Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Jan 15, 2016 2:43 AM

Offline
Apr 2011
1056
Tsukkimaru said:

Yeah I understand where you're coming from, I guess I just got my hopes up, I'm just sick of the whole 'female MC falls in love with male MC' thing, because it doesn't have to end up like that. Look at Gou in free! she is surrounded by boys yet she doesn't have a crush on any of them, she instead takes her role as their coach/manager very seriously, even brushing off the boys that do have a crush on her, and because of this she is one of my top girl-crushes. Shinoa can still want to protect Yuu without being in love with him, she is the squad leader, it is her duty to make sure her group stays alive, this could have easily been her motivation for protecting Yuu/everyone else, not because she's in love with him. (this would have also made her so much more in my eyes, yaaass girl you show us that you don't need no man)

Oh ofcourse I know we no nothing about Krul, but just because vampires are asexual* doesn't mean they can't fall in love (cue Mika, and just before you say 'Mika was a human though', so were all the other vampires) or have sex. (different types of asexuality) Krul just gave so much more impression, from the very get go you could tell she meant business. It was refreshing every time she came on screen.

Also, Mitsu has a crush on Yuu (though it is subtle) but Kagami has yet to dwell on it, one of the reasons I actually like her, even though tsunderes aren't my type, the fact that Mitsu hasn't linked any of her actions towards Yuu (unless you count helping Mika escape with him - which was technically initiated by Shinoa/Yoichi) is such a nice thing to see, and Mitsu is pretty much a side characters atm, yet we know more about her than Shinoa, who is the female lead. This is why if it had to end with a heterosexual romance (I hope not, god please) I would want Mitsu and Yuu to end up together, their pasts about losing their family/comrades would help them connect due to the similar feelings, they could comfort each other, Yuu maybe even reassuring Mitsu that she wasn't to blame and that he wasn't going to let her friends/family/comrades die again. (I haven't some what shipped a hetero couple in a while, this is weird)


You have to consider that OnS and Free! have different audiences and MC-Main leads focus. Free! targeted the female and fujoshi/fudanshi audience. OnS targets mostly males even though the ratio is 52:48, so both male and female readers enjoy it (marketing of course goes towards the female audience because it's been proved time and time again that females buy more than males regarding merch).
Plus, it's a 'dark, fantasy story' under Shounen so it's vastly different from Free!.
Gou also wasn't the female lead nor any of the mains. The story focused on the boys, their bonds and swimming. I think a good comparison for OnS would be AnE which is also under JUMP SQ and closer to OnS genres.

I didn't mean that Shinoa protects the squad and takes the lead because she likes Yuu. I meant that because of Yuu mostly she has started to change. She herself is capable enough to become a responsible and serious leader, we have seen she is changing in the manga and become more serious. And no she protects the squad because for the first time in her life she feels she has a family. Yuu gave her one, the same as he is trying to do with Mika now. He also did the same for the rest. That's why in the new fanbook they all answer the person they are most interest to are Yuu while Yuu cares about all of them the same. I just believe that a woman with a crush on a man or a woman, doesn't mean she is downgraded of becoming cool or badass. Shinoa doesn't need Yuu's approval or agreement (the whole team talks about their plans and what they should do) and if anything she has told him many times to not rush in the battle as she should because he can put them in danger.

Yes, I am aware of love=/=sex thing. I can't say something about different types of asexuality because myself I don't know the topic well enough to discuss it so I am going with whatever the info has provided it thus far which is that vampires take pleasure, immoral one and both parties feel good/heated up, from drinking blood directly. Now what the sexuality of a human before s/he turns into a vampire was, it could be anything but that sexuality is 'deleted' the moment they become vampires. In folklore there are stories of vampires becoming humans again and one of the first things they do is r*pe because sex was an 'need/instict' they couldn't feel as a vampire.

