Everything wrong with Tenki no Ko

Mar 17, 2023 8:57 PM

Offline

Oct 2021

350

I should preface this with a couple of warnings:
> MAJOR SPOILERS FOR EVERY PART OF THIS MOVIE AHEAD
> It’s fine if you liked this movie, I’m not here to judge, but I will be breaking down every inconsistency I have noticed throughout my two watches.
> I don’t hate Makoto Shinkai as a director, in fact, I loved Kimi no Na wa so much that it’s one of my few 10/10 ratings on MAL.
> This is by no means a conclusive list, nor is is it professionally written (this is definitely a pure rant on my part).

(Almost) everything wrong with Tenki no Ko:

THE MCDONALDS AD
Why did Hina get fired? She said it wasn’t because of the free burger, but never actually explains why.
Hina leaving her DYING MOTHER’S bedside to go on top of a random building just because it had some light shining on it.
Where are the security guards? Was nobody concerned about this teenager going into a condemned building ALONE? Don’t tell me nobody was around, IT’S SET IN THE HEART OF TOKYO, THE MOST POPULATED CITY ON EARTH.
Hodaka supposedly has a troubled home-life, having unexplained bandages at the beginning, but that’s never elaborated on. Moreover, after returning home at the end, he seems to have been just fine living there for a few more years.
When the two idiots fly above the clouds, forget the need for oxygen I guess!
Hina is both a horrible sister and friend, willingly sacrificing herself and leaving her little brother (who had already lost so many people) with NO FAMILY! Not only that, but she’s also dumping the burden of raising him on Hodaka.
Nobody IN THE ENTIRE CITY OF TOKYO saw either of them flying into the sky? Really?
Hina’s gradual transformation…. THAT ISN’T HOW WATER WORKS.
The “sky realm” isn’t elaborated on AT ALL.
Don’t even get me started on their “100% sunshine girl” business, are no scientists (particularly meteorologists) concerned about this? IT WAS ON NATIONAL TELEVISION!
The business doesn’t have a license.
Why is a sacrifice even necessary?
In the modern world, is this weather maiden mess happening in other cities? If so, why is nobody talking about or trying to fix this? If not, why Tokyo and why now?
So, have pilots just never bothered to look down and notice the ENTIRE REALM ON TOP OF THE CLOUDS? Don’t tell me that normal people can’t see it, because Hodaka can very well see and interact with it.
How are they standing ON TOP OF CLOUDS!? CLOUDS ARE MADE OF WATER. YOU CANNOT STAND ON A CLOUD LIKE IT’S A FLUFFY PILLOW.
The side plot about the gun for some reason.
WHY WAS A FULLY LOADED GUN JUST IN THE TRASH CAN!?
The side plot about that random guy which takes up like half the movie and has nothing to do with the main points.
The timeline errors which retroactively ruin the consistency of an actually good movie (Kimi no Na wa.).
The fact that the water starts floating in mid air and nobody else cares (IS EVERYONE IN THIS CITY BLIND!?).
Hina getting a random ability to strike lighting when she’s mad, but that never comes back later.
How and why can Hodaka enter the shrine thing to fly? I thought only the weather maiden had that ability. If that’s the case, why has nobody else discovered this in the years this thing has been around?
When Hina makes the sacrifice and turns into ‘water’, why on earth do her clothes and hair ties stay on but the ring falls off? Is it a plot contrivance, or is that outfit molded into her body?
So, did she just stop being the Weather Maiden at the end? Is that how this works?
Why is it still raining? Can’t the system pick another weather maiden or is the area just ruined forever now?
If that’s the case, does that mean EVERY SINGLE past weather maiden ever made the sacrifice? If not, other places in the world would be constantly flooded like this too, but that isn’t mentioned.
Why on earth are so many people still living in raintopia Tokyo after three years?

