| In my opinion it's a really interesting anime. Animation is really decent. Plot is interesting. MC is pretty cool. How come this has 6.6 rating while Kenja no Mago that's really average gets 7.3. What do people dislike about this show ? |
| Episode 5 most likely, a lot of people were hating that episode. |
| I don't quite understand either. Most of the episodes have been interesting, humorous, or questioned conventional ethics. However, the two MCs ought to be fleshed out more. I still don't know much about Zero at all, and the information we have on Inyou is limited. |
| For me it's just as bad as kenja no mago |
 |
| I think this is a weird brainstorming about what is a good or bad or mediocre anime all across MAL. The crowd likes a Lot of mediocre as I see #1 + #2 khm.... But it's in the air, I mean it's the same with movies or music too. Btw Magmel is a fine (6) anime to me. Just compared to the overrated animes ( and there is a Lot of them) it looks like this is a bad rating, I say it's one of the most accurate, but ther are tons of 7+ animes and most of them are not deserve it. So don't be mad, just go on and enjoy it! Your gain, their loss. |
| Merciful lies or painful truth? |
| I did like early episode, but it started to get worse I personally would not rate it more than 6/10 unless it gets betters |
| Because it's garbage?! |
| What plot are you talking about? |
Momentay said: I think this is a weird brainstorming about what is a good or bad or mediocre anime all across MAL. The crowd likes a Lot of mediocre as I see #1 + #2 khm.... But it's in the air, I mean it's the same with movies or music too. Btw Magmel is a fine (6) anime to me. Just compared to the overrated animes ( and there is a Lot of them) it looks like this is a bad rating, I say it's one of the most accurate, but ther are tons of 7+ animes and most of them are not deserve it. So don't be mad, just go on and enjoy it! Your gain, their loss. Nah I'm not mad. I see your point. For me it's a 7, but 7 is like average score for me. I give most anime 7. Only anime I consider good, great or one of the best get beyond 7 score from me. For example: 8 in my book is good/great , 9 is best. Never gave a 10 because I think I would have to be really mindblown to give such a score. |
| - Its pretty boring, nothing seems to lead anywhere - Side characters are mundane and 2 dimensional - Main characters have hardly any backstory if any (also their not really likeable) - Animation quality is lacklustre for today's standards anyway - The world has so much promise but just doesn't deliver An anime can have awful animation but great story, they can have beautiful art work but frustrating characters and still be seen as relatively good shows because they have some form of a redeemable feature, however this show seems to be lacking in every department. That's just my opinion anyway feel free to disagree. |
Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso is shit |
| I actually enjoyed the first few episodes, but my excitement is starting to go downhill. I hope this anime gets better tho. |
  |
| i was already thinking about put it on drop and low rate without even watching just because i didn't like the synopsis/promo video (and that's a fun way to drop my score a little) i ended up watching and kind of enjoying the first 3 episodes, thinking i could actually finish the anime.......but then that shop thing happened and what was already not so good, turned out to be even worse, so...ya trash anime lol |
winddevil1Jun 4, 2019 8:49 AM
favorite "new girls" from fall <3 (lol i only watched these) ... click sig for older seasons  |
abyss_will said: kenja no mago is way worse. gunjou no magmel at least is quite new, but still illogical and just sillyFor me it's just as bad as kenja no mago |
 |
| 1. Trailer misleading (hyped) 1.a No plot (All of it are Filler) 1.b The characters are meh ( I like the boob girl though) 1.c There is an episode where MCs are assholes 1.d Not appealing enough. MCs are dumb. 1.e Overall, the story is a mess and even if you put it in comedy perspective well its like watching Tom and Jerry |
 |
| I don't get the hate for this anime either, like it definitely wasn't amazing but it was solidly OK. The complaints about it seem rather... hive minded? I can't explain it perfectly but a large degree of the hate doesn't seem derived from original opinions. IDK maybe it is just a consequence of the disparity from the potential displayed in the trailer and the relatively average final product? Either way, if you're someone who hasn't watched this but is considering doing so and you somehow manage to get past all the hate to read this; if the setting seems appealing to you I suspect you'll enjoy this anime enough to make it worth giving a try. |
| Honestly I don't think it's a problem of the content it's more of a loss hope type thing to me. From episodes 1-4 you got a very serious vibe and we'll built starting point for a great anime but after that it changed to more of a comedy. That is where it loses out imo. I mean sure it has character but the theme shifted quite a bit after those first few episodes |
Luroon said: - Its pretty boring, nothing seems to lead anywhere - Side characters are mundane and 2 dimensional - Main characters have hardly any backstory if any (also their not really likeable) - Animation quality is lacklustre for today's standards anyway - The world has so much promise but just doesn't deliver An anime can have awful animation but great story, they can have beautiful art work but frustrating characters and still be seen as relatively good shows because they have some form of a redeemable feature, however this show seems to be lacking in every department. That's just my opinion anyway feel free to disagree. Two episodes in and this exactly what I felt this could become. So far I would rate it a perfect 5/10, just in the middle, not doing this all that bad, but not trying to excede to higher levels in anyway. I have seen series with no plot develoment or every episode is its own story and are very good, but this one lacks depth |
| 35 years old ossan who still watches anime |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Gunjou no Magmell Episode 13 Discussionalexanderthekek - Jun 23, 2019 |
38 |
by yveltalkyogre
»»
Oct 6, 7:01 AM |
|
Poll: » Gunjou no Magmel Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )P_S_Y_C_H_O - May 6, 2019 |
65 |
by MedK001
»»
May 7, 4:56 AM |
|
Poll: » Gunjou no Magmel Episode 3 Discussiondbaranyi - Apr 20, 2019 |
40 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Apr 14, 3:10 PM |
|
Poll: » Gunjou no Magmel Episode 2 Discussiondbaranyi - Apr 13, 2019 |
48 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Apr 14, 2:42 AM |
|
Poll: » Gunjou no Magmel Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Apr 7, 2019 |
111 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
Apr 14, 2:34 AM |