ClawViper7 said: I do not believe someone should just skip out on something because the original version is better. I do not play VNs, but I want to enjoy the Fate series, so why not? Its not about what is better or worse. DEEN's FSN anime to FSN VN is what Twilight is to Bram Stoker's Dracula. |
 |
Jakerific said: Why the heck do you care if I watch this or not? Because if you watch it and start bitching about the story being badly written and not making sense it wont be the original's fault nor Fai's if you even after all that go ahead and watch the anime while expecting something like FZ. |
Jakerific said: ssjokg said: Jakerific said: Why the heck do you care if I watch this or not? Because if you watch it and start bitching about the story being badly written and not making sense it wont be the original's fault nor Fai's if you even after all that go ahead and watch the anime while expecting something like FZ. ...and what if I said that I like this anime and I haven't watched Fate/Zero (yet)?? Then you just liked an average anime that is based on a story,not an adaptation.Nothing wrong with that. The whole thread is for those that want to actually understand the chars and the lore without having to guess what is going on or just accept it. |
| don't watch it |
| So much hate, about to watch the Fate/Zero's etc. and maybe I'll change my mind after, but I liked the FSN series a lot. Christ, it got a 9 from me. Anime adaptations are rarely bang on, but they have created something enjoyable even if it isn't entirely accurate. Maybe the fact it is called FSN annoys you more than anything? I could understand if I played the LN etc. and then watched it and if it did it an injustice being annoyed, but the fact is the majority of people watching this won't have played squat or done any background into it and willl have just happened upon it (an assumption, but not unreasonable I think you would agree). As a stand alone action/romance anime (which it is classified as, so don't be surprise if there is a someone x someone involved) it's a decent anime. Maybe as an adaptation it fails, but as an anime it's a decent watch. |
| One day we will come upon each other, and for that day my claws, teeth, ears, hands and hair are at the ready. |
DriveYouCrazy said: So much hate, about to watch the Fate/Zero's etc. and maybe I'll change my mind after, but I liked the FSN series a lot. Christ, it got a 9 from me. Anime adaptations are rarely bang on, but they have created something enjoyable even if it isn't entirely accurate. Maybe the fact it is called FSN annoys you more than anything? I could understand if I played the LN etc. and then watched it and if it did it an injustice being annoyed, but the fact is the majority of people watching this won't have played squat or done any background into it and willl have just happened upon it (an assumption, but not unreasonable I think you would agree). As a stand alone action/romance anime (which it is classified as, so don't be surprise if there is a someone x someone involved) it's a decent anime. Maybe as an adaptation it fails, but as an anime it's a decent watch. I found it average before reading the VN. |
| Meh, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but find it surprising that this anime has such a large anti-fan base (I guess that would be the correct term?), but I guess a popular loose adaptation will get that. |
| One day we will come upon each other, and for that day my claws, teeth, ears, hands and hair are at the ready. |
DriveYouCrazy said: Meh, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but find it surprising that this anime has such a large anti-fan base (I guess that would be the correct term?), but I guess a popular loose adaptation will get that. It isnt hard to find holes in the anime.Which story wise doesnt make it great. |
| i'd like to say something, Fai i think u're complaining too much, i watched the anime and played part of the VN fate route and found nothing inconsistent between the two. i watched the anime first and then read fate, personally i feel deen represented the characters and set the tone just fine, to elaborate on this when i read the VN it felt very light hearted and calm, that's the exact same feeling i get watching the anime. The characters personalities remained the same too as well most of the story. so honestly don't see what the problem is, i think you think the anime sucks simply because u read the novel first and expected to get the same feelings out from the anime sure they made some minor changes but most of the feelings was the same and i'm pretty sure if you do a plot and timeline poster you will find most of the events that happen are the same.[u/] but i do think it was epic fail attempt to establish the relationship between Rin and Sakura. |
I_Am_AwesomeSep 29, 2013 2:22 AM
wakka9ca said:"The endless debate between fans and haters... is totaly pointless"  |
ssjokg said: DriveYouCrazy said: Meh, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but find it surprising that this anime has such a large anti-fan base (I guess that would be the correct term?), but I guess a popular loose adaptation will get that. It isnt hard to find holes in the anime.Which story wise doesnt make it great. this i agree with |
wakka9ca said:"The endless debate between fans and haters... is totaly pointless" |
| I too watched the anime before reading the visual novel. I didn't find it to be THAT bad. But yeah, I definitely recommend reading the visual novel over the anime. If you have around 50 hours of spare time, read the visual novel. It's worth it. As a general rule, ALL visual novel adaptations will have tons of flaws, due to scenes being cut out, resulting in less developed characters in the anime. It's inevitable. |
 |
I_Am_Awesome said: i'd like to say something, Fai i think u're complaining too much, i watched the anime and played part of the VN fate route and found nothing inconsistent between the two. i watched the anime first and then read fate, personally i feel deen represented the characters and set the tone just fine, to elaborate on this when i read the VN it felt very light hearted and calm, that's the exact same feeling i get watching the anime. The characters personalities remained the same too as well most of the story. You mean except for the fact that Shirou is litterally 180 degree different from his VN counterpart, the events are toned down from the way they happen in the VN and the actual character development is removed. fate in VN was basically a cat and mouse game of "find the master". there's nothing lighthearted at that. DEEN's FSN turned it into sexist dating sim. sure they made some minor changes but most of the feelings was the same and i'm pretty sure if you do a plot and timeline poster you will find most of the events that happen are the same.[u/] Except not. They took the certain VN events and added them in the same order into otherwise ENTIRELY different narrative. MCsq2 said: I too watched the anime before reading the visual novel. I didn't find it to be THAT bad. But yeah, I definitely recommend reading the visual novel over the anime. If you have around 50 hours of spare time, read the visual novel. It's worth it. As a general rule, ALL visual novel adaptations will have tons of flaws, due to scenes being cut out, resulting in less developed characters in the anime. It's inevitable. The difference is that most of adaptations STILL relatively follow the plot and logic of the VN. DEEN's FSN is litterally "fuck this, let's do something random" |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fate/stay night Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )WinterNightsFall - Jul 31, 2008 |
597 |
by Ricky16
»»
Sep 16, 10:44 AM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Desian - Sep 14, 2008 |
109 |
by NoviSun
»»
Aug 3, 11:48 PM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )DaBigD - Oct 4, 2008 |
90 |
by UveVauliett
»»
Jun 17, 7:32 AM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night Episode 14 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Ruzgfpegk - Jul 3, 2008 |
141 |
by UveVauliett
»»
Jun 17, 7:30 AM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night Episode 23 Discussion ( 1 2 )ItsMeAndrea - Dec 14, 2008 |
69 |
by L1on777
»»
Jun 2, 3:55 AM |