| Proposal 1:Take away character's item (DENIED with 14 votes) - club description:You can take a character's item. 3 claims per member, 4 per admin. can be hats, can't be shirts or skirts or pants. can be dolls wepons and other items. can't be robots. - exsample claim:"Baka-Chibi took Meroko's hat"(full moon wo sagashite) Proposal 2: Open a restaurant (DENIED with 14 votes) - club description:need 1 cook, 2 waiters and a name. you are the manager. needs pics of all charas. - exsample claim:"Baka-Chibi's restaurant:Shinobu-cook, Naru-waitress, Tatsuma-Waiter - Name:the whatever restaurant" (you know how those banners works...)(Love hina, love hina, yoake mae) Proposal 3: Claim a robot/cyborg) (DENIED with 11 votes) - club description:you can claim a robot (any kind of robot) or a cyborg. one claim per member, 2 per admin. - exsample claim:"Baka-Chibi claimed Chachamaru"(negima) Proposal 4: Club Name:Claim a person with a strange obsession (APPROVED with 10 votes) - club description:You can claim a character with a very wierd obsesion for something. proof needed. one claim per member. - exsample claim:"Baka-Chibi claimed Fuko"(clannad) Proposal 5: Claim a lesbian (APPROVED with 10 votes) no need of explanation, 1 claim per member, 2 per admins. proof needed=3 example:"Baka-Chibi claimed Chikane"(kannazuki no miko) Proposal 6: Claim a gay (APPROVED with 10 votes) same as the last idea but with boys. example:i don't watch any shonen ai animes so i don't have any example, but it's basicly the same thingXP Proposal 7: Claim a Childhood(?) Memory/Flashback (APPROVED with 10 votes) I can't really explain what I mean, (well, literally the title itself [I would think] is self explanatory) but what the banner would have on it would be a childhood flashback like in shugo chara Ikuto was playing the violin while Utau would be singing. - 150 post to claim - At least one month membership - 1 claim per member Example Claim: azncrisis Claimed Utau's Childhood Memory Or azncrisis Claimed Kukai's Childhood Flashback (?)I'm thinking maybe a childhood flashback because it's more unique than just having a common flashback.? Proposal 8: Claim a Pirate (APPROVED with 12 votes) -Claim any pirate or space pirate. (I don't know that many pirates in anime/manga, not including one piece, so tv shows, books, movies and video games are included.) -300 posts -Darkneko Claimed Tetra Proposal 9: Claim an Officer (APPROVED with 13 votes) -150 posts, 2 month membership -1 or 2 claims per member (not sure about this yet) -the character must be some form of detective or police officer [ex: shinsengumi, town police, marines, FBI, etc.] -disciplinary committee members do not count. -proof and MAL page is needed. ^these are just basic rules. They may be tweaked a bit if it's accepted. Proposal 10: Claim a Twin-Tailed Character (DENIED with 10 votes) - Claim a character with twin-tails(Pig tailed) as their hairstyle. As proof, the claimer will need to post a ScreenShot/Official Image of the character wearing twintails (or pigtails) - 150 posts, atleast one month of membership. Atmost 2 Twintails per person and 3 for the Staff. Violet Rebellion claimed Anya from Code Geass as her TwinTailed Claim Proposal 11: Claim a scary character (DENIED with 15 votes) - A claim club for scary/creepy characters. Scary/creepy=weird and somewhat different characters. Perverted characters are NOT included. -6 months member+ 20 posts - Anju from Karin Reminder of the rules *You MUST state why you voted that way or else your vote will not count *If you proposed the club idea, you cannot vote for your own idea *Everyone must state reasons even admin *DO NOT BE BIASED! (or else your vote will not count) *I like this idea/I don't like this idea is not a valid reason |
Tsuruya-sanDec 22, 2008 3:43 PM
