A Certain Magical Index (light novel)
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
eddy-sama said: They are not just controlling them but protecting them, and since those students are not "normal" they should have something Anti-espers/Anti-magicians otherwise they are completely useless. By control I meant maintain peace.Anyway.. Magic isnt supposed to exist. Considering that the only have problems against magicians because thy have no info about them and the powerful espers(level 5s), there is no reason to use something like that. You dont see policemen using rocket launchers if the robbers have armored vehicles(with or without guns). And dont forget that Anti-Skill is basically teachers and other adults protecting the students for free, because they want to. And there is always Judgement that even has Level 4s, that can help them. If the job that they must handle is too much, they arent even informed and the task goes straight to [spoiler]organizations like Group(which Accelerator,Unabara and Motoharu are part of),Item(from Railgun S) and other underground factions. |
ssjokgJul 3, 2014 8:45 AM
| This is one of the most inconsistent shows I think I've ever seen. I disliked the first arc, hated the second one, liked the third one, absolutely detested the fourth one, liked the fifth one and had an okay time with the last one. It's super-generic, very badly organized, and painfully bad in spots, but there are some good ideas on display here. And hell, there was a really solid performance from Kana Asumi in the last arc, so that was nice, although, I laughed when Touma just happened to find Hyouka at the end of this episode. |
| Why the bittersweet ending? :( Well, not that much bittersweet, but still, felt kinda unnecessary that she disappeared. But at the same time, I guess it will come back because of that Aleister plan. Kuroko make me laugh so much with all her crazy attempt toward Misaka :P Misaka is so cute too, the way she got embarrassed while being close to him :3 Himegami trying to be moe was funny too. Touma sure brofist a lot. Now, he brofisted a golem. Isn't it a bit dangerous to jump on someone while being meters and meters from the ground, Index? Well, now, up to Railgun bitches! More Misaka! More tsundereness! More Kuroko lewdness! Woot! |
| «Time is passing so quickly. Right now, I feel like complaining to Einstein. Whether time is slow or fast depends on perception. Relativity theory is so romantic. And so sad.» - Kurisu Makise a.k.a. The Zombie |
| Well this arc was quite average. Nice to see Misaka 20001 by hospital Accelerator's bed in the end. I liked all the previous arcs though. Touma is pretty cool, Index isn't as terrible as people make her to be and of course much less Misaka than in Railgun so I rate it higher - 7/10 from me. Wasn't as childish as Railgun too. I hope there's more Kanzaki in s2. |
AizixAug 17, 2014 1:21 PM
| "Your personality of going all out when it comes to women..." Devil's Blood to Touma haha. That pretty much sums up the entire Index series. Touma is sucha feminist yea!!! YES FIGHT FOR THE WOMEN!! That scene with Last Order with Accel was awesome. I wonder if we get to see the Daihesei Festival in the next season!!! |
_Dazzle_Aug 30, 2014 2:37 PM
| fragmented filler show of peace.. each of those 'arc' aka waste of fucking time fillers can be done in 1 EP each per arc fucking shit sucks ass 3/10 |
 |
flaxman85 said: fragmented filler show of peace.. each of those 'arc' aka waste of fucking time fillers can be done in 1 EP each per arc fucking shit sucks ass 3/10 Yeah. Because they werent butchered enough. You should become a scriptwriter. |
| This show has no sense of direction. It starts out promising, but the plot changes on a whim and it happens OVER AND OVER AND OVER again. By the time you reach the end, it's like you're watching an entirely different show. Villains are introduced, then disappear. Characters are introduced, then their motives and personalities change abruptly. I still don't know what the fuck the main plot/conflict is. Writers, please: just stick to one fucking thing and then build upon it. As the show progressed, I found myself less and less engaged and eager to watch the next episode. But the worst part is, the protagonist transforms from a very likeable guy into your typical protagonist with a "helping people problem" once his memory is wiped. |
notsomacho said: "Villains" disappear because they are defeated.This show has no sense of direction. It starts out promising, but the plot changes on a whim and it happens OVER AND OVER AND OVER again. By the time you reach the end, it's like you're watching an entirely different show. Villains are introduced, then disappear. Characters are introduced, then their motives and personalities change abruptly. I still don't know what the fuck the main plot/conflict is. Writers, please: just stick to one fucking thing and then build upon it. As the show progressed, I found myself less and less engaged and eager to watch the next episode. But the worst part is, the protagonist transforms from a very likeable guy into your typical protagonist with a "helping people problem" once his memory is wiped. Characters motives are very clear and they change because either they cant fulfill their goals or they are fulfilled. The main plot is Touma meeting people and helping them and where that leads.We dont need a BiG goal, like becoming the King of Level 5s. He was like that since the first arc.Really the only thing that changed is that he has no memories. |
| It was a nice ending of the season. I like more the story about Misaki than this last... Besides this anime was very awesome! :D Just like the second opening says "It's only my thing highest masterpiece!" ;) |
| Maloween 2017 Main Candies   |
| I was only watching this for Accelerator (who didn't appear as much as I thought), but still I expected more considering its popularity. 7/10 |
 |
| Good BUT: Arcs were too short and rushed and every arc ends in the same no-one-dies cheesy way. It was pretty average. 6/10. |
| I want to give this a 7/10 but it's lacking something. I feel that it's just arcs followed by arcs followed by more arcs. There is no central focus and for 24 episodes, all of the arcs still didn't really link up nor did we get like a main plot/climax, overall. I think I enjoyed Accelerator's arc the most as he was very interesting to watch and Last Order was adorable. He had more character development than Touma in just two episodes, man. Instant fav boy. God bless Okamoto Nobuhiko. Yo, the world building is superb in this series, along with both Railgun seasons. My favourite part of the show is feeling like I'm in Academy City and it's fancy science and technology. Another flaw it had was that mostly all of the villains, including Accelerator, had little to no backstory, foreshadowing and motive. The last girl (Sherry?) randomly wanted to start war and shit. She did explain her reasons but dang, it was rushed. I felt that Hyouka, aka megane, was just there to force the viewers to cry. She was kind of dumb overall and I don't get how she could have existed. Then again, most of this show is sci-fi fantasy. I want to see more. Will download and start s2 after midterms end. |
| Magic and Science , Unification . Materialization of the benevolent one . The Fortunate reality . GREAT EPISODE . Glad the anime got me enjoyed and motivated at the same time . It's really a nice feeling that you've watched such a great anime . Well , Preparations for the sequel !!! |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| The most disappointed arc in my opinion. Episode 1&2 are the best of this series. I think Touma is the strongest Level 0. That would be cool. Series Rating: 8/10 |
 |
| Hmmm... Right. Well, I think this had a strong start but it started going downhill after Touma lost his memories. It feels like this series is losing any sense of overall plot and each new arc has some conflict that came out of nowhere. It just feels way too random. Also, most of the villains weren't good. Let's take the Alchemist and this last villain, for example. Their motives made no sense. Apparently they pretended to be evil and for some reason weren't evil, and meanwhile I still don't quite understand either a) what they're trying to achieve or b) why they're trying to achieve it in that way. For me, characters are extremely important. I can deal with even a terrible plot if I really like the characters, but aside from Accelerator and Misaka, none of them were all that appealing to me. Touma really got on my nerves. He's so interfering! This goes beyond saving people, it's not even letting people do anything at all because someone will be at risk. Also, he really needs to stop with those cheesy speeches. I had liked Index, but after Touma lost his memories she stopped developing as a character completely and never did anything. Most of the supporting cast were very stereotypical and annoying. The only two with real personality were Misaka and Accelerator imo, and they were only supporting characters. Also, can we just talk about Okamoto Nobuhiko's voice acting? :D The guy is amazing. My one complaint with Accelerator's story: I think it's a bit of a stretch to have killed 10,000 people and then feel guilt. The idea itself is fine, in fact I liked it, but the anime (novel, whatever) chose terrible numbers. 10,000. Ten freaking thousand. That's A LOT. That's also literally impossible, by the way, so the experiment itself was flawed. He could have killed one of those clones every single day since his birth to age 20 and he still wouldn't have killed 10,000. Besides I'm pretty sure he's 17, and the project started long after his birth. Anyway, I wanted to give this 7/10, but I really feel like I can't give this higher than a 6/10. And I am going to watch index II, mainly because I see that Misaka and Accelerator are main characters there. EDIT: Forgot to mention something that really bothered me. I couldn't help but feel like either you saw Touma's weakness or his right hand worked overly well when it served the plot. One example is when his blonde-haired friend beat him with no problem in the Angel Fall arc. I mean, at that point Touma had taken down ACCELERATOR. And suddenly he can't beat a guy in a fist fight? |
KageNoAbisuJan 14, 2016 11:05 AM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Hmm... well that's kind of an unsatisfying ending for a season. Although Misaka blushing again is cute. Maybe I would appreciate Railgun more since Misaka is there. Overall, I enjoyed it (mostly because of Misaka). Touma's harem just kept on growing and growing... but they never developed. Like seriously. Take out Himegami from the equation and the story line will not change whatsoever since only the sensei is needed. 8/10 |
 |
notsomacho said: This show has no sense of direction. It starts out promising, but the plot changes on a whim and it happens OVER AND OVER AND OVER again. By the time you reach the end, it's like you're watching an entirely different show. Villains are introduced, then disappear. Characters are introduced, then their motives and personalities change abruptly. I still don't know what the fuck the main plot/conflict is. Writers, please: just stick to one fucking thing and then build upon it. As the show progressed, I found myself less and less engaged and eager to watch the next episode. But the worst part is, the protagonist transforms from a very likeable guy into your typical protagonist with a "helping people problem" once his memory is wiped. There is no real plot or character development. Just a white knight saving women, lecturing people into his ridiculous moral code and defeating pathetic villains. There is no real attempt to bring together all the mini arcs together into anything coherent and no one is that interesting. There was an attempt to show Misaka as possibly entertaining but she quickly fades to the background and seems pathetically weak for being a "Level 5", she only gets defeated by Touma and admits she can't beat Accelerator. Takes no part in the fights in the season. What use is she? What use are any of the many side characters who sometimes pop back up in this show? To blush at the MC? This doesn't even feel like a real harem show as none of the females get much screen time except for Index. Who imo is the most irritating character in the show. Gave this a 6 for being mildly entertaining every now and then but hardly anything to remember. I even see that Misaka is thought of as one of the "tough" women in anime which I find doubly confounding as she has as of yet done nothing to earn this. I'm a few eps in the second season as well and she is once again shoved to the side... not looking good for her. |
 |
| This was an ok ending. Index is still really meh. Touma was fun but that's about it. Might watch season 2 eventually but I'm not in a hurry. |
 |
| The part with Sherry didn't really go anywhere, but at least she revealed her motivation, so it wasn't a complete failure. I liked Kazakiri, but her scenes in this episode were beyond cheesy. Then there were one or two scenes where we were reminded that Mikoto and Himegami still exist, but I already forgot what they were about. The info dump with Aleister and Tsuchimikado was even less clear than in the previous episodes, so that just ended up confusing me instead of creating intrigue. Well, in spite of everything I just wrote, I still might watch more of this franchise. Magnus got a new assignment, Kanzaki is missing; the Misaka and Accelerator are still recuperating. There is material for more, but having seen the way this season was executed, I don't expect any miracles from season 2. |
| Season started pretty good and promising, but at some point there was less progress and the story started to stagnate. Yet I enjoyed a bit of the comedy and sol parts. And well, it still served as a nice set up for the sequel where hopefully more will happen. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| Not a bad ending and overall it was a good series. |
 |
| This show started off weak and ended weak. No character I'm particulary fond of, very generic protagonist and antagonists. I feel like even that number is too low for the enjoyment I got out of it, but I don't feel like giving it even less either so... 3/10 |
| I really do love this entire series, just finished re-watching it on Blu-Ray and was so good :) Can't remember why Kanzaki is missing though, will have to jump onto Season 2 again in time for Season 3's release :D |
| I likeed how Last Order stayed by Accelerator despite having no prior knowledge of him due to the 7 day memory wipe incident. Shows that they were destined to be with each other. Misaka, bending down to get something in a bathroom is a REALLY BAD IDEA. Especially if you are with someone like Kuroko. But it was quite funny. Laura Stewart makes an appearance. Wonder what will happen next. To me, Accelerator and Last Order were obviously the best parts of Index, along with its soundtrack and sci-fi concepts(The first couple of episodes in the Deep blood arc were cool too.). The magical concepts, not so much. 9/10. But I think I will continue with the light novel from now on. |
 Without change,we end up becoming the very person we hate. I was dead until the moment I met you. I was a powerless corpse pretending to be alive. Living without power, without the ability to change my course, was bound to lead me to a slow death. |
| Should I watch rail gun now or go straight for Season 2?! |
 |
GosuGian said: Should I watch rail gun now or go straight for Season 2?! Honestly, you can just read the wiki if you want to jumo to season 3. I mean Season 2 is pretty bad as anime goes. Railgun is anime-only friendly, but its filled with Cute Girls Doing Cute Things filler, positive side is that its entry friendly, with clear "bad guy/good guy". With Index, you really have to be into Conspiracy, Absurdity, and Occultism, plus being a bit autistic and really REALLY into Aleister Crowley and Insane rambling from 19th century. At the basic level, Kamachi expect his reader to at least know what is "Thelema". You can skip season 2 and move to season 3, since that is suppose to wrap up the first entry of the possible Toaru Index Trilogy. |
| "You had no free will, you chased your vices along the same path as all of the others." - Shikieiki Yamaxanadu, Diamond in the rough |
| so what was that with the finale...leaves you hanging with a lot of questions |
 |
| Wow, for one of the most popular anime out there, I just couldn't get into it, the best part of the show for me was the Accelerator episodes when the usual cast didn't show up. I found it very difficult to follow, it tries so many times to explain plot and events with vanacular and terminology relating to its world, and once you don't know what these words mean it's impossible to keep up, no idea why they don't keep things simple. Still have no idea the difference between magicians and espers. It just tries too hard to be unique and forgets to carry along the viewers. 6. |
 Join the MSP Club for an in-depth look at score progressions and other stats of currently airing anime |
| Better than I expected it. At least, Touma didn't end up lying in the hospital bed again lmao. Kazakiri saving Index was great! So, we know why Sherry doesn't want that both the magic and science sides get together. That dude in the tube (Aleister Crowley) lured her into Academy City. His plan seems to be interesting. In the other side, it was nice to see Accelerator for a last time. Touma was a good MC, I didn't find him annoying. I think that this season was mostly an introduction to the world and characters. Overall, first and second arc were rushed, third arc was bad, fourth was average and fifth and sixth were good. So, 6/10 for the anime. |
| All weebs creatures of the galaxy, hear this message. Those of you who listen will not be struck by western animation. You will no longer know hunger, nor pain. Your Anime have come to lead you now. Our strength shall serve as a luminous sun toward which all intelligence may blossom. And the impervious shelter beneath which you will prosper. However, for those who refuse our offer and cling to their western animation ways… For you, there will be great wrath. |
| The show gives a different vibe compare to the other anime and I liked it. It's just the show is not too entertaining but it is good, I just feel the show is somehow has a boring vibes. |
 |
| I enjoyed seeing these arcs animated, but I probably would have enjoyed them a lot less had I not read the novel first. Pacing is rushed in all arcs besides the first one, a lot of exposition is left out as well as Touma's internal monologues and motivations. Animation is decent though and sound effects are pretty good and help recreate the atmosphere I'm familiar with from the novel. I give it a 6/10 |
| Good series. 7/10 I watched Accelerator series before Index. I finally know the reason why Accelerator is a bad guy and why he got shot in the head. |
 |
| Well, not a bad last episode.. Hyouka's arc end is closed well, I'd say.. And some teases awaits for us in the future.. Overall, I don't know, how I feel about these series.. First episodes, when there was development between Index and Touma were just fantastic.. I ship them enormously from that time, it was just so touching and wholesome.. But rest of the series, I think, lacked Index.. I think they needed to include more of her.. But they included lots of arcs of very many characters, it feels.. I think it at the same time creates feeling of it being too fast, and too slow.. As in too fast, that a lot of characters get introduced, and a lot of things are told about them, some things about their backstory and personality.. But also slow, because it seems that these characters are maybe a bit undeveloped.. I think in the end, with time, I will enjoy characters more and more, series is certainly constructed to be long running one, with a lot of things not revealed, as well as characters developing randomly at times.. In the end, only for beginning episodes with more focus on Index I'd say it's satisfying show.. Beginning was just too great, really.. Other episodes were alright, I guess.. More time really is needed for all the characters they introduce.. In the end, I still feel that I got a feeling in the beginning of anime, which I'm not getting every day, or which I'm not getting in every anime.. So just for that wonderful feeling, I'll give anime a high score.. But also feel that other characters need to get more screen time, as well as Index could show more as well, this part being called after her.. ;P Overall, a nice anime, in the end.. I might pick up more in the future, especially as I heard that next Railgun is more focused on slice of life, what is really needed for this show, really, I feel.. To grow to like, feel and understand characters better.. But maybe in the future.. ;p |
