My Youth Romantic Comedy Is Wrong, As I Expected (light novel)
| Basically all you gotta know is that Yui wanted to keep their feelings towards Hikigaya on hold and have the relationship they have continuing. Yukinoshita was about to accept but Hikigaya declines for her because that kind of fake relationship isn't what Hikigaya wants ( He wants the genuine/true/real thing ) and wanted Yukinoshita to decide for herself and solve the problems herself. Yui wanted everything just like she said, however she ultimately knows she can't attain everything without losing something which is shown and told. I don't know if Yui said the whole "lets keep this relationship on hold" thing while knowing that Hikigaya would reject it (just like the said "I knew you would say that") but I'm sure she was okay with whatever that was going to happen imo. We pretty much can assume that the trio all know how their relationship is towards each other and at this point is where the anime is cut off. |
 "If I don't have to do it, I won't. If I have to do it, I'll make it quick." -Oreki Houtarou |
| This is just my interpretation so take it with a grain of salt. 1.Hachiman put labels onto people because it's then easy for him to characterize people and their interactions. Yui, as he labeled was a nice girl and Yukinon is a strong willed girl. But as he finds out Yukinon has her share of problems, specifically when standing up for herself and creating her own path and decisions. Yui however will use means that may be deemed inappropriate to further her own agenda. Like when she said I'll take everything it most likely meant that she gets to control the way the club will go on form then and gets the first shot at Hachiman's love. 2.Hachiman as he stated doesn't want bonds that aren't real and are just there because the can be he wants something genuine. 3. So when Yui offers to pretty much handle Yukinon's problems Hachiman rejects this because it goes against what he feels is right. As he said somebody shouldn't chose someone else's life for them so he was to some degree disgusted with Yui and Yukinon. So the finale ended off with us getting Yukinon's request and them choosing to help her but not make any key decisions. Yui more or less got her feelings across and Hachiman is happy that they are going into a direction where something genuine is possible even though it may end up hurting all three of them. |
| Big Order (TV):great anime or greatest anime? |
bobzanny said: 1.Hachiman put labels onto people because it's then easy for him to characterize people and their interactions. Yui, as he labeled was a nice girl and Yukinon is a strong willed girl. But as he finds out Yukinon has her share of problems, specifically when standing up for herself and creating her own path and decisions. Yui however will use means that may be deemed inappropriate to further her own agenda. Like when she said I'll take everything it most likely meant that she gets to control the way the club will go on form then and gets the first shot at Hachiman's love. 2.Hachiman as he stated doesn't want bonds that aren't real and are just there because the can be he wants something genuine. 3. So when Yui offers to pretty much handle Yukinon's problems Hachiman rejects this because it goes against what he feels is right. As he said somebody shouldn't chose someone else's life for them so he was to some degree disgusted with Yui and Yukinon. Yeah don't forget though, Yui told Hachiman "I thought you'd say that". Yui also wanted Yukino to make her own decisions. That's why she stared so intently at Yukino fighting for a response. I believe there's a reason she invited Both of them out and initiated that conversation. She knew Yukino wouldn't make her own choice (she was about to say "I wouldn't mind that" but Hachiman isn't the type to stay silent, and he didn't, opening Yukino's eyes in the process. Yui stated she wants it all. Her friendship and the guy, but she already knows it's not possible. Basically, she was making effort to bring it up to Yukino who just "goes with the flow" and feigns ignorance when it comes to those things. |
| - Yui is going to start being competitive over Hikki's love with Yukinon - Yui calls everyone out on a "group date" as "one last hurrah" with everyone together as they have been before she starts taking the aggressive approach - Yui wants to win the bet that took place at the beginning of season one where whoever solves the most challenges gets to ask whoever to do whatever - Yui wants to win so she can ask Hikki to go out with her - Yui knows that Yukinon really really wants the trio to stay together, and so Yui asks her if it's okay to do that - Thus, this makes Yui really unfair and deceiving since she knows Yukinon won't be able to say "no" to her - When Yukinon is about to say "yes" (really her only option), Hikki steps in since he notices Yukinon being