| 1)lolz Sure why not~ not a bad idea~ 2)No... too similar to get your own cafe... 3)No... sounds like mecha claim o.O 4) Sure Not a bad idea~ 5) No because some people might find it offensive 6) No because some people might find it offensive 7)No Vote 8)Sure since it hasn't been done before 9)Sure because it hasn't done before 10)No vote *is good idea and original but then we get a bunch of hair style claim clubs* 11) No because there's really no accurate meaning of scary |
| 1- No. There's lots of clubs that includes accessories. 2- No. Get your own cafe etc~ 3- No, if there's a mecha claim that Yuki said. 4- [blank] 5- No. Claim silver haired chara, claim short chara... 6- No. Claim silver haired chara, claim short chara... 7- [blank] 8- Yeah... Why not. It's good to be able to claim pirates from movies, books etc too. 9- [blank] 10- No. Claim silver haired chara, claim short chara.. 11- No. Claim silver haired chara, claim short chara.. |
| 1)i dunno about this one, seems a bit pointless unless you can only take away a certain amount of objects from each character 2)i like it,why not 3)No... sounds like mecha claim o.O 4) dont see why not, im pretty sure its not been done before 5)no, isnt it justclaim a character whith limitations and some people may find it offencive 6)no, same as above 7)No, i dont like the idea very much 8)Sure since it hasn't been done before 9)Sure because it hasn't done before 10)No, i just dont like the idea 11) No , because scarey would be based on personal opinon, a good example is elizabeth from gintama |
| Proposal 1: No. It's like claiming an accessory except you're just "taking" it. Proposal 2: No. There's already a "Make a Cafe" or something, so it's a duplicate. Proposal 3: There's already "Claim a mecha" so no. Proposal 4: Yes. It's original and could work. Proposal 5: This could work. Yes for now. Proposal 6: Same as Proposal 5. Proposal 7: I guess this could work. Yes for now. Proposal 8: Sure, it hasn't been made yet. Proposal 9: Sounds like a good idea, and hasn't been done yet. Yes. Proposal 10: I have to think about this one... Proposal 11: Scary has different meanings, I'm gonna say no. |
Tsuruya-sanDec 14, 2008 4:30 PM
| 3. I think it's a good idea, if it excludes mechas. 'Cause there's many other robotic kinds of characters. |
 |
| 1) No: Its rather similar to claim an accessory and the rules are kind of ambiguous. You can take their hat but not other clothing items? I can see some confusion arising when it comes to which items you can take. 2) No: We already have "Get your own cafe" which is essentially the same as this. 3) Undecided: Same reason as x_alice_x stated. 4) Yes: This hasn't been done before. 5) Yes: It hasn't been done before 6) Yes: Same as above. 7) No vote 8) Yes: It hasn't been done before and I like that it includes characters outside of anime/manga as well. 9) Yes: It hasn't been done before. 10) No: Same reason as HikariDawn stated. 11) No: Same reason as HikariDawn stated. |
 |
| no 1; No, Kinda like another club. no 2; Yeah, It's intresting. 8D no 3; Why not? It reminds me of Cat-Eared claim club. no 4; No. 'Strangeness' depends on the view. I coud cal the 'Orenji-kun' obsession strange, but an orange farmer might not ;D no 5; No Vote no 6; No Vote no 7; Yes, but for some reason it feels like it's been done already? no 8; If you can claim Kunoichi, it's obvious, yes. no 9; Yes, for the same reason you can claim a Pirate. no 10; No Vote no 11; No-Same as no.4 |
| 1. No just like claim an accessory, but you take away it instead 2. No. There is already a similar club 3. No. Already have a club like that. 4. [no vote] 5. Yes. Hasn't been done yet 6. Yes. Hasn't been done yet 7. [no vote] 8. Yes. Hasn't been done yet 9. Yes. Hasn't been done yet 10. No. Same reason HikariDawn said 11. No. Too many different opinions |