Mar 17, 2023 9:08 PM

Jellyeon

Offline

Apr 2022

Atsunome said:
I should preface this with a couple of warnings:
> MAJOR SPOILERS FOR EVERY PART OF THIS MOVIE AHEAD
> It’s fine if you liked this movie, I’m not here to judge, but I will be breaking down every inconsistency I have noticed throughout my two watches.
> I don’t hate Makoto Shinkai as a director, in fact, I loved Kimi no Na wa so much that it’s one of my few 10/10 ratings on MAL.
> This is by no means a conclusive list, nor is is it professionally written (this is definitely a pure rant on my part).

(Almost) everything wrong with Tenki no Ko:

THE MCDONALDS AD
Why did Hina get fired? She said it wasn’t because of the free burger, but never actually explains why.
Hina leaving her DYING MOTHER’S bedside to go on top of a random building just because it had some light shining on it.
Where are the security guards? Was nobody concerned about this teenager going into a condemned building ALONE? Don’t tell me nobody was around, IT’S SET IN THE HEART OF TOKYO, THE MOST POPULATED CITY ON EARTH.
Hodaka supposedly has a troubled home-life, having unexplained bandages at the beginning, but that’s never elaborated on. Moreover, after returning home at the end, he seems to have been just fine living there for a few more years.
When the two idiots fly above the clouds, forget the need for oxygen I guess!
Hina is both a horrible sister and friend, willingly sacrificing herself and leaving her little brother (who had already lost so many people) with NO FAMILY! Not only that, but she’s also dumping the burden of raising him on Hodaka.
Nobody IN THE ENTIRE CITY OF TOKYO saw either of them flying into the sky? Really?
Hina’s gradual transformation…. THAT ISN’T HOW WATER WORKS.
The “sky realm” isn’t elaborated on AT ALL.
Don’t even get me started on their “100% sunshine girl” business, are no scientists (particularly meteorologists) concerned about this? IT WAS ON NATIONAL TELEVISION!
The business doesn’t have a license.
Why is a sacrifice even necessary?
In the modern world, is this weather maiden mess happening in other cities? If so, why is nobody talking about or trying to fix this? If not, why Tokyo and why now?
So, have pilots just never bothered to look down and notice the ENTIRE REALM ON TOP OF THE CLOUDS? Don’t tell me that normal people can’t see it, because Hodaka can very well see and interact with it.
How are they standing ON TOP OF CLOUDS!? CLOUDS ARE MADE OF WATER. YOU CANNOT STAND ON A CLOUD LIKE IT’S A FLUFFY PILLOW.
The side plot about the gun for some reason.
WHY WAS A FULLY LOADED GUN JUST IN THE TRASH CAN!?
The side plot about that random guy which takes up like half the movie and has nothing to do with the main points.
The timeline errors which retroactively ruin the consistency of an actually good movie (Kimi no Na wa.).
The fact that the water starts floating in mid air and nobody else cares (IS EVERYONE IN THIS CITY BLIND!?).
Hina getting a random ability to strike lighting when she’s mad, but that never comes back later.
How and why can Hodaka enter the shrine thing to fly? I thought only the weather maiden had that ability. If that’s the case, why has nobody else discovered this in the years this thing has been around?
When Hina makes the sacrifice and turns into ‘water’, why on earth do her clothes and hair ties stay on but the ring falls off? Is it a plot contrivance, or is that outfit molded into her body?
So, did she just stop being the Weather Maiden at the end? Is that how this works?
Why is it still raining? Can’t the system pick another weather maiden or is the area just ruined forever now?
If that’s the case, does that mean EVERY SINGLE past weather maiden ever made the sacrifice? If not, other places in the world would be constantly flooded like this too, but that isn’t mentioned.
Why on earth are so many people still living in raintopia Tokyo after three years?

