anime/novel same ending ?

May 14, 2018 8:26 AM

Offline

Feb 2018

4

bracktiscing said:
i think there is something missed in the anime ending :/

The anime had an open ending which made viewer speculate the ending, while the novel had more definite and fixed ending. Kyoani fixed the bad way of ending the novel in the anime.

May 14, 2018 11:20 PM

#3

IshiAlice

Offline

Apr 2013

120

The anime and the nivel are a little bit different, the order of the events in both really differ, so indeed the endings are different but I don't think you miss a lot. Just one fact of the story change in the anime that made it to take a different route of the story, kind of.

Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.

May 14, 2018 11:30 PM

#4

sunako199

Offline

Apr 2017

878

well lets wait for the 14th episode so we can tell

still life: pink roses

Aug 13, 2018 6:03 PM

#5

Kirito_Alsufi

Offline

Mar 2016

221

Pan_Panda said:

bracktiscing said:
i think there is something missed in the anime ending :/

The anime had an open ending which made viewer speculate the ending, while the novel had more definite and fixed ending. Kyoani fixed the bad way of ending the novel in the anime.

How do they fix the ending if some people still confused and they still have questions like Gilbert status and his relationship with Violet wasn't clear if it's in romantic way or not because Kyoani didn't explain that and let the fans fight with each other if it's a romantic or as daughter and father or as a good person and if they ended up together or not ... I guess you should think twice about saying the ending was fixed while the fans still fighting for being confused about it

Oct 23, 2021 11:52 PM

#6

brenobluhm

Offline

Feb 2021

539

Kirito_Alsufi said:

Pan_Panda said:

The anime had an open ending which made viewer speculate the ending, while the novel had more definite and fixed ending. Kyoani fixed the bad way of ending the novel in the anime.

How do they fix the ending if some people still confused and they still have questions like Gilbert status and his relationship with Violet wasn't clear if it's in romantic way or not because Kyoani didn't explain that and let the fans fight with each other if it's a romantic or as daughter and father or as a good person and if they ended up together or not ... I guess you should think twice about saying the ending was fixed while the fans still fighting for being confused about it

Well, it became pretty clear with the film they are in a loving relationship.

Nov 10, 2021 3:05 AM

#7

SapooBijook

Offline

Apr 2020

1

Kirito_Alsufi said:

Pan_Panda said:

The anime had an open ending which made viewer speculate the ending, while the novel had more definite and fixed ending. Kyoani fixed the bad way of ending the novel in the anime.

How do they fix the ending if some people still confused and they still have questions like Gilbert status and his relationship with Violet wasn't clear if it's in romantic way or not because Kyoani didn't explain that and let the fans fight with each other if it's a romantic or as daughter and father or as a good person and if they ended up together or not ... I guess you should think twice about saying the ending was fixed while the fans still fighting for being confused about it

Personaly I think open ending was the better option. They made it free for their fans to interpret Violet and Gilbert's relationship. There are those who think that romantic relationship was a better option, those who think that father-daughter relationship fits better especially because of the age gap, some even call out Gilbert a p*do for confessing his love to 14 y.o. Violet back in the war. Perhaps, putting it simply, making it an open ending was a safer choice to prevent further controversies. But for me, personally, the fact that they live together (or at least that was what the after credits implied), that's good enough

» About the end of this Chapter (7) pingasusualisee - Sep 26, 2021	0	by pingasusualisee »» Sep 26, 2021 1:39 PM
Poll: » Violet Evergarden Volume 1 Discussion Zaphkiel_El_Rem - Jun 18, 2017	13	by EpIcChEeSeMaN »» Aug 27, 2021 4:53 PM
Poll: » Violet Evergarden Volume 2 Discussion Reverberate - Jul 9, 2017	20	by Leo »» Jan 15, 2021 5:15 AM
» "Violet Evergarden Ever After" Novel On Sale from the 27th of March _MushiRock11_ - Feb 21, 2020	14	by FrailVendetta »» Mar 7, 2020 12:17 AM
» Is Violet a demigod? ugn01 - Oct 15, 2018	2	by HGX »» Jan 26, 2019 8:33 AM

anime/novel same ending ?

More topics from this board

» About the end of this Chapter (7)

Poll: » Violet Evergarden Volume 1 Discussion

Poll: » Violet Evergarden Volume 2 Discussion

» "Violet Evergarden Ever After" Novel On Sale from the 27th of March

» Is Violet a demigod?

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters