the hentai director is gonna be the scapegoat of the production committee

So you want us to blame the higher ups for appointing them as the director?
How is it different from blaming them?

Blaming the director
"Hentai director ruined One punch man"

Blaming the higher ups
"producers ruined One punch man by appointing a Hentai director"


My point is, ultimately blame anyone, the bullet hits the staff who worked on it. You are just hitting the same person indirectly.

Why is people assuming he's gonna make a bad work? There are a bunch of good actors who started in p*rn industry.

My point is: being a romance/hentai director doesn't make you a bad one. And even them need to evolve and have good opportunities doing another stuff.

Even more, they wouldn't leave OPM to a bad director. That could be catastrophic.

>it’s not even out yet
>are you a psychic?
>jesus fuck you whiny people are annoying

Just wait and see, stop acting like you have foresight to the future, then when it’s out, you can shit on it all you want, this is just miserable people being miserable. Cry harder.

So you want us to blame the higher ups for appointing them as the director?
How is it different from blaming them?

Blaming the director
"Hentai director ruined One punch man"

Blaming the higher ups
"producers ruined One punch man by appointing a Hentai director"


My point is, ultimately blame anyone, the bullet hits the staff who worked on it. You are just hitting the same person indirectly.

People watching Ore dake Level Up na Ken which had atrocious animations have already disproved your point.

Go and import the Japanese Blu-rays of the first season to send a message that could have a chance of sticking.

@V1P3R0P I know he’s done a lot of hentai work, but have you checked out his other past projects? Shinpei Nagai was an episode director for Psycho-Pass, Food Wars, and Gangsta. He also has a ton of experience with storyboarding, which is really important when directing anime. Sure, he’s only directed one show (I Can’t Understand What My Husband Is Saying), and while it wasn’t amazing, I thought it was pretty solid so I’m willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.

I mean, what were we expecting? we get a Shingo Natsume or Tetsurou Araki-level director for One Punch Man? It’s not like we’re getting Mob Psycho treatment here. Honestly, the producers don’t seem like they give s**t anyway. But at least, in my opinion, we got a better director than Chikara Sakurai (One Punch Man Season 2). And even if the animation doesn’t look as great as Season 1, we still have the amazing sound design from Yoshikazu Iwanami and a new banger opening by JAM Project.

I mean, we should just be happy One Punch Man is even getting a Season 3 after what happened with Season 2. Well, I just wish J.C. Staff luck with the upcoming project. It’ll either be a disaster or at least somewhat decent.

????

With anime to his name like ...

Sword Art Online: Alicization - War of Underworld (2019-2020)
Sword Art Online: Alicization (2018)
Blood Lad (2013)
Hunter × Hunter (2011)

... what are you talking about? He's responsible for the worst SAO anime, something forgettable from over a decade ago and the shitty HxH remake.

@Haigen the hentai director said he is training and learning 3dcg and hybrid animation so you can expect mid quality level at best considering many anime fans hates any 3dcg

@deg Do have any source that support this?

I love watching people not from Japan cry about stuff made for Japanese people.

No the majority of it is still made for Japanese people and they ship it out to the west to make money. They don’t care about you or your feelings or what you want. The only ones that do are the studios owned by western companies like Netflix.

People should blame J.C. Staff

Starving for attention again, huh?

I wonder how was deg's childhood like for him to be turned out like this.

And blaming them will change what?
Japanese people still loved the 2nd season for what it was, regardless of whatever quality we got.

And to whoever calling Season 2 bad. Sure it doesnt stand up to Season 1 qualtiy, but it was still decent. Could've been better, but not downright "Bad"

Western People blamed producers for season 2 quality. They blamed producers for hiring a no name director. What really changed? And what are you expecting would change now?

And how are you so sure this season will be bad when we dont even have a proper trailer
And the episodes are yet to release?

Also JC staff ace animator Kenichiro Aoki who carried season 2 on their back, is also involved in the production (Shinpei Nagai followed them yesterday after name reveal). So there will be good action moments.

I'm just being rational here rather than being overly pessimistic or optimistic.

Shinpei Nagai was the key animator for Dead mount Death play episode 1.
in the first half, there was a really good fight scene which had a 3dcg skeleton monster. It was really good.

Also, 3DCG in season 2 was also really good. The centipede and millipede fight scenes especially.

3DCG has become a standard in the industry.. So I'm not sure why anyone will complain about it??

the people complaining about it are minorities who are adamant about changes and use of newer technologies. Like I said, every project - even the major ones - use 3DCG!!

Then how are shows like Gundam still popular?

yep!! You still see new entries in the franchise. If that is not because of popularity, then why?

And when did MAL popularity become the standard for a show's popularity??

Ok, maybe Gundam is a bad example for what you are referring to.
Lets take shows like Demon slayer. You cant say western people in majority complain about its CG use??

Look buddy. Long story short. There will always be people with Tantrums. Like you already experienced in this discussion where someone talked shit about HxH, Sword art Alicization or Solo levelling animator Kanno. You cant impress everyone. So why do you care so much if the 3dcg will repel people or not. I'm sure if you go to season 1 forums, you'll find someone or the other complaining how it was bad for some shitty reason.

the sakuga is complimented by CG vfx. the layouts in that show is mostly 3dcg. Many demon models in there is also 3dcg

But in season 2 of One punch man, CG was used only on monster design and layouts. Characters were all 2D. less Sakuga moments? Sure. But back then the entire project was a mess due to time problem.

I never said that. But you are basically thinking in a "Guilty until proven innocent" mindset. Attack on titan season 4 kept improving with its CG models were only bad in part 1. Part 2 and 3 had good CG.

Also funny how you kept telling this director is a scapegoat, but you keep blaming him for something we dont even know about yet. Sounds like you are just paranoid and nothing else

you are being too paranoid to call your expectations realistic. Your tone changed from "Dont blame the director" to downright blaming the director at the end. I've read his comments multiple times already. but anyways, thank you for the debate!! It was surely insightful

then why are you still calling them "Hentai director" as if its a bad thing. You can refer them as a newbie director or a no name director.
Already many here mentioned, its too soon to talk about the quality before its release. But you dont seem to be agreeing with their thoughts. You kept insisting people to check their past works as a means of creating a negative image on them. If you really thought they're just a scapegoat for the producers, you wouldnt proceed to create a negative impression on them. You'd have just stuck to your first statement that they're a scapegoat.

Then you started explaining me how them using 3dcg to speed up the production is something negative. While I kept telling CG may be used on monster models, you insisted that you are sure character models will also be CG and it will be bad!! Because, of the director.

The director told they're good with hybrid animation, but you are taking it in a negative perspective. Forget the other people here. You are sharing your opinion where you said you are OK with it, but yet you kept picturing it as something bad.

So am I a fanboy or are you just not a man of your words?