Relax. I think its a pretty solid movie i would say

Mar 17, 2023 9:09 PM

K7N6

Offline

Mar 2023

your gripes

McDonalds ads

no oxygen in the air

people not seeing them fly

her transformation and how that isn't how water works
P.S. the entire film isnt suppose to be super realistic obviously and it's methorphical and uses heavy Japanese culture influences. So if you don't know Japanese culture well and what they believe in and their ideals this is gunna fly over your head

alot of your criticisms are childish if I'm being honest

Mar 17, 2023 9:16 PM

lFrogs

Offline

Sep 2021

225

Jellyeon said:

(Almost) everything wrong with Tenki no Ko:

THE MCDONALDS AD
Why did Hina get fired? She said it wasn’t because of the free burger, but never actually explains why.
Hina leaving her DYING MOTHER’S bedside to go on top of a random building just because it had some light shining on it.
Where are the security guards? Was nobody concerned about this teenager going into a condemned building ALONE? Don’t tell me nobody was around, IT’S SET IN THE HEART OF TOKYO, THE MOST POPULATED CITY ON EARTH.
Hodaka supposedly has a troubled home-life, having unexplained bandages at the beginning, but that’s never elaborated on. Moreover, after returning home at the end, he seems to have been just fine living there for a few more years.
When the two idiots fly above the clouds, forget the need for oxygen I guess!
Hina is both a horrible sister and friend, willingly sacrificing herself and leaving her little brother (who had already lost so many people) with NO FAMILY! Not only that, but she’s also dumping the burden of raising him on Hodaka.
Nobody IN THE ENTIRE CITY OF TOKYO saw either of them flying into the sky? Really?
Hina’s gradual transformation…. THAT ISN’T HOW WATER WORKS.
The “sky realm” isn’t elaborated on AT ALL.
Don’t even get me started on their “100% sunshine girl” business, are no scientists (particularly meteorologists) concerned about this? IT WAS ON NATIONAL TELEVISION!
The business doesn’t have a license.
Why is a sacrifice even necessary?
In the modern world, is this weather maiden mess happening in other cities? If so, why is nobody talking about or trying to fix this? If not, why Tokyo and why now?
So, have pilots just never bothered to look down and notice the ENTIRE REALM ON TOP OF THE CLOUDS? Don’t tell me that normal people can’t see it, because Hodaka can very well see and interact with it.
How are they standing ON TOP OF CLOUDS!? CLOUDS ARE MADE OF WATER. YOU CANNOT STAND ON A CLOUD LIKE IT’S A FLUFFY PILLOW.
The side plot about the gun for some reason.
WHY WAS A FULLY LOADED GUN JUST IN THE TRASH CAN!?
The side plot about that random guy which takes up like half the movie and has nothing to do with the main points.
The timeline errors which retroactively ruin the consistency of an actually good movie (Kimi no Na wa.).
The fact that the water starts floating in mid air and nobody else cares (IS EVERYONE IN THIS CITY BLIND!?).
Hina getting a random ability to strike lighting when she’s mad, but that never comes back later.
How and why can Hodaka enter the shrine thing to fly? I thought only the weather maiden had that ability. If that’s the case, why has nobody else discovered this in the years this thing has been around?
When Hina makes the sacrifice and turns into ‘water’, why on earth do her clothes and hair ties stay on but the ring falls off? Is it a plot contrivance, or is that outfit molded into her body?
So, did she just stop being the Weather Maiden at the end? Is that how this works?
Why is it still raining? Can’t the system pick another weather maiden or is the area just ruined forever now?
If that’s the case, does that mean EVERY SINGLE past weather maiden ever made the sacrifice? If not, other places in the world would be constantly flooded like this too, but that isn’t mentioned.
Why on earth are so many people still living in raintopia Tokyo after three years?

Relax. I think its a pretty solid movie i would say

bro you totally misunderstand the point of criticism or this thread

Mar 17, 2023 9:18 PM

KanataX

Offline

Oct 2022

370

is this guy really trying to correlate a fictional fantasy to real life you can't be serious?😭 next my guy is gonna say humans can't fly so that's a fault as well

Mar 17, 2023 9:19 PM

Hearts__

Offline

Oct 2022

TBH i never really liked this movie that much, i just watched this and i was like meh..

To answer some of your questions based on my perspective, this story was like a forced one to just focus on the MC and Hina and didn't really put that much effort into side details because well come on this is a 1hr 30mins movie and you can't do that much in this timespan. The story progressed a bit faster(i think) and that'a another proof that this has short timespan.

