Season 1 adaptation

INSANELYWP said:
it was a decent adaptation. changes that i remember:

-Kiyo and Horikita confronting class c guys was actually Kiyo and Ichinose

-class size is 40 instead of the number shown in the anime (doesn’t really change much except in later volumes)

-pool scene was with Kei instead of Horikita (also doesn’t really change much but should be noted that this took place after vol 4)

-anime hinted Horikita having romantic feelings towards Kiyo which never actually happened nor does happen

-Chabashira threatening Kiyo after the island test -> this scene was before the island test and is what made him use effort to win the test (very important: shows his motivations)

-made Kiyo an emotionless figure that views everyone as tools -> while true this is how he is on this outside a lot of his inner monologues were cut which shows that he is actually quite a normal person with normal desires and such

don’t really care what’s cut and changed as long as the main scenes are there. it was a pretty decent adaptation.

PhatScythe said:
It was fine they just made Horikita look like the main girl when she’s not

BenTen52 said:

That's were you're wrong. She's clearly the main girl of the series. The anime depicted her as the one solving pool incident instead of Kei so I get what you're taking about.

filimaua13 said:

I agree. Horikita is definitely the main girl with second importance to the story after Ayanokoji, but that doesn't mean she's the love interest. There's a difference.

PhatScythe said:

Yeah I just meant like theres other important girls too but Horikita kept replacing their scenes

BenTen52 said:

That's were you're wrong. She's clearly the main girl of the series. The anime depicted her as the one solving pool incident instead of Kei so I get what you're taking about.

PhatScythe said:
It was fine they just made Horikita look like the main girl when she’s not

Mr_Srijan said:
I haven't read the LN so can't say about that, but the anime was shit. The only good thing were probably the first 4 episodes. Rest, especially the entire Island arc, was boring af. So yeah, either it's a bad adaptation or it was just not for me.

PhatScythe said:
It was fine they just made Horikita look like the main girl when she’s not

NowiseNovice said:
The anime changed some critical details in the LN. For example, the pool scence, where Kei Karuizawa was replaced by Suzune Horikita. Horikita also replaced Honami Ichinose in that Sudo vs Ryueen conflict. Also, the class strength in the anime is shown to be 25 whereas it is 40 in the LN, which is a crucial detail. These are some of the reasons LN readers were disappointed by the anime. We are hoping that they rectify these things in Season 2.

INSANELYWP said:
it was a decent adaptation. changes that i remember:

-Kiyo and Horikita confronting class c guys was actually Kiyo and Ichinose

-class size is 40 instead of the number shown in the anime (doesn’t really change much except in later volumes)

-pool scene was with Kei instead of Horikita (also doesn’t really change much but should be noted that this took place after vol 4)

-anime hinted Horikita having romantic feelings towards Kiyo which never actually happened nor does happen

-Chabashira threatening Kiyo after the island test -> this scene was before the island test and is what made him use effort to win the test (very important: shows his motivations)

-made Kiyo an emotionless figure that views everyone as tools -> while true this is how he is on this outside a lot of his inner monologues were cut which shows that he is actually quite a normal person with normal desires and such

don’t really care what’s cut and changed as long as the main scenes are there. it was a pretty decent adaptation.

official_brown said:
Sorry, not a LN reader. But every LN or manga reader is insanely stuck up. I’ve seen people complain about adaptations when it was 1:1. I would just try both if you want to know the difference because most stuck up readers will complain about the smallest stuff. I thought the anime was fun, so I highly doubt you would really miss anything. I like the anime specifically because it depicts the MC as more emotionless than the LN. But every LN reader will complain about the smallest stuff, especially for this anime.

Rishon007 said:
Was season 1 adapted poorly or skip some parts of LN or something like that? Cause I have seen people complain about S1 and worried about S2 adaptation.

PhatScythe said:

Yeah I just meant like theres other important girls too but Horikita kept replacing their scenes

Rishon007 said:
Was season 1 adapted poorly or skip some parts of LN or something like that? Cause I have seen people complain about S1 and worried about S2 adaptation.

INSANELYWP said:
it was a decent adaptation. changes that i remember:

-Kiyo and Horikita confronting class c guys was actually Kiyo and Ichinose

-class size is 40 instead of the number shown in the anime (doesn’t really change much except in later volumes)

-pool scene was with Kei instead of Horikita (also doesn’t really change much but should be noted that this took place after vol 4)

-anime hinted Horikita having romantic feelings towards Kiyo which never actually happened nor does happen

-Chabashira threatening Kiyo after the island test -> this scene was before the island test and is what made him use effort to win the test (very important: shows his motivations)

-made Kiyo an emotionless figure that views everyone as tools -> while true this is how he is on this outside a lot of his inner monologues were cut which shows that he is actually quite a normal person with normal desires and such

don’t really care what’s cut and changed as long as the main scenes are there. it was a pretty decent adaptation.

official_brown said:
Sorry, not a LN reader. But every LN or manga reader is insanely stuck up. I’ve seen people complain about adaptations when it was 1:1. I would just try both if you want to know the difference because most stuck up readers will complain about the smallest stuff. I thought the anime was fun, so I highly doubt you would really miss anything. I like the anime specifically because it depicts the MC as more emotionless than the LN. But every LN reader will complain about the smallest stuff, especially for this anime.

Rishon007 said:
Was season 1 adapted poorly or skip some parts of LN or something like that? Cause I have seen people complain about S1 and worried about S2 adaptation.

Rishon007 said:
Was season 1 adapted poorly or skip some parts of LN or something like that? Cause I have seen people complain about S1 and worried about S2 adaptation.