| Proposal 1: No, for the reasons everyone already said. It's like a "claim an accessory" and "claim a weapon" together. >_> Proposal 2: No. Get Your Own Cafè is basically the same desu. Proposal 3: Eto... There is already "claim a mecha", plus I'm SURE I've seen a "claim an android" somewhere on MAL once. So, no. Proposal 4: Too similiar to "claim an otaku". Characters/people obsessed with something are usually considered otaku. Once again, no. Proposal 5: It hasn't been done before, so yes. Proposal 6: Same as above desu. Proposal 7: Yes, why not. Proposal 8: Hasn't been made before, so yes. Proposal 9: As above desu. Proposal 10: Would be nice, but I gotta say no. Approve one, approve 'em all. And I don't want to see 140 claim clubs about hair. Proposal 11: Ahem. No. *points to Claim a Killer and Claim a Psycho* Killers and psychos are usually scary/creepy, you know. |
 hugging six rabbits and having pink nightmares |
| Proposal 1: No, it's too similiar to "Claim an Accessory" club. Proposal 2: No, there's already a club like that. (Get Your Own Cafe) Proposal 3: Such a club already exists (Claim A Robot, where you can both claim mecha and a robot), duh! First check the other claim clubs, then give ideas! >.> Proposal 4: It hasn't been done before..Why not. Proposal 5: [no vote] Proposal 6: [no vote] Proposal 7: I guess it could work...so yes. Proposal 8: If it's just fine to claim from movie, video games, TV shows, etc..Then no. (They can be claimed in Claim A Movie Character; Claim A Video Game Character; as for anime...there's just One Piece, so it just can't work out) Proposal 9: I'm not sure about this one, so [no vote] Proposal 10: I don't like this idea. No. Proposal 11: No. (The same reason as HikariDawn) |
| Proposal 1: No, Claim an accessory is the same except for the "Take away" Proposal 2: No, *Points to Get your own cafe.* (But the club is dead?) Proposal 3: No, Claim a Mecha is similar to this. Proposal 4: [Not voting] Proposal 5: [Not voting] Proposal 6: [Not voting] Proposal 7: Yes. It seems interesting. Proposal 8: Yes. It's original. Proposal 9: Yes. It's original. Proposal 10: No. *Points to -Cynthia- and Hikari reasons* Proposal 11: No. *Points to Rena reason* |
They see me trollin', they hatin'. |
| Proposa1 1: (character's item) No, there's this claim an accessory club~ Proposal 2: (restaurant) No, too similar to Get your Own Cafe club~ Proposal 3: (robot) No, there's already Claim a Robot/Mecha club~ Proposal 4: (obssession) No, that's practically claim an otaku, since people with whatever obssessions are in fact otaku~ Proposal 5 & 6 : (homosexuals) I guess this one is not yet made (it's not like a couple, right?), so I'll say Yes~ Proposal 7: (memory/flashback) Yes, original idea~ =] Proposal 8: (pirate) There're not so many pirates, but if someone wants I guess they'll be able to find many [no vote] Proposal 9: (officer) Yes, it's not yet done and there're plenty of them~ Proposal 10: (twn-tailed chara) No, this whole thing about hair must stop now~! Proposal 11: (scary chara) No, we have already denied short and shy character clubs and that's just another claim a ----- character~ |
 |
| Proposal 1: No.. There's already "claim an accessory" and "claim a weapon", nee.. Proposal 2: No.. If there's a "make a cafe".. Proposal 3: No.. If there's a "claim an android" (I remember there's a club like that too).. Proposal 4: [Not voting] Proposal 5: Yes.. It hasn't been done before.. Proposal 6: Yes.. It hasn't been done before too.. Proposal 7: [Not voting] Proposal 8: No.. *points to Penguin-Musume's reason* Proposal 9: Yes.. It hasn't been done before.. Proposal 10: No.. Another hair-related claim.. (x_x) Proposal 11: No.. *points to Leinel's reason* |
| made it to on today, don't tell anyone._. ok: Proposal 1:Take away character's item this is my idea, so i don't think i can actually vote on this, but i think that i can explane why it is NOT like accessory/wepon claim. well, glasses, shoes, pens, bags, are those things accessorys? not really=3 Proposal 2: Open a restaurant VERY OLD IDEA... i added it before the cafe thing was around. so the club you say is a duplicate of this ideaXP Proposal 3: Claim a robot/cyborg) i am not voting for my own ideas since all of them are yes, however i figured there is such a club so please ignore this idea. Proposal 4: Club Name:Claim a person with a strange obsession -this is cofe's idea so i can vote, yes. because strange people with strange obssesions are super-cool, and i can think of a few cool people that can be claimed there' and people may like this club=3 Proposal 5: Claim a lesbian my own Proposal 6: Claim a gay my own Proposal 7: Claim a Childhood(?) Memory/Flashback i am not sure i understood this idea so clearly, but it seems pretty cool and original. so i say yes=3 Proposal 8: Claim a Pirate sure!!! this is agood and original idea, and i don't see why it shuldn't be approved^.^ Proposal 9: Claim an Officer cool idea, original, so yes. Proposal 10: Claim a Twin-Tailed Character this idea was one of my lost ideas, and it bothers me that when i posted it it was deleted, but anyway yes because i wanted this club very much._. Proposal 11: Claim a scary character cool idea, and i like it, however total-sempai said it's like the shoet and shy thing. i say yes for this, but i don't think that it will be good for the ufcc to approve it and not to approve the others (it's like braking your own rules.) if you count my vote for my own ideas then yes for all (but not the syborg thing, please delete it because takuya and rena sayd theres a andruid club. i am not sure when i posted this idea so i can't tell... anyway ignore this.) |
♥  |
| Proposal 4: No, too much like 'claim an otaku' and strange isn't very specific. Proposal 5: Although the title sounds a bit offensive (to me at least), it hasn't been done before so yes. Proposal 6: ^ Proposal 7: Yes it's an interesting and original idea (plus I really want to claim from here >.>) |
 |
| I've been told that all claim clubs are "Claim a character" with restrictions, so that can't be used as reason to deny them. I disagree with that (there is still a lot of ways to make an original claim club without just adding restrictions to "Claim a character") - thus I'd vote No on proposals 4, 5 and 6, but I'll vote without thinking of them as duplicates of "Claim a character". Proposal 4: Yes, there's only "Claim an Anime Otaku" club, thare are a lot more obsessions that aren't cover by that. Proposal 5: Yes, haven't seen a club letting that kind of characters to be claimed. Proposal 6: Yes, haven't seen a club letting that kind of characters to be claimed. Proposal 7: Yes, it's original, haven't seen anything like that before. |
nozetsuDec 14, 2008 7:02 PM
Momo-Hime said: Proposal 4: No, too much like 'claim an otaku' and strange isn't very specific. Proposal 5: Although the title sounds a bit offensive (to me at least), it hasn't been done before so yes. Proposal 6: ^ Proposal 7: Yes it's an interesting and original idea (plus I really want to claim from here >.>) 4-whatOo? (haruka asked) 5,6:lots of people said that it sounds "offendive". WTH? why shuld it be? am i missing something? i know it was approved alredy but i still wonder._...... so is haruka's idea approved? 8 people said yes, almost all those who said no said it is because it's similar to otaku and this idea has nothing to do with otaku and i posted it for her a LONG LONG LONG time before the otaku club was posted as an ideaOo... she really wants to know and she kinda bothers me about it._. |
♥ |
More topics from this board
» Current Clubs ( 1 2 )Islaya - Oct 5, 2008 |
83 |
by villains
»»
May 31, 2009 2:43 AM |
|
Sticky: » Post Club Ideas Here! (no discussions) ( 1 2 3 4 5 )BenjoKun - Oct 9, 2008 |
233 |
by Ginaz
»»
May 26, 2009 6:57 AM |
|
» Approval Vote: Club IdeasFreedomWingz - Mar 18, 2009 |
1 |
by Loxaris
»»
Mar 23, 2009 3:11 PM |
|
» Approval Vote: Club Ideasnozetsu - Feb 4, 2009 |
14 |
by nozetsu
»»
Feb 10, 2009 2:42 PM |
|
» Banlist Remake - Voting *CLOSED*nozetsu - Feb 1, 2009 |
26 |
by Hime-sama
»»
Feb 4, 2009 3:52 PM |