unable to speak for herself - He doesn't agree that it's okay for a bet to determine what someone can and cannot do - If Yui wins the bet and does with it what she plans to do, Yukinon won't be able to tell Hikki her feelings, so that is why Hikki is against this (since she wouldn't be able to do what she wanted, which is unfair. It's like controlling someone's options in life, which Hikki definitely doesn't agree with) - Yukinon says "this isn't the final anything" since they still have to do Hikki's request. They still need to find something genuine. She wants them to all still stay together regardless of what relationships they may have currently or in the future - Yukinon has a request for the Service Club, but... CLIFFHANGER (she doesn't tell us what the request is) |
 |
DoctorWasabi said: - Yui is going to start being competitive over Hikki's love with Yukinon - Yui calls everyone out on a "group date" as "one last hurrah" with everyone together as they have been before she starts taking the aggressive approach - Yui wants to win the bet that took place at the beginning of season one where whoever solves the most challenges gets to ask whoever to do whatever - Yui wants to win so she can ask Hikki to go out with her - Yui knows that Yukinon really really wants the trio to stay together, and so Yui asks her if it's okay to do that - Thus, this makes Yui really unfair and deceiving since she knows Yukinon won't be able to say "no" to her - When Yukinon is about to say "yes" (really her only option), Hikki steps in since he notices Yukinon being unable to speak for herself - He doesn't agree that it's okay for a bet to determine what someone can and cannot do - If Yui wins the bet and does with it what she plans to do, Yukinon won't be able to tell Hikki her feelings, so that is why Hikki is against this (since she wouldn't be able to do what she wanted, which is unfair. It's like controlling someone's options in life, which Hikki definitely doesn't agree with) - Yukinon says "this isn't the final anything" since they still have to do Hikki's request. They still need to find something genuine. She wants them to all still stay together regardless of what relationships they may have currently or in the future - Yukinon has a request for the Service Club, but... CLIFFHANGER (she doesn't tell us what the request is) Are you guys kidding me? Most of you have the wrong impression of Yui. If she wanted Hikigaya for himself she would have asked only asked him on a date. Her plan was to be the wingman, she knew Hikigaya would step in and stop her "grand scheme" thats why she was smiling and teared at the end. The proposal was meant to be stopped, if Yukinon agreed, it wouldn't have been what Yui wanted. But it was the best thing she could think of, she would have probably backed out if yukinon confessed or gave her chocolate. Part of why Hikigaya stopped this nonsense was because he knew Yui wasn't being true to herself and that she didn't really want what she was saying. Same with Yukino. In short, Yui pulled a Hachiman. In order for any growth to be possible and problems to be resolved there needs to be conflict. And she was the conflict. She was sacrificing herself. It was evident since episode 12, where she refused hikigaya twice because she knew yukinon liked him. She was giving up her feelings in order to let yukinon and hachiman's relationship grow. |
AoiYuukiHusbandoJun 27, 2015 12:28 AM
Dragon0129 said: It's okI kinda understand what they are talking at the end but I kinda don't understand. |
 |
SquirrelKing said: Are you guys kidding me? Most of you have the wrong impression of Yui. If she wanted Hikigaya for himself she would have asked only asked him on a date. Her plan was to be the wingman, she knew Hikigaya would step in and stop her "grand scheme" thats why she was smiling and teared at the end. Part of why Hikigaya stopped this nonsense was because he knew Yui wasn't being true to herself and that she didn't really want what she was saying. Same with Yukino. yes, i said something similar. yui had a reason for saying it with both of them present. |
TyphoonS said: She did not give up her feelings at all from what I can see. She gave cookies to Hachiman IN FRONT of Yukino. That is not something that seems like giving up to me. while saying, "this is just gratitude ----for saving my dog back there, nothing romantic about it----" as much as it was a lie, was i the only one to read that between the lines? (obviously i wasn't the only one, that's just a way to talk) |
 Fixes to make the Profile more bearable after "the Modern★Profile★Update★★Rip★Profile★" |
