One-Shot Topic: Naoshi Komi and Boichi

Apr 10, 2009 3:13 PM

Offline

Sep 2008

2742

This is the topic for discussing the one-shots of Komi and Boichi. Most of these can be found on mangahelpers or mangatraders.

Naoshi Komi:

Apple
Island
Koi no Kami-sama
Personaut
Williams < I haven't been able to find this one yet, so tell me if you do!

Boichi:

Apr 11, 2009 6:57 PM

sakura_r0se

Offline

Mar 2008

772

Apple - 7/10

Island - 7/10

Koi no Kami-sama - 6/10
My least favorite.

Personant - 8/10
My favorite.

Williams - 7/10
My second favorite.

I think that Komi-sensei has proved to us now that he has a pretty creative mind. I only wish that he can find success with a longer series since Double Arts has been cancelled.

sakura_r0seApr 14, 2009 9:00 PM

Apr 14, 2009 8:58 PM

sakura_r0se

Offline

Mar 2008

772

Diadem - 7/10
My least favorite out of the 3 by Boichi, but that's mainly because of the extremely short length. In fact, I almost gave this a 6 if not for the ending.

Hotel - 9/10
So far this is my favorite oneshot EVER. I was skeptical at first 'cuz I thought how the heck can one make such an interesting sci-fi story, but cram it into a oneshot? Boichi did with this! I could have given this a 10, but unfortunately it's still a oneshot and I don't think any oneshot (maybe if it was an entire volume with multiple chapters) can surpass the even more developed stories of a much longer series. Still, this was pretty darn good! I only wished that it was more than 1 chapter.

Present - 8/10
This one was actually pretty creative.

I wish somebody would scanlate Boichi's latest ongoing works since I'm interested in seeing how his longer series would compare to his oneshots.

Apr 24, 2009 1:24 AM

Batmanfreak

Offline

Mar 2008

4410

Where can I find Diadem?

Apr 24, 2009 7:50 AM

xMatronxMalicex

Offline

Sep 2008

2742

I think I found it on mangatraders or mangahelpers.

May 6, 2009 12:15 AM

Batmanfreak

Offline

Mar 2008

4410

I finally finished all of these. hahah. Took me a while. I have to say, I like Naoshi Komi work better than the other person's. Now onto the next set of one shots!

BatmanfreakMay 6, 2009 12:20 AM

See All Discussions

More topics from this board

» Manga topic: Deep Love - Reina no Unmei. Start date 03/22/09 demondude777 - Mar 9, 2009	4	by Meggzz_xp »» Aug 4, 2011 1:59 PM
» Manga topic: Deep Love - Host. Start date 03/15/09 demondude777 - Mar 9, 2009	7	by Meggzz_xp »» Aug 4, 2011 1:38 PM
» Manga Topic: Rozen Maiden; starting 2/5/2011 Kino_no_Tabi - Feb 2, 2011	1	by Bluestreak2 »» Feb 7, 2011 1:37 PM
» Manga Topic: Tokyo Crazy Paradise. Start date: 9/07/10. Batmanfreak - Sep 7, 2010	3	by Turbe »» Oct 22, 2010 11:22 AM
» Manga Topic: Lone Wolf and Cub. Start date: 6/01/10. Batmanfreak - Jun 1, 2010	13	by Batmanfreak »» Sep 2, 2010 8:40 PM

One-Shot Topic: Naoshi Komi and Boichi

More topics from this board

» Manga topic: Deep Love - Reina no Unmei. Start date 03/22/09

» Manga topic: Deep Love - Host. Start date 03/15/09

» Manga Topic: Rozen Maiden; starting 2/5/2011

» Manga Topic: Tokyo Crazy Paradise. Start date: 9/07/10.

» Manga Topic: Lone Wolf and Cub. Start date: 6/01/10.

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters