Kidou Senshi Gundam Thunderbolt

I went into this show with some knowledge of Gundam, although I have not watched much, and with the idea of reviewing a short series for the night I watched it. Robots, dark stories, the combat of war...these are all things that interest me, so with a solid score, I dove into Mobile Suit Gundam Thunderbolt.

The tone of the show's darkness definitely strikes right away, after a jazzy start of a space army getting ready and then going right into getting blown away. While Thunderbolt gets right to the point, in this regard I feel it suffers, giving little room to consider or process events ... and frequently moving too fast to really create an investment with the characters. Talking about the overall plot and narrative of Thunderbolt is hard because, honestly, it...doesn't have much of one, despite the dark atmosphere, the plot is very barebones: I know it is a four 18 minute episode anime, but I feel even something like Space Patrol Luluco (13 episodes of 7 minutes, 91 minutes of runtime compared to Thunderbolt's 72) had a stronger plot and Luluco's plot wasn't even anything special. The strongest theme is pretty obvious: War has a lot of hard descisions you have to make and that sucks. Any meaning or plot aside from that basically is "Federation vs. Zeon!", little to it.

The problem with this largely comes down to the characters, which are almost entirely exceedingly flat. The only one with any life in them is one of the main cvharacters, Daryl, who gets some level of characterization over his Paraplegia and flashbacks...but, in part due to the constant flow of interrupting nothingness, the fact that the flashbacks give little context or reason to interest us aside from the most obvious, and the lack of seeing Daryl doing things not related to it, it comes off as rather trite, and his reactions to the events of the story around him are mixed in interest. This is especially notable near the end when his rival, Io Fleming, makes a line that the show presents as dramatic and meaningful, with the exception that it is rather counter to his emotional reaction and the story beforehand, which basically makes it come across as trying to be deep but ending up cheap.

Pretty much everyone else in this show is flat. Io Fleming, the rival to Daryl, who is nothing you haven't seen before if you have seen a cursory amount of media in general, the guy who has thrills for battle with a cultural twist, in this case jazz music. Karla and Claudia have no impact on the story despite the amount of time devoted to Karla and she comes off as somewhat of a caricature of the common character archetype (non-fighter forced to fight/do combat research/etc) with her vanilla backstory and lack of scenes NOT relating to that. Claudia's character barely is expanded on and seems like she is supposed to serve as something to relate with Io, except their interactions pretty much mean nothing. Death in this series is hardly a spoiler when so many characters die, but Claudia's is noticeably disappointing as it is clearly meant to serve as an emotional/dramatic high point. I found myself unable to care. Nobody else is even worth mentioning, and there's lots of characters who exist as throwaways to show the "dark" setting: These characters usually get a handful of scenes where they show little or no traits outside of what is necessary for the story, making connection and thus caring about them beyond the cursory "oh, they died" extremely difficult.

I'm sure it can be argued that, as a short anime, I should expect characters to be more shallow and for them to get more time to grow as things go on. The problem with that here is that, frankly, I'm not given much of a reason to BE invested in these characters, with the majority being cannon fodder as well, and no plot to really hook onto or become interested in. If this was, say, the 4-episode start to an anime, I doubt I would be very interested in watching the rest of the show. It isn't a good anime as a standalone and it isn't an interesting start: Other Gundam series certainly have superior starts, let alone counting other depth naturally.

If there is one good thing in the series, it is the music, which not only sounds quite nice between both how it sounds and some good uses of merging of it with the show, and is pretty much the high point of the series, merging music with flashbacks, action and the bits in between. The animation generally looks nice, but fight choreography is rather disappointing, and the "Thunderbolt" of the title so far is useless aside from Deus Ex Machina at certain points in the series, although given how it is used I assume that it will actually mean something later in the series. Only the last fight is notable for much and it isn't honestly all that great in the context of Gundam, let alone all other anime and shows.

In conclusion, I would personally avoid Mobile Suit Gundam Thunderbolt for all but diehard fans of Gundam, as it is not an especially good or deep representative of the series, nor is it especially interesting on its own. with trite and shallow characterization, little is left to the show except for action set pieces, which do not properly utilize the animation that it has. Plot is largely non-existant, although it at least manages to avoid major issues due to the lack of it, so unless you really like mixing in music into animation, it doesn't really have much to offer on a watch.

I personally chose the shortest Gundam series I found on here and decided to watch it because I had some time. I only did this so I actually say I've at least seen some installment of one of the classic mecha series. I'm honestly really disappointed with it though and I'll explain why.

The story really isn't anything more than a typical war in space story between opposing federation factions. That's really all there is to it, except that they use giant robots are their weapons. I wish they actually showed some weapons or something being used on the Gundams because they ... were kind of lame. I'm just going to assume that all Gundams have this type of story so luckily I watched the shortest one.

I'm personally sick of the kind of music used in this anime because it's used in almost every show like this. I really hate this kind of music so even after only 2 or 3 anime using it, I'm sick of it. It works for this style of anime though. I guess it's better than out of place music.

The art and animation were pretty good. That's the one good compliment I'll give the series. Too bad the art and animation can't make up for the horrible characters. The characters really didn't have any substance to them. Most of them were just people blindly following orders and they didn't really have any good reason for why they were fighting. The character portion is definitely the weakest part of the anime, but there were some decent interactions between a few characters so I'll give a small amount of credit for that.

I personally don't recommend this or any other gundam and or just mecha series that sounds similar, assuming they all follow this type of story. At least, I can say I've watched one now though. I suppose it's better to have seen it and have reasons for not liking it than just basing hatred on a description alone.