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/user/ur107632777/?ref_=uspf_nv_profile |
caliburn1337 said: I personally like the edgy mc but I'll def check the manga out after ep 12 coz I doubt will get a s2 anytime soon.AishaBi said: a lot of anime onlys hate this series because the MC is edgy and too smart. At the beginning they hated this series because because it was too predictable, later they hated this series because it's too unpredictable and use an excuse as cringe. You can even look at all the comments in this thread. This anime is criminally underrated because of these people It's edgy because the anime makes Yuuichi feel edgy. All the characters feel pretty superficial on the anime, and when the adaptation is this bad people won't even try checking out the manga, which is a shame. |
|
Apolygon2 said: That's why most are saying check out the mangaAishaBi said: Is there any valid reason to hate this series? I do agree the animation isn't top notch but it isn't that bad either. Anime with mind games tend to have lots of asspull and plotholes yet I haven't seen flaws till now. I'm genuinely asking because I couldn't find any reason to say this show as bad. because the mind games are the only good thing about it. the animation is below average. the directing is boring at best. the music is nothing special. its edgy, and a lot of times not in a good way. the script is weak at best. thr art is meh. the pacing in't thr best. it doesn't have any truly original ideas. it doesn't use show don't tell and it doesn't even have good design. not for the characters, and not for everything else. It's easily a 9 You don't have to worry about half of the things you mentioned. |
|
Apolygon2 said: AishaBi said: Is there any valid reason to hate this series? I do agree the animation isn't top notch but it isn't that bad either. Anime with mind games tend to have lots of asspull and plotholes yet I haven't seen flaws till now. I'm genuinely asking because I couldn't find any reason to say this show as bad. because the mind games are the only good thing about it. the animation is below average. the directing is boring at best. the music is nothing special. it's edgy, and a lot of times not in a good way. the script is weak at best. thr art is meh. the pacing isn't the best. it doesn't have any truly original ideas. it doesn't use show don't tell and it doesn't even have good design. not for the characters, not for everything else. Yeah, this sums up my thoughts well. Except, even the mind games are average. |
 |
| yes, very valid, here are the notes I wrote down as the episodes aired: Notes: Beginning has an extreme lacking problem, but it definitely is setting itself up to be interesting, first episode sucked big time No build on characters on episode 1, I dont know or care about any of them therefore what's the point of a death game at this point in time? For a show that translates to Friends Game it does a pretty ass job Death Games can't handle exposition, the narration characters theyve added add nothing to the show, if anything it takes away from it because it feels less personal and more an excuse for lazy explanation and writing too difficult for anyone to understand Sloppy writing, edgy teenager bait, pretending to be something it isnt Death Note second half tier plot twists with nothing but shock value to back them up |
 |
| Because I was born before 2004, have seen more than 30 anime and have a mean score less than 8.0 (only half joking) It's neither mentally stimulating nor is it mindlessly entertaining, it's simply predictable, edgy garbage with laughable directing and a stupid cast, aimed at teens green behind the ears. |
More topics from this board
» Give me hope manga readers or anyoneisAvamarie316 - Sep 30 |
21 |
by Konstantinos88
»»
Oct 3, 10:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Tomodachi Game Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Mapachecool999 - Apr 5, 2022 |
326 |
by purpspin
»»
Aug 26, 7:57 AM |
|
Poll: » Tomodachi Game Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )KANLen09 - May 10, 2022 |
259 |
by Ba-Cii10
»»
Jul 30, 12:12 PM |
|
» Since it's been 3 years after episode 12Jeremygrandison - May 21 |
19 |
by mshfqtny
»»
Jul 28, 5:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Tomodachi Game Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )KANLen09 - Jun 21, 2022 |
230 |
by renzospark
»»
Apr 25, 11:38 PM |