| I feel like Railgun (season) has a deeper story than Index, but Railgun somewhat more boring... Final battle Railgun> Index I still think Idex is better tho |
 |
| It takes 3 TOUMAN PUNCHES to defeat Sherry, bravo to her 👏 When I first watched this a few years ago I was intrigued by the concept of the Science vs Magic faction and the various characters that make up this interesting world, but after reading the first 6 LN vols and then rewatching this again makes the show seemed quite weak. Toaru's strong point is its worldbuilding, which JC cant quite nail it. While it's a good show on it's own, I'm dropping my score from 8 to a 6 now since it's just a "decent" adaptation If I were to rank the arcs... Great
Good
Meh
|
FragmantLemonNov 11, 2020 1:37 AM
| season 1 was good, but not on the same level as the Railgun spin-off. One of the things that sort of ruined my enjoyment of this series were the characters, some of them really suck. Index acts like an ungreatful bitch half the time, specially during the Hyoka arc where the only thing she does is constantly abuse Touma for no reason at all, I really hate the character archetype which only trait is to make the MC's life a living hell. Hyoka is the worst character easily, she is the definition of a non-character, nothing more than a tool to advance the plot. Touma is not a bad character but he is very predictable and can be boring at times, other than that he is a good MC with a heart of gold. The deep blood arc was unnecesary, you can skip it and nothing of importance will be lost. I found the science side of Index way more interesting and entertaining than its magic counterpart. The sisters arc and Accelerator's arc easily carry this show, without I would have lowered the score by 1 or 2 points. The show is way more interesting when Touma is not the main focus and we get the POV of other characters. I found Accelerator's sacrifice very endearing. 7/10 |
| A strange/difficult one to rate if I'm being honest, I think it was slightly too convoluted and sporadic with the story and the little arcs, but I did somewhat enjoy most of it. I enjoyed the side characters more than the main duo. 7/10. Plenty of sequels/spin offs which has me quite interested... |
| was okay overall, that girl from the church with ellis wasn't convincing. Misaka and Misaka 20001 saved this show, 3/10. |
 |
| So I really wanted to like this show as I tend to have a soft Spot for light novel Adaptions. So I thought I would love Index. But this just didn't grow on me. I found Touma to be an Amazing lead character, I loved Him. But Apart from that, The memory loss thing came way too Early for me to really be shocked about and didn't have such a big impact since we as Audience had Barely Gotten to know anything about Touma or his relationship with Index at this point. I was also missing a greater plot Progression as it felt like Several Individual Arcs that Were only loosely connected...the final episode didnt feel like a finale either. 7/10 for me. Will keep Watching the spin offs/sequels and see. |
| 8/10 for me Enjoyable, cute when needed, thought provoking but so many wasted opportunities. That whole memory loss thing, it could have been quite a story line, it could have been the whole season, but it was ignored and only mentioned when needed. How do you forget about a loss of memory? Oh yeah! Right. |
| Well this was ok, guess maybe I'll get answers in the sequels bcs I didnt rly understand much overall :D |
 |
| Touma really is the real One Punch Man lol Okay Bitter Sweet Ending 6/10 i'm watching the released order, so next is Toaru Kagaku no Railgun |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » To Aru Majutsu no Index Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )angel999 - Nov 8, 2008 |
200 |
by whitebeartigtig
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » To Aru Majutsu no Index Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )removed-user - Nov 1, 2008 |
151 |
by whitebeartigtig
»»
3 hours ago |
|
Poll: » To Aru Majutsu no Index Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )angel999 - Oct 25, 2008 |
157 |
by whitebeartigtig
»»
8 hours ago |
|
Poll: » To Aru Majutsu no Index Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )angel999 - Oct 18, 2008 |
159 |
by whitebeartigtig
»»
Yesterday, 2:30 PM |
|
Poll: » To Aru Majutsu no Index Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )angel999 - Oct 11, 2008 |
204 |
by whitebeartigtig
»»
Yesterday, 2:01 PM |