Actually we know more about Shinoa besides some family things which theories are going around but I won't talk about them here. From Mitsu we only her past in a team which ended bad but we don't know much about her family and especially what's going on with her sister. I don't have a problem if we have a hetero end pairing or not. I don't want it to be rushed and poorly written. I don't ship YuuxMitsuba but I wouldn't mind it as well. All the pairings in OnS, besides Mikayuu, are friendly/platonic to me. (Mikayuu is both platonic and romantic to me).
Jan 15, 2016 3:40 AM
Offline
Dec 2015
17
About OnS demography:

http://www.charapedia.jp/research/0066/
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/35dm7e/japanese_gender_demographics_of_spring_shows/
(8 months ago)

終わりのセラフ Overall - 1834 ______ Men - 414 _____Women - 1420 _____ Men% - 22.57 _____ Women% - 77.43




http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2016/01/08/japanese-anime-fans-name-which-recent-anime-or-hyouka-needs-sequel
http://www.charapedia.jp/research/0101/



I think Shone Jump SQ is a magazine that aims mixed gender public.
Mostly because they have sometimes authors knows as good shojos magakas publish there (Kono Oto wo Tomare!) and ecchi(almost 18+? I think it could be 18+ sometimes...) like "To Love Darkness" at the same time
I don't think they are much supportive with lgbtqia+ ... unfortunately =_=
I just hope the author really care about discrimination issues
O_________oJan 15, 2016 4:09 AM
Jan 15, 2016 5:41 AM

Offline
Apr 2011
1056
O_________o said:
About OnS demography:

http://www.charapedia.jp/research/0066/
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/35dm7e/japanese_gender_demographics_of_spring_shows/
(8 months ago)

終わりのセラフ Overall - 1834 ______ Men - 414 _____Women - 1420 _____ Men% - 22.57 _____ Women% - 77.43




http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-news/2016/01/08/japanese-anime-fans-name-which-recent-anime-or-hyouka-needs-sequel
http://www.charapedia.jp/research/0101/



I think Shone Jump SQ is a magazine that aims mixed gender public.
Mostly because they have sometimes authors knows as good shojos magakas publish there (Kono Oto wo Tomare!) and ecchi(almost 18+? I think it could be 18+ sometimes...) like "To Love Darkness" at the same time
I don't think they are much supportive with lgbtqia+ ... unfortunately =_=
I just hope the author really care about discrimination issues


Thanks for the links. They are helpful :)

I was using this for my reply to Tsukkimaru:
https://anime.dmkt-sp.jp/animestore/survey_sum_pc?surveyId=24&summaryType=1

Jump SQ is mostly fantasy, dark, action stuff. Their demography is mostly around 16+ years old hence some series like "Claymore" and "To Love Darkness" or like OnS, AnE and Gate7.

I am not very familiar with magazines that support lgbtqia regarding manga (besides GL, BL etc.) so I can only say that I am not expecting any MikaxYuu or any other non-hetero pairing from OnS. It's another case if someone is homosexual but relationships....nope.
Jan 15, 2016 11:55 PM
Offline
Dec 2015
17
yuyyuka said:

I am not very familiar with magazines that support lgbtqia regarding manga (besides GL, BL etc.) so I can only say that I am not expecting any MikaxYuu or any other non-hetero pairing from OnS. It's another case if someone is homosexual but relationships....nope.


Yeah, I know.
But I'm hoping that the author at least care for lgbt(+) issues. (as we can't hope for the magazine)
I'm also expecting that it ends with no canon hetero pairing for Yuu and Mika. (it would be too much of queer baiting if it does, considering chapter 36,37 and episode 22)

( https://twitter.com/kagamitakaya/status/675661498320994311 << about episode 22, Kagami made sure that it was like he wanted, it seems)

It would still be some fitting end considering the magazine, and it's not uncommon for stories in manga to end with no fixed romantic couple. (and if he really care a bit for the international fans in general, I hope he don't put a heteronormative end)
At most, I'm hoping for an implied end, like Samurai Flamenco or Tales of Zestiria.
O_________oJan 16, 2016 5:37 AM
Jan 16, 2016 10:49 AM

Offline
Apr 2011
1056
O_________o said:

Yeah, I know.
But I'm hoping that the author at least care for lgbt(+) issues. (as we can't hope for the magazine)
I'm also expecting that it ends with no canon hetero pairing for Yuu and Mika. (it would be too much of queer baiting if it does, considering chapter 36,37 and episode 22)

( https://twitter.com/kagamitakaya/status/675661498320994311 << about episode 22, Kagami made sure that it was like he wanted, it seems)

It would still be some fitting end considering the magazine, and it's not uncommon for stories in manga to end with no fixed romantic couple. (and if he really care a bit for the international fans in general, I hope he don't put a heteronormative end)
At most, I'm hoping for an implied end, like Samurai Flamenco or Tales of Zestiria.