| Thank you OP for posting this. I have followed this entire season really well until the last 5 minutes or so of this episode, and then I was just confused by all that was left unsaid. It turns out, from this comments in this thread, that I basically comprehended everything. The debate over Yui's true intentions has been valuable though, so I'm really glad I saw this thread and was able to form a fuller opinion of the entire thing (I'm going to lean with the idea that she is pushing Hachiman and Yukino together by creating conflict like Hachi did in the beginning). This show is suffering from some major Shoujo syndrome right now though, like no one is communicating their feelings clearly and it is just a lot of drama over unspoken feelings. I love this generally, but not as a finale!!! I just felt like it needed something more... What a cliffhanger ugh. |
Ahri said: Make out what you will with this, personally I think this is the best way to think about it and to me it sounds pretty spot on to what's currently happening. https://data.archive.moe/board/a/image/1435/39/1435399375898.jpg If there's something that I do disagree with on this post however.. I don't think Yui has given up, after you read her diary then you could see that Hikki means so much more to her than she probably realizes. Conclusion, I really love both of them. I don't want to see either of them get hurt, but I want to see this conclude without an open ending. I can't decide who I want to win. |
Takuan_Soho said: I think you have not read the Light novels. Now i will put some of 8man's monologues from certain scenes that were shown in the anime This show is frustratingly good because the author (and the wonderful job Feel is doing adapating it) makes things as ambiguous as possible. Literally every possibility is potentially true. I am curious about two things, one why did Hachiman accept a "date" with Yui? Second, when Yui was comparing the jellyfish to fireworks and the three were at the window, notice Hachiman's eyes. Who is he looking at? This is the second episode in a row where Hachiman had a memory about something he and Yui did in the past. So on the surface both Yui and Yukino know the other is in love with Hachiman, Yui thinks Hachiman is in love with Yukino, and Yukino is afraid to put herself out. But why? That dependency thing? Is that really the problem with her (and god knows she has a lot of them, what was with the sharks (and why did Yui know to apologize)), but is that the case this time? No, I think what Yukino fears is that Hachiman loves her, but while she likes and greatly respects Hachiman she is not in love with him, in short the cookies were giri not honne chocolate. Why she was afraid to give them to him was because she was afraid he would misunderstand, not as Yui supposed with her just being bashful. There is the strong possibility that Yukino is already in an unrequited love situation (hence her getting sad about the life pair bonding line and why she can't move forward), and would reject Hachiman were he to propose. She knows that if this happens then the three to break up because everyone would feel rejected (Hachiman by Yukino, Yui by Hachiman, and Yukino by the other two), and that is what she is afraid of since they are the first friends she has ever had and the first people she could ever rely on. Hachiman likewise noticed that Yui was about to defer to Yukino, and Hachiman stopped it both because he didn't want that to happen, and because he believes Yukino does like him, or rather is confusing dependence for love (which is why he was so upset when she parroted him when she called her sister). In a nice bit of adapting did anyone notice how when she was looking out the window, to Hachiman it seemed that one of her eyes was staring straight at him? So basically all three of them are misreading the situation, all of them are willing to sacrifice for the others, but there really isn't anything to sacrifice. True? Only Watari knows, but that was what I got after understanding this episode. But I love thinking about all the hints this show has given and trying to figure out how these fit together, only this puzzle can create different designs if you just rearrange the pieces. If this is true then the rest is simple. Yukino loves Hayato, but there is something with her family preventing that from happening (and somehow dogs enter into it). Hayato returns the feelings, but thinks Yukino doesn't. So they are at a standoff, with both thinking the other doesn't like them, and both sacrificing themselves for the other. In other words, the same exact thing as now. History is repeating, and it will be up to Hachiman to prevent that from happening and restore what is right in the universe. Rollercoster scene This scene as well as the expression on 8man's face tells that this had a big impact on him after her request. Now the train scene in volume 10 This scene indicates that he wants to know more about Yukino. Something he has never thought of for any other girl. Now another service club scene in volume 10 Her it's obvious that they were not normal blushes but rather 8man's was actually attracted to