The tokyo that's portrayed here is a somewhst corrupted one, for example like a cyberpunk city (except remove all the hyper technology stuff like flying cars..). To put it simply, people are corrupted. So the use of guns has increased and maybe someone who used it just threw it in the dustbin, maybe because they were running away from the cops and just wanted to hide it.. the other questions can be answered like this if you were to think a bit creatively(or stupidly)..

Also about the man who took like half screen time, he does have a bit of plot like him having a wife and child and the wife passing away and stuff, well things need to happen for the story to progress you know like i said "Forced story, mainly focused on MC and Hina"

Seeking logic in a fictional movie isn't going to work.. yes somethings you said didn't really make any sense but there are a lot of fictional animes and movies out there which, if you were to compare with RL, doesn't make any sense whatsoever. You know, you just have to enjoy it cause you can't experience it.

Hearts__Mar 17, 2023 9:23 PM

Mar 17, 2023 9:41 PM

Jellyeon

Offline

Apr 2022

lFrogs said:

Jellyeon said:

(Almost) everything wrong with Tenki no Ko:

THE MCDONALDS AD
Why did Hina get fired? She said it wasn’t because of the free burger, but never actually explains why.
Hina leaving her DYING MOTHER’S bedside to go on top of a random building just because it had some light shining on it.
Where are the security guards? Was nobody concerned about this teenager going into a condemned building ALONE? Don’t tell me nobody was around, IT’S SET IN THE HEART OF TOKYO, THE MOST POPULATED CITY ON EARTH.
Hodaka supposedly has a troubled home-life, having unexplained bandages at the beginning, but that’s never elaborated on. Moreover, after returning home at the end, he seems to have been just fine living there for a few more years.
When the two idiots fly above the clouds, forget the need for oxygen I guess!
Hina is both a horrible sister and friend, willingly sacrificing herself and leaving her little brother (who had already lost so many people) with NO FAMILY! Not only that, but she’s also dumping the burden of raising him on Hodaka.
Nobody IN THE ENTIRE CITY OF TOKYO saw either of them flying into the sky? Really?
Hina’s gradual transformation…. THAT ISN’T HOW WATER WORKS.
The “sky realm” isn’t elaborated on AT ALL.
Don’t even get me started on their “100% sunshine girl” business, are no scientists (particularly meteorologists) concerned about this? IT WAS ON NATIONAL TELEVISION!
The business doesn’t have a license.
Why is a sacrifice even necessary?
In the modern world, is this weather maiden mess happening in other cities? If so, why is nobody talking about or trying to fix this? If not, why Tokyo and why now?
So, have pilots just never bothered to look down and notice the ENTIRE REALM ON TOP OF THE CLOUDS? Don’t tell me that normal people can’t see it, because Hodaka can very well see and interact with it.
How are they standing ON TOP OF CLOUDS!? CLOUDS ARE MADE OF WATER. YOU CANNOT STAND ON A CLOUD LIKE IT’S A FLUFFY PILLOW.
The side plot about the gun for some reason.
WHY WAS A FULLY LOADED GUN JUST IN THE TRASH CAN!?
The side plot about that random guy which takes up like half the movie and has nothing to do with the main points.
The timeline errors which retroactively ruin the consistency of an actually good movie (Kimi no Na wa.).
The fact that the water starts floating in mid air and nobody else cares (IS EVERYONE IN THIS CITY BLIND!?).
Hina getting a random ability to strike lighting when she’s mad, but that never comes back later.
How and why can Hodaka enter the shrine thing to fly? I thought only the weather maiden had that ability. If that’s the case, why has nobody else discovered this in the years this thing has been around?
When Hina makes the sacrifice and turns into ‘water’, why on earth do her clothes and hair ties stay on but the ring falls off? Is it a plot contrivance, or is that outfit molded into her body?
So, did she just stop being the Weather Maiden at the end? Is that how this works?
Why is it still raining? Can’t the system pick another weather maiden or is the area just ruined forever now?
If that’s the case, does that mean EVERY SINGLE past weather maiden ever made the sacrifice? If not, other places in the world would be constantly flooded like this too, but that isn’t mentioned.
Why on earth are so many people still living in raintopia Tokyo after three years?