I can see no pairing for Mika but for Yuu...I can see him ending with someone. Is just that, with both Shinoa and Mitsuba having a crush on him the chances are 50-50, for me at least. But we will see. My ending would be something as you said with Zestiria (I would agree with SF as well but I read that the creator literally said 'no homo' and some other stuff that were not pretty good...)

Actually that tweet doesn't say that. It only says that he had to re-make many of the scenes in the manga time and time again and he can't wait to see how it will be adapted in the anime.
Jan 16, 2016 11:17 AM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
@ O_____________o

Lol I ship Yuunoa like Fedex and badly want them to get together, so if the anime changed her to look as though she has a bigger crush on Yuu, no complaints from me. XD Just the opposite, really.



Jan 17, 2016 12:25 AM
Offline
Dec 2015
17
yuyyuka said:

I can see no pairing for Mika but for Yuu...I can see him ending with someone. Is just that, with both Shinoa and Mitsuba having a crush on him the chances are 50-50, for me at least. But we will see. My ending would be something as you said with Zestiria (I would agree with SF as well but I read that the creator literally said 'no homo' and some other stuff that were not pretty good...)

Actually that tweet doesn't say that. It only says that he had to re-make many of the scenes in the manga time and time again and he can't wait to see how it will be adapted in the anime.


With the current development of Yuu feelings/relationship for either Shinoa or Mitsuba as an heteronormative end and how developed his feelings with Mika are, I think the odds of him having an heteronormative end is lower than what you say.
50-50 is too high for this point of story.

And honestly I will drop OnS if I feel like he will really do queer baiting. (And I saw also many say the same)

That being hetero have to be the standard message hurts a lot. OnS gave enough feels that if it take a heteronormative path, it will be to erase all the implications and possibilities of a non-het(m/m in this case) ship for MC. Plus, there is some implications that Yuu isn't hetero that I don't want to see erased


About SF, I had to google a bit to find those:
http://yuudachi.tumblr.com/post/95834159400/what-interview-is-that-accidental-character
オトナアニメvol.34より http://ikura.2ch.sc/test/read.cgi/anime2/1397088317/422

At least he didn't step more by putting a heteronormative end to make the feelings worse. But it's with no doubt, queer baiting just by the fact that he deny it.... (I gotta stop talking about SF and indicating it)(Thanks for telling me about this)

About the tweet from Kagami,
yeah, in the 3rd sentence: "アニメではどうなるか楽しみ" << I might have got this wrong, reading it again, since in the first read, I understood he was making reference to a who was reading the tweet, not 1st person. I wish I understood japanese better to be sure... What put me in doubts is that it would imply he didn't watch the anime previously.
The way I understood it was: "Let's enjoy/look_forward how the anime will turn out"
but could be really as you pointed out: "I'm looking forward to how the anime will turn out"


Just to be sure if I read right the 1st and 2nd sentence too: "はじまった!" "ここ、原作も何度も書き直したとこ" << could it be translated as: "It started!" "Here, I had to rewrite from the original work in many scenes"
?

"It started" is referring to the start of the anime on TV, since one of his previous tweets to this one in the same day was: https://twitter.com/kagamitakaya/status/675653150653607937

"Here" making reference to the episode 22 (this tweet being very specific about it being done for episode 22, I don't remember he saying to do the same for any other episode)





Chiibi said:
@ O_____________o

Lol I ship Yuunoa like Fedex and badly want them to get together, so if the anime changed her to look as though she has a bigger crush on Yuu, no complaints from me. XD Just the opposite, really.