her and the same can be said for her. Now the Infirmary scene where you think that it's nothing but normal blush 8man has never thought of Yui like this in the whole series. This moment also tells a lot as he was pretty much describing her every feature while staring at her. This is not a normal blush. I don't know why you are saying that Hachiman feels nothing towards Yukino as all the above scenes prove that he wants to know more about her and is attracted to her. Hachiman accepted Yui's date because he had promised her which is again mentioned in volume 9 and episode 9 as well. I don't know why you think that 8man has feelings for her just because he decided to keep their promise. He can be thinking that it's something he has to fulfill their promise nothing shows that he has romantic feelings for her.Also of course he will remember the fireworks scene. He had watched the fireworks scene with her like 4 to 5 months ago. Just because you remember some scene with someone doesn't mean that you are in love with them. He also remembered the pan-san scene with Yukino as well in their conversation with Yukino after the rollercoster scene. If she fears that 8man loves her and she doesn't have feelings for him then why would she want to give him chocolates after already giving him cookies? also why would she get flustered if she has no feelings for him. Also why would she back off from giving him the chocolates and feel sad for not being able to give them twice? If she has no feelings for him it would be an easy task for her. It's very obvious that she was in panic on how to give it to him and hence was worried when Yui decided to leave. With the mess Yukino is right now why would she want to give chocolates to someone who she doesn't even love ? Please give me some proof that Yukino has unrequited love for Hayato. From volume 1-4 it's proves that she really hates hayato ,even 8man realises that. It proves that something happened between them and Hayato hurt her in the past. Her thanking him for being considerate of her proves that she is actually over him and is moving forward. If she has no feelings for 8man then would she get worried whrn haruno mentioned that Yukino gave Hayato chocolates/cookies in the past and look at 8man's reaction? By your logic she should feel happy that Haruno is helping her in making Hayato remember the past event. Also by the end of Volume 11 8man is aware of Yukino's dependancy issues. But he also knows that she can face her problems all she needs is some encouragement. 8man even says that Yukino is a strong girl. You are saying that Yukino left them alone in the penguine scene because she has feelings for Hayato? It rather seems that she know that she is a mess right now and is a third wheel on their date. Also she might be thinking that she doesn't deserve 8man as by that point it's pretty obvious that she knows that Yui has feelings for 8man. Also even though she left the two alone 8man still went to her. If he loves Yui then why did he go after Yukino she even said that she will be inside. By your logic their would be no reason for him to go after Yukino. Also the most important point why was Yukino so sad when Yui asked her to agree with her. It's obvious that she was at her breaking point. If she has no feelings for 8man she would have said to Yui to go after 8man. Considering the mess she is right now it would have easy for her to avoid any unnecessary love traingle. Also if she loves Hayato then why would she get mad at him for calling her by first name? Throughout the series(i am talking about LN) 8man has shown growing interest in Yukino and feels attracted to her. He wants to know more about her. Yukino's actions by no means show her being in love with hayato but rather her getting over him and their issue. I think your imagination is going wild as the hints in LN proves something else. |
| So the show ended and I still haven't figured out what's up with the idiotic vague dialogues. |
smegmarta said: So the show ended and I still haven't figured out what's up with the idiotic vague dialogues. HAHAHAHA okay Try to solve it by yourself its more fun in that way, I'll just give you something Clues Yui Love Hikki Yukino Love Hikki Yui want to date Hikki and Maintain the friendship Yui maked a moved first Because if she didnt, who will? |
 |
Takuan_Soho said: If that's what the author is doing, then Iroha should be the end girl xDDCutePriest said: 8man has never thought of Yui like this in the whole series. I had been in the Yukino camp up until this episode, but there was a flashback around the 3:35 mark of last episode that started me thinking that Watari is fooling us by downplaying Yui too much previously, the flashback this episode (remembering the fireworks) and the final scene is what pushed me into the Yui camp. So the above scenes from the novels I know very well, and yes they suggest that Yukino and Hachiman have been slowly falling in love with the other, but where is the "Screw Up" in that? If Yukino is the end goal, then this will have been a pretty normal rom com: two people meet, they initially don't like each other, but slowly over time their feelings change. Don't you think Watari is better than that? His title promised us more. So I wouldn't say my theory above is based on imagination as much as it is based on suspicion. Anime Haganai spoiler: |
