Feb 6, 2015
Story: 90%
The story of "Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan" may seem a bit too simple and even cliché at first, but after about two chapters we realize that this is not like this... The manga depicts the love as it really is: a pure love, without ulterior motives by the characters or stupid things like: "I met you today, let's get married!". It's a mature and poetic love, which is emphasized with the beautiful phrases present in the script. Good joob!
Art: 50%
The art is the worst part of the manga. Sometimes a simple thing can be better than a complex one, but in this case
...
this is VERY simple and there are moments that the background is completely white. Even if the ambients are limited (the most of the manga happens inside of the prison), Yumeka could have put more details and a better contour even for the characters. The simple art can transmit a bit of nostalgia, but here it does not work very well.
Characters: 90%
Even if with 4 characters, it is too difficult to develop calmly and carefully each one in 8 chapters. But 'Watashitachi' could tell the story of each of them and made sure we are going to treat the characters as real people and be concerned what will happen to them; in other words, that isn't superficial. Because... Ok, you have the most beautiful story in the world but you don't have good characters. So, your manga will continue bad.
Enjoyment: 92%
Read the manga was a extremely fast experience. By the whole set (good characters and good story), each chapter has gone faster than the wind, for me. I became increasingly enchanted by every single word of the manga and each chapter, which made me super anxious for the end... Which is very sad...
Overall: 8,02% = 80% show less
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