Relax. I think its a pretty solid movie i would say

bro you totally misunderstand the point of criticism or this thread

I know, but im not into that kind of thing where people actually watch it on 0.25 speed just to get that every single detail of the movie.

Im just gonna say this. I watched the movie, even though the plot is soo random such as hodaka coincidentally found a gun in trash bin.

Its a movie that plot the whole story.
And the whole story is purely a plotted imaginary from the author himself. All i can do is observe it.

Im saying random skidaddle bcoz of how the first thread just jump in so randomly so basically
Just random things mixed up

Mar 17, 2023 9:42 PM

ktg

Offline

May 2016

1682

I thought it will be an interesting, objective read, but it was stupid and childish.

Just because YOU can't explain something, it doesn't mean it's inconsistency.

To be inconsistent, you have to name 2 moments and compare those.
What you worth here is plot conveniences, which are not exactly problems.

EDIT: I mean your points have more inconsistency than the film has.

ktgMar 17, 2023 11:05 PM

Mar 17, 2023 10:07 PM

bradyc_16

Offline

Aug 2021

Good movie, but every time there was a problem in this movie, it was resolved in literally a few minutes. Characters were good but the impact isn’t as impactful as your name.

Mar 17, 2023 10:28 PM

#10

lalHD68

Offline

Jan 2021

don't remember 90% of the movie tbh

Mar 17, 2023 10:31 PM

#11

VilexRoss

Offline

Aug 2020

353

for me the ending makes no sense.
what is the massage?
we should not try to control global warming?

𝕾𝖕𝖊𝖆𝖐 𝕾𝖔𝖋𝖙𝖑𝖞, 𝕷𝖔𝖛𝖊

Mar 17, 2023 11:07 PM

#12

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

ktg said:
I thought it will be an interesting, objective read, but it was stupid and childish.

Just because YOU can't explain something, it doesn't mean it's inconsistency.

To be inconsistent, you have to name 2 moments and compare those.
What you worth here is plot conveniences, which are not exactly problems.

EDIT: I mean your points have more inconsistency than the film has.

If the viewer is unable to comprehend and or enjoy the plot of a movie, the entire point of having a piece of entertainment has failed.

Mar 17, 2023 11:17 PM

#13

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

I’m trying to quote people but this system doesn’t seem to work :/

Mar 17, 2023 11:20 PM

#14

ktg

Offline

May 2016

1682

Atsunome said:

If the viewer is unable to comprehend and or enjoy the plot of a movie, the entire point of having a piece of entertainment has failed.

First, no, certain movies are made for certain people with different intellectual level. And I'm not necessarily talking about smart people. It's even true for stupid people, like fart jokes are not funny above a certain intellectual level.
Second, no, because most people enjoyed it as the score shows.

You are minority here, so every argument when you try to legitimate your point by talking about majority, average or generality, is a fallacy.

Mar 17, 2023 11:21 PM

#15

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

K7N6 said:
your gripes

McDonalds ads

no oxygen in the air

people not seeing them fly

her transformation and how that isn't how water works
P.S. the entire film isnt suppose to be super realistic obviously and it's methorphical and uses heavy Japanese culture influences. So if you don't know Japanese culture well and what they believe in and their ideals this is gunna fly over your head

alot of your criticisms are childish if I'm being honest

As I said at the beginning, I love Kimi no Na wa and all of the symbolism it includes. This is because that movie is able to construct and describe a proper narrative without any outside knowledge needed (it perfectly relates the flow of the cords and time back to the main story). Tenki no Ko fails in every single aspect of that, unable to even stick to one motif and elaborate in a way that allows viewers to understand.