| I think EVERYone has their own thoughts on this episode but for me the explanation given on the reddit forum (Link below) matchedthe most with the summary of this Final Episode. http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/3b9vw5/spoilers_yahari_ore_no_seishun_love_comedy_wa/csk8897 |
liveanime said: I think EVERYone has their own thoughts on this episode but for me the explanation given on the reddit forum (Link below) matchedthe most with the summary of this Final Episode. http://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/3b9vw5/spoilers_yahari_ore_no_seishun_love_comedy_wa/csk8897 Yeah, i have seen this link before, the O. post and some of the replies are a very good read. Although they missed something, when Yukinon left Hikki and Yui alone, then after that Hikki follows Yukinon.. This is not because of his "feelings" for Yukinon, but this is because Yui sends Hikki after Yukinon. (Well according to an LN reader anyway... Not yet confirmed. We need to see the translation on that part.) And again, showing interest in someone does not necessarily mean a romantic one. |
testamentKAISERJun 28, 2015 5:35 PM
 |
NeedHelp56 said: There's one idea I really can't wrap my head around, and that's the assumption (?) that Hachiman already knows about how Yui feels about him, or even how he knows about Yukinon's feelings. Idk if this was LN mentioned or off-scene somewhere that I may have missed, but honestly, I thought Hachiman didn't think these girls liked him in a romantic way. Sure, he likes Yukinon, but I never saw an indicator that told him that the girls felt the same way about him, especially when they call him gross or trash. I mean, throughout the whole scene, I thought Hachiman ended up stopping Yui because he saw that Yukinon was being forced into a decision that was not her own with Hachiman not having any knowledge of the situation. I thought Hachiman was just standing up for Yukinon without any info, which I could see him doing. This was my outlook if I go by the assumption that Hachiman had NO idea that the girls liked him. hachiman knew the feelings of the two. hachiman didnt think that yui and yukino has a romantic feeling for him, he acted innocent and nice to both yui and yukino knowing that it is the right thing to do. he is not used to it. but haruno pointed it out to him it was not trust but something cruel/sinister. |
| internet is a cruel mistress |
Takuan_Soho said: As i said he remembered that scene , it's obvious that he will remember that in volume 9 Yui says "it feels nostalgic" to make him remember. Also the final scene makes him realise that Yui really has feelings for him as he realises that those cookies are not just for gratitide. Also actually Yui will be a normal rom-com end , her whole character revolves around the romance subplot. He saves her dog , she falls for him due to his heroic act , tries to win him and succeds. Watari can give a Yukino end without making it stereotypical, i have faith in his writing. Even Iroha has chance of winning. In volume 11 in case of positive character development Watari has taken Yui to the top of the Mountain while he has thrown Yukino at the bottom of an abyss. Making a Yukino end while giving her a positive push up with believable development in one volume(considering vol 12 is the last one) is actually the biggest challenge Watari can face. CutePriest said: 8man has never thought of Yui like this in the whole series. I had been in the Yukino camp up until this episode, but there was a flashback around the 3:35 mark of last episode that started me thinking that Watari is fooling us by downplaying Yui too much previously, the flashback this episode (remembering the fireworks) and the final scene is what pushed me into the Yui camp. So the above scenes from the novels I know very well, and yes they suggest that Yukino and Hachiman have been slowly falling in love with the other, but where is the "Screw Up" in that? If Yukino is the end goal, then this will have been a pretty normal rom com: two people meet, they initially don't like each other, but slowly over time their feelings change. Don't you think Watari is better than that? His title promised us more. So I wouldn't say my theory above is based on imagination as much as it is based on suspicion. Also Yui ending will feel plain the conflict between Yui and 8man resolved very quickly and easily and Yukino played a big part