Well, not everyone will feel like it make her pitiable. -shrugs- (the things that I pointed previously)
If those changes were made with Mitsuba, it would makes more sense and not change her character that much, since those excuses works better with her personality. But I still wouldn't be happy to see it for other reasons(forced heteronormativity). In Shinoa's case, I really like her, and I think she deserves better representation, plus I don't enjoy watching her being used to reaffirm some heterornormative agenda with all queer coding.
O_________oJan 20, 2016 4:07 AM
Jan 20, 2016 4:08 AM
Offline
Dec 2015
17
Oh yeah, just remembered another indicative on manga and anime that Yuu have a crush on Mika.
He himself have the headcanon (when trying to power up with Asumaru) of intertwining fingers with Mika.
He could have thought in a hug or just hand shake/grab. But no, it was surely intertwining fingers what came to his mind when it' was about connecting with Mika.
Feb 23, 2016 9:22 PM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
O_________o said:
Oh yeah, just remembered another indicative on manga and anime that Yuu have a crush on Mika.
He himself have the headcanon (when trying to power up with Asumaru) of intertwining fingers with Mika.
He could have thought in a hug or just hand shake/grab. But no, it was surely intertwining fingers what came to his mind when it' was about connecting with Mika.


So what?
You see fingers intertwined between girls in shoujo manga a lot too. Sailor Moon, for example. But it doesn't mean they're lesbians. lol



Feb 28, 2016 2:02 PM

Offline
Oct 2015
325
Chiibi said:
So what?
You see fingers intertwined between girls in shoujo manga a lot too. Sailor Moon, for example. But it doesn't mean they're lesbians. lol


Sailor Moon had a canon lesbian couple though, lmao (Neptune and Uranus)
Mar 1, 2016 5:05 PM

Offline
Nov 2008
10508
Tsukkimaru said:
Chiibi said:
So what?
You see fingers intertwined between girls in shoujo manga a lot too. Sailor Moon, for example. But it doesn't mean they're lesbians. lol


Sailor Moon had a canon lesbian couple though, lmao (Neptune and Uranus)


Yes, I know and they are very awesome....but Naoko draws like every girl holding hands with every girl....cause they are friends. XD

It's pretty obvious Haruka and Michiru are WAY more than friends. XD They don't just hold hands; they're always all over each other, live together, and say the same things all lovers say to each other. In fact some of their comments to each other even mention "bedroom talk". It's pretty funny how they talk to each other even in public. They don't give a shit. XD



Mar 2, 2016 7:46 AM

Offline
Oct 2015
325
Chiibi said:
Yes, I know and they are very awesome....but Naoko draws like every girl holding hands with every girl....cause they are friends. XD

It's pretty obvious Haruka and Michiru are WAY more than friends. XD They don't just hold hands; they're always all over each other, live together, and say the same things all lovers say to each other. In fact some of their comments to each other even mention "bedroom talk". It's pretty funny how they talk to each other even in public. They don't give a shit. XD


Yes it is very awesome, although I don't really enjoy Sailor Moon as whole, it is very nice for them to have a lesbian couple in a shoujo. It's a shame gay men are treated somewhat differently than gay women.


(Have you seen the new OnS official art?! It's so precious and adorable)
Mar 2, 2016 9:57 AM
Offline
Feb 2016
4
Tsukkimaru said:

(Have you seen the new OnS official art?! It's so precious and adorable)



Are you talking about this official art, which came out yesterday?

Well then, no gay undertones over here. I don't see why anyone would think Yuu and Mika could become a romantic couple. Judging by this official art, they're just bros doing what heterosexual bros do.

(For the record I'm being sarcastic here. I know sarcasm is hard to pull off on the Internet.)
Me_HiMar 2, 2016 2:20 PM
Mar 2, 2016 1:55 PM

Offline
Oct 2015
325
Me_Hi said:
Are you talking about this official art, which came out yesterday?


*SQUAWKS UNCONTROLLABLY* YESYEYSYES YESYEYSYES TOTAL BROS RIGHT THERE, BEST BROS FOR LYFE HAHAHAHAHA JUST SOME HeTeRO BrOS DoiNg HeTEro ThINgS.