Mar 17, 2023 11:22 PM

#16

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

Jellyeon said:

lFrogs said:

Jellyeon said:

(Almost) everything wrong with Tenki no Ko:

THE MCDONALDS AD
Why did Hina get fired? She said it wasn’t because of the free burger, but never actually explains why.
Hina leaving her DYING MOTHER’S bedside to go on top of a random building just because it had some light shining on it.
Where are the security guards? Was nobody concerned about this teenager going into a condemned building ALONE? Don’t tell me nobody was around, IT’S SET IN THE HEART OF TOKYO, THE MOST POPULATED CITY ON EARTH.
Hodaka supposedly has a troubled home-life, having unexplained bandages at the beginning, but that’s never elaborated on. Moreover, after returning home at the end, he seems to have been just fine living there for a few more years.
When the two idiots fly above the clouds, forget the need for oxygen I guess!
Hina is both a horrible sister and friend, willingly sacrificing herself and leaving her little brother (who had already lost so many people) with NO FAMILY! Not only that, but she’s also dumping the burden of raising him on Hodaka.
Nobody IN THE ENTIRE CITY OF TOKYO saw either of them flying into the sky? Really?
Hina’s gradual transformation…. THAT ISN’T HOW WATER WORKS.
The “sky realm” isn’t elaborated on AT ALL.
Don’t even get me started on their “100% sunshine girl” business, are no scientists (particularly meteorologists) concerned about this? IT WAS ON NATIONAL TELEVISION!
The business doesn’t have a license.
Why is a sacrifice even necessary?
In the modern world, is this weather maiden mess happening in other cities? If so, why is nobody talking about or trying to fix this? If not, why Tokyo and why now?
So, have pilots just never bothered to look down and notice the ENTIRE REALM ON TOP OF THE CLOUDS? Don’t tell me that normal people can’t see it, because Hodaka can very well see and interact with it.
How are they standing ON TOP OF CLOUDS!? CLOUDS ARE MADE OF WATER. YOU CANNOT STAND ON A CLOUD LIKE IT’S A FLUFFY PILLOW.
The side plot about the gun for some reason.
WHY WAS A FULLY LOADED GUN JUST IN THE TRASH CAN!?
The side plot about that random guy which takes up like half the movie and has nothing to do with the main points.
The timeline errors which retroactively ruin the consistency of an actually good movie (Kimi no Na wa.).
The fact that the water starts floating in mid air and nobody else cares (IS EVERYONE IN THIS CITY BLIND!?).
Hina getting a random ability to strike lighting when she’s mad, but that never comes back later.
How and why can Hodaka enter the shrine thing to fly? I thought only the weather maiden had that ability. If that’s the case, why has nobody else discovered this in the years this thing has been around?
When Hina makes the sacrifice and turns into ‘water’, why on earth do her clothes and hair ties stay on but the ring falls off? Is it a plot contrivance, or is that outfit molded into her body?
So, did she just stop being the Weather Maiden at the end? Is that how this works?
Why is it still raining? Can’t the system pick another weather maiden or is the area just ruined forever now?
If that’s the case, does that mean EVERY SINGLE past weather maiden ever made the sacrifice? If not, other places in the world would be constantly flooded like this too, but that isn’t mentioned.
Why on earth are so many people still living in raintopia Tokyo after three years?

Relax. I think its a pretty solid movie i would say

bro you totally misunderstand the point of criticism or this thread

I didn’t slow the movie down at all, and I’ve actually only watched it twice. As I said, there is likely a lot more I missed and this is just scratching the surface.

Mar 17, 2023 11:23 PM

#17

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

KanataX said:
is this guy really trying to correlate a fictional fantasy to real life you can't be serious?😭 next my guy is gonna say humans can't fly so that's a fault as well

I literally said that I liked Kimi no Na wa, which also includes fantasy elements. Not only that, but I’m generally a fan of well-done fantasy shows and movies. It’s the poor execution and nearly non-existent explanations in Tenki no Ko that make it a terribly written movie.

Mar 17, 2023 11:36 PM

#18

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

ktg said:

Atsunome said:

If the viewer is unable to comprehend and or enjoy the plot of a movie, the entire point of having a piece of entertainment has failed.

Tell me, then, can you explain the lore of Tenki no Ko?

Secondly, I never talked about the majority, I said ‘the’ as a way to describe myself and a few other people who share the same thoughts.

Tying back to the first post in this chain, calling an argument ‘childish’ is an opinion backed up by nothing.

