Reviews

Feb 21, 2024
Mixed Feelings
Preliminary (53/? chp)
I am a crazy man........ I am a crazy man to hold out hopes for this genre, desperately wanting to feel that same arousal which I got the first time I held a power fantasy. But time after time, I have been shitted on by the manhwa gods, only able to clutch to a husk of such saturated mediocrity, it saddens me.

"The Dragon Slayer Academy's Hotshot" is nothing but titbits of various clichés which are already introduced, used and spat out by countless of its predecessors, all crumpled into one place. It seemingly baths in its mediocrity. It saddens and amuses me at the same time that the situation of the power fantasy scene in manhwas has become a stark competitor with the isekai scene in mangas, both competing to prove their dominance over mediocrity. And while isekais are my guilty pleasure, so I usually look the other way, but this kind of benevolence from me is not enjoyed by the power fantasy genre.

Cliched, cliched, cliched....... It looks like it has become the mantra of various power fantasy manhwas, where we see the same rehash of a manwha nearly everyday or so, it seems. And this manhwa blatantly makes it its motto to the point where it starts to feel a copy.

Talking about copying, it has an eerily close resemblance to one of my first manhwas "A Returner's Magic Should Be Special".
I JUST CAN'T GET IT OUT OF MY HEAD! The resemblance seems too close for it to be an inspiration and the allegedly copied manhwa is not even that good to begin with. But I would rather refrain from saying that because some people who like it would come after my ass saying "HoW cOUld YoU sAy iT Is A coPy?", when it clearly is.

That is not to say that it is bad, but it is just MID. People give various example, this is mid, that is mid, but I think this right here truly captures that meaning of mid, just perfectly mediocre, right in the middle.

Not good, not bad, Just MID.

But, but, bear with me, I did not have any cringey moments with it. Ok I maybe lying when I said that, but the cringe amount was definitely in miniature. It definitely feels weird to have a positive ending when all I have done in the majority of this review is just dogpile on it. And it is better than most manhwas I have given a 5 anyway. So it deserves atleast a 6.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login