Separate rating lists by genre for more fair comparisons

Yeah, I'm pretty sure this thread is gonna get nuked again, because comparing and ranting about the scoring system in general, is against forum rules.

I'll repeat what I said before in your last thread, you're not looking at it right. The score is simply based on how much the audience enjoyed a specific show, on average. It is not supposed to be a metric of comparison, like a poll/competition between shows that have nothing in common.

What you're thinking of is actually practiced in Award ceremonies because there is actual comparison and ranking there, that's why they make categories to keep things fair.

My advice would be to enjoy the shows you like, and to get your gratification from the experience you have watching them; not looking at the show's statistics and feeling bummed because a romance anime got a higher number.

Sounds like way too much work imo. Just leave things as is.

you can already do that by filtering shows by tag like romance and by rating tho. there's the global ranking with every anime and then you can check for each tag. which makes the most sense imo.

Anyone who just slightly suggests that SnK is on the same level or even close to shows like Monster, is a troll.
And yes, KaoHana is objectively better than SnK. This is not even a question.


That system is called me, you can ask me and I'll tell you that.

here is a simple solution: accept others opinions.

you should know MAL scores are based on general public opinion, not professional opinion. you are in the wrong place if thought MAL scores are metric for content quality. if you object the scores, then make a suggestion for MAL to have separate professional scores like Rotten Tomatoes or something rather than belittle other genre you are not into and even tried to separate them like a second class content, geez.

Ratings aren't meant to show an objective quality (such a thing does not exist in the first place) they are meant to show the aggregate opinion of the people who watched it.

I get your point but at the end of the day people dont score things solely based on how good they are, but also based on enjoyment and other things, and even though i agree aot is one of if not the best created animes, there are other animes i enjoyed watching more than aot, so my point is that its subjective and theres no need for a different way to rate different generes, though i also agree that this specific romance anime doesnt deserve such a high score

doing that would just make more violent discussions, you dont specifically need a ranking for them as their all subjective and is based on the viewers preferences. And theyre gonna have to move all those different animes into a new list which is a pain in the ass if you know how to code a website, just enjoy and watch them and stop making unemployed discussions

Entries need to have a minimum number of scores from users to have their score calculated; otherwise, it will be N/A.

Anyone who just slightly suggests that SnK is on the same level or even close to shows like Monster, is a troll.
And yes, KaoHana is objectively better than SnK. This is not even a question.


That system is called me, you can ask me and I'll tell you that.

@The_Spectre_01 Come on man. Put your back into it, grit your teeth and do it. it's only one time work, but it would make the experience better forever, don't be lazy

this is such a non issue, youre definitely unemployed. You got way too much free time that you spend it on this stupid shit, its basic math. And thatll never happen anyway and if it did any human with a working brain could also figure out its credibility

@Mathi786 I'm just a normal MAL user tho

also thats like trading with fake money a trading app gives you and then flaunting that youre rich, no one will believe you. And if youre talking about the majority of the reviews its all subjective. If you really want to make those segregated lists so bad just make a tierlist or trello yourself, and advertise the hell out of it so you can get a userbase. This website or app is a forum and isnt supposed to have massive changes, its sole purpose is for anime manga webtoon manhua shit or events regarding those. Have you ever seen reddit change anything major in the past 5 years?

mal doesnt even put low rating animes on the top anime lists so whatre you talking about, and for the second time its the users responsibility to check credibility. So dude just get your ass to sleep so you can have a clear mind, its obvious youre knocked the hell out and just blurting bonjobums out

It really isn't when you understand what those scores are meant to represent, which has already been told to you. Regardless of who you are and what the show is, you can have an opinion on it and reflect that opinion with a score. When there is a large enough sample of those occurrences, a score is calculated and reflects an aggregate opinion, thus doing its job.

The calculations don't need to be linked to your enjoyment. I'd argue it has no correlation to your enjoyment whatsoever, from an objective pov.
Going to a poll based space on the internet to echo your sentiments for validation seems like a pointless endeavor to me.
If you like something and you know it's good, you don't need a list and popularity ranking to tell you it's good. Have some confidence in your taste and opinion. Nobody uses these ratings as an objective basis of comparison.

The genre wise rating filter already exists. Click on the genre under any anime you like, and sort the list by score. That's how you can filter out the romance titles, it seems reasonable to me. Those shows won't even appear alongside your 'greats'.

its not about being lazy, you also have to pay developers to rewire the code for the lists. and its not pocket change, its not like dev teams do any work for free i doubt you even donate to this website, they already have a working database. And as ive said before its a forum app, changes are either not gonna happen or happens rarely. Just go to bed my guy youre not saving the world by fixing supposedly laziness of the devs

okay, I might got the wrong idea. so, are you trying to say MAL should also have rank numbers based on each genre represented by the content? like said if you click hold rank number in the content page it will pop up rank position from each genre rather than currently only global rank? if so then yeah, it will be a great feature.
because I still don't get it in what context you want to separate the genre so it will be fair by your view.

not only are you ignorant youre also gullible, just because people agree with you doesnt mean youre right🥀

People are seriously butthurt because some other anime has score higher than their favourite one as if those scores were relevant. Remember Okaenix crashouts?
Yeah, no. It's an idiotic proposal and you should probably just accept that some people may have different opinions and think think that Kaoru Hana does it's job and represents it's genre better than AOT or Monster does theirs.

It is inefficient to you, because your feelings get hurt seeing your 'greats' beneath a romcom.
I'm saying thats the wrong mindset.

The confidence bit has nothing to do with making noise here. Your intent behind this demand of yours just looks like you seek validation, and want the internet to echo your opinions.