Mar 17, 2023 11:57 PM

#19

KanataX

Offline

Oct 2022

370

Atsunome said:

KanataX said:
is this guy really trying to correlate a fictional fantasy to real life you can't be serious?😭 next my guy is gonna say humans can't fly so that's a fault as well

idk how you pointing out things like McDonald's ad,them breathing over clouds with no o2 even standing on clouds,buisness not having licence,how water works among others then expect me to believe you're a fan of the fantasy genre yea sure,idk how any of this need an explanation in a fictional world?

Mar 18, 2023 12:11 AM

#20

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

KanataX said:

Atsunome said:

Fantasy only really works to immerse the audience when the lore points are explained within the selected media. If the producers of Tenki no Ko has put even an ounce of effort into having one of the characters state WHY they are able to breathe with so little oxygen, walk on the clouds (can anyone do that? Are they special for some reason? Just provide an answer!) or how the water in THIS VERSION OF THE WORLD works (if you make something new up, you need to explain how and why it functions the way it does) it would have been much better.

Sure, the business thing might have been a nitpick (still my opinion), but the other points still stand. As for the McDonald’s ad, I personally find it to be a slap in the face to subtly and artistic value (Kimi no Na wa has an ad for Boss, but they handled it in such a way that it didn’t blatantly take me out of the movie).

Mar 18, 2023 12:45 AM

#21

KanataX

Offline

Oct 2022

370

Atsunome said:

KanataX said:

i mean if you need an explanation for those ig you need explanation for how they're able to fly as well as i previously stated?or how a random girl is able to control weather suddenly,the movie is by no means a perfect movie there's too many imperfections but the people involved in it assume those that are gonna watch this have the capability to differentiate fiction and real life i got nothing else to say

Mar 18, 2023 12:55 AM

#22

Atsunome

Offline

Oct 2021

350

Alright, this thread is getting a bit wild so I’ll be heading off now.

I won’t be responding to anything after this.

Let’s agree to disagree with our opinions.

Mar 18, 2023 1:00 AM

#23

souraia

Offline

Aug 2022

316

im not gonna lie, most, if not all of this list is just childish and/or petty complaints for a very good movie

Mar 18, 2023 4:05 AM

#24

bkacpii

Offline

Jun 2022

VilexRoss said:
for me the ending makes no sense.
what is the massage?
we should not try to control global warming?

Yes we should return to oceans

Mar 18, 2023 5:00 AM

#25

Piromysl

Online

Jul 2015

11253

That's some serious nitpicking right there.

Mar 18, 2023 5:02 AM

#26

K7N6

Offline

Mar 2023

Atsunome said:

if you love the symbolism in your name then how does the same level of symbolism that's displayed in weathering with you made by the same guy fly right over your head and you reduce it to the most simplified thing?

Mar 18, 2023 5:22 AM

#27

Steph

• Mafumafu Fan •

Offline

Apr 2018

675

Thread locked for not encouraging discussion.

Anime Discussion Rules 2: Please refrain from creating threads that do not encourage discussion.

• AMQ: StephWeeb
• Discord: drsteph
• Join me on AnimeMusicQuiz!

See All Discussions

Poll: » Tenki no Ko Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) -Stray - Jul 18, 2019	383	by Myetx »» Mar 9, 3:16 AM
» Am I wrong here? I loved it Hrusi - Mar 16, 2020	32	by DFrench125 »» Oct 21, 2023 8:23 AM
» kimi no na wa and tenki no ko is connected ?! nanatshi - May 28, 2020	12	by elGatoGordo06 »» Apr 11, 2023 11:45 PM
» What did you guys think of weathering with you? cauthecow793 - Sep 9, 2020	19	by Atsunome »» Mar 13, 2023 5:50 PM
» Did anyone spotted Yotsuha Miyamizu (Mitsuha's little sister)???? IvenDOCson - Jun 17, 2021	5	by Dutch_Chief »» Mar 11, 2023 4:05 AM

Everything wrong with Tenki no Ko

More topics from this board

Poll: » Tenki no Ko Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» Am I wrong here? I loved it

» kimi no na wa and tenki no ko is connected ?!

» What did you guys think of weathering with you?

» Did anyone spotted Yotsuha Miyamizu (Mitsuha's little sister)????

Preview MangaManga Store

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters