Attack on Titan
| Eren needs Sieg to transform himself into the original titan However, this is nonsense. - All the people of Ymir come from only one person -> Ymir, the slave of King Fritz Who are the people of Ymir? The Eldians (those of the walls, and those of the camps). - Ymir's daughters (Rose, Maria, Sina) eat their mother at the request of King Fritz. The king asks them to reproduce. So logically the Eldians are all of royal blood because they are his children. BEFORE YMIR, TITANS DIDN'T EXIST. I have read the entire wiki and in fact -> Only people of Eldian blood can be qualified to own a primordial titan. They are all linked by "the Path", which is confirmed later. Inconsistency around Sieg: - He is the son of a "Fritz" as a "major" argument, but Eren is in contact with the Reiss thanks to Historia. Dianah Fritz (Jager) and Historia Reiss have the same roots. - Another argument that becomes an inconsistency at the end of the manga: the non-aggression pact. Sieg proves to Eren that he can command Ymir and asks him to create false chains, he chains Eren just after. Eren takes possession of the original without Sieg's consent. So why does Eren needs a “royal blood” - in this case that of Sieg - to summon the original Titan? Knowing all that? Thanks |
 |
Ameen_Aftab said: engich said: The rumbling getting stopped with zeke getting killed is the biggest pothole that has been bugging me, but there are no discussion about it because most of the people have wrong assumptions how Coordinate power works and so they don't bother with this issue.Originally people thought that Yimir had "slave mentality" or something so she obeyed eldian royals. But with "Yimir actually loved Fritz" I'm not sure about her motives anymore. Only Yimir knows maybe. Also killing Zeke supposedly stopped the rumbling. But in 138 Eren transforms into CT which kinda requires FT powers I guess (I mean Eren didn't eat Armin to transform into CT so we can only assume that he did it with the FT power)? Why didn't the mangaka talked the story issues over at the end of the publication ? I feel like the '' Ymir world '' totally bugged the story and made it confusing. |
|
engich said: lXlOlXl said: Why didn't the mangaka talked the story issues over at the end of the publication ? I feel like the '' Ymir world '' totally bugged the story and made it confusing. There are a lot of interviews but all of them are about Mikasa and her feelings. The editor said that the whole story is about Mikasa and her choice to save the world or something. Isayama could literally explain Yimir, Eren, paths but I think that he doesn't even know about it himself. Ty for telling me. It's so boring honestly. It's the same old story for a majority of " good " mangas. I always get this feeling. The mangaka creates a universe that excites everyone. Then, further in the story we realize that he no longer knows where he leads the story by making incoherent choices. The lure of profit is too great. It's a big mess. |
|
ezz365 said: When the daughters eat Ymir they get three titans, when their sons eat them they get nine titans. Nine of which only one is the founder, all those who descend from that founding titan are the royal family This theory seems the most logical I've read until now. My only regret comes from the author, who clearly had botched this part in the last chapters. I will not judge the end of SNK because it's his own creation. |
|
lXlOlXl said: Eren needs Sieg to transform himself into the original titan However, this is nonsense. - All the people of Ymir come from only one person -> Ymir, the slave of King Fritz Who are the people of Ymir? The Eldians (those of the walls, and those of the camps). - Ymir's daughters (Rose, Maria, Sina) eat their mother at the request of King Fritz. The king asks them to reproduce. So logically the Eldians are all of royal blood because they are his children. BEFORE YMIR, TITANS DIDN'T EXIST. I have read the entire wiki and in fact -> Only people of Eldian blood can be qualified to own a primordial titan. They are all linked by "the Path", which is confirmed later. Inconsistency around Sieg: - He is the son of a "Fritz" as a "major" argument, but Eren is in contact with the Reiss thanks to Historia. Dianah Fritz (Jager) and Historia Reiss have the same roots. - Another argument that becomes an inconsistency at the end of the manga: the non-aggression pact. Sieg proves to Eren that he can command Ymir and asks him to create false chains, he chains Eren just after. Eren takes possession of the original without Sieg's consent. So why does Eren needs a “royal blood” - in this case that of Sieg - to summon the original Titan? Knowing all that? Thanks Exactly I have had this same question for a while, but we didn't even get the explanations of the major stuff lmaaaooo |
 |
ChibiTalha said: lXlOlXl said: Eren needs Sieg to transform himself into the original titan However, this is nonsense. - All the people of Ymir come from only one person -> Ymir, the slave of King Fritz Who are the people of Ymir? The Eldians (those of the walls, and those of the camps). - Ymir's daughters (Rose, Maria, Sina) eat their mother at the request of King Fritz. The king asks them to reproduce. So logically the Eldians are all of royal blood because they are his children. BEFORE YMIR, TITANS DIDN'T EXIST. I have read the entire wiki and in fact -> Only people of Eldian blood can be qualified to own a primordial titan. They are all linked by "the Path", which is confirmed later. Inconsistency around Sieg: - He is the son of a "Fritz" as a "major" argument, but Eren is in contact with the Reiss thanks to Historia. Dianah Fritz (Jager) and Historia Reiss have the same roots. - Another argument that becomes an inconsistency at the end of the manga: the non-aggression pact. Sieg proves to Eren that he can command Ymir and asks him to create false chains, he chains Eren just after. Eren takes possession of the original without Sieg's consent. So why does Eren needs a “royal blood” - in this case that of Sieg - to summon the original Titan? Knowing all that? Thanks Exactly I have had this same question for a while, but we didn't even get the explanations of the major stuff lmaaaooo I feel less alone when I read that people are realizing the same issue. When I talk about that stuff on forums I frequently use, mates always answer me ' You're the only one to think about it, no one cares ''. it's like I'm driving a car and hitting a wall. I was stopped in my reading on this point. |
|
More topics from this board
» Most underrated AOT part/arc in your opinion?DarkFirefly72 - Oct 7 |
11 |
by Rexaly
»»
Oct 9, 11:00 PM |
|
» 'Even a Child Can Do It': Shonen Jump Editor Calls Out Attack on Titan as Just 'Making a Lot of Noise'deg - Jul 18 |
6 |
by therealnagora
»»
Sep 13, 10:00 AM |
|
» Worst death of the series?Dragevard - May 29, 2021 |
3 |
by Kawaii_Otaku04
»»
Aug 3, 8:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 19 Discussionricardocsc - Oct 2, 2012 |
17 |
by Jeffrey8172
»»
Jul 11, 7:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin Chapter 130 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )keragamming - Jul 6, 2020 |
213 |
by Adam_________
»»
Jun 3, 1:39 PM |