do anyone think that bellamy will join luffy crew?

Shaduge said:
Great idea.

kingdude267 said:
i think he might..idk y tho lol i just think he will

Lolack said:
Can I murder you?

Satan-sama said:
it's not the only one who doesn't fit to join e crew but oda can do whatever he want

doordoor123 said:

Whoever becomes the next member has to have a big backstory and a big goal. Not really sure what Jinbei's is though. Maybe keeping his promise to Ace?
I don't think Bellamy has enough. If we start seeing a backstory on one specific person, we'll know who it is.

Shanks_Hashirama said:
How about Doflamingo join the crew?

HalibelTheEspada said:
No, Bellamy won't join the crew because: for one his ability is too much like Luffy's so there's not really any room for him to have a unique fighting style. Two, he is apparently too weak... though who knows exactly how strong Elizabello's punch was, though I'm sure most (if not all) of the Straw Hats could have taken it fine. Not to mention, while he's not the same as he was before, I think he's still a pretty bad person compared to the other Straw Hats... he's just matured some since Luffy knocked some sense into him. And as was already mentioned, he really just has no role in the crew. There's too many better candidates in this arc for Bellamy to really stand a chance.


I do agree that the next member will have a deep past and will certainly stand out. I know that it generally plays out that way, but I don't think it's quite so predictable... because every single major arc has a big flashback somewhere, and rarely does someone actually join, even if it seems like they will... it could also be like Nami or Robin, whose past wasn't revealed until a few arcs after they joined the crew. And, while I do sort of like Rebecca and she seems to have some story behind her... I can't help but think it's kinda pathetic if she was being "bullied" by Spartan, who got raped by Luffy. There'd have to be something seriously deep going on for me to accept her in the crew. Though even less is known about them,

If anyone's to join the crew this arc I hope it's either Bartolomeo or Cavendish... just because I think they're awesome. Of course until more is revealed about them, I can't be certain if they're Straw Hat material, not to mention they both have a grudge against him, apparently. Of course other wishful possibilities, in order of probability (completely imo) are: Momonosuke, a dwarf/gnome (preferably Wicca), Kanjuro, Baby 5 (hey, she's awesome), Kin'emon, "Thunderous Soldier of Rage" (le toy soldier), Aokiji, and Perona (never forget!)

kiDnameDSkia said:


lol that's quite a bit of candidates...For me the only legit ones are Cavendish and Barto, although I think they're gonna be more like allied pirate crews to the straw hats, if any...you can't just tag the captain of some existing crew out and put him in the SHs ^^
the broken toy soldier could be a nice addition, depending on how he looks like after he turns into a human again. Aokiji's role is more of a advisor type, like Rayleigh, in my opinion. The rest are just characters that come and go with the arcs

HalibelTheEspada said:
Yeah, I know lol. I agree, those two seem to be the most qualifying at the moment. My honest wish would be a dwarf more than anyone else, but everyone expected a fishman, and that didn't happen so who knows. I agree with pretty much everything you said, but I will say that if you think about it, the only member to really join on their own accord was Robin... and even then only because Luffy forced her to live (twice), so it's not impossible. But you're probably right. Just can't help but like all these cool characters. >>

Also, I don't think the next member will be weaker than Usopp (like Rebecca), or cuter than Chopper (Momonosuke?). If they get someone else, they need to be really unique compared to the other members. If they get someone physically strong... I think it should be a female. They already have 2 swordsman, so I don't think they'll get another one any time soon. Cavendish also reminds me too much of Sanji, at least in looks and being a sort of lady's man. Bartolomeo is really unique, and it would be nice to have someone to shield the ship. But I feel like it would be too cheap of an ability, and if enemies ever get strong enough to break his shields I can't really see him improving them very much.

Just so I'm not going off topic... Bellamy is nowhere near unique, and he is definitely weaker than Usopp, so yeah, I don't think he's got a chance.

jimbob1141 said:


I dunno, 3 swordsman seems like a common thing to me :P like 3 musketeers? :D

Of all the people we have seen so far, the one i'd like to see join the most is probably kin and momo. He's a swordsman, he's below zoro, has a unique way of using his sword and his personality blends well, momo is just too funny and has a cool fruit. They fit in really well. But who knows, they may just be like vivi.

HalibelTheEspada said:


Lol, I didn't think of the 3 musketeers thing. I GUESS that would be somewhat cool... Though, the Straw Hat crew kinda already has that "all for one, one for all" motto...also in the 3 musketeers there's technically always 4, counting D'Artagnan.

Also, we really haven't seen Kinemon do anything except the one time he cut fire. I'd be more interested to see Zoro simply learn that technique from him... though I just realized there could end up being a need down the road to cut fire *cough* Mera Mera no Mi. But really the only "unique" thing I see in him is his Devil Fruit... which is interesting... it could at least give Oda the chance to show off all kinds of outfits he has in mind at any given time, and would be good for disguises (like this arc). But overall as bred samurai... I feel like even if Kin'emon / Momonosuke are unique within the crew... they would fight just like anyone from the Wano country, which that in itself would make their fighting styles kind of generic. Of course, I could be wrong about that.

xHikaru13x said:
Join? No
Alliance? Maybe yes

Soudadorable said:
Oh god no, please no.



No.

Shaduge said:

Die? Definitely

jal90 said:
I'm surprised at the amount of negativity for Bellamy. And specially while people hold Cavendish (seriously?), Bartolomeo (he much likely has his crew and own objectives) and Rebecca (who isn't even related to piracy from what we know so far) as serious options. Not that they are completely impossible choices but they are certainly not more fitting than Bellamy.

Yes, he was an ass in Jaya. And he was weak. Two years ago. What do we know about his power now? He apparently gets beaten by a punch that can destroy a mountain, while the only survivor is a guy with a barrier ability. I love how people are assuming that he's weaker than all of the Straw Hats because of that.

I don't think that a 195.000.000 berries reward comes from nowhere, so the strength aspect is much likely covered, and we have seen him develop a very different relationship with Luffy in this arc, so his past in the series is probably irrelevant at this point. And now with the plot device about Doflamingo's orders they are going to develop something more about him and Luffy. So yes, there is a chance.

At this point the only thing I don't like about his potential nakamization is his fruit/ability, which looks quite boring to watch in action. But I think it's reasonably likely. I would prefer some dwarf to join in (Wicca?) for the sake of curiosity/weird fighting style, but wouldn't be all offended if Oda took this pathway. This would, to a point, cover a role in the story; transforming a previous villain into a crew member would be an interesting twist to show how the characters change their mindset and relationships as they advance in their objectives.


Death... in One Piece?

kiDnameDSkia said:
^