(No for real, this image just reeks of gay and it's amazing)
Sep 11, 2016 12:50 PM

Offline
Aug 2016
15
Nope to the nope.
I personally ship them with Mika and Mitsuba, respectively, and I genuinely cannot see them together as a romantic couple. It's just so wrong.
Nov 25, 2017 5:30 PM

Offline
Nov 2017
1242
I think Mikayuu is probably Better then Yuunoa the only reason people are denying the MikaXyuu ship is because there both boys or because there Yuunoa shippers (I get it though some people don't feel comfortable with BL) Btw there not really family so it's not incest I'd say that there relationship is like bestie related (They both will do anything for each other even destroy the world if it we're to bring yuu or mika back)

Also, Yuu always seems to be interested in what mikas doing (*Manga*) and it's obvious that most of the fans watching the series ship mikayuu maybe the writers and producers etc. Will make it a thing. Quite obvious that Yuu has sumthin for mika and mika has sumthin for yuu can't deny the chemistry.

What may interest some of you is that Mikas seraph is Michael (*Archangel*) and Yuus seraph is Lucifer (*Satan*) the fallen angel, Maybe the romance between them will sprout into something that perhaps benefits them both? And plus I love that LuciferxArchangel cliche.

My bad I'm way off topic main concern is the yuunoa ship... To break it down nice and easy Yuu isn't ready for a relationship as stated in the manga and he shows no Feelings whatsoever for Shinoa. He probably only Cares about her in a professional way like How he cares about guren. Shinoa is well another story she cares for yuu because yuu showed her sumthing that she never experienced (To be depended on) {sumthin like that}.

I ship Mika and crowley Hope one day they can make some Vampire babys (Jp)
-fujo-Nov 25, 2017 5:34 PM
Jan 12, 2019 2:49 PM

Offline
Jan 2019
9
I don't hate MikaxYuu, but I just don't really see it. I've always seen them as close brothers, and I don't see a lot of romance. I think there's more hints in the anime than in the manga imo. The story is going in the YuuxShinoa route right now anyway.

I do understand Shinoa's feelings for Yuu, moreso in the manga, even if it seemed sudden at first. I'm pretty curious about how Yuu's feelings toward her would be, though. As of now he's not shown too many romantic feelings towards her,
and there's a chance it could be forced. I think YuuxShinoa has potential to be good but it depends on how it's handled.
Jan 3, 2022 8:36 PM
Offline
Feb 2021
532
That Yaoi side of this manga disgust me. I hope he will end up with Shinoa, and this is neither BL or Yaoi and since published in Shonen Jump MikaYu will never happen.
Feb 11, 2022 9:13 AM

Offline
Mar 2010
19
Abysmal_Saint76 said:
That Yaoi side of this manga disgust me. I hope he will end up with Shinoa, and this is neither BL or Yaoi and since published in Shonen Jump MikaYu will never happen.


Yeah! How dare they have one gay relationship in my overly manly manga!
That's why I don't like Naruto. Just full of people being in love, it's not action anymore it's romance!
Feb 15, 2022 11:29 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
3
Abysmal_Saint76 said:
That Yaoi side of this manga disgust me. I hope he will end up with Shinoa, and this is neither BL or Yaoi and since published in Shonen Jump MikaYu will never happen.


excuse me but, the fact that OnS isn't bl doesn't mean it can't have mlm relationships, like why wouldn't it?? if Kagami wants a gay relationship, it will happen and that's it. Canonically, both Mika and Shinoa love Yu, but the difference is what they are capable to do because of it, (spoilers) Mika died twice for Yu, and always tried to protect him, he also did everything just for him, while at the other hand, Shinoa didn't even bothered to give a little of emotional support to Yu when Mika died, and at this point she just seems selfish, in recent chapters Yu only seems to care deeply about Mika, so I'm sorry but if there's a ship to happen, it might be the one between Mika and Yu, or there would be no canon ship at all, YuNoa feels pretty forced, and if you really are bothered by that, maybe OnS isn't for you at all.
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

Poll: » Owari no Seraph Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Jun 6, 2015

373 by Sharpedon »»
Nov 14, 9:28 AM

Poll: » Owari no Seraph Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Stark700 - May 23, 2015

229 by Sharpedon »»
Nov 14, 2:38 AM

Poll: » Owari no Seraph Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Apr 25, 2015

261 by Sharpedon »»
Nov 13, 7:34 AM

Poll: » Owari no Seraph Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Jun 20, 2015

403 by Mewtho »»
Oct 7, 1:45 AM

Poll: » Owari no Seraph Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stark700 - Apr 4, 2015

600 by Mestre_Saturno »»
Sep 28, 9:22 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login