in resolving that by"You can start a new". On the other hand the conflict between 8man and Yukino plays a big part in developing both of them. They came to know their flaws and realised that they were wrong about each other and stopped predicting each other. Rejection is important for Yui's character development. Out of the trio Yui had the most stable and happy life. 8man and Yukino have experienced rejection from people and society while Yui has experienced none. Also i honestly can't guess what Yukino's request will be. She has recovered a bit after 8man's speech so it's even more hard to exactly predict her request. Also with the story progress i bet the last volume will be focused mainly on Yukino (even more than 8man i think) Watari can do anything he want. From an objective point of view i will say 8man feels something for both of them but it's still not confirmed for whom he has romantic feelings. I will say anybody from thr main 3 girls has chance to win the 8bowl. |
CutePriestJun 29, 2015 3:50 AM
Zymf said: It's so damn confusing! Why did they have to make all the conversations between the 3 main characters so non-informative yet complicated??? I'm not sure if I should give this second season a 4 or even lower -.- http://i.imgur.com/dwhueAG.jpg |
 |
ShrewOne said: At the cultural festival he just avoided her confession and did not actally reject her. The ebnina confession was nothing but an act even Yui understands that she was just shocked. It was not a rejection either. Rejection is when someone listens to your confession and then says sorry as they cant return their feelings. Nothing like this has happened to Yui while both 8man and Yukino(with a lot of hints from the novel ) have gone through it.CutePriest said: Rejection is important for Yui's character development. Out of the trio Yui had the most stable and happy life. 8man and Yukino have experienced rejection from people and society while Yui has experienced none. I don't agree. She's already been through enough heartbreak. For example, at the end of episode 5 (season 1) when Hachiman thinks she's being nice out of guilt because he saved her dog, he basically cuts ties with her and causes her to run off crying. Also, in episode 2, when Hachiman fake confesses to Ebina, Yui initially thinks he's serious about it and that obviously hurt her a lot. And she's been waiting for Hachiman when he's ready for the promise date, and when he's finally ready to ask, Yui has to now consider Yukino's feelings. Normally she would have accepted in a heartbeat. |
Takuan_Soho said: CutePriest said: The ebnina confession was nothing but an act even Yui understands that she was just shocked. It was not a rejection either. Rejection is when someone listens to your confession and then says sorry as they cant return their feelings. Nothing like this has happened to Yui while both 8man and Yukino(with a lot of hints from the novel ) have gone through it. You really don't think that Hachiman understands Yui's feeling? Because if he does, then every time he has avoided dealing with it has been a rejection to her. And despite what you think, he obviously does get it. The only real question is why he pretends not to (is it because he loves Yukino, or is it because he is similar to Ebina). That is one of the two questions remaining with this series. When did i say 8man is unaware of Yui's feelings? He was aware of them since volume 5 and knows that she wants him romantically by the end of volume 11. Are you saying that him not always thinking about that means rejecting her romantically? We all know 8man is bad at handling girls , also i really want to were this "going out together" promise came into the picture at the end of volume 4. Avoiding and rejecting may sound similar but still their meaning is vastly different. Also we still don't know what 8man thinks of Yukino, he only gets Yui's feelings by the end of volume 11. |
Takuan_Soho said: Hachiman was a loner and was rejected before in middle school for carelessly thinking that the other girl likes him just because she was talking to him. At that time he had enough reasons to think that was the case for Yui as well.CutePriest said: Are you saying that him not always thinking about that means rejecting her romantically? Yes that is what I am saying. If he knows and is not interested he should be a man and reject her rather than string her along. So either he doesn't know, or he doesn't want to reject her. To not reject her because of "friendship" is anti-Hachiman, so this means that there is another reason why he either doesn't reject her, or more to the point, why he can't accept her feelings yet. We still don't know the reason why 8man asked Yui if she was free? He might have been thinking of clearing things up once and for all, that's why i am waiting for volume 11 translation. Also if you know please tell me where this "you have to make us hanging out together come true" promice comes into picture by the end of volume 4? He had never promised something like that to Yui by that point. |
CutePriestJun 29, 2015 9:02 PM
ShrewOne said: Bro i think you are confused about the sequence of events their conflict was resolved before their date. Avoiding someone and specifically rejecting them are two different things.CutePriest said: At the cultural festival he just avoided her confession and did not actally reject her. The ebnina confession was nothing but an act even Yui understands that she was just shocked. It was not a rejection either. Rejection is when someone listens to your confession and then says sorry as they cant return their feelings. Nothing like this has happened to Yui while both 8man and Yukino(with a lot of hints from the novel ) have gone through it. Yeah, it's not exactly like the rejection you mentioned, but it is a rejection in a way. Actually, it could be worse because if it's a love rejection, you don't necessarily have to be on bad terms with that person, like Iroha and Hayama. Yui obviously wanted to get close to Hachiman and he basically rejected that offer by cutting ties with her. Keep in mind, Yui had no idea if she would ever talk to Hachiman again after that. It was a whole week before they even started talking again. In the end, it hurt her a lot. If that was a rejection then she would have stopped making advances on him by understanding that 8man does not have such feelings for her. Considering she is a character who takes the surrounding in consideration the most while doing something. But that's not what happened. |
CutePriestJun 29, 2015 10:52 PM
ShrewOne said: I am referring to the scene after the fireworks when 8man and Yui are going home. The Ebina confession upset Yukino a lot as well does that mean she was rejected by 8man in that situation?CutePriest said: Bro i think you are confused about the sequence of events their conflict was resolved before their date. Avoiding someone and specifically rejecting them are two different things. If that was a rejection then she would have stopped making advances on him by understanding that 8man does not have such feelings for her. Considering she is a character who takes the surrounding in consideration the most while doing something. But that's not what happened. There was no confession at the cultural festival, unless you're talking about the honey toast part, which I don't consider a confession in the slightest. She was shocked at the Ebina confession, but considering how emotional she got, I think it upset her quite a bit more than you're letting on. Anyway, when I was mentioning Hachiman rejecting Yui, I was referring to episode 5 of season 1 when he found out that she was the owner of the dog he saved. Also, regarding that, the point I was trying to get across is that the rejection hurt Yui and yes I know it's obviously not exactly the same as a love rejection. I don't actually believe a character should lose just because they haven't faced a love rejection in their life. After all, Yui has already gone through plenty of "suffering". In episode 5 he was not rejecting her he stated that she should stop coming to him out of pity. Also the whole thing was nothing but a misunderstanding as Yukino said. 8man was rejected, looked down upon by people and was never acknowledged by others and was forced to be a loner. That is what rejection means both by people and society whether it's romantic or not. I would say Hachiman is sane enough right now only because of Komachi, she was by his side the whole time. Yukino was bullied by other girls for being a bright student, good looking beauty. She was used as a substitute by her own family , she had no one to support her or encourage and it resulted in her creating a shell around herself and also her dependency issues, making her the most broken character at the moment. That is what rejection means by people and society whether romantic or not. What has Yui faced as compared to those two? A rejection in a high school love is nothing compared to what 8man and Yukino have faced. She has always avoided being rejected and went with the flow which she herself even admits. Whether romantic or not she hasn't faced any. That's why a rejection is important for her character development. |
CutePriestJun 29, 2015 11:31 PM
More topics from this board
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 9, 2015 |
458 |
by FaiziTheGreat
»»
Sep 14, 7:16 AM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 25, 2015 |
1009 |
by Fvrenight
»»
Jul 22, 7:34 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 21, 2015 |
675 |
by SyncxzSolos
»»
Jul 7, 4:13 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 7, 2015 |
425 |
by Onb_Simidi
»»
May 19, 8:30 AM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 28, 2015 |
372 |
by Shah24
»»
Apr